The GOP doesn’t want you to retire:
The GOP doesnt want you to retire:
Thursday, Apr 23, 2015 04:15 AM EST
Leading presidential candidates want to raise the age of retirement. It's not going to sit well with our electorate
For years, the Social Security and Medicare systems have been under assault from the Republican Party, which views the programs as irredeemable socialist institutes. In the Bush years, this attack took the form of introducing privatization that would slowly move Social Security away from the government altogether.
Having failed at that, Republicans are slowly refocusing around a new way to target both of these retirement programs: raising the age that people are eligible to take advantage of them.As of this writing, the top expected GOP candidates for the presidency have all endorsed or floated plans that would raise the retirement age.
Proponents of this move insist that people are living longer, so its reasonable to raise the age when they retire. The problem is, these gains in life expectancy are far from equal. Research by the Center for Economic and Policy Research shows that the bottom half of the population in terms of income has seen very little growth in life expectancy:
Raising the retirement age saves very little money it would be much more efficient simply to lift the payroll tax cap so that the very rich have to pay taxes on all of their income rather than just the first $117,000. Doing so would ensure there is no shortfall of financing for Social Security for generations.
In short, these plans makes little economic sense; they would keep older Americans in the labor pool longer, freezing them in positions that younger workers would therefore be denied, and represent a challenge to the traditional ethics about the necessity for society to take care of the elderly. But in a Republican Party whose top donors are the Koch brothers, who once advocated eliminating Social Security and Medicare altogether, its not expected.
Rand Paul: The junior senator from Kentucky says raising the retirement age is the only way to manage possible funding shortfalls in the future. Paul bluntly told an Iowa audience that life expectancy is now 80 years old, but this simply isnt true for many Americans. Black men, for example, have a life expectancy of closer to 71 years .
Lindsey Graham: Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) has yet to declare, but he is strongly considering a White House bid, saying only the amount of money it takes to win is an obstacle. At the end of 2012, Graham threatened to refuse to raise the debt ceiling unless the age of retirement for Social Security was hiked, saying that the debt problems of the country must be dealt with first. Yet Social Security doesnt add a dime to the deficit, as even GOP President Ronald Reagan admitted .
Chris Christie: Christie put out the most detailed plan for Social Security and Medicare of any of the nominees, calling for a new retirement age of 69 (it is currently 65 and on its way to being hiked to 67). He also has the wrinkle of means-testing the program, paring back benefits for those earning $80,000 of additional income and eliminating them at $200,000, a move that is likely to put the upper echelons of the middle class and everyone above that against everyone below.
Jeb Bush: Bush announced his support for raising the retirement age last week. His brother George W. Bush was the president who overreached in trying to privatize Social Security, dealing his party huge losses.
Democratic Pushback
As the Republicans are settling on a more modest form of Social Security cuts than their last venture, Democrats are actually positioning to expanding the program. Forty-two Democratic senators voted for an amendment to do so, and possible 2016 candidates Bernie Sanders and Martin OMalley have both expressed support for this position. Meanwhile, Hillary Clinton has stepped up her defense of the program.
At this rate, the 2016 presidential campaign may expose diametric views of Americas retirement programs. The Democrats are coalescing around a position that says Americans need more help to have secure retirements, while the Republicans seem to be saying that Americans should simply put off retiring.
http://www.salon.com/2015/04/23/the_gop_doesnt_want_you_to_retire_why_the_party_will_regret_its_latest_gambit_partner/
Tags
Who is online
162 visitors

Let me get this right, GOP wants to raise the retirement age to 70 years old, repeal Obamacare, that means no health care while you work until you're 70..that in my calculations means certain DEATH, no way of collecting Social Security Benefits, these are the worst Con Men on planet earth, they are not even pretending anymore, flat out thieves...
You have to wonder what percentage of the GOP base is really going to accept this?
What am I thinking.... It will still be about God, guns, gay-bashing and abortion at election time.
What is said during an election rarely means what they are going to do when in office. That might be the talking points, Fly, but I think at the end of the day, it will be about what happens to SS and Obamacare, etc.
The GOP's heath plan has always been the same as it's Social Security plan for middle-income and lower workers. Make sure they die before/instead of them getting any benefits they paid into for (with that money going to the rich). The GOP wants you dead once you can no longer work and they want no health care along the way to ensure that happens. They are nothing short of murderers.
Social Security began in 1935, with the benefits kicking in at 65.
Life expectancy in 1935 was 65. This means that if you somehow lived beyond the average life expectancy, you could draw a pension from the government.
Today, life expectancy is approximately 78.
You can begin drawing Social Security as early as 62.
Is this really a partisan issue, or is it a financial issue?
Life expectancy is a very flexible number depending on which income class you are from.
The report found that life expectancy is 81.6 for males and 84.5 for females in Fairfax County, Virginia (a very affluent area) and 81.4 for males and 85.0 for females in Marin County, California (another upscale area) compared to only 63.9 for males and 72.9 for females in McDowell County, West Virginia or 66.7 for males and 73.3 for females in Tunica County, Mississippi.
