╌>

Republicans Learn to Play Hardball

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  30 comments

Republicans Learn to Play Hardball

Politics can be aspirational, though mostly its just transactionala straight-up game of giving and getting. The lefts tantrum this week over the stalled nomination of Loretta Lynch is a reminder to Republicans that their best bet for notching any accomplishments during this Congress is to keep it nakedly transactional.

Ms. Lynchs vote to become attorney general is on hold for precisely one reason: Democrats wont play ball on a bill to combat human sex trafficking. This is legislation, note, that is as bipartisan as it comes. It was jointly authored by Republican John Cornyn and Democrat Amy Klobuchar, and co-sponsored by much of the Senate. Majority Leader Mitch McConnell followed regular order, and Democrats gave unanimous consent to move the bill.

Yet suddenly faced with the real prospect of doing something productiveafter six, long years of hiding from votesthe Senate Democratic caucus wigged out. (Debate? Vote? How does one do those things?) Desperate to revert to comfortable dysfunction, Democrats suddenly discovered language in the bill that upholds a prohibition against the federal funding of abortions.

Yes, it is language that has been in law for 37 years and yes, it was in the bill all along, and yes, Democrats had voted for it unanimously in committee, and yes they had voted for it unanimously last year in an appropriations bill. But Minority Leader Harry Reid needed a reason to balk, and the abortion language had the side benefit of allowing Democrats to revive the Republican war on women. They filibustered.

At which point, something new happened. Mr. McConnell made clear that so long as he didnt get his trafficking bill, Democrats didnt get Ms. Lynch. He would devote the rest of this week to the Cornyn-Klobuchar legislation, next week would be about the budget, the week after that would be Easter recess, and so on. Lets hope Ms. Lynch enjoys Sudoku. No give, no get.

Democrats are furious, though watching them try to shame Mr. McConnell into moving up a vote on the first black woman nominee for AG is amusing. Someone had the bad idea to roll out Sen. Dick Durbin (D., Ill.), who compared Ms. Lynch to Rosa Parks, railing that Republicans were making her sit in the back of the bus.

This would be the same Dick Durbin who filibustered Janice Rogers Brown (the first black woman nominee to the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals) and who kicked off the bus Miguel Estrada (the first Hispanic nominee to that court)filibustering him seven times over 28 months, until he withdrew his nomination. Progress, thy name is not Dick Durbin.

Similarly laughable are Democratic claims that Ms. Lynch has now waited longer than any AG nominee since Ed Meese in 1985. That number only works if it includes all the time last year that Mr. Reid, who was still running the Senate (remember that?), didnt act on her nomination http://www.wsj.com/articles/kim-strassel-republicans-learn-to-play-hardball-1426805918


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Well done. If the Demo want to be obstructive, it should be boldly advertised as such.
 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

As is yours. And they only reason you comment is to throw your typical one-line negativity against any bipartisan relationships.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Actually your taking a non-issue and making it a basis point to stop legislation. The party after, what was it, 7 or 8 unanimous approvals on a law that has been on the books for almost 40 years are now hanging their hats on THAT?

Absolutely ludicrous!

The more the Democrats do this stuff, the more they are showing the American people who has been blocking legislation for the last few years.

Which means that the Democrats in office now refuse to do anything unless they get what they want and to hell with anyone else.

I hope they keep it up.

2016 is coming and we need all the ammo we can get.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago

Comment deleted as a personal attack. D

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
The democrats are now filibustering a bill they co-sponsored and passed out of committee. How do you deal with that level of crazy?
Of course, when the abortionist money starts demanding attention, the democrats drop everything. Abortionists say jump! Democrats say "how high?"Abortion ber alles.
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Your self-awareness of the recent history of your own party is stunningly pathetic.

How about enlightening us John. Personally I don't want Lynch anyway since I see her as Eric Holder in drag and would only be changing the name and the clothes if she were to become the new Attorney General.

I believe the Republicans need to go back to the Nuclear Option like Harry Reid did. Don't you think that would be fair? After all the Republicans were unable to get anything passed for the last six years, were blamed for obstruction when it was Harry Reid who was the real obstructionist.

I'm getting a little tired of Obama hiring people to work for him instead of the citizens of this country.

