No, Don’t ‘Audit the Fed’
What backers of the plan want is influence over monetary policy
Misguided members of Congress have again introduced bills in the House and the Senate to perform what they call a full audit of the Federal Reserve, conjuring images of a Fed with books out of balance and assets or liabilities misstated in financial reports.
Dont believe the insinuation. The financial statements of the Federal Reserve and the 12 district banks are already independently audited, and the auditors findings are included in the Feds annual report. What the legislators pushing this bill are actually after is influence over monetary policy.
The Government Accountability Office is currently authorized to audit all of the federal bank supervisory agencies, but with respect to the Federal Reserve such audits may not include review of deliberations, decisions, or actions on monetary policy matters or the transactions made under the direction of the Federal Open Market Committee. The bills would repeal these exclusions and others.
Are these changes necessary? The Federal Reserve is already the most transparent central bank in the world. After each meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee, the 12-member body that sets key interest rates, a statement is issued announcing any actions or decisions and which members voted for or against. Minutes of each FOMC meeting are issued several weeks later. Board governors and district bank presidents regularly give speeches and interviews on the policy changes being considered and the indicators that might trigger the Fed to make them. The Federal Reserve is hardly cloaked in secrecy, as Sen. Rand Paul has alleged.
The Fed chair and governors also appear periodically before congressional committees to answer questions about monetary policy and other economic matters. By law, the Federal Reserve Board delivers a report on monetary policy to Congress twice a year. If legislators want more Fed transparency, these hearings are the place to obtain it. If legislators truly care about the substance of monetary policy, their questions should focus on the objectives Congress has set for the Fed: long-run growth of the monetary and credit aggregates commensurate with the economys long-run potential, so as to effectively promote maximum employment, stable prices, and moderate long-term interest rates.
It is unclear what benefit a full audit would provide. But there are clear risks. Opponents of the bills, including current Fed Chair Janet Yellen ,maintain that such legislation would allow Congress to put short-term political pressures on the Federal Reserve. This would strike a blow to the Feds independence, which has served the nation well in good times and crises. Legislators should exercise oversight to ensure that the Feds decisions align with Congresss monetary-policy objectives, but they should not attempt to implement monetary policy or politicize the Feds decision-making.The bills also raise an important additional concernthe chilling effect of congressional scrutiny. In 1993 then-House Banking Committee ChairmanHenry Gonzalezfirst asked for transcripts of FOMC meetings. At that time I was deputy general counsel of the FOMC. Up to that point, a good number of people who sat in the committee meetings were unaware that deliberations were taped and transcripts prepared and retained. The Fed decided to release those transcripts with a five-year lag.
This decision had an immediate chilling effect. What before had been vigorous, unscripted debate on the best course of action became instead choreographed performance, with committee members reading from prepared scripts.
It has been some time since I sat in on an FOMC meeting, but I imagine that virtually all those sitting around the table now speak from notes. Inviting a Government Accountability Office auditor to the table or otherwise further opening the process would make that problem immeasurably worseto the great detriment of sound monetary policy and the U.S. economy.
Transparency in all facets of our government is important. But the manner and timing of disclosures must be responsibly established, not ideologically driven. Before voting to audit the Fed, Congress must consider the potential long-term adverse implications for the U.S. economy and financial stability.
No, Dont Audit the Fed , by Ernie Patrikis, Wall Street Journal
Mr. Patrikisis a partner in the global law firm White & Case who served more than 30 years at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.

"Get rid of the Fed!"
That's such a profoundly stupid idea that only the craziest of crazies -- or most ignorant of the ignorant -- still call for abolition. But the wingnut faithful doesn't give up its bumper-sticker slogans easily, and the cynical puppeteers who manipulate the poor dumb Tea Partiers have come up with the best of both worlds!
"Audit the Fed!" The tricorn hat battalions haven't the slightest idea what this slogan means... but it "clearly" calls for getting that terrible rogue Fed under control! So now they're shouting "Audit the Fed!"
It's depressing that so much energy is wasted in service to such abysmal ignorance...
I have to agree with you Bob. Maybe it's the accountant in me, but I feel that all agencies that deal with large amounts of money should be audited. It would be the best investment in our government and would save us billions in government waste.
The Fed is already audited, several times, by several different entities, concerning its financial operations.
That isn't what the puppeteers want. They want to "audit" Fed policy development and management. They want to second-guess Fed decisions.
In reality, they want to control the Fed. Kinda the opposite of "independent central bank". But of course!These guys know so much better that tiny grey-haired woman...