It's a financial issue, as much as it's a class issue. The affluent of the GOP wants the working class to pay into the system and then die before they can really collect anything from it.
...
Again, I don't believe that it's a partisan issue.
Where government benefits are concerned, they take the average life expectancy of the population, not unlike an insurance company would.
What the government did NOT do was make adjustments to payments and benefits over the years. There are people who have been collecting Social Security for 20 years and more who receive several times more than they ever paid in, because appropriate adjustments were not made.
This is the #1 reason why we are having this discussion now.
Then the people who are mostly likely to live longer, the affluent, should be paying a lot more into Social Security (raise the cap significantly), since they are most likely to live well into their 80's and collect more (plus need it less),while the less affulent should pay much less into the Social Security fund since they are much more likely to die before they collect what they contributed (if they live to collect any of what they paid in at all). Problem solved.
Nope. Raising the cap on contributions by the more affluent solves the problem in a much more fair way then raising retirement age, because most people of the working and lower classes barely live to retirement age as it is, even after paying into the system all of their working lives. Raising the retirement age screws them over, which is of course a tenet of GOP politics. Fuck the workers and the poor.
The average household wage is $68,000.
The Social Security is capped at $118,000.
There's no cap on Medicare.
Your statement on the lower class' life expectancy is cherry picked by the 2 counties with the lowest life expectancy.
Read the article before commenting. The were representative samples by Institute of Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of Washington and were found to be pretty much true across the country. Poverty, as shown by more then one study in the article, strongly affects one's life expectancy, primarily due to worse healthcare. Somehow I expected better then a cheap reach around like that from you. You're a disappointment in this one.
Social Security needs to be capped a $250,000 and the retirement age left alone. I think the system will be in much better shape in the future if that is done. And it'll be more fair to the fewer poor and middle class who actually, in spite of the GOP's best efforts, do live long enough to collect their fair share.
100% in Agreement MM...
Raising the minimum age from 62 to 63 one month per year coupled with a capped system at $250,000 will do wonders.
Move it from 62 to 63 at one month per year, stopping at 63and cap contributions at $250k. I could go along with that.
It really doesn't matter what we do. We've raised a bunch of idiots who are not motivated to save anything on their own or try to improve their lives in the least. Like this fellow told me, "I don't work for the government. I've figured how to make the government work for me".
You could raise the cap to $1,000,000 and it wouldn't ever be enough. The idea is to level the playing field by taking all the money from the people who work for it and giving it to those who don't work for it. The left will not be satisfied until all the wealth except for the elites who are behind all of this has been taken from the middle income who actually pay taxes and then there will be two classes of individuals in this society, one being the elites like Hillary Clinton, Bill Clinton, Barack Obama and the other super wealthy for example and the rest of us.
The way it has been going the wealthy have been getting richer, the middle income has been getting poorer and the poor have basically remained the same because they are totally dependent on the government to take care of them, just like the liberal elite like it. This gives them their voters, because they keep falling for the same old lies over and over.
A long screed of useless garbage that says nothing. Just bitches, but says nothing. It's all a bunch of strung together bits and pieces of propaganda from several philosophies (some that actually oppose each other), political parties, ideals, complaints, liesand just plain bullshit into something that really says nothing at all.
What the hell does it mean? Are you trying to start a new political party based on incoherence?
Oooops!
Just slow down and say it in English....
I suspect that you've been all in on "piss on economics" (AKA :trickle down) since it's installation in the early 1980s Six. So no surprise in your comment of the 47% since you want to ignore cause and effect.
You want to talk about job migration do you...? From 2000 to 2008 America lost 5.8 million manufacturing jobs. Since 2009 that trend has been reversed, but not nearly enough.
True to form, like so many other conservative mindsets, which includes the God/guns/gay-bashing/abortion crowd, your blind support of GOP ideology ignores the root causes of many of America's problems. I guess I've been wrong now for many years in that you can polish a turd. Your support of GOP no matter what is proof of that.
How the world turns.
Raising the minimum age of retirement of SS is a democrat idea going all the way back to the early '80's. the last major SS reform package the retirement age was forced to 67 by 2017 and 2000 was raised to 66 in steps. The idea was introduced by congressman J. J. Pickle (DTX), at the time, Chairman of the House Ways and Means Subcommittee on Social Security. In 1980, He proposed that phasing in an increase to age 68 over a period of 10 years beginning in 1990 was the best course. Pickles proposal was panned at first by Speaker Tip ONeill in what Time magazine then dubbed one of the more egregious examples of partisanship. Because O'Neill didn't want to shift the heat for SS reform off the president.
Pickle eventually got a age increase put into the bill and passed in 83 which raised the age to 66 in 2000 and 67 in 2017. This was done in order to extend the time the government would be able to write check to recipients. Without it, SS would have died from bankruptcy in 1984.
How little we forget.
Raising the SSA retirement age is a democrat idea, not a republican one.
Let's look at some facts Fly. The national debt is nearly double since Obama took office. The Fed has done everything they could to prevent the inevitable hyper inflation, which I expect they will stop doing when a Republican takes over in 2016.
