╌>

Bringing down 'King Bibi' - the man who changed the tide in the Israeli election

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  cm  •  11 years ago  •  36 comments

Bringing down 'King Bibi' - the man who changed the tide in the Israeli election

Bringing down 'King Bibi' - the man who changed the tide in the Israeli election

If Benjamin Netanyahu loses his premiership in the election, he'll have the former caretaker of his residence to thank for it in part.

Meni Naftali, the former caretaker of the PM's residence.

Meni Naftali, former chief caretaker of the PM's residence. If not for the election, his suit might have been no more than juicy gossip. Photo by Moti Milrod

Vast empires can sometimes be brought down by the smallest of things.

In 2012, Time Magazine published a cover story on Benjamin Netanyahu titled King Bibi. The cover was graced by an intense, somber portrait of Israels second-longest-serving prime minister. Hes conquered Israel, the subtitle declared. But will Netanyahu now make peace or war?

Netanyahu was then at the height of his power hugely popular, with a coalition of monstrous size (which collapsed soon after) and there was a feeling among many Israelis at the time that there was no viable alternative to his rule.

Its hard to reconcile Netanyahu 2015 with the self-assured, smug leader that graced the cover of Time in 2012. Trailing in the polls behind Isaac Herzogs Zionist Union, at this writing, he hasnt appeared to be this panicked since the last time he lost an election, in 1999, with his rule weakened, his invincible aura perhaps irreparably cracked.

If Netanyahu loses his premiership in Tuesday's election, as some polls predict, it wont be too hard to pinpoint likely explanations: Whether its housing prices that leapt by approximately 55 percent from 2008-2013, or the fact that wars are occurring every other year Israelis arent short on reasons to oust the prime minister. But such things were also happening in 2013, when Netanyahu handily won the election (albeit thanks to the partnership between Likud and Avigdor Liebermans Yisrael Beiteinu).

So what has changed in the interim? Maybe Israelis have finally had enough of Netanyahus mismanagement. Or maybe his situation can be attributed to a man named Meni Naftali.

Naftali is not a politician nor a political activist; he has never run for public office, is not a regulator and does not hold a senior military rank. He is the former chief caretaker of the Prime Minister's Residence, who exposed the dirty secrets of King Bibis court. After serving as caretaker between February 2011 and November 2012, Naftali filed a lawsuit last year against his former employers, Benjamin and Sara Netanyahu and the state, demanding over 1 million shekels (approximately $250,000) in compensation for alleged emotional abuse and racist behavior that he claims to have suffered in particular under the hand of the prime ministers wife.

If it werent for the elections, Naftalis lawsuit might have remained no more than juicy gossip. Indeed, his original lawsuit against the Netanyahus contained plenty of that: the story about Sara Netanyahu apparently waking him up at 3 A.M. to admonish him for buying the wrong kind of milk, for example, or about her husband allegedly complaining that the caretaker brought the couple too much food. We are sophisticated Europeans, Netanyahu was said to have asserted. We dont eat as much food as you Moroccans (Naftali is of Moroccan descent).

These kind of salacious details keep tabloids on high alert, but usually the furor dies down after a while and serious political interest wanes. Such stories certainly dont oust prime ministers, let alone kings.

In 2010, similar allegations were brought against the Netanyahus by Lillian Peretz, a former housekeeper who also claimed to have suffered frequent humiliation and emotional abuse at their hands. Peretz eventually withdrew her lawsuit, following an out-of-court settlement in 2012, and her story was added to the ever-growing list of scandals that failed to hurt "Teflon Bibi."

But the Naftali case is different. Unlike the Peretz saga, it contains more than she-said-he-said arguments and counter arguments, more than just gossip: It includes serious claims of gross financial and other misconduct, including alleged criminal withholding of state funds. In what has been dubbed the "Bottlegate" scandal, Naftali claimed that Sara Netanyahu ordered the prime ministers staff to return bottles to supermarkets, pocketing thousands of shekels in redeemed deposits funds that legally belong to the state. In response, the Netanyahus claimed the deposits amounted to only 4,000 shekels, which the couple already returned to the state on their own initiative in 2013. For his part, however, Naftali countered that the real sums were much larger than that.

