╌>

Freedom of Speech Trumps Offensiveness on NYC Buses.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  perrie-halpern  •  11 years ago  •  20 comments

Freedom of Speech Trumps Offensiveness on NYC Buses.

A pro-Israel advocacy group known for publicly criticizing Islam can display its political advertisement containing the phrase "Hamas Killing Jews" on New York City's buses, a judge said.Judge John Koeltl said in a decision made public Tuesday that the advertisement is protected speech.

He said he was sensitive to the Metropolitan Transportation Authority's claim that the ad could incite violence and appreciates the efforts necessary to prevent violent attacks.

But he noted that substantially the same advertisement ran in San Francisco and Chicago in 2013 without incident. He added that examples of violent attacks cited by the MTA show that individuals may commit heinous acts without warning.

1876_discussions.jpg

"Under the First Amendment, the fear of such spontaneous attacks, without more, cannot override individuals' rights to freedom of expression," Koeltl said in a ruling dated Monday. He stayed the effect of the decision for a month so it can be appealed.

MTA spokesman Adam Lisberg said the agency is disappointed in the ruling and is reviewing its options.

It came in a lawsuit filed last year by the American Freedom Defense Initiative, an organization headed by blogger Pamela Geller that's behind the advertisement.

David Yerushalmi, a lawyer for the organization, said the decision "sends a strong message both to government bureaucrats who would restrict our freedom of speech based upon what they perceive to be a global jihadist threat, and it also sends a telling message to our enemies abroad and at home: Their threats of violence will not prevent the courts from upholding the First Amendment."

The lawsuit said Geller's group buys the advertisements to express its message on current events and public issues "including issues such as Islam's hatred of Jews."

The lawsuit was filed after the MTA notified the group in August that it would display three of four proposed advertisements but not an ad with the quote "Killing Jews is Worship that draws us close to Allah" because it could incite violence. In the ad, a covered face is shown next to the quote, which is attributed to "Hamas MTV." It is followed by the words: "That's his Jihad. What's yours?"

In a September statement, the MTA said it recognized that the rejected ad was a parody of "MyJihad" ads sponsored by the Council on American-Islamic Relations, which said it was promoting the concept that jihad is an individual and personal struggle rather than a violent conflict or terrorism.Koeltl said he recognized that the MTA believes it would be far more difficult to counter the advertisement because it has parodic aspects.

But he said he believes the agency underestimates "the power of counter-advertisements to explain that the MTA does not endorse the ad and that the ad is not to be taken seriously."

Monica Klein, a spokeswoman for Mayor Bill de Blasio, noted in a statement that the mayor has said "these anti-Islamic ads are outrageous, inflammatory and wrong, and have no place in New York City, or anywhere."

"These hateful messages serve only to divide and stigmatize when we should be coming together as one city," she added. "While those behind these ads only display their irresponsible intolerance, the rest of us who may be forced to view them can take comfort in the knowledge that we share a better, loftier and nobler view of humanity."
http://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/local/Killing-Jews-Ads-MTA-Buses-New-York-City-Judge-Ruling-300871681.html

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Where do you stand on this issue?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

I am trying not to be inflammatory on purpose.... it is the issue of freedom of speech v inflammatory that I am discussing. The sign is offensive, and that is stated in the title

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    11 years ago

Free Speech is a wonderful thing, as long as it fits our moral values or out personal Ideology, ....but when we don't agree with what is being said all of a sudden its not so FREE......

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

If he made the right decision.. then he not such an idiot.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

This is true LR.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

He isn't clueless since he understands the law a lot clearer than many other judges. His opinion might differ from yours. I happen to think that Geller is quite serious

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

The description in the article does not match the actual words on the poster, in my opinion.

You are correct, which is why I changed the title to the issue and not words that don't exist.

Hamas Killing Jews" could be "political

Not to much. When a Hamas says "Killing Jews is worship"... that is pretty awful in its own right.

which I suspect is where the opposition to the poster comes from.

The opposition comes from the fact that NYC has 103 mosques and our mayor doesn't want to offend and because we are an international city. People tend not to like harsh reality when on vacation. And let's face it, Pam Geller is trying to get a rise out of the Muslim community while spreading her message.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

No he didn't. He made the right ruling and then stated his opinion, which any judge can and does do. Again you might not agree with his opinion but he still made the right call.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

LMAO. Pass one in my direction...I start to drink at 4.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

The ad is clearly intended to not only be anti-Hamas, but anti-Muslim.

How is it anti-Muslim? Hamas is not all Muslims but a terrorist group.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

The Ad is a parody of a statement attributed to Hamas. Intimating that killing Jews is holy work.

at the same time, it is a parody of the "My Jihad" ad campaign sponsored by the Council on Islamic-American relations.

