So like you got to play nice... which means if you are going to use one of these words... it better not be directed to a member. Anyone else is fair game.
Perrie, both videos are playing simultaneously, and automatically... I have to turn one off in order to hear one. EEK! Is there any way to set them so they don't play automatically? thanks!
as for the CoC, I have NO problem with it. I think that it is a little two faces when we make rules that say we can't call each other racist but we can call the rest of the world racists.
What's the point in fighting racism if we the ones who are fighting it sweep it under the carpet when it happen in our won front page articles? It make us look like hypocrites....
I disagree. Calling each other racists would foster hard feelings between particular members. However if we ban the use of the word racist when talking about a racist outside of the group, like those boys on that bus at OU, then what word would we ban next? I mean I think we should be free to use any words we want on non-members, because if we start curtailing them, the next thing you know this site would be about as exciting a church Sunday afternoon ladies tea party.
There is nothing hypocritical about it. We have the rules here so that we don't get into name calling each other in the heat of the moment. That doesn't preclude what goes on in someone heads... but hey, no one can control that.
But this is a discussion site and racists to exist outside in the real world. If an event is news worthy and it deals with race relations, people's are going to make judgements.
And still no one has discussed the subject at hand. If you are not interested in discussing the subject (instead of going meta) then stay off the article.
I think that some of the words that SOME of the students at the University Of Michigan shows that even a fine institution as Michigan admits total morons from time to time The word are only slightly in common and some are completely off board. In short they're morons who do not represent the bulk of students at U of M.
In reality it is about self respect, do I want to be viewed as a member of the maddened crowd, or do I want to be a member of the human race.
Banning words solves nothing. That is the point. It relates on a meta basis especially in a group that is why such subjects devolve into meta at the start. It represents the ME attitude, ie, MY view is the CORRECT view.
When the real discussion is self control and respect for others. LR has a valid point to a point. But that isn't the point of this article. He does it so I should be able to do it is not a valid basis.
It is asinine to BAN specific words based upon an ideological basis, it is not only hypocritical, it is laughable, no matter who exhorts us to do it..
I think that certain words should be banned between user, but are OK to use on others, That said It think the point of this article what words OTHERS want bannedat their school. U ofM for example.
I agree with you about the N word. It was something I used to scold my students about. Educated black adults do not use that word (unless they are referring to a low life black). It is a poor inner city thing.. But one has to look at the origin of the word to know that it is racist, since it was the word that slave owners used to use. In current context, if they don't want it to be used, they shouldn't use it themselves.
I know a lot of gays and they don't use the word fagot. Queer is fine by them for everyone. And yes I have heard straight people tell gay jokes using those words with no problem.
Years ago I did an article call "When is a joke not a joke" I might revive it.
Banning words solves nothing. That is the point. It relates on a meta basis especially in a group that is why such subjects devolve into meta at the start. It represents the ME attitude, ie, MY view is the CORRECT view.
It is asinine to BAN specific words based upon an ideological basis, it is not only hypocritical, it is laughable, no matter who exhorts us to do it..
Banning words in everyday life is a bit silly. But on the other hand, if we use them, and people find them offensive, then we get the fallout from using them. It is part of being and adult. We own what we do, actions and words. So it is not so much the usage of words as knowing they are emotionally charged. If one choses to use that... I think they have the right to, but if they piss off a lot of people, well, they shouldn't be shocked. Bottom line... I think it goes to intention. If the intention is to mock and hurt by using specific words, then anger is what they will probably get back.
I am hesitant to ban words of any kind or description
What is the next step, banning certain types of art or subjects of art? ......certain books? ......certain speakers whose words or message we do not like?
Free speech is a pretty broad concept.
Do hurt feelings rise to the same level, as "crying fire in a crowded theater"? Perhaps, perhaps not.
All of that being said - I am all for civility in conversation and intellectual debate and zero tolerance for name calling, stereotypical labels and direct or implied insults to people and groups of people.
The golden rule of social intercourse if you will.
I am all for civility in conversation and intellectual debate and zero tolerance for name calling, stereotypical labels and direct or implied insults to people and groups of people.
What is the next step, banning certain types of art or subjects of art? ......certain books? ......certain speakers whose words or message we do not like?
Yup. Very Fahrenheit 451.
You are right. It is the golden rule. Civility is the answer... as in don't talk to others as you wouldn't want them to talk to you.