It all sounds silly and it is. But one cannot underestimate the influence Naftalis revelations have had on Netanyahus image and his electoral standing. Once again, as in Netanyahus various other expense-related affairs, this saga has offered Israelis another glimpse inside the court of King Bibi. It contains the perfect combination of an unbelievable level of pettiness, an unjustified feeling of aristocratic entitlement and an apparent complete disregard for rules and laws. It also blew up at a horrible time for Netanyahu, just before state comptroller Joseph Shapiras long-awaited report on his household's expenses, and at a time when Israelis crumbling under the burden of a soaring cost of living are finally becoming outraged at the hedonism they previously ignored.

The legal ramifications of the bottle affair are currently unclear. Naftali has been investigated thoroughly by the police (in return for which he was granted legal immunity), reportedly supplying further evidence of alleged criminal wrongdoings by the Netanyahus. But Attorney General Yehuda Weinstein has decided to hold off on making any decision regarding an official investigation into the matter until after the election. In any event, the potential legal ramifications of this case is the least of Netanyahus concerns: Maybe pushing his excessive household spending and sense of entitlement to the forefront of the political agenda might end up costing him the election?

The Netanyahus, to be sure, have tried to battle Naftali's revelations to the best of their ability. At first, after Shapira's report highlighted their outrageous spending, they blamed the former caretaker, who then reacted by suing them for slander. Afterward, different claims surfaced regarding Naftalis own past including allegations that he sexually harassed a co-worker at the Prime Ministers Residence, which Naftali has vehemently denied. In one of the more amusing turns the story took, Sara Netanyahu has now claimed that Naftali threw away food prepared by the staff at the residence, forcing the family to order in.

Despite attempts to besmirch him or discourage him in other ways, Naftali apparently enjoys widespread popularity: After turning to the Israeli crowdfunding site Headstart about a week ago in an attempt to raise funds for his legal battle against the Netanyahus, he raised about half of his 75,000-shekel (approximately $18,700) goal in one day (his crowdfunding campaign is currently 64-percent financed, with 24 days to go).

Every shekel I get, Naftali wrote in his appeal, will go to the war of the weak against the strong. In a country reeling from the effects of rising inequality and tycoon-ization, this sentiment is fairly common.

Naftalis allegations, of course, will not be the only reason for Netanyahus downfall, should it come about. But thanks to Naftali, Israelis have been awash for weeks in reports on the troubling conduct in the prime minister's household, reminding them again of all the past instances where Netanyahus apparent taste for opulence has been revealed.

The revelations have painted a pretty vivid portrait of a prime minister who believes that he is king, allegedly operating above and beyond the law. The damage the stories have caused is arguably greater than what 1,000 campaign ads about the rising cost of living would have wrought. They allowed opponents like Yair Lapid and Isaac Herzog to attack Netanyahu where it truly hurts: at home.

After the polls, well know if this was enough to finally dethrone King Bibi.

http://www.haaretz.com/opinion/1.647340


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Naftali claimed that Sara Netanyahu ordered the prime ministers staff to return bottles to supermarkets, pocketing thousands of shekels in redeemed deposits funds that legally belong to the state.

Very strange, but I suppose their is $$$ for returning bottles..I don't buy soda so I do not know...

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

How much bottled water, soda, etc., can one family drink?

The issue seems to be more about Netanyahu's and his wife's attitude of entitled aristocracy, rather than any real wrong doing. I can imagine that those Israelis who work hard for a living on the front lines, so to speak, wouldn't be pleased about this...

Great article! Thanks for posting it!

