Next-generation nuclear reactors may not be safer: French watchdog
(Reuters) - The next generation of nuclear reactors being developed in countries such as France, Russia, China and Japan may not be safer than those being built today, French nuclear safety watchdog IRSN said on Monday.
In a study of six future reactor designs being worked on by the U.S.-led "Generation IV International Forum", the IRSN said only the sodium-cooled fast reactor (SFR) model was far enough along in the development process to envisage building a prototype during the first half of this century.
But it could not say whether it would be safer than models currently being built for service.
"While it seems possible for SFR technology to guarantee a safety level at least equivalent to that targeted by generation III pressurised-water reactors, IRSN is unable to determine whether it could significantly exceed this level," it said.
The comments represent the first significant public criticism of the next-generation designs among nuclear safety officials of the 4G forum's 13 member countries, which also include Britain, South Korea and Canada.
The vast majority of the more than 400 so-called second-generation reactors operating worldwide today are pressurised-water reactors (PWR), built mostly between 1970 and 1990.
Utilities are also building a handful of third-generation reactors like Areva's EPR reactor and Westinghouse's AP1000, which use the same basic design as 2G reactors but offer more safety features.
The 4G forum focuses on radical new designs, such as cooling reactors with liquid metals instead of water, and operating at much higher temperatures.
Leading
nuclear nations channel millions of dollars into 4G reactor research every year, but the 2011 Fukushima nuclear disaster, the renewable energy boom and cheap shale gas have raised questions about the project.
The IRSN said that while the SFR reactor - unlike PWRs - could operate at low pressure, its main disadvantage was that sodium was highly reactive with water and air.
The agency also questioned the degree to which the reactor would be able to burn up "actinides", among the most dangerous by-products of nuclear fission.
4G advocates argue that SFRs would reduce the amount of nuclear waste and the need for deep storage, but the IRSN said this feature offered "only a very slight advantage", which would not be the deciding factor in the choice of future reactors.
The IRSN said that one of the six 4G models, the Very High Temperature Reactor could bring significant safety improvements, but that the feasibility of that concept had yet to be determined.
http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/04/27/us-nuclear-future-france-idUSKBN0NI1WJ20150427

I wish Slartibartfast (EI) were here to give us some insight to theses sodium reactors vs. say the CANDU reactors that can dispose of plutonium by burning it as a fuel. The other nice thing about the CANDUs is that the fuel is typically enriched to between 2% and 5% U235, much lower than the enrichment for other power generating reactors.
On paper and practice, U233 can be made by irradiating thorium. The result is a fissionable weapons grade/reactor grade material. In fact, the US has lost track of about 200 pounds of U233 made from thorium.
There were many attempts to make use of thorium throughout the 1950s/1960s and even up into the 1970s. The facilities though just couldn't quite get their act together to make a viable product. Given that Hanford, and Oak Ridge were up and making large quantities of Plutonium and weapons grade uranium, the thorium operations were kind of like the red-headed step-child of the industry. As such, the US government gave up on it sometime in the 1970s.
I got to study an overview of this technology back in 1979 when I took a class in radiation biophysics. Thanks for the memory jog. I'm guessing the Chinese are looking into the technology.
I fail to see how a liquid metal cooled reactor can be considered safer than a water cooled reactor. Obviously, I don't understand the process. However, a release of radioactive anything is never good, I guess, if it's water or liquid metal. Seems to me that they are going about the problem by introducing even more pollutants.
They need to build these in a more geologically stable environment, not along fault lines and subduction zones... And line everything with bentonite, which remains 'plastic'. Sigh!
We both know that nuke power isn't going to go away given the energy needs of the world. What happened in Japan with regards to the design and location of the plants was borderline criminal.
I know the pressurized water reactors have been around for some time, but they are pretty much proven technology, and if designed like the CANDU reactors, they can burn plutonium from decommissioned warheads making that form of waste go away.
Nuke power.... the gift that keeps on giving!
I got my B.A. at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario. McMaster was the first university in the whole British Commonwealth of Nations to have an operating nuclear reactor on its campus, which was in operation while I was there. It was used for research purposes, under the guidance of the great Dr. H. G. Thode, and was instrumental in developing the use of isotopes for the treatment of cancerous diseases.
(I just HAD to get in a bit of flag-waving there. LOL)
One of the problems with water cooled reactors happens in the event of a flood . If the pumps that move the cooling water are inactivated by the flood the danger of a meltdown becomes very large .