What if you could learn something that no one else knew? Question to NT members...
A simple question for comment and discussion.
If you could learn something that no one else had learned, or could learn, and pass that knowledge back on to humanity, even if it meant giving up your life, would you do it?
If you had the opportunity to learn an pass on for example:
- The key to traveling faster than the speed of light.
- What/where was the universe prior to the big bang.
- Where is the universe.
- Is there a unified force driving the universe (some might call it God).
- Master anti-gravity
- Cold Fusion.
Besides your family, or your country, what would you be willing to do or learn and give your life in return?

For me, beyond family and country, the knowledge of FTL travel, or cold fusion would be worth giving my life for.
The recent movie "Interstellar" was what brought this question to mind.
Is there one thing in particular that you would actually jump at the chance to learn John?
If it would save mankind, yes.
If it is something personal, then, don't worry about me, I won't remember to tell it.
FTL travel would be a biggie. We gotta get off this rock at some point or be crushed by the weight of our own feces. But instead of sharing it with the world then dying, I'd rather tell just tell one prominent scientist, let them get the credit and go on living on a new planet. That would be awesome.
Being a geologist.... If you could discover a method of accurately predicting earthquakes.... would you do it?
Cure for cancer, but wait till I'm around a hundred or so.
Good one!
Too many of my friends have been diagnosed with it of late. I'm guessing I've entered that time where life stops giving us things, and starts to take them away.
Excellent idea, and actually within the grasp of humanity if we set our minds to it.
Yellowstone going critical, or an asteroid impact are inevitable thus ending life on the surface from what I understand. If we as a species plan to survive long term, getting off this rock to other rocks is a must.
Cure for ALL cancers. Please God...
We must carefully choose which rock, though...
Evidently, the things that cause the most problems, (volcanos and earthquakes), are the things that keep our planet alive and dynamic.
Yes. They are still working on that one. Volcanos are a bit easier, but it still isn't exact.
Worried about over population as the flip side of that coin?
Very true Dowser.
People worry about radiation, but the truth of it is.... we're bathed in it. Without it, its doubtful that we would have the diversity of life that is and has been present on Earth.
I'm not that altruistic either, but for me, learning is the thing...
If I had enough money to have all my bills paid, live comfortably, I'd be a professional student. So much to learn and try to grasp. Unfortunately I'm fighting poverty like most.
Probably either buy it from you or kill you for it and keep the secret to themselves.
True, but I won't care cus I'll be dead....!
Is there anything you would be willing to learn in trade for your life Six?
What about telepathy and/or telekinesis?
What about time travel?
Fountain of Youth, (or it's technological equivalent.)
100% accurate scrying, (foretelling the future.)
Contact with other species/Galactic Federation.
Nope, I want to live and die as those before me have done. I don't relish the thought of dying, but I don't relish the thought of no one dying either, at least here on this earth, but I would like to know how to put a governor on those who wish to have power over everyone else.
Serve one up, they're all good! If you had to choose Wheel, which one, and maybe why.
Or a cure for all diseases that kill, or leave people disabled.
This sounds nice ... until you get The Russell to try to define "fairness" ...
"The Man Who Knew Too Much" [the take from Hitchcock] :
The correct resolution to Maxwell's demon .
Sure. I'm suicidal anyway, so I might as well leave something good behind beforeI swallow the pills anyway. Not that it matters because I'll be dead and won't give a shit anyway.
LoL!!!!....I guess thinking big is not a requirement. Molecular level knowledge is just as facinating and important.
Me, I think something important might be the thermos.... It keeps hot things hot, and cold thing cold......How do it know?
Have a good one.
Actually it's a conundrum. what Maxwell said was it would be possible to do if someone could figure out how to build the doorway.
Theoretically, it states that the second law of Thermodynamics has an end around.
Maxwell, usually regarded as the third greatest physicist behind Newton and Einstein, was credited by Einstein that without Maxwell there would be no special theory.
That rates him pretty high in my book.
Now, if the Second Law of Thermodynamics has an end around, without upsetting entropy, then overunity is possible. Maxwell believed it was. That's why he postulated his daemon.