Hey, but there is always going to be an uncivil person. Then what?
Listen here kid, I would love to sit a chat with you, ... but (and there always is a butt) if you are feeling spotty today, I really can't afford to catch the measles at my age,....
Intention is the operative here. You can be a sadist troll or a real human being. the choice is yours.
On the flip side, how much you get of each is a choice also. The Internet forums are a constant battle between good and evil, you find out what is really in a person heart very quickly. As it is the easiest medium for expressing such. ie, very little risk. So some throw off all the decorum of civility and allow the emotions to reign.
Kinda like a look into the world as it would be without morality. It ages you quickly.
Yes do unto others is also a philosophy of relationships, not just a philosophy of living, you don't need a physical presence to apply it or require it.
Giving is not the natural existence of the human being, it is a learned behavior. One not learned enough it seems.
Call the behavior what it is, call the person brother/sister.
No brother or sister of mine is a racist. If racist seeming words come from them, I ask if that was their intent.
CIO brothers and sisters CIO (check it out) Reserve judgment for repeat behavior, then and only then STDFYF!
It never pays to become a bigot to fight a bigot. No message is sent except the validation of the tactics and ideals of racism.
Getting angry solves nothing, If I am angry, there is something wrong with me and I need to take action to fix it.
So everytime you explode in anger at a racist, the problem is yours and you have justified the racists position. (in the worst possible way, the racists own mind)
The racist thinks that if he wasn't right, then you wouldn't be so angry.
A little bit of self justification there don't ya think? Yes the racist will give a shit, cause he HAS to.
I don't think any words should be banned on here either. But not if they are directed to another member because, in this bit of the cyber universe, we all have to live together.
Self justification, no.Better yet, it's just pointing outto thesurrounding folks what they have in their mist. Racist hate that.
Why would you think that someone ''explodes in anger at a racist''. Calling a person a racist, isn't exploding in anger at them, it's simply pointing out what you believe them to be. The racistsare usually the ones that ''explode in anger''.
The racistsare usually the ones that ''explode in anger''.
Agreed..
NWM said:
Getting angry solves nothing, If I am angry, there is something wrong with me and I need to take action to fix it.
The same goes for racists. (except they don't "think" there is anything wrong with them) Since they don't think there is anything wrong with them, the best response is calm straitforward ridicule.
The best response tactic to clear racism is always , Test First, Reject after. It was good enough for MLK, it's good enough for me. (we could sure use some of that old time religion in the world , not this new modern judgmental crap)
Hey, but there is always going to be an uncivil person. Then what?
Then you cut back on participation and become very choosy about who you decide to engage in conversation and debate with and simply stayaway for those that tend towards the uncivil in discourse and discussion.
At least that is what I a doing
Great article by the way - the only one I commented on today.
An ineffective and wrong approach to trying to establish civility in debate and discussion in my view --
I found this insight on the issue quite interesting
The idea of banning words and phrases crops up repeatedly. While certainly its worthwhile to draw attention to clichs, vogue words and otherwise potentially troublesome expressions, I dont think banning them is a sensible solution. At the very least, it inculcates a proscriptive and censorial attitude, which is unconstructive. And what happens when a word you need is a word youve banned?
The fact that everyone draws the line differently on clich should give one pause before pressing the Big Red Ban Button. When I see people banning words, I want to use those words purely out of contrariness or devilment. What is this compulsion to impose ones preferences on the rest of the world? In most cases it amounts to an indulgence in peeving, with occasional incidental awareness-raising.
If you dont like a word or phrase, dont use it. Explain why, if you like, to anyone willing to listen. But banning everyone everywhere from ever using it is futile and heavy-handed.
John E. McIntyre, at You Dont Say , wonders why anyone would want to ban words in the first place. Yes, for editorial purposes a little Amish shunning seems apt, but not obliterating them from the language. Besides, the language attends to itself.
Food For thought.
So like you got to play nice... which means if you are going to use one of these words... it better not be directed to a member. Anyone else is fair game.
when it comes to "Playing nice" I see more of a double standard thing than I see of following the rule when playing nice...
Perrie, both videos are playing simultaneously, and automatically... I have to turn one off in order to hear one. EEK! Is there any way to set them so they don't play automatically? thanks!
it better not be directed to a member. Anyone else is fair game.
