Is Your Job Creative Enough to Resist Robot Automation?
Robots carry dishes and offer service for customers at a robot themed restaurant in China.Getty Images
Think your job is too creative for a robot to do it?
Think again, warns a new report co-authored by Oxford University academics.
Jobs that are considered creative today may not be so tomorrow, according to the report, Creativity versus Robots , written with Nesta, a London-based non-profit research and innovation group. The paper, published last week, delves into the possible effects of automation on the workforce.
The Nesta /Oxford report tries to handicap which occupations are creative enough to avoid near-term automation. Of the 702 occupations categorized in the U.S., 21% ranked as highly creative,offering the most protection against automation. Such jobs included artists, architects, web designers and IT specialists.
Jobs that are highly susceptible to computerization, according to the report: office administrators, call-center staff, librarians, cattle and crop farmers, loggers, miners, car salesmen and hotel staff.
The results strongly confirm the intuition that creative occupations are more future proof to computerization, the report states, adding that the results also suggest a pervasive restructuring of labor markets over the decades to come. The report urges governments to help workers that are made redundant into novel creative professions.
Here are five jobs the report says have a very low probability of computerization:
- Translators and interpreters (5.8%)
- Performing artists (7%)
- Radio broadcasters (7.7%)
- Film and TV producers (8%)
- R&D on natural sciences (10.9%)
Here are five jobs the report says have a very high probability of computerization:
-
Peat extractors (100%)
-
Motion picture projectionists (97%)
-
Copper producers (70.7%)
-
Mailing list publishers (69%)
-
Bartenders (67.5%)

Robots carry dishes and offer service for customers at a robot themed restaurant in China.Getty Images
Who knew that bartending as a profession was at such risk of robotic replacement
I think that already happened about thirty years ago.
I think they are talking about there not being a human hand involved (as shown in your picture), just a robot dispensing the drinks you order electronically.
Good for you
R W
Thanks for the feedback and perspective
You are exactly correct - automation is not something to be feared or avoided, it is a reality that must be embraced. There are significant pluses to the advancement of robotics and automation, but there are also corresponding bad effects in the areas of unemployment.
Since it is a reality, changes in industry must be matched by change sin education and preparation of the work force.
Obviously you're not paying attention John....
We have spent the last several thousand years creating machines to reduce physical labor of all kinds. And this has been good, because it is how civilizations are created, and how economies grow. Machines are how we got here.
Technology is advancing and adapting at a pace that is far greater than humans have the capacity for. Technology has replaced human muscle with mechanical muscle. We are now at the point of replacing human thinking and decision making with machine thinking and reasoning. If you think for one minute that technology is going to stand still, you are sadly mistaken.
FLY
A key point is emphasized when you say
Thanks for the perspective
Those with creative skills such as artists, writers, and musicians make up a very small portion of the workforce.
BTW..... Translators, and interpreters are near term targets for automation.
In 15 years or less, I believe you will see the end of truck drivers, heavy equipment operators and taxi drivers.
FLY
I agree with you on translators and interpreters as these areas are a prime opportunity for the efficiency and accuracy of advancing technology.
As to your 15 year prediction - I agree on the career fields being prime for automated replacement, but am not sure we will "see the end" of people doing those functions in 15 years, but within a few decades I would agree
Thanks for the perspective and feedback
Absolutely.
Though automation has decreased the number of techs it takes on average, to run lab tests.
Larry
True enough
Thanks for the perspective and feedback
R W
Excellent point, this must be addressed in education reform and quickly
Also very true
The time for education reform with an emphasis on technology and technical skilled careers is now
badfish
But as banking and loan automation continues to expand, don't you agree that your type of position will be on life support vey soon as the loan process becomes more and more automated, with less and less human interaction in the process (just numbers)?
I've retired a good number of robots in my career, does that count?
I'd say they are working on the components that will eventually be adapted to make an automated soldier. If you ever read Starship Troopers, I foresee a powered suited human before we see a fully robotic soldier.
Robots can be made to move faster, jump higher, Etc., but to adapt one to effectively operate in a combat world that is designed for bipeds with two hands, under all circumstances outside my realm of thinking.
Lets just hope we outgrow war first.
Syonara
Me too, but I have a robotic vacuum cleaner that keeps the man cave clean, and that used to be one of my chores
badfish
You mean a land operating drone?
Indeed
That is not a man cave - it is a surgical suite
jennilee
Absolutely true
God bless all the teachers out there
I'm retired. That got a robot to replace that yet?
Nor should they!
Look at the bright side Mike......
You sure as hell aren't going to feel like tipping a robot, yielding more for alcohol. My two-cents.
Couldn't open the image, but Robbie the Robot could produce whatever drink you might prefer.
Buzz
We have a "Robbie the Robot" at the local watering hole, well at least his name is Robbie and he serves pretty good drinks and always has a story to tell.
Thanks for the feedback
badfish
Not questioning the service you provide customers in any way, just opining that the human element is likely to be removed from loan decisions and the numbers (income, debt, credit rating, loan amount desired, terms etc) will determine the yes or no on loans.
You have a tough job and do a service for many people
I get that
Thanks for your service
The personal touch and interaction will always be important in the education and socialization process - human, personal interaction is key to the Socratic method of teaching which in my view is the most effective, but automation and technology play a larger and larger role in education with every passing day.