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Thank you Dowser, I agree with your comment, from other news reports I have read, the people are not happy about the economy, although, they are concerned about security, as all of us are, but, yes, as the headline seems to suggest, Netanyahu forgot he was elected and that he is not King Saul...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

LMAO!!!! You are so in Love you have to talk about him everyday..that's true Love...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

I became interested in Netanyahu when he got involved in American Presidential Election in 2012 between Obama and Romney, he should have stayed out of it...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

3:37 P.M. MK Dov Khenin accuses Netanyahu of racism and incitement against Arab voters

Joint List candidate and MK Dov Khenin petitioned the Central Elections Committee to remove the Likud campaign that casts Arab voters in a negative light.

"A prime minister who campaigns against voting by citizens belonging to an ethnic minority is crossing a red line of incitement and racism. This is especially severe on Election Day, when the message to Israeli citizens is to participate in the elections, vote, and take part in the democratic system. A statement like that, issued by the prime minister, shows that he has completely lost his way and that he is ready to break all the principles of democracy to safeguard his regime."

Meretz chairwoman Zehava Galon also slammed the prime minister, sharing his Facebook post and commenting laconically, "Serious warning: Israeli citizens are voting in the elections." (Haaretz)

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Anything that brings the Supreme Leader of Iran and the Supreme Leader of America together, has got to be good.

#1.. Correction, there is NO supreme Leader in America, stop listening to right wing hate speeches..

#2...As long as Iran and America are not trying to blow each other up, Peace is always good...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

Live updates:

6:50 P.M. Netanyahu slams election panel decision to bar his address from the airwaves

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said "no one will shut us up," after the Central Election Committee barred the media from airing his address, deeming it "illegal election propaganda."

"All day politicians have been talking in the media. Tzipi, Bougi, and Yair Lapid, talked in every possible TV studio and issued obvious campaign propaganda. The only one barred from talking over the media is me. The Likud prime minister," Netanyahu said in a Facebook post.

It should be noted that Netanyahu appeared earlier on Tuesday on a Channel 10 talk show.

In his statement, posted on his Facebook page, Netanyahu called on his supporters to vote, saying the margin between Likud and the Zionist Union is due to "foreign funds" funneled to "leftist groups."

Netanyahu also referred to his earlier statements that "the right's regime is in danger. The Arabs are moving in droves to the polling stations." Netanyahu said that there's nothing wrong with Jewish and Arab citizens voting as they see fit, but accused "funds from foreign governments and organizations" of being used to bring Arab voters "en masse" to the polling stations. According to Netanyahu, this skews the elections in the left's favor, giving power to the "extremist Arab list," meaning the Joint List, headed by Israeli Arab Ayman Odeh. (Haaretz)

What's good for the goose is good for the gander MR. Netanhayu, remember those Israeli funds brought into USA to influence and assure right wing senator's wins..e.g. Tom Cotton and Joni Ernst???

Theres a reason for Williamss suspicion. Kristols Emergency Committee for Israel gave Tom Cotton nearly $1 million in his race for the Senate just five months ago, Eli Clifton reported . Cotton received $960,250 in supportive campaign advertisingin the last month. (Thanks to Kay24 in comments).

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago
 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

LIVE BLOG: Exit polls show Zionist Union, Likud neck and neck; Rivlin calls for unity government

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Exit polls of voters by two Israeli TV outlets showed his party tied with the center-left opposition Zionist Union party at 27 seats each in the next Knesset, or parliament. A third station showed Netanyahu narrowly ahead, 28-27.

The close results, if upheld when votes are counted, increase the likelihood a national unity government could be formed. Running in a strong third place in the exit polls with 13 seats was the United List, a coalition of small Arab paries.

The exit poll results suggested Netanyahu's party was doing better than earlier polls indicated.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

10:53 P.M. Likud officials estimate: Netanyahu will work for coalition with Herzog

Likud officials estimated Netanyahu will work toward forming a national unity government with Zionist Union's Isaac Herzog.

"Netanyahu doesn't want a unity government, but sometimes you find yourself with no choice. In this case, the most likely scenario is that the prime minister will agree to pay Zionist Union a heavy price, among other things, leaving Bennett or Lieberman in the opposition, to make it easier for Herzog to make the move agreeable for his party. (Jonathan Lis)

Looks like that warmonger will still be around...