As an engineer you know what that would mean to the world. It would be a thousand times more important a discovery than gravity and man's understanding of it.
Just imagine what that would do to the oil, gas and electric companies.
Yeah someone just might invent a Dewar flask, then where would Thermos be?
How Muslim of you ... think about it .
Amen to that. I lost my uncle to ALS.
Muslims believe in an afterlife. I know there isn't one, so it's not "Muslim" at all. How could I care? I'll be dead. I'll no longer exist.
Sorry, too many days on call....
These all seem like wonderful things. But sometimes wonderful things have undesired outcomes.
Oppenheimer thought the atomic bomb would be a good thing.
Until he saw what it did.
He went from this:
There must be no barriers to freedom of inquiry There is no place for dogma in science. The scientist is free, and must be free to ask any question, to doubt any assertion, to seek for any evidence, to correct any errors.
to this:
Now, I am become death, the destroyer of worlds.
Be careful what we wish for.
Fair enough . Muslims believe they will be rewarded in their believed afterlife for purposeful destruction in this life . But your suicidal tendencies could just as easily be turned into a Muslim mindset , at least on the surface ...
I'm afraid I don't see how. My suicidal tendencies are a combination ofdisease and pure selfishness. The disease takes away any inhibition I have to do it and the selfishness comes in by deciding the time I want to die. That will happen when I decide that my quality of life is not what I want it to be. It will be my decision and mine alone. That is the sellfish part.
The idea that life has to have "quality" seems like an artificial construct to me , like Katy Perry deciding what kind of prop to wear on her boobs on a particular day :
Nuclear fission is most definitely a double edged sword. I wish to get rid of nuclear weapons just as much as everyone else but lets look at some realities.
1) Whom would you rather have seen get the bomb first in 1945, the US, USSR, Nazi Germany?
2) While we continue to live under the threat of nuclear annihilation, the simple fact is that we are all still here. It is quite possible that having developed thermonuclear weapons has given the biggest kids on the block pause about going to war. Yes there have been endless regional conflicts with conventional weapons, but we seem to have been able to avoid that all out WWIII. It may be by the nuclear powers understanding that nothing is worth Armageddon, or by sheer dumb luck. I don't know for sure.
So back to the original seed question Perrie. What would you be willing to give your life for if you could pass it's secrets back to mankind?
The seeded question back to you Petey...
Is there anything that you would give your life for in return to learn its secrets and pass that knowledge back to humanity.
You bringing up Maxwell's demon jostled some old brain cells from my thermodynamics class soooooo many years ago.
Professor Umholtz and his liquid cooled piece of chalk........ He would write with the right hand and erase with the left as he moved his way across the board. The highest grade in the class was a +C!!! What I did learn every well in his class was to develop heat transfer equations and work the equations backwards from what you want as a result toward what the input values needed to be.
So your telling me that the Dewar flask is going to be smarter than the Thermos? Bitchen!!!!
Hard to make things idiot proof when idiots are so ingenious.....
I could get behind that one Larry............
Well let's say then that when I no longer get the amount of personal satisfaction I desire.
My personal belief is that the next nuclear explosion in anger will be fired by Israel against Iran.
You and I must have had the same professor. But I managed a B- and had to argue to the point of almost begging to get that.
I had a problem with working the problem backwards. I always thought that the issues of thermodynamics should be worked from the input side rather than that result side. Long and tedious I know, and pointless from a practical standpoint. but I learned very well. My final paper was on building an ice plant that required no pumps working on heat transference alone. He gave it a C.
The Daemon caught my fancy as such technical things do with the possibilities inherent in the ideal...
If it were Possible .... It would change the world. one hell of an if...
For those uninitiated in technical equipment jargon, A Dewar Flask is a much more efficient Thermos bottle. Hence a thermos being a practical everyday example of scientific knowledge being made useful in everyday life. ah, the Dewar Flask came first.
Whose to say if Dewar was smarter than Thermos, who made more money off of the deal?
Your beliefs are completely unfounded in any realistic evidence . Here are some facts to consider , however . Iran is constantly threatening Israel with destruction and calling the US "the great Satan".
Back to the seeded topic gentlemen.....
This is a one and done warning.
Back to the seeded topic.