╌>

The Growing Chorus Against the Iran Deal

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  buzz-of-the-orient  •  11 years ago  •  18 comments

The Growing Chorus Against the Iran Deal

The Growing Chorus Against the Iran Deal

By Max Boot, COMMENTARY

President Obama would like to pretend that anyone who opposes the nuclear deal with Iran that he is in the process of striking must be a warmongerbecause war is the (supposed) consequence of not doing a deal. But that charge is hard to level against some of the high-profile critics who had spoken out in recent days.

In the Wall Street Journal , former secretaries of State George Shultz (architect of the Intermediate Nuclear Forces Treaty with the Soviet Union) and Henry Kissinger (architect of the Strategic Arms Limitation Agreement with the USSR and the opening to China) blast Obamas deal-making. They warn that not only will the agreement be extremely difficult to enforce, it is unlikely sanctions will be reimposed even if Iran is caught cheating: Iran is in a position to violate the agreement by executive decision. Restoring the most effective sanctions will require coordinated international action.

The result of these talks, they warn, will be an increase in Irans regional power and a nuclear arms race in the Middle East:For the U.S., a decade-long restriction on Irans nuclear capacity is a possibly hopeful interlude. For Irans neighborswho perceive their imperatives in terms of millennial rivalriesit is a dangerous prelude to an even more dangerous permanent fact of life.Some of the chief actors in the Middle East are likely to view the U.S. as willing to concede a nuclear military capability to the country they consider their principal threat. Several will insist on at least an equivalent capability. Saudi Arabia has signaled that it will enter the lists; others are likely to follow. In that sense, the implications of the negotiation are irreversible.

On the Journal s website, Aaron David Miller (one of Bill Clintons chief negotiators in the 1990s working on a deal between Israel and the Palestinians) is even more starkwhat we know now, he writes , suggests thatthe mullahs got the better end of the deal. The U.S. went from seeking to dismantle a putative nuclear weapons program to trying to impose limitations on one, he explains. Score one for the mullahs. By the time a final agreement is reached, Irans right to enrich uranium and its nuclear infrastructure may be validated in a U.N. Security Council resolution. That would be another win for the mullahs. Finally Miller notes: its stunning that the president of the United States is protesting Mr. Netanyahus terrible statements about Israeli Arabs and not blasting Tehran for its human rights abuses.

Also in the Journal , William Galston (another former Bill Clinton aide and a veteran Democratic thinker) doesnt come out completely against the agreement but he advocates greatly strengthening it, in ways that, among others, the Israeli government has advocatedand that Obama is certain to reject. He also writes: Many of our traditional allies in the Middle East fear that they are being sacrificed to Mr. Obamas aspiration to achieve a historic breakthrough with the Islamic Republic. He should reassure them by strengthening U.S. security guarantees, pledging the long-term presence of U.S. military assets, and by acting far more forcefully against Iranian meddling in the internal affairs of other countries.. And finally, the Obama administration should relax its opposition to meaningful congressional involvement in vetting a final agreement.

Asked about the Kissinger-Shultz op-ed, the best that the State Department spokesman could do was to describe it as a lot of big words and big thoughts, as if thats a criticism. (Does this administration favor small words and small thoughts?) Wonder what the White House thinks about what Shultz, Kissinger, Miller, and Galston have said? Are they neocon warmongers too? Or is it just possible that they are reasonable centrists who have grave reservations about the unprecedented concessions that the president is making to a regime whose animating slogan is Death to America?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Don't worry, they'll just say they're right-wing warmongers and the source is biased. They cannot refute the facts, so that's what they'll do.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

I always thought the goal was to allow peaceful nuclear power and eliminate the ability to make a weapon. That was what the BO lead me to believe his stance was too. Just another in the long list of lies. Nothing to see here. Now we are negotiating when they will get a weapon.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

And the fact is it doesn't really matter. Iran wants one, they WILL get one. short of going to war (with boots on the ground) or bombing them with those nuclear weapons you don't want them to have, they will obtain nuclear capability.

The Saudis now want the same capability, they will get it, probably from us, If not us then France, without any of the angst currently shown over the Iranian nuclear program.

Iran wants a nuclear weapon so what happened to Iraq does not happen to them. I would say that such is pretty smart thinking. You always get the biggest gun your capable of handling sufficient to handle the threat. A nuclear Iran would not stop Russia or us for that matter from destroying them if we needed to, it's to prevent the others in the Mideast or Europe from entertaining it.

If I was them, it is what I would do.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Would you like to prove that what I post is "unjust bullshit" or are you going to stick with all you are capable of doing - attacking me and my source?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

If you want to put forth a legitimate argument, direct your criticism at russia and china. Those two nations are behind the success in iran's nuke progress, despite sanctions.

If China, at least, has been keeping Iran afloat during the sanctions period and turning a blind eye to Iran's nuclear development, IMO it won't change if there is an agreement anyway. I am now convinced that Iran having the bomb, and a number of other Middle East states playing "catch-up" and getting the bomb, is inevitable whether it happens now or in 10 years time. Considering their philosophy, I don't have much hope for human life to continue to exist in the future on our planet, notwithstanding Pakistan's restraint. Take your pick of the "Nuclear War movies" and put it in your crystal ball.

There is a common saying that "Art imitates life", whereas I have pointed out in many circumstances already that "Life imitates art".

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

real potential for peaceful diplomacy for once

1931_discussions.jpg?width=721

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

I'm not the author of the articles, but I think it's necessary to provide a little balance to your and a few others' love affair with everything the great Obama does, or else everyone will think that Newstalkers is just a promotion/propaganda site for your flawless (s/) POTUS. By the way, I'm not a citizen of China. China doesn't allow foreigners to become citizens, and I would never give up my Canadian citizenship anyway.

As for Israel, I doubt that Israel has committed any more wrongs than your "beloved" America so pot-kettle, as they say. As for where blame really belongs, that's a matter of opinion and I'm as entitled to mine as you are to yours. If my comments are unjust bullshit, so are yours.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

I just watched the movie "Threads" which Nowhere Man was good enough to post on NT. Since Iran is known to arm terrorists and back terrorism (Argentina is an example) give them the bomb and look forward to what I just watched.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

The problem with this site is that is has too many members who criticize what they have not experienced and really have no first hand knowledge about.. Armchair critics.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

What kind of argument is that, Max. You say I'm "afraid" to criticize the government? I never said I was "afraid". I just happen to be smart enough to not want to be punished for doing something I have neither the need nor desire to do. Tell me something Max, are you "afraid" of killing someone, or do you just want to obey the law of the country you live in? Are you critical of being punished for disobeying the laws of the country you live in? Let's try NOT to be hypocritical, eh Max?

To set the record straight, I'm going to write an article on what it's like for me, as an expatriate Canadian, to live in China, so I can in that way correct the prejudices I have to deal with on NT.

I buy logical arguments, so to JohnRussell I say "touchee", (something he NEVER says to me) but not to you.

 
 

Who is online



130 visitors