╌>

Israel's Best Friend: an Article by Bestselling Author Thomas L. Friedman From the New York Times

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sixpick  •  11 years ago  •  10 comments

Israel's Best Friend: an Article by Bestselling Author Thomas L. Friedman From the New York Times
The only question I have when it comes to President Obamaand Israelis whether he is the most pro-Israel president in history or just one of the most.

Why? Because the question of whether Israel has the need and the right to pre-emptively attack Iranas it develops a nuclear potential is one of the most hotly contested issues on the world stage today. It is also an issue fraught with danger for Israel and American Jews, neither of whom want to be accused of dragging America into a war, especially one that could weaken an already frail world economy.

In that context, President Obama, in his interview with The Atlantics Jeffrey Goldberg and in his address to Aipac, the pro-Israel lobby, offered the greatest support for Israel that any president could at this time: He redefined the Iran issue. He said rightly that it was not simply about Israels security, but about U.S. national security and global security.

Obama did this by making clear that allowing Iran to develop nuclear weaponsand then containing it the way the U.S. contained the Soviet Union was not a viable option, because if Iran acquires a nuclear bomb, all the states around it would seek to acquire one as well. This would not only lead to a nuclear Middle East, but it would likely prompt other countries to hedge their commitments to the global Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty. The global nuclear black market would then come alive and we would see the dawning of a more dangerous world.

Preventing Iran from getting a nuclear weapon isnt just in the interest of Israel, it is profoundly in the security interests of the United States, the president told The Atlantic. If Iran gets a nuclear weapon, this would run completely contrary to my policies of nonproliferation. The risks of an Iranian nuclear weapon falling into the hands of terrorist organizations are profound. ... It would also provide Iran the additional capability to sponsor and protect its proxies in carrying out terrorist attacks, because they are less fearful of retaliation. ... If Iran gets a nuclear weapon, I wont name the countries, but there are probably four or five countries in the Middle East who say, We are going to start a program, and we will have nuclear weapons. And at that point, the prospect for miscalculation in a region that has that many tensions and fissures is profound. You essentially then duplicate the challenges of India and Pakistan fivefold or tenfold. In sum, the president added, The dangers of an Iran getting nuclear weapons that then leads to a free-for-all in the Middle East is something that I think would be very dangerous for the world.

Every Israeli and friend of Israel should be thankful to the president for framing the Iran issue this way. It is important strategically for Israel, because it makes clear that dealing with the Iranian nuclear threat was not Israels problem alone. And it is important politically, because this decision about whether to attack Iran is coinciding with the U.S. election. The last thing Israel or American friends of Israel Jewish and Christian want is to give their enemies a chance to claim that Israel is using its political clout to embroil America in a war that is not in its interest.

That could easily happen because backing for Israel today has never been more politicized. In recent years, Republicans have tried to make support for Israel a wedge issue that would enable them to garner a higher percentage of Jewish votes and campaign contributions, which traditionally have swung overwhelmingly Democratic. This has led to an arms race with the Democrats over who is more pro-Israel and over-the-top declarations, like Newt Gingrichs that the Palestiniansare an invented people.

And it could easily happen because money in politics has never been more important for running campaigns, and the Israel lobby both its Jewish and evangelical Christian wings has never been more influential, because of its ability to direct campaign contributions to supportive candidates.

As such, no one should want domestic electoral politics mixed up with the Iran decision, which is why it was so important that the president redefined the Iran problem as a global proliferation threat and grounded his decision-making in American realism, not politics.

Reports from the Aipac convention this week indicated that those advocating military action were getting the loudest cheers. Id invite all those cheering to think about all the unintended and unanticipated consequences of the Iraq war or Israels 1982 invasion of Lebanon. Thats not a reason for paralysis. Its a reason to heed Obamas call to give diplomacy and biting sanctions a chance to work, while keeping the threat of force on the table.

If it comes to war, let it be because the ayatollahs were ready to sacrifice their whole economy to get a nuke and, therefore, America the only country that can truly take down Iran's nuclear program had to act to protect the global system, not just Israel. I respect that this is a deadly serious issue for Israel which has the right to act on its own but President Obama has built a solid strategic and political case for letting America take the lead.

~~Link~~
Remember this article is 3 years old. That's the thing with evolution, I guess.

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    11 years ago

Today

The White House has lost Thomas Friedman on Iran

posted at 6:01 pm on March 18, 2015 by Noah Rothman

The strategic blunders of the opponents of a prospective nuclear accord with Iran keep piling up.

First, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahus disastrous decision to address a joint session of Congress just weeks before his countrys parliamentary elections galvanized the Iran deals opponents. On Tuesday, he won a dramatic victory for a fourth term as prime minister.