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

According to New York News, Netanyahu declaring victory before the final results..that warmonger wants war with Iran and wants American children to fight his war..as I have said in a previous post about Netanyahu not my children he can go "F" himself...

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    11 years ago

#3..The Middle East won't have a prayer until Netanyahu is gone.

Your full knowledge of the Middle East, on display for all.

Thank you.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

There is a 10 cent return for bottles and cans in MI. It adds up.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

The United States has always been involved in other countries elections. We use to try and keep the Communist from gaining power, but the coin has flipped and now we try and get the Fascist and Communist in power.

Take Egypt for example, we really backed Morsi, a Muslim Brotherhood member. We were so pissed off when the Egyptians kicked his MB ass out of office we refused to do business with them, which turned out to be bad for us since that void was filled by Russia.

It wouldn't surprise me if Obama's membership isn't in jeopardy with two losses now.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Benjamin Netanyahu and the Likud party are the worst things to happen to possible peace between Israel and the Palestinians since the PLO and Yasser Arafat. He is the single biggest elected terrorist in the world and needs to be defeated. If he is not he will try to absorb the occupied territories into Israel and at that point the US should break off all ties to Israel and leave them isolated. The same kind of sanctions we hold against Iran, should be held against Israel if he tries to annex the West Bank. That land does NOT belong to Israel!

He is "expanding his space" as other countries in the last century did and in the same manner. He won't stop with just the occupied territories either. He'll want to expand Israel until it controls the whole region, with him as the only leader. We've seen this movie before.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

#3..The Middle East won't have a prayer until Netanyahu is gone.

I couldn't agree more. Likud with Bibi running it is no better then Hamas.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    11 years ago

And now, your full knowledge of the Middle East, on display for all.

Thank you, sir.

 
 
 
CM
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  CM    11 years ago

I hope you have a few children or grand children to go fight for Netanhayu...People who has nothing to lose are crying for war with Iran..send your children, not mine...

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    11 years ago

He won't stop with just the occupied territories either. He'll want to expand Israel until it controls the whole region, with him as the only leader. We've seen this movie before.

Would you be so kind as to identify the countries that Israel will be expanding into?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

It wouldn't surprise me if Obama's membership isn't in jeopardy with two losses now.

What in the fuck does the President have to do with who wins in Israel? And I mean a real reason, not some right wing trash talk.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

He won't right away. He'll build more and more power and then take Lebanon. But first he'll take back Gaza. Then Syria. After that, most likely he'll exert influence in what's going to be left of Iraq after we get rid of ISIS before they get to him. He doesn't have to worry about Iran, since (as usual) he's going to get the US to do his fighting and dying there (how many Israeli troops fought in Iraq?). Then it'll fall under his influence also. He is a dictator wanna be and as I've said, we saw this same movie last century. Take a little, then a little more and then before you know it you have it all.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago
 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

2 adages come to mind:

All the king's horses and all the king's men...

He who laughs last, laughs best.

I'm so happy to see that we have a member on NT who is capable of mind-reading and predicting the future. He could make a fortune if he didn't consider himself vermin.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
What would better serve the cause of civilization? Israel ascendant or Palestine ascendant? We all know the answer.
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

And make no mistake, he is dying, or rather wants our troops to die, for war with
Iran. If he wants war with Iran, then let Israel do it alone. We have no good reason to back them up. I want peace in the ME, but Bibi wants war and the annexation of territories that do not belong to them. If he wants war, then fuck him, let Israel fight it alone! We owe them nothing, especially the lives of our troops just because he jacks off over war.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

He also has a very wild imagination too.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Neither and both. Two states or continued war.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Congrats!
 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    11 years ago

I'm sorry, Randy.

I cannot respond to your post without violating the CofC.

Good night.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

You should learn how to express yourself better then.

 
 

Who is online