Absolutely. They are there for the insulting. Like those 47 motherfucking traitors that are now trying to back away from the letter they sent Iran.
Huh?
If I understand you... It means follow the CoC. No double standard.
They don't do that on my computer.. IDK why and I am not sure how to get it to stop. They are companion pieces.
Well, yeah I guess Randy. But the actual topic was not addressed. Give it a go.
I saw the show, but I can't resist taking a shot at the 47 traitor Senators whenever I can.
Didn't do it on my computer.
I must have some setting wrong... Don't worry! I'll just click one off!
double standard equals:
Black person can say Nigger and it is considered just another brother being cool
White person says Nigger and it is a racist white person.
A Gay person can tell gay jokes, use the words faggot and queer and it is funny
A straight person tells a gay joke, uses the words faggot an queer and they are a Bigot.
If the words are going to be banned they first must be banned by ALL people and not just some. NO EXCEPTIONS
as for the CoC, I have NO problem with it. I think that it is a little two faces when we make rules that say we can't call each other racist but we can call the rest of the world racists.
What's the point in fighting racism if we the ones who are fighting it sweep it under the carpet when it happen in our won front page articles? It make us look like hypocrites....
I disagree. Calling each other racists would foster hard feelings between particular members. However if we ban the use of the word racist when talking about a racist outside of the group, like those boys on that bus at OU, then what word would we ban next? I mean I think we should be free to use any words we want on non-members, because if we start curtailing them, the next thing you know this site would be about as exciting a church Sunday afternoon ladies tea party.
No words are being banned, word usage is being controlled, particularly certain words used as adjectives to describe other members of the group.
Somebody may be a fuckhead liberal, but you cannot say John Q Whatchamacallit is a fuckhead liberal if he is a member of the group.
It is called treating others with respect.
It all centers around this group Newstalkers, either we rise above the typical din on the internet or we sink into it.
And we do that by respecting each other.
Otherwise we learn what walk softly and carry a big stick means.
LR,
There is nothing hypocritical about it. We have the rules here so that we don't get into name calling each other in the heat of the moment. That doesn't preclude what goes on in someone heads... but hey, no one can control that.
But this is a discussion site and racists to exist outside in the real world. If an event is news worthy and it deals with race relations, people's are going to make judgements.
And still no one has discussed the subject at hand. If you are not interested in discussing the subject (instead of going meta) then stay off the article.
I think that some of the words that SOME of the students at the University Of Michigan shows that even a fine institution as Michigan admits total morons from time to time The word are only slightly in common and some are completely off board. In short they're morons who do not represent the bulk of students at U of M.
In reality it is about self respect, do I want to be viewed as a member of the maddened crowd, or do I want to be a member of the human race.
Banning words solves nothing. That is the point. It relates on a meta basis especially in a group that is why such subjects devolve into meta at the start. It represents the ME attitude, ie, MY view is the CORRECT view.
When the real discussion is self control and respect for others. LR has a valid point to a point. But that isn't the point of this article. He does it so I should be able to do it is not a valid basis.
It is asinine to BAN specific words based upon an ideological basis, it is not only hypocritical, it is laughable, no matter who exhorts us to do it..
I think that certain words should be banned between user, but are OK to use on others, That said It think the point of this article what words OTHERS want bannedat their school. U ofM for example.
LR,
I agree with you about the N word. It was something I used to scold my students about. Educated black adults do not use that word (unless they are referring to a low life black). It is a poor inner city thing.. But one has to look at the origin of the word to know that it is racist, since it was the word that slave owners used to use. In current context, if they don't want it to be used, they shouldn't use it themselves.
I know a lot of gays and they don't use the word fagot. Queer is fine by them for everyone. And yes I have heard straight people tell gay jokes using those words with no problem.
Years ago I did an article call "When is a joke not a joke" I might revive it.
NWM,
It is about respect.
This is true!
Banning words in everyday life is a bit silly. But on the other hand, if we use them, and people find them offensive, then we get the fallout from using them. It is part of being and adult. We own what we do, actions and words. So it is not so much the usage of words as knowing they are emotionally charged. If one choses to use that... I think they have the right to, but if they piss off a lot of people, well, they shouldn't be shocked. Bottom line... I think it goes to intention. If the intention is to mock and hurt by using specific words, then anger is what they will probably get back.
I am hesitant to ban words of any kind or description
What is the next step, banning certain types of art or subjects of art? ......certain books? ......certain speakers whose words or message we do not like?