Second, the Senate GOPs open letter to the government of the Islamic Republic warning that the upper chamber of Congress would have to ratify a deal in order for it to outlast the Obama presidency has also failed to reflect negatively the letters signers. Two recent Rasmussen Reports surveys found that 60 percent of the public believes an Iran deal is unlikely to prevent the state from nuclearizing, and another 60 percent believe the 47 Republican senators were right and Congress should play a role in nuclear negotiations with Iran.

In fact, the president has been put so far back on his heels over his rush toward a nuclear agreement that even his erstwhile allies are questioning the logic of the diplomatic push. The latest of the administrations friends to get cold feet over the White Houses policy toward Iran is New York Times columnist Tom Freidman. In his most recent piece , Friedman wonders, given that the White House has facilitated the expansion of Iranian influence across the region, why the administration thinks it can compel Tehran to accept a deal that limits its ability to nuclearize at a time of its choosing.

Geopolitics is all about leverage, and we are negotiating with Iran without the leverage of a credible threat of force, Friedman wrote.

He went on to note that, while the threat posed by the abhorrent Islamic State is a grave one, its a questionable U.S. policy to welcome Irans service as a proxy army in that war. Why are we, for the third time since 9/11, fighting a war on behalf of Iran? he pondered.

Politico went on to summarize Friedmans fatalistic take on Irans growing influence and what he believes is Tehrans understanding of the limited upsides associated with a nuclear deal:

Though Republicans have criticized the president for working toward what Netanyahu calls a bad deal, many supporters of the negotiations remain hopeful that a final agreement will stave off a nuclear Iran and reincorporate the regime into the international community.

Friedman believes this is pure fantasy. [T]he past has carved so much scar tissue into that landscape that its hard to see anything healthy or beautiful growing out of it anytime soon.

Sorry to be so grim, the columnist concludes.

Its perhaps slightly less than a canary in the coal mine to learn that Friedman has grown uncomfortable with Irans creeping influence over the Middle East, but it is a welcome sight nonetheless.

~Link~

I find it strange when France is having second questions and saying to themselves, "Why such a big hurry?" Also I find it strange how Netanyahu can get the racist treatment and a very late call from Obama after he won the election by a greater margin than any other Prime Minister in the history of Israel. We know the State Department has put lots of money and one of obama's most important strategist in Israel to help overthrow Netanyahu and Obama lost badly. Condemning Netanyahu while Iran has a number of American prisoners, the last 7 females running for office have been disqualified. Stoning if your raped and executed if you kill your rapist doesn't sound too good. Even the young people who made a video of he song "Happy" were put in jail. We're not dealing with but one person there and he is the Supreme leader like I feel Obama is jealous of, since he doesn't have to deal with a Constitution.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

The link doesn't work . In 3 years things can change a lot ...

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

That's right, Petey. Three years ago was when Obama wanted Jewish money for his upcoming re-election campaign.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    11 years ago

The link doesn't work . In 3 years things can change a lot ...

Hey Petey, it does now. That's what you get when you just type ~~Link~~ instead of making it a link. Thanks for telling me. Here it is again done correctly. ~~Link~~

The fact is in the article Obama as usual has a completely different perspective in his speeches and intentions 3 years ago when he needed something and now he's ready to throw them under the bus as he has thrown so many others. I just can't understand how he can be so opaque to so many and so transparent to so many others. It's the 8th wonder of the world.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago

Hell, he even told Russia, but nobody seemed to care...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    11 years ago

I don't think Obama is that smart. I just think he can read a teleprompter good, has a good voice for making speeches, although it is getting old listening to him lie every time he opens his mouth with many many speeches on video to prove it is true. And most of all, Obama has a cult like following who would support him no matter what he did or said.

He has bullied the American people, those who don't support him, and fooled the rest who do support him for over 6 years now. I keep wondering if they will ever see the transparency quite a few of us see in Obama one day. He has been slapped down every time he has tried the same tactics outside this country especially in the Israel election where he had his brown shirts working overtime in trying to oust Netanyahu, who won the election for Prime Minister by the greatest margin in the history of Israel, even though the MSM promoted the idea it was going to be so close and Netanyahu would probably lose right up until even past the final day.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
Obama's also willing to say anything for his own advancement. A man without scruples who can fool others into believing that he does can do significant damage.
 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago

Well, at least Friedman apologized for telling the truth, eventually...

Sorry to be so grim, the columnist concludes.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

And two years from now, these same hacks will pat themselves on the back for being non-partisan because they "opposed Obama" on Israel, although they conveniently waited until opposing Obama had zero meaning.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    9 years ago

Funny how some things never change except the clarity of what was the real objective in the first place.  No different than the destruction of Libya.  It was one of those conspiracies that Libya was destroyed because Qaddafi wanted to trade oil with gold or another currency that was swept under the rug at the time or Obama was Israel's greatest friend when he all of a sudden he wasn't, but some conspiracies continue to come true.  

 
 

Who is online


Trout Giggles
devangelical
Hallux


131 visitors