There are more people on Food Stamps now than there ever have been. The work force is the smallest it has been since the 1970's relative to the population. Obama's first Jobs Czar was Jeffrey Immelt top dog at GE who controls NBC who feeds the media to the Grubers and under him the United States shipped ten of thousands of jobs overseas especially from GE, although some are coming back because of the energy cost overseas.
Now that doesn't have anything to do with Obama except he has fought tooth and nail to prevent the explosion of the United States becoming the world's highest producer of Natural Gas.
The World Economics Forum's Global Competitive Index rated the USA as #1 when Bush passed the office to Obama in spite of the financial crisis. After 3 years of Obama they ranked the USA fifth place and went as high as seventh place, but you're correct it has come back down to rank in fifth place now.
We're building other countries economies at the expense of this country. Without the aid of the Fed the stock market would fall like a rock and everyday citizens aren't making a dime from Wall Street, only the elite for the most part who will be the same people who take advantage of the inevitable correction.
Retirees are not living off their retirement profits, but the actual value of their accounts watching them diminish with each month unless they stick their necks out and jeopardize the whole account because the rates are being artificially kept low.
Well, I could go on, but you're wrong about it being Republican vs Democrats. I am a Democrat and thought Bush was a very bad president, Clinton had the benefit of the Dot.com bubble. He could have spent his whole term in his office with Monica and it wouldn't have made any difference, in fact it would have been better.
The lack of regulations and the crazy people like Barney Frank who wouldn't stop the "giving everyone a home" even when they couldn't afford it nor had any plans of paying for it combined with the Fannie Mae fiasco and Wall Street taking advantage of the situation was one of the biggest reasons we had the recession.
Keep in mind Nancy Pelosi wasted more money than all the Speakers of the House combined during her reign and the Democrats were all for it. Obama is importing hundreds of thousands of liabilities into this country who are costing the taxpayers, you know, the people who are actually paying taxes and their whole premium for Obamacare for themselves and everyone else every year he has been in office.
Now the Republicans aren't any better in my opinion. When they had the legislature they spent like sailors as well.
The wind is coming from the ENE and I smell a turd.
Without the aid of the Fed the stock market would fall like a rock and everyday citizens aren't making a dime from Wall Street, only the elite for the most part who will be the same people who take advantage of the inevitable correction.
A great many common citizens saw their IRA's collapse as did many people whose other pension plans were really just investments in the market. They took a punch in the gut too and a lot of people who had their retirement all planned out had to wait a few years for the "correction" to happen before they could retire. Not only the rich were hurt by Bush's collapse or benefited from Obama's recovery.
Now the Republicans aren't any better in my opinion. When they had the legislature they spent like sailors as well.
So get rid of them all? All of the Democrats and Republicans? That's what you are proposing. You don't like any of the Washington politicians at all. Not a one. So let's get rid of all of them! Democrats and Republicans! Throw the bums out! And replace them with who? It's easy to say let's just throw them all out, without considering the fact that it leaves us with no one to run the government. There certainly aren't going to be a rush of common citizens to fill the jobs and they would know what the fuck to do if they did.
Yeah, and LBJ was only a republican in drag I suppose.
WE are in this pickle today because of a TEXAS democrat.
Agree RW...
Agree also...
Define hate!!!
Well, here is something hateful, how about adjustments made on the payout to you, that is a reduction in your receipt of SS Benefits, no one has suggested anything hateful, all we were saying is that the participants in FICA, the income level be raised, you call it hateful and I wanted to define what I would consider been hateful!!!
And no, that doesn't mean we pay them any more money out, as Social Security is based on income AND how much you pay in FICA. They are already getting the max Social Security payout and that would stay the same. What you pay in FICA is already capped at an income level of $117,000 and that is the cap we are talking about raising. No matter how much more money you make above that amount, that $117,000 is the most FICA you will be paying into the system for. For instance, if you make $1,000,000 per year, you are still only paying into the Social Security system the FICA amount based on the first $117,000 per year you make and nothing above that. You are NOT paying FICA based on $1,000,000. That cap should be raised to the first $250,000 you make and that would save Social Security for generations, while only taking what amounts to a smidgen more money out of your $1,000,000 per year income.
I hate my fellow man?
I didn't really think you'd ever say anything like that about me.
I just try to ignore him because he is SOignorant on SO many subjects that trying to make sense of what he is saying and trying to explain things to him will just make you crazy.
BTW, I think you're just about the least hateful person I know.
HIM on the other hand....
They are already getting the max Social Security payout and that would stay the same.
Which, BTW is currently 3501.00 per month (if they worked the bulk of their adult life and retired at 70 years oldin 2014). No matter how much they made in income over $117,000 per year throughout their lifetime they would not get more money, except (as everyone does) a cost of living increases, which the GOP is trying to take away too.
So raising the cap on the limit they have to make (to $250,000 as many advocate)before they don't have to pay any more into FICA (Social Security) does not mean the government will pay them more in Social Security income.
These numbers will increasefor 2015.
WE are in this pickle today because of a TEXAS democrat.
And?