International Law is on Israel’s Side
International Law is on Israels Side
International legal expert outlines Israels clear legal right to Judea-Samaria, wonders why Israeli leaders wont say it out loud.
By Shimon Cohen, Editor, Sovereignty Journal
Prof. Eliav Shochetman, an expert in international law, states: according to documents of international law accepted by the nations, the rights over Judea and Samaria belong exclusively to the Jewish People andtoits national home. So why is it that everyone is convinced that international law is not on our side and why doesnt Israel use these arguments?
These days, when Leftist organizations are warning about the dangers presented by the court in the Hague and international law, Prof. Eliav Shochetman, a world-renowned expert in international law, listens to the Israeli reaction and cannot understand why Israel keeps repeating security justifications and totally ignores the best card in her hand Judea and Samaria are areas that belong to it according to any reading of international law, in addition to the historical justification.
It turns out that what the radical Left has managed to embed within the Israeli publics consciousness during three and a half decades simply lacks any factual basis. And while the average Israeli might define our position in Judea and Samaria by the familiar clich occupation-it seems that the international documents state the total opposite: it is not occupation, but Israel standing up for the right of the Jewish People as it wasdeterminedby the nations, and yes, even if we have not understood it until now, it relates to Judea and Samaria also, and not just to Tel Aviv and its surroundings.
In order to understand the background and the sequence of events, Prof. Shochetman has set out a short but essential historical survey for every Israeli. The right of the People of Israel to the Land of Israel was recognized by the League of Nations in 1921 with the end of the First World War. This international organization determined the partition of states that was necessitated as a result of the changes in the Ottoman Empire and in Europe. Within the framework of this assemblage it recognized the right of the People of Israel to the Land of Israel.
This recognition was achieved with the international adoption of the BalfourDeclaration, which, until then, had only been accepted by the British government and from this moment on, became accepted by all of the nations. This decision was unanimously taken in San Remo by all of the 52 countries that were members of this organization.
After the People of Israel had been in exile for so many years, its right was recognized to return to its Land. The practical translation of this recognition of the right of the Jewish People to its land was expressed in the text of the British Mandate for the Land of Israel, within which framework, Britain was named to be the executor of the plan to establish a national home for the People of Israel, Shochetman explains.
The text of the Mandate prohibits Britain from transferring any territory of the Land of Israel to a foreign sovereignty
The way to implement this international decision was to add to it several clauses, which also dealt with increasing Jewishimmigrationto the Land of Israel, the Jewish People being a small minority in the Land, faced with an absolute Arab majority. In addition to this, in order to assure that the government of Britain would indeed carry out this plan, a specific clause was defined in the text of the Mandate in which it was stated that the government of Britain was forbidden from transferring any of the territory of the Land of Israel to a foreign sovereignty.
This decision did not differentiate between the western part of the Land of Israel and the eastern part. Actually, every necessary step was taken in the framework of the text of the Mandate to assure the establishment of a national home for the Jewish People in the Land of Israel.
Within a short time, the government of Britain that had led the BalfourDeclaration, the government under the leadership of Lloyd George, whose foreign minister was Lord Balfour, fell, and was replaced by another government, which was hostile to the Zionist idea and within a short time it led to an interpretation that allowed territory of the Land of Israel east of the Jordan River to beremovedfrom the area in which the British mission was to establish a Jewish homeland and this territory was transferred to the Royal Hashemite family. Prof. Shochetman does not wish to enter into pedantic political arguments about Britains authority (whether it had such authority or not), to act in this manner since ultimately the present, concrete reality until today is that on the eastern side of the Jordan River, the government of Jordan exists and this is not the time to deal with questions of what if.
The UN Charterenshrinesandreinforcesthe rightsset forthand approved by theLeague of Nations
After the British governments about-face, only the western part of the Land of Israel remained, from the river to the sea, in the area that was intended to establish the national home for the Jewish People. Prof. Shochetman clarifies: Clearly, there is no basis for any other sovereignty besides that of the Jewish People on territory within the western Land of Israel. This is how it is, according to international law. Since then until today nothing has changed regarding international law, rather the opposite. This view has even been reinforced in international law after the Second World War. The League of Nations ended its role then and in its place the UN was established andin the UN Charter there is a special clause, no. 80, in which it is said that all of the rights that were recognized in international law by the League of Nations still exist and are still binding. This clause was stated so that it would be clear that there was no validity to the idea that since a new organization had been created, the rights that were recognized by the previous organization are canceled.
Shochetman adds a comment that testifies to the historical uniqueness of clause 80, which, in accepted diplomatic jargon, was call the Palestinian clause, since its entire purpose is to assure the rights of the Jewish People, despite the fact thatthe nameof the Land of Israel is not mentioned.
