╌>

Obama and the ‘Inevitable Critics’

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  buzz-of-the-orient  •  11 years ago  •  6 comments

Obama and the ‘Inevitable Critics’

Obama and the Inevitable Critics

By Bret Stephens, Wall Street Journal, April 7, 2015

We are dealing with a case of Mutually Assured Obfuscation .

So when you hear the inevitable critics of the deal sound off, ask them a simple question: Do you really think that this verifiable deal, if fully implemented, backed by the worlds major powers, is a worse option than the risk of another war in the Middle East?

That was Barack Obama on Thursday, defending his Iran diplomacy while treating its opponents to the kind of glib contempt that is the mark of the progressive mind. Since Im one of those inevitable critics, let me answer his question.

Yes, its worse. Much worse.

Yes, because what the president calls this verifiable deal fails the first test of verificationmutual agreement and clarity as to what, exactly, is in it.

Take sanctions. Iran insists all sanctionseconomic as well as nuclearwill be immediately revoked and that the P5+1 member countries are committed to restraining from imposing new nuclear-related sanctions. But the Obama administration claims Iran will only get relief if it verifiably abides by its commitments. The administration adds that the architecture of U.S. nuclear-related sanctions on Iran will be retained for much of the duration of the deal.

So who is lying? Or are we dealing with a case of Mutually Assured Obfuscation?

Yes, too, because the deal fails the second test of verification: It cant be verified.

Here again there are significant discrepancies between the U.S. and the Iranian versions of the deal. The administration claims Iran has agreed to implement the Additional Protocol, a reference to an addendum to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty that permits intrusive inspections. But Tehran merely promises to implement the protocol on a voluntary and temporary basis, pending eventual ratification by its parliament, inshallah.

Weve seen this movie before. Iran agreed to implement the Additional Protocol in 2003, only to renounce it in early 2006, after stonewalling weapons inspectors.

But even the Protocol is inadequate, since it doesnt permit no-notice, anytime, anywhere inspections. A verifiable agreement would require unfettered access to all key facilities, personnel, documentation, and other information being sought, notes Olli Heinonen, a former top nuclear inspector for the International Atomic Energy Agency. The Protocol, he adds, does not fully oblige this.

Yes, as well, because Mr. Obamas caveat, if fully implemented, is catnip to the rulers of Iran. What happens if Iran complies with every aspect of the accord, save onefor instance, if it starts fielding more advanced centrifuges?

The Iranian regime cheats incrementally, not egregiously, even though the sum total of its incremental cheating is egregious, says Mark Dubowitz of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies. Does anyone think Mr. Obama will walk away from his deal at the first instance of Iranian noncompliance? This is a president who failed to inform Congress of Russias suspected violations of a 1987 nuclear arms-control treaty so he could get his own treaty ratified by the Senate in 2010.

Yes, furthermore, because a deal that is backed by the worlds major powers, as Mr. Obama says, is also beholden to those powers.

That would include the Europeans, who will re-enter the Iranian market with the animal spirits of famished poodles . It will include the Chinese, eager to extend their new economic silk road through Persia. It will include Russia, which will invest even more heavily in Iranthink nuclear reactors and advanced surface-to-air missile systemswhile holding Iran policy hostage to its own demands in Ukraine and elsewhere. Of all the flaws in this deal, none is so fatal as the subordination of the U.S. to the U.N. on the most consequential diplomatic agreement so far in the 21st century.

***

It is typically crass of Mr. Obama that he should try to justify his failed diplomacy with the false alternative of a hypothetical war. If John Kerry were half as canny a negotiator as Javad Zarif, wed have a better deal in hand.

But lets accept the presidents premise. Should the current deal hold, Iran will be able to develop all the nuclear infrastructure it wants by the time my youngest child is in college. And it will do so not over Washingtons objections, but with our blessing.

Maybe by then the Iranian regime will have changed for the better. More likely not. Their economy will have revived thanks to the end of sanctions. Their geopolitical position will be stronger thanks to the internal convulsions of some of their neighbors. And they will have a nuclear infrastructure capable of producing many bombs on short noticetoo short for the U.S. to do anything about it. The same will likely be true of Saudi Arabia and Turkey.

So let me rephrase the presidents question: Is targeted military action against Irans nuclear facilitieswith all the unforeseen consequences that might entaila better option than a grimly foreseeable future of a nuclear Iran, threatening its neighbors, and a proliferated Middle East, threatening the world?

I know my answer. Whats yours?

http://www.wsj.com/articles/bret-stephens-obama-and-the-inevitable-critics-1428361609?mod=hp_opinion


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

We are yet to see if Iran will agree to inspections, which ones they will permit, but please note that they will NOT include "no-notice, anytime, anywhere" inspections. Surely Iran is smart enough to get around that one.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Len.... Is that you?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

LOL!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Mutually Assured Obfuscation ...

Got it ... MAO ...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Well Iran says they're going to get on with the program and Obama says we got em. Read my lips, oops sorry, writing, THERE WILL BE NO MORE SANCTIONS NO MATTER WHAT!!!!

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Len.... Is that you?

I guess you mean that to be a backhanded insult. I am not Len, and I do not always agree with him so can apologize if you have any integrity.

Perhaps there is some opinion in the article but I am amused that that is all you can see. What you are ignoring in order to maintain your praise for such a great deal and your unabatable loyalty to Obama and the belief in everything he tells you are the FACTS in the article that cannot be denied.

INSPECTIONS - ONES THAT CAN CATCH THE IRANIANS CHEATING WHICH THEY ARE APT TO DO - IS WHAT IS NEEDED, AND THEY ARE NOT PROPERLY DEALT WITH IN THE "DEAL". That is what this article is really about.

 
 

Who is online



140 visitors