If you are unable to debate my comment without a "Your self-awareness of the recent history of your own party is stunningly pathetic" comment, then please just keep it to yourself as I've stated my feelings, whether you like it or not is not my problem. Try and see if you can enlighten us some as you seem to have all the answers hidden deep inside your head and it's not worth your time to actually express them in an intelligent manner.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
My facts are correct, Mr. Sinclair Lewis fan.

Discuss them.
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

When the Right won majorities in both houses, they claimed that they would now show us what real leadership was.

What do you think about the Nuclear Option now that the Republicans have control JW? I mean harry reid did it. Then the majority would have the power and we would have to fight over those 9 votes any longer. I say what's good for the goose is good for the gander, would you say so?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

2. The Republicans are trying to set a precedent by re-labeling "fines" as "taxes."

Don't you just love it when you hear things like that. It sounds like "fees/fines" as "taxes" doesn't it? Remember that? What's good for the goose is good for the gander. Republicans need to get rid of the filibuster rule until further notice.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Gentlemen, please stick to the subject and refrain from the personal attacks. D

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Look about jwc.. it was handled.

Cerenkov, I know you can do better.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Wall Street Journals Kim Strassel:

"It is language that has been in law for 37 years and yes, it was in the bill all along, and yes, Democrats had voted for it unanimously in committee, and yes they had voted for it unanimously last year in an appropriations bill. But Minority Leader Harry Reid needed a reason to balk, and the abortion language had the side benefit of allowing Democrats to revive the Republican war on women.

The Washington Post Editorial Board:

" legislation to combat human trafficking cited concerns with language they claimed would greatly expand the reach of Hyde Amendment restrictions on abortion. But when John Cornyn (R-Tex.), chief sponsor of the trafficking bill and Senate majority whip, offered a compromise that would seem to answer their stated objections, it was rejected out of hand. Perhaps Democrats thought they could score political points, or maybe they didnt want to anger their traditional allies in the abortion rights lobby. Either way, it became depressingly clear that what they werent thinking about was the needs of vulnerable people, mostly young women and girls, who are the victims of sex trafficking...

Democrats unfortunately seem to believe that response is in their political interest. Not only are Republicans denied boasting rights for getting something done, but also Democrats dont risk running afoul of the abortion rights groups that are scoring the vote"


Even the Washigton Post sees through the BS rationalization the Democrats are belatedly offering for filibustering a bill they unanimously passed through committee. It's about kowtowing to the abortion industry that gives the party millions of dollars and obstructing just to make the Republicans look bad.

Who cares about the innocent victims who are being trafficked when money and politics are at stake? says the democrats.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Hey guys... much better! A question and an answer.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago

Lost amidst all this is the fact that there are now more humans being trafficked then ever before in recorded human history. Arguing politics is obviously vastly more important than putting a kibosh on selling children for sexual torture.

Pitiful

;^(

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

I'm not sitting here watching everything you say JW, actually. I just came back and saw you had posted a comment. Be patient and I'm also on chat. If you put a comment up and I don't jump on it and respond immediately, you can contact me on Chat and let me know.

Can you dispute the facts, Six?

I assume this is what you are talking about and yes I can dispute facts. The fact is both parties use anything they can to get their way and this is no different. The Democrats are using this to not pass the one bill and the Republicans are using it to keep from nominating Lynch. Anything they can do to keep from making Lynch our next Attorney General within the law of the land is fine with me. I don't want her as I see she has already given herself away basically saying an illegal immigration policy Obama has promoted by executive order is not the pardon the punk "way we do business here" although it really is.

Now if you want to answer a question for me, don't you think the Republicans should get rid of the filibuster until further notice if they really want to be as fair as Harry Reid was?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Ms. Lynchs vote to become attorney general is on hold for precisely one reason: Democrats wont play ball on a bill to combat human sex trafficking.

Which has absolutely nothing to do with Lynch's confirmation!

Democrats discovered that tucked inside the bill was a controversial provision that would bar the fund from being used to pay for abortions for the victims, except in cases of rape or incest, or if the life of the woman were in jeopardy.Congress has been inserting similar languageoften known as the Hyde amendment into annual spending bills for the past four decades.The differences between those efforts and this one, though, is that budget riders arent permanentthey need to be reauthorized each yearand that theprevious provisions only concerned taxpayer dollars, not criminal penalties like the ones that would pay for the victims fund. (Republicans already wont let taxpayer money directly fund abortions; Democrats dont want that ban to extend to other government-collected cash.)

