╌>

Why You Shouldn't be Surprised that Prisoners Crushed Harvard's Debate Team

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  ambivalent  •  11 years ago  •  10 comments

Why You Shouldn't be Surprised that Prisoners Crushed Harvard's Debate Team

2_discussions.jpg

Last month, a debate team of three inmates with violent criminal records defeated a team of three Harvard University undergraduates.

It sounds like an underdog story plucked from the pages of a yet unwritten Walt Disney screenplay and in some ways, it is.

But its also worth pointing out the fallacy of our underlying assumptions about such a match-up the first (and most pernicious) being that if a definitive link between criminality and below-average intelligence exists, nobody has found it.

Despite living behind bars, prisoners have recorded albums , produced fine literature , run lucrative criminal enterprises and mastered the ancient meditation technique known as Vipassana .

[Baltimore jail case depicts a corrupt culture driven by drugs, money and sex]

As the highly sophisticated prison break from Clinton Correctional Facility in Dannemora, N.Y., made clear earlier this year, inmates are not only intelligent, but often more capable and deliberate than those of us on the outside. Richard Matt may have been smart enough to tunnel his way out of prison using rudimentary engineering skills picked up on the fly, but like many career criminals, his greatest gifts were probably rhetorical in nature, prison staffers said.

The debate took place last month at the Eastern Correctional Facility in New York, a maximum-security prison about an hour southwest of Bard College. The hosts beat a Harvard team that had won three of four American Parliamentary Debate Association National Championships.

There are few teams we are prouder of having lost a debate to than the phenomenally intelligent and articulate team we faced this weekend, the Harvard College Debating Union wrote on Facebook after the defeat. And we are incredibly thankful to Bard and the eastern New York correctional facility for the work they do and for organizing this event.

Representatives from the Harvard team did not respond to repeated requests for comment from The Washington Post.

What makes the victory over Harvard impressive is less about who pulled it off than how they did it.

To prepare for the competition, the inmates, members of Bards Prison Initiative , were forced to acquire knowledge the old-fashioned way: Without access to the Internet, according to the Wall Street Journal . In 2015, can you seriously imagine preparing for anything from purchasing a movie ticket to looking up directions or researching basically anything without using Google?

Complicating their challenge, the Journal noted, was the fact that research requests for books and articles had to be approved by the prison administration and that could take weeks.

Consider that for a moment: Weeks, not minutes or even days and all while attempting to map out a research strategy that hinged upon institutional approval. If debate is equal parts rhetorical flourish and strategy, its worth asking whether circumstance forced the prisoners to devise an approach in which limited resources demanded sharper focus and more rigorous planning that resulted in superior lines of argumentation.

http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/why-you-shouldn%e2%80%99t-be-surprised-that-prisoners-crushed-harvard%e2%80%99s-debate-team/ar-AAfcLTQ?li=AAa0dzB&ocid=U305DHP


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Although in no way am I trying to deprecate the debate, but I'm somewhat interested in knowing who the debate judges were, and their qualifications.

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    11 years ago

I've read this with great interest, unfortunate its not picked up by the media nationally. Evidence of hard work and intelligence are two characteristics not usually bestowed upon inmates.

Way to go gentlemen.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Buzz all the judges were veteran debate judges from the highest levels of debate.

Here is a comment from one of them.

''Ms. Nugent said it might seem tempting to favor the prisoners team, but the three judges have to justify their votes to each other based on specific rules and standards.

Were all human, she said. I dont think we can ever judge devoid of context or where we are, but the idea they would win out of sympathy is playing into pretty misguided ideas about inmates. Their academic ability is impressive.

It should be noted that the inmates have beaten other top teams...West Point for one.

Another thing is that they had to debate a position that they were all against. The Harvard team said that they were caught by surprise on the line of reasoning that the inmates used.

Another thing that I found amazing, is that the inmates DO NOT have access to the internet. Books must be requested from the prison, and can take weeks to get a clearance to receive them.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

It would be interesting to me to know their background and what paths led them to their current situation; whether lack of real opportunity in their early years made them feel they had only the road to self-destruction to travel.

Keen intelligence doesn't always guarantee good choices if a person doesn't have the guidance to make them.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

Agreed. Wish there were a way to flag their stories and be notified. Thank you for the article.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    11 years ago

Absolutely awesome.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

This really didn't surprise me, as I have read about the prisoners becoming "jail house lawyers" in the past. What could the prisoners have going for them, that the Harvard debate team did not?

Time. Long periods of time to study, read, digest, and think about the subject matter. Harvard has a rigorous curriculum. The young men/women on the Harvard debate team are scrambling to finish up this paper or take that test-- they don't have the time to fully concentrate on any one thing.

Books-- I love the internet and the availability of reading materials, but, let's face it. There is more in a book than on the internet. Holding a book in one's hand offers many opportunities to read and re-read a paragraph, to flip through the pages and find references, to compare and contrast... Give me a real book, any day, to trying to find something on the internet.

Experience-- the prisoners have real life experiences on which to draw, whereas the students participating in the debate have only been in school. They haven't had the time to really live, and understand what life is really about. They have never had to do the things the prisoners have had to do to survive.

Not a surprise, to me, anyway. Smile.gif

 
 

Who is online





90 visitors