How should we punish grandma and grandpa for opposing gay marriage?
Conor Friedersdorf, a libertarian and supporter of gay marriage whos nonetheless horrified by the mobbing of Memories Pizza, wonders what sort of discipline the Lords of Tolerance have in mind for dissenters on SSM . Because the dissenters arent all white, rural, red-state small-business owners, the sort of person a committed SJW might be looking for a reason to stomp. Some of them are immigrants. Some of them are gasp black. Lets lay down some rules, says Friedersdorf. What punishments are we imagining for felony thoughtcrime in refusing to serve a gay wedding?
The question Id ask those who want to use non-state means to punish mom-and-pop businesses that decline to cater gay weddings is what, exactly, their notion of a fair punishment is. Nearly every supporter of gay marriage is on board with efforts to publicly tell people that their position is wrongheadedIve participated in efforts like that for years and insist that respectful critique and persuasion is more effective than shaming. What about other approaches? If their Yelp rating goes down by a star does the punishment fit the crime? Is there a financial loss at which social pressure goes from appropriate to too much? How about putting them out of business? Digital mobs insulting them and their children? Email and phone threats from anonymous Internet users? If you think that any of those go too far have you spoken up against the people using those tactics?
A relatively big digital mob has been attacking this powerless family in rural Indiana, but I dont get the sense that its participants have reflected on or even thought of these questions. I dont think they recognize how ugly, intolerant and extreme their actions appear or the effect theyll have on Americans beyond the mainstream media, or that their vitriolic shaming these people has ultimately made them into martyrs. I fear that a backlash against their tactics will weaken support for the better angels of the gay rights movement at a time when more progress needs to be made, and that theyre turning traditionalists into a fearful, alienated minority with a posture of defensiveness that closes them off to persuasion
Id be fascinated to [know] how many grandparents of mob participants oppose gay marriage and what degree of social stigma they would want directed toward them .
Ah, but what if grandma and grandpa are only pretending to oppose gay marriage because they want to be attacked by a left-wing mob and have a sympathetic GoFundMe page started for them ? Bet you didnt think about that, huh?
There will, I suspect, eventually be some navel-gazing among the media about the mob atmospherics in punishing gay-marriage opponents. Noah had a good joke about that a few days ago on Twitter: Looking forward to the introspective think pieces next year on whether Memories Pizza really deserved total ruin over the online mobs pique. Im sure there are some liberal/media consciences that are bothered by whats happened here, just as there were when the left demagogued the living hell out of conservatives for their rhetoric after Gabby Giffords was shot. There were some misgivings expressed about that after the fact, as I recall long after the fact, when the mob had dissipated and the author was at no risk in criticizing them. Same thing here. Expect some clear-eyed reflection from the media about the Memories Pizza saga circa late summer/early fall.
Contra Friedersdorf, though, I think most gay-rights mobbers do recognize how ugly, intolerant and extreme their actions appear. They just dont care and they dont feel they should have to. Some of that spirit of nastiness is revanchism at work, nicely expressed in cartoons like this and this that liberal trolls have been tweeting at me. Gays have spent centuries in the closet, afraid to reveal their sexuality publicly; now its time to wreck a few Christians lives in the name of rough justice, to see how they like it. Some of it is a tactical thing: If Memories Pizza took a worse beating than they deserved, well, thats a lesson to other business owners who might be disinclined to cater a gay wedding, pour encourager les autres . And some of it is just the pleasure of cruelty for its own sake, aimed at someone whom its now socially acceptable (on the left, at least) to be cruel to. http://hotair.com/archives/2015/04/03/how-should-we-punish-grandma-and-grandpa-for-opposing-gay-marriage/

But having Pizza for a wedding should be. How goshe.
TMI, TMI, TMI