It remains unclear exactly how directly the Hyde language would impact victims of human trafficking under the billmany would appear to still be able to use the restitution fund for an abortion under the rape exemptionbut liberals fear the provision would set a dangerous precedent for Republicans to exploit down the road. The bill as written, according to Reids office , could lead to a dramatic expansion of abortion restrictions in future years.

Adding some intrigue to the somewhat wonky sticking point is that the legislationcomplete with the controversial abortion languageactually managed to sail through the Senate Judiciary Committee last month without Democrats so much as noticing it. The provision itself is on Pages 4 and 5 of the 68-page bill , although whoever wrote it appears to have gone to considerable lengths to avoid actually using the word abortion . Instead the provision makes a rather convoluted reference to the Hyde amendment, declaring that the victims fund shall be subject to the limitations on the use or expending of amounts described in sections 506 and 507 of division H of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2014 ... to the same extent as if amounts in the Fund were funds appropriated under division H of such Act.

What do you want me to tell you? We missed it! Sen. Dick Durbin, the chambers No. 2 Democrat, told Politico last week when asked why Democrats didnt recognize the language. It was an obscure reference. Clearly if it had been front and center, we would have caught it.

Democrats blame Republicans for circulating a legislative briefing that conveniently failed to mention the abortion provision, and Chairman Patrick Leahy claims he and the rest of the judiciary panels Democrats were assured it wasnt in the bill. Republicans, meanwhile, say that wasnt the caseand furthermore contend Democrats had plenty of chances to actually read the bill for themselves.

Regardless of the disputes origins, though, it appears likely to derail a planned procedural vote on the bill tentatively set for Tuesday. Republicans would need at least six Democrats to break with their party to avoid a filibuster.

Let's tell the whole story, shall we?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Let's tell the whole story, shall we?

I agree and I also suggest we play by the same rules Harry Reid decided to play by and get rid of the possibility of a filibuster. I think the name of the article was "Republicans Learn To Play Hardball" wasn't it? Well I'd say they're still playing softball and need to take some lessons from Harry Reid and learn how to really play hardball if they want to be more effective, wouldn't you say so?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Well then JW, are penalties paid in cash fines?

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
SCOTT'S says they ate the sane thing, in some situations at least.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The point is that no money collected by and spent by the federal government should be used to pay for abortion except for rape, incest, and life of the mother at risk.

No. The point is, legislators shouldn't hold the country hostage on important matters to placate their base on matters not in any way related to the issue at hand.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

So calling the Taxes and Fines contained within Obamacare "Fees" wasn't the exact same thing?

If I remember right, the Supremes said if they were "Fees" (as the administration was claiming them to be) then Obamacare under the commerce clause, would be unconstitutional. The Court ruled that they were actually taxes, administered and collected by the IRS, That made the claimed "FEES" taxes, and based upon a states police power to levy taxes Obamacare was constitutional.

IF such is bad for Republicans and is nothing but a slinky slimey subterfuge, what do you call it when the Democrats do it?

I guess we really do see what the problem is. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

It's not good, but that IS the way it works in our type of government.

WE both know this.

What gets me is democrats spout off about how bad it is when republicans do it, but they remain silent when democrats do it, like the four years of Harry (no bill shall be read) Reid when he was in control.

If it is as bad as all that, would you at least agree that it is bad when Democrats do it?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

A penalty can be paid with any monetary instrument. But a fine is not a tax.

Well, thank you very much for clarifying that with the two definitions. I think that is pretty clear to me as well. Obama seemed to think the same thing when discussing the Obamacare mandate, although he knew as always he had other intentions for later on when he said a penalty or fine was not a tax .

But the strange thing is his attorneys argued before the Supreme Court the penalty/fine/fee was really a tax . Do you have any idea why? I mean do you have any idea why he didn't want to tell the "stupid Americans" using Grubber's words, not mine, what they were going to do when the mandate went to the Supreme Court?

Another thing, do you know of any tax the Federal Government has put on people for things they didn't buy? If you do, other than the ACA, then tell me, since I don't. Well, I know they have penalties/fines/fees they can charge a person who doesn't purchase a product or participate in a government required activity, but not a tax .