This international paragraph received more reinforcement a few decades ago in the shadow of the African conflict, which, seemingly, does not relate to the Jewish People. In southwest Africa, in the country that today is called Namibia, there were arguments about the rights that had been recognized by the League of Nations. In the decision of the court in The Hague, it was said that all of the rights that had been recognized by the League of Nations are still binding and still exist. This is correct regarding Namibia and of course, it is also correct regarding the rights of the Jews in the Land of Israel, and this thing takes on even more validity from the international court in The Hague.
Prof. Shochetman summarizes these things with a clear and resolute statement: there is no document in international law that grants rights of sovereignty to anybody other than to the Jewish People. This is the legal position.
If this is so, it is really not clear why the State of Israel does not officially make use of this argument in international arenas.
It is just as unclear to me as it is to you.
To the best of my understanding, there is no answer to this argument
Shochetman adds that there is no answer to this legal argument that he presents except, at the most, a legal claim that touches on appropriate treatment of the Arabs located in Judea and Samaria. This is indeed a practical problem, but not a legal one. Legally, to the best of my understanding, there is no answer to this argument.
These words are said not only by Shochetman, but also by Israeli jurists, who do not have access to thepublicstage in order to say them, but also by international jurists in the world. Prof. Shochetman mentions a fewexamples Prof. Julius Stone, Prof. Shnabel and others.
Shochetman proves the claim from another direction. According to him the legal claim that he presents here was at the basis of the view that guided the government of the United States after the Six Day War when resolution 242 was passed in the UN, which talked about Israeli withdrawal from territories and not fromtheterritories. Why, if Israel had been considered an occupier, they would have called on her to withdraw from all of the territories and would have used the term theterritories. The reasoning here is that since it is not occupied territories at issue, but territories that Israel has a legal claim of sovereignty over, she need not withdraw from all of the territories but only from territories according to negotiations that would occur between the sides. From this as well, it seems that the world sees Israels position not as an occupier, but a state with rights over the territories.
Despite all of this,the government of Israel mystifyingly withholds this winning argument and ignores it. Prof. Shochetman has no solution to this diplomatic-political-legal mystery. These are things that in the past would have been acceptable to Israeli governments, but for many years, unfortunately, it refrains from using this argument, which works only in its favor. I do notunderstand, I really do not understand why they do not use this argument, but only the security argument.

If only there were such a thing as an unbiased court to hear such matters, I would love to see the result of an argument made about this. It has already been the subject of the Levy Report where a legal opinion was previously submitted. I don't think anyone here is qualified to enter judgment on it, but opinions are welcome. There have been many arguments made against such a claim, but then I'm not so sure about how much they are based on personal interests and bias.
Jews getting control over Judea ... who'd a thunk it ?
There "used to be" an International Court, but it has gone on the wayside in the past 40 years.
Kinda reminds me of a couple SCOTUS decisions for the Native American tribes/nations that the tribes/nations should be using but are not. Dunno why.
Maybe because the US government has the power to declare them no longer as tribes?
"Hey, the Chickasaw are kicking up a fuss today. How about we tell them we decided they no longer qualify as a bona fide "tribe?" That'll show their Indian asses who's the boss of them!"
(Hearty laugher around the card table.)
Not really sure. Maybe it is similar to the sickness BO has that renders him unable to say "Islamic terrorist".
Believe it or not, that happened in 1906 when our government was totally wiped out by the gvnmnt. They ruled us 'til the IRA in 1934 - BUT - appointed all our legislatures until we had a constitution in 1986.
I remember an article about this you posted once before; it places Indians in an untenable position in which the Chiefs and Elders, and the Tribal Councils literally place the entire tribe's life and welfare, their future, on the line, if they press for the legitimate terms agreed upon by the parties to the signed treaties.
Israel is under somewhat the same constrictions in that if the US turns on them they will be standing alone in their defense. It won't matter that the international theater agreed to this and that years ago... in their whimsy to be PC they have decided that Israel and Jews should bow their heads and place them on the chopping block to mollify Obama and his Muslim sympathies.
Exactly.
This is partly Israel's fault. For decades, Israel did not deign to argue. Israel was right, and there was no need to insist.
Meanwhile, the Palestinians and their allies were tirelessly filling TV discussions with their vocabulary. They had locked down the conversational framework before Israel even understood that there was a need to participate in those TV shows. A generation of Europeans and Americans heard only the Palestinian line. The "occupied territories"...
When there is only one message, it will be presumed true.
Bob Nelson - an absolute truth, and one I have been saying for years. The lack of public relations was tantamount to Israel shooting itself in the foot.
Bob, you and Buzz are correct. Israel made a huge mistake in not pushing the public relations side of things.
Bob, you and Buzz are correct. Israel made a huge mistake in not pushing the public relations side of things.
True. They really, really suck at PR.