Iran nuke deal is no deal at all
Iran nuke deal is no deal at all
By Jonah Goldberg, THE COMMERCIAL APPEAL
The first thing one needs to know about the nuclear deal with Iran is that it is not, in fact, a deal. The various parties to the talks did come away with an agreement, but it was an agreement to haggle more about what a deal might look like. We dont have a good word for such things, so people use deal as a placeholder.
But in any other realm of life, if you left a negotiation where things stand in Lausanne, Switzerland, you wouldnt think you had a deal. The known disagreements are profound, and the room for further disagreements is vast.
When you have a deal with a car salesman, money changes hands and papers are signed. But if you left a car dealership with this kind of understanding, you might never get a car, or you might expect that the salesman will ultimately sell you a new Porsche while the dealer is equally confident youll come down to the lot next weekend to pick up your used Zamboni.
The other thing you need to know is that even if the White House gets what it wants, that wont stop Iran from being able to get a nuclear bomb. No matter what, Iran keeps all of its research facilities and would ultimately be limited to a one-year breakout time. Also, nothing in the deal see, Im even doing it addresses ballistic missile development. So, in theory, Iran could have everything else ready to go, once it decides to sprint for a bomb.
President Obama is OK with all this because his larger goal is more ambitious than a mere arms control agreement with the worlds leading state sponsor of terror. He says he wants to bring Iran out of the cold, to break through (their) isolation and help them become a very successful regional power.
In February, a former National Security Council senior director, Michael Doran, showed in an article for Mosaic magazine that much of what passes for foreign policy dithering and incompetence can better be understood as Obamas attempts to seduce Iran into a new strategic role. The purpose of the nuclear talks is less about stopping the bomb as it is launching a new era of engagement with Iran. To keep the talks going, Obama has become Irans air force in Iraq, has let Vladimir Putin literally get away with murder in Ukraine, and has grown increasingly deaf to warnings, from the French to the Israelis to the Saudis.
To be fair, Obamas goal is a good one. A civilized Iranian regime would presumably stop supporting Hamas in Gaza, Hezbollah in Lebanon, Houthis in Yemen, Bashar Assad in Syria and Shiite militants in Iraq. Itd even stop routinely calling for the destruction of Israel and Death to America!
Who wouldnt want that?
No one denies itd be great if the ruling mullahs changed their stripes. No one disputes that it would be wonderful if the National Institutes of Health could make chewing gum that cures cancer, either.
The question is: Is a new Iran possible? And, just as important, if it is possible, are the costs worth it?
Theres little reason to believe the answer to the first question is yes. If the Iranian regime was interested in being a constructive member of the international community, it would have been acting like one already, right?
But maybe Obama sees something no one else does. At home and abroad, Obama has an invincible confidence that he understands everyones self-interest better than they do. Maybe, for once, hes right.
Unfortunately, the players in the region dont think so, which is why Sunni Saudi Arabia has launched a bloody proxy religious war with Shiite Iran and is even pondering its own nuclear weapons program. Israel, which would only gain from a reformed Iran, doesnt think Obamas quest for a legacy will pay off either.
Which brings us to the costs. So far, Obama has calculated that the bloodshed, chaos and frayed alliances are worth it if he can be remembered as the president who opened the door to Iran. Those benefits, if they ever arise, may come at the expense of losing a hell of a lot more.
Jonah Goldberg is a fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and a senior editor of National Review.
Tags
Who is online
130 visitors

Dream on.
A bad deal is a bad deal no matter how many synonymous phrases for "deal" you are capable of dreaming up. The article does not focus on parsing the word "deal", it indicates why it's a BAD deal.