Free speech is a pretty broad concept.
Do hurt feelings rise to the same level, as "crying fire in a crowded theater"? Perhaps, perhaps not.
All of that being said - I am all for civility in conversation and intellectual debate and zero tolerance for name calling, stereotypical labels and direct or implied insults to people and groups of people.
The golden rule of social intercourse if you will.
Yes!
Robert,
Yup. Very Fahrenheit 451.
You are right. It is the golden rule. Civility is the answer... as in don't talk to others as you wouldn't want them to talk to you.
Hey, but there is always going to be an uncivil person. Then what?
Yeah, I know you do Robert... and being quite the wordsmith, you can get your message across in very creative ways. But not everyone has your gift...
"You are right. It is the golden rule..." ??? I think it is those who make the Gold, Make the rules......
Yeah, that would be the Bible, LR.
Listen here kid, I would love to sit a chat with you, ... but (and there always is a butt) if you are feeling spotty today, I really can't afford to catch the measles at my age,....
LMAO!!!
I'm still spotty.. but not ill.
I don't think any words should be banned on NT. Who gives a shit if you call a racist, a racist. Well, maybe the racist would...
YES!
Intention is the operative here. You can be a sadist troll or a real human being. the choice is yours.
On the flip side, how much you get of each is a choice also. The Internet forums are a constant battle between good and evil, you find out what is really in a person heart very quickly. As it is the easiest medium for expressing such. ie, very little risk. So some throw off all the decorum of civility and allow the emotions to reign.
Kinda like a look into the world as it would be without morality. It ages you quickly.
Yes do unto others is also a philosophy of relationships, not just a philosophy of living, you don't need a physical presence to apply it or require it.
Giving is not the natural existence of the human being, it is a learned behavior. One not learned enough it seems.
Call the behavior what it is, call the person brother/sister.
No brother or sister of mine is a racist. If racist seeming words come from them, I ask if that was their intent.
CIO brothers and sisters CIO (check it out) Reserve judgment for repeat behavior, then and only then STDFYF!
It never pays to become a bigot to fight a bigot. No message is sent except the validation of the tactics and ideals of racism.
Getting angry solves nothing, If I am angry, there is something wrong with me and I need to take action to fix it.
So everytime you explode in anger at a racist, the problem is yours and you have justified the racists position. (in the worst possible way, the racists own mind)
The racist thinks that if he wasn't right, then you wouldn't be so angry.
A little bit of self justification there don't ya think? Yes the racist will give a shit, cause he HAS to.
My question is...
DO YOU?
I don't think any words should be banned on here either. But not if they are directed to another member because, in this bit of the cyber universe, we all have to live together.
Amen Brother.
Nice when we find agreement. Truly.
Self justification, no.Better yet, it's just pointing outto thesurrounding folks what they have in their mist. Racist hate that.
Why would you think that someone ''explodes in anger at a racist''. Calling a person a racist, isn't exploding in anger at them, it's simply pointing out what you believe them to be. The racistsare usually the ones that ''explode in anger''.
Kav said:
Agreed..
NWM said:
The same goes for racists. (except they don't "think" there is anything wrong with them) Since they don't think there is anything wrong with them, the best response is calm straitforward ridicule.
The best response tactic to clear racism is always , Test First, Reject after. It was good enough for MLK, it's good enough for me. (we could sure use some of that old time religion in the world , not this new modern judgmental crap)
Test first, I have no problem with.
''old time religion'' is a non starter for me. They don't have the best track record.
Me either, since I have no religion at all.
It was meant as a joke...
You all should know by now that I do not support organized religion.
I know!
Perrie
Then you cut back on participation and become very choosy about who you decide to engage in conversation and debate with and simply stayaway for those that tend towards the uncivil in discourse and discussion.
At least that is what I a doing
Great article by the way - the only one I commented on today.
GGGRRRRR!! I can't open them. IMO......the bottom line is....treat others the way you wish to be treated!!!
Nona,
You can view them here:
I thought about this topic and I believe I've come up with the solution ...
An ineffective and wrong approach to trying to establish civility in debate and discussion in my view --
I found this insight on the issue quite interesting
read more at
Oh well , this thread is dead .
Who gives a shit if you call a racist, a racist. Well, maybe the racist would...
They are sensitive that way....