So it stands to reason Roberts went out of his way unconstitutionally to rewrite the Constitution to make the Obamacare mandate fine a tax . So now that sets a precedence where you can now be charged a tax by the United States Government if you don't buy a product . I mean, you don't have to put these solar panels up, but if you don't you will have to pay a penalty, I mean tax for not doing so.

Here are two videos, one of Obama knowing he was lying through his teeth and the other one of his attorneys lying through their teeth. The first one is Obama being interviewed by George Stephanopoulos, well I think this will say it better than me....

In this Sept. 2009 interview with ABC's George Stephanopoulos, President Obama argues over and over and over that the individual mandate penalty was NOT a tax . He says it flatly and repeatedly. Then the admin. does a 180 and argued in court that is actually IS a tax . Now John Roberts and the 4 liberal Justices on the Supreme Court have decided that the law can stand because it IS a tax . We have been lied to - flatly and repeatedly.

Published on Jul 9, 2012

'Obama Solicitor General Argued Before Supreme Court that ObamaCare Mandate is a Tax'

Barack Obama travelled far and wide promoting ObamaCare, promising that the middle class would not have their taxes raised, promising everyone the moon.

Meanwhile as ObamaCare was being rammed through Congress, anyone who considered the ObamaCare mandate a tax was put in a box, labeled as an extremist, a right-wing radical.

When twenty-six states challenged the constitutionality of ObamaCare, Obama's own Solicitor General, in order to cover all the bases, argued before the Supreme Court that the Mandate was in fact a tax.

When Chief Justice Roberts sided with the liberal wing of the Supreme Court and concurred with Obama to allow Congress to literally compel any behavior by simply taxing the American people, Obama and his surrogates had the audacity to state that the Mandate was in fact not a tax.

Does Obama think the American people are stupid? Does he think that we exist within the confines of Orwell's dystopian novel 1984 where the past is shoved into a memory hole?

The Supreme Court oral argument transcripts, the audio, clearly have Solicitor General Donald Verrilli arguing that the mandate is in fact a tax. And if that is the case Obama has lied on two counts: 1. That he wouldn't raise taxes on the middle class. 2. That the Mandate was not a tax.

When exactly the American people will become disgusted with this man's lies; with his Attorney General's lies; with the constant lies that proceed out of his Administration bolstered by his media palace guards, remains to be seen.

Let us hope it is soon.

Unfortunately it hasn't stopped.

So you cleared that up and showed me you knew the difference, but you have one more question you haven't addressed and that is do you think the Republicans could learn how to play hardball a little better by learning from Harry Reid and using the "Nuclear Option" so they don't have to worry about a filibuster?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

It's not good, but that IS the way it works in our type of government.

Which is why I wrote "legislators" rather than "Republicans."

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

I know Brother, let me apologize for using your post to make sure the point was made.

But it needed to be spotlighted. It is not a Political issue, it is a functioning government issue. Smile.gif

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

This is the Right's typical ploy. It's an attempt to backdoor a precedent by inserting a reference to language contain in another bill entirely in an effort to call taxes and fines the same thing.

It's low, underhanded, sneaky, rotten and typical of the Right.

So using your logic that "It's low, underhanded, a sneaky, rotten and typical of the Right, well maybe we should just say "low, underhanded, sneaky and rotten" and leave out the "Right" as you will have to add the "Left" with that argument after I pointed out and proved without a shadow of a doubt in my previous comments on the page before this one that is exactly what Obama did with the ACA mandate in the comments above and we don't want to do that now, do we? The comments were above but now they're a page back. They completely go over it and show without a shadow of a doubt including two videos, one of Obama repeatedly saying the mandate was not a tax and the other video of Obama's Solicitor General arguing to the Supreme Court the mandate was a tax.

Do you see what I mean, both parties basically do the same thing, so why is it "low, underhanded, sneaky and rotten" when you say the Republicans are doing it and all nice and goody when the Democrats do exactly same thing?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

But it needed to be spotlighted. It is not a Political issue, it is a functioning government issue.

No apology necessary; you were right to spotlight it and put it in the proper perspective.

Just got back to my laptop or I would have posted this sooner.

 
 

Who is online