It ties Hamas and Islam relatively together, it does not say all Islamics are Hamas, it does not say all Hamas is Islamic. But it does relate the two together because they are related in intent. Some (read most, not all) of Hamas would like to see Israel eliminated and as many Jews as possible exterminated. Islam, is in the same boat but extends that thinking to all "Infidels", those who do not follow Islam.

That is the point of the ad in question. Although different, they are the same. The parody is that the ideals that Hamas has for Israel, are the same ideals that Islam has for the rest of the world.

Is it hate speech? not if you believe what both groups have freely spoken for and advocated.

This is the basis of the judges decision.

A very sound decision made despite his political leanings.

It is the way this nation is supposed to work.

Truth wins out over fear mongering every time.

Get over it.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

LMAO on the horse.

I'm sorry, but using one word doesn't make it about Muslims. I just don't agree with you. If the bus drove by fast, all anyone would see is Allah, with no context. It wouldn't be an insult. But in fact, the words that stick out are Jews, worship, Allah, followed by "That Jihad" which is kind of funny.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Not all speech is protected by the First Amendment, a lesson some need to learn.

If what Geller et al have to say is factually-based, then it is most likely protected speech/expression. The ultimate question is whether or not a particular expressed fact, one expressed in a particular venue, does anything to improve/correct/solve/mitigate or result in anything positive and useful, or, if it has any purpose other than to incite.

I could create a bus advertisement that is factual that might read

"IT IS A FACT THAT I AM OF THE OPINION THAT GELLER IS A HATER AND HAS NO OBJECTIVE BEYOND SPEWING HER HATRED TO SATISFY A PERSONAL AGENDA."

We all good with that freedom-of-speech item?

______________________________________________

For the record:

Numerous activities that do not involve the use of words have been held to be speech, while in some cases, use of language, both written and oral, may not be considered speech.

Examples of expressive conduct that have been held to be speech are wearing black armbands or burning the American flag to protest the Vietnam war.Although no words are spoken, the acts themselves are intended to communicate ideas and may be given the same protection as actual words.

On the other hand, the government may punish painting words on a public building (graffiti), or threatening to reveal damaging secrets if not paid (blackmail), even though that conduct involves written or spoken words.

2.Is it Protected Speech?

Next, it must be determined if the speech in question is protected by the First Amendment.

Certain kinds of speech have not been given constitutional protection.

For example, states may allow damage suits against persons who have made slanderous or libelous statements. Slander consists of orally making and libel consists of publishing false statements that are damaging to the reputation of another.

Another example of unprotected speech is incitement to illegal action.Someone who stands before a crowd and encourages them to start a riot would not receive First Amendment protection.

Fighting Words

Government may prohibit the use of fighting words, which is speech that is used to inflame another and that will likely incite physical retaliation.

Likewise, language that is meant to incite the masses toward lawless action is not protected. This can include speech that is intended to incite violence or to encourage the audience to commit illegal acts. The test for fighting words is whether an average citizen would view the language as being inherently likely to provoke a violent response

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

No problem with me Brother as long as the origin of the opinion is clearly revealed so one could deduce it is an opinion.

This is the same basis upon which the Nazi's get to publish their screed.

YES That is what I think is a whole lot different that "this is what you need to do"

100% agreement brother.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago

Tellme that the most globally prominent and recognized characteristics of Islam aren't terrorism and murdering others. If Muslims want a better image I'd suggest they root-out the extremism in their midst, that is by far more clearly defining Islam to the rest of the non-muslim world, than any other single Islamic characteristic.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

For the past year there has been an international campaign carried out even in the US State Department, in the White House, on US campuses, in the US media, and anywhere you care to look, verbally and written, that Israeli Jews indiscriminately murdered women and children without reasonable cause during the summer war with Gaza; that Israeli Jews illegally occupy land belonging to Palestinian Arabs; that Israeli Jews, by closing the border to Gaza condemns the Palestinians to hunger, lack of medicine, inadequate housing... the list is endless.

These accusations incite and inflame attacks against Jews in the United States and all over the world, yet are allowed in this country under the rule of free speech. Advertisements, meetings and seminars promoting BDS are allowed everywhere. What's the difference?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

This was a violation of the impasse rule . Apparently some people can't help but transgress against the rules regularly .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

or, if it has any purpose other than to incite.

Inciting opposition to violence is a positive thing IMO .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Inciting opposition to violence is a positive thing IMO .

I'll keep that in mind in the event we happen to meet; I wouldn't want to be a victim after all.

BTW, aren't you the guy who commented just yesterday about the gun violence in American cities?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

This is why the Court applies "Judgment" to the speech. The real thing is the intent of the speech, not the point the speech is making.

The point made may be very valid, the intent of the speaker with his speech may not be.

In the extant case, the point is sarcasm and ridicule of the Council on Islamic-American relations. Being based upon the stated precepts of both organizations, the basis is truth, and therefore not hate speech.

 
 

Who is online



154 visitors