Michael S. Schmidt, the New York Times reporter who broke the original Hillary Clinton email story on Monday evening (yes, the one that's already been dismantled ) followed it up on Thursday with a piece entitled "Hillary Clinton Asks State Department to Vet Emails for Release".
While you might get the impression from the mellow headline that there's not much to see here, the author made it clear on Twitter that this is not the case:
And there you have it, straight from the horse's mouth...it's all about Benghazi.
Thank you for clearing that up, Michael.
Here's the thing though: There's nothing in his latest piece that factually establishes that the real, secret reason for the State Department's request for Hillary's emails was due to the tragedy that occurred in September 2012. He merely insinuates it with little evidence, which is something he was already good at.
The closest he gets to something firm is this paragraph:
But it was the review of Benghazi-related documents last summer that, within the State Department, set off the chain of events leading to the public disclosure this week of Mrs. Clintons use of a private email account, according to the current and former department officials.And what is the Benghazi-related "chain of events" that Schmidt presents? This:
-State Department officials, including Secretary Kerry's chief of staff, sign off on the request for Hillary Clinton's emails.
-Starting last August, the State Department begins talking with Clinton's people about releasing her emails.
-In October, the Department asks all previous Secretaries since Madeleine Albright to turn over their government-related emails.
-In December, boxes containing around 50,000 printed pages of Clinton's emails are turned over.
-Department lawyers eventually determine that about 900 of these emails pertained to Benghazi and turn them over to the House Select Committee.
Did you notice that one of these things is not like the others? If so, you may be wondering what Madeleine Albright, Colin Powell and Condoleezza Rice have to do with Benghazi. The answer, obviously, is nothing.
Schmidt's reasoning for lumping in this event with Benghazi seems to be based on timing and nothing else. And while the timing might be interesting, do you know what else was happening right then? That would be the passage of the Presidential and Federal Records Act Amendments of 2014 , a bill introduced in early 2013, passed by the Senate in September 2014, and signed into law two months later by President Obama. It includes such sections as:
(Sec. 3) Provides that the transfer to the Archivist of records by a federal agency that have historical significance shall take place as soon as practicable but not later than 30 years after the creation or receipt of such records by an agency. Expands the authority of the Archivist with respect to the creation and preservation of audio and visual records.
and
(Sec. 9) Transfers responsibility for records management from the Administrator of the General Services Administration (GSA) to the Archivist. Requires the transfer of records from federal agencies to the National Archives in digital or electronic form to the greatest extent possible.
While it's unclear if this updated law is the exact reason for the State Department's request for emails going back to the late 1990s...it's certainly a more logical explanation than Benghazi. It also happens to be a law at the heart of this whole story in more ways than one, but it's not mentioned here...just as it was absent in Schmidt's piece from Monday that kicked this whole thing off. Convenient, eh?
But the most damaging evidence against Schmidt's shoddy insinuation of a Benghazi/State Department conspiracy comes from an unlikely source: the conclusion of his very own piece.
Since the disclosure that Mrs. Clinton used the private account, a spokeswoman for the State Department has described the request from Mrs. Clinton as part of the departments larger efforts to improve its record-keeping. The spokeswoman, Marie Harf, was asked on Tuesday whether there was any connection between the requests from Congress and the decision to ask the former secretaries of state for emails from their personal accounts.Amazing.The letter actually went before we got the request from the select committee, Ms. Harf said of the request to the former secretaries. It went in October of 2014 that was before we had gotten a request from the committee as part of our records-maintenance upgrading and the process we go through.
Ms. Harf said that Mrs. Clinton was the only secretary of state who had sent back copies of emails.
In the end, not only does the "Benghazi chain of events" timeline fall apart, but it also turns out that Hillary Clinton is the only Secretary of State so far who's delivered on the Department's request...which sounds like something that should be applauded.
To his credit, Schmidt also includes a quote from a senior State Department official that flies directly in the face of his nonfactual assertion that it's about Benghazi:
"It would be oversimplified and inaccurate to draw the conclusion that the preservation of her records was done for one purpose.But Michael S. Schmidt of the New York Times just did it anyway.

Dailykos? Of course.
Okay, what possible innocent reason did Hillary Clinton and her top lieutenants have to exclusively use a Clinton controlled server for government work?
If this is so innocent, why did Hillary fire an ambassador for using personal email to conduct government business?
Read it first, then comment.
NOTE: I may treat others as I have been treated (although it's against my nature to thwart discussion even when I don't agree with what transpires within a given discussion).
By all means, disagree if that's your choice, but,
UN-SUBSTANTIATED PRONOUNCEMENTS, NAME-CALLING AS OPPOSED TO CONTENT-CITED ALLEGATIONS WILL BE REMOVED!In the end, not only does the "Benghazi chain of events" timeline fall apart, but it also turns out that Hillary Clinton is the only Secretary of State so far who's delivered on the Department's request...which sounds like something that should be applauded.
Mac, you can lead the stupid to the intelligence, but you can't make them think. There are many on the right wing that prove that.
I did it read it. I laughed, especially at the part about how the story has been dismantled.
But I'd like answers to my two reasonable questions concerning this "dismantled" story. If you can't provide them, so be it.
MM,
My intent is to provide "Free Knowledge."
The catch here is that individuals must bring their own containers still I will fill those containers to overflowing
be they buckets or thimbles.
That's the kind of guy I am.
NOTE: Because you did not name any individual(s) per se, your comment regarding stupidity and intelligence is deemed a generic one descriptive of a phenomenon.
Interesting Sean; you were okay with the author on his original article -- but now that the same reporter clears it you and you don't like it you want to kill the messenger.
The Daily Kos article is ON THE RECORD WITH REGARD TO THE AUTHOR OF THE STORY AND THE ULTIMATE SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STORY.
So, Sean, challenge the content presented by the source AS I INVARIABLY DO WHEN GOING AFTER A SOURCE!
If you have no valid counter-points, you have nothing.
You tell me; your "question" is nothing more than innuendo until you show wherein the guilt resides. Post a link to a report of that firing and we'll go from there.
Regardless of whether she broke laws or not. She knew what she was doing was wrong. In fact, everyone in politics knows this is wrong and that is why it is now against the law. Yes others have done similar things in the past so I guess "Bush did it" will never end, but make no mistake, she went far further than anyone else to make sure she could keep it all private. Not to mention the fact that she did ALL her business from that email during her entire tenure as SOS. Why would anyone from the administration of transparency do such a thing? And why are you guys OK with being handed the exact opposite of the transparency we were promised?
If that's true, why weren't others who broke the law indicted, prosecuted or convicted?
Are you indignant because a public official allegedly broke the law, or, indignant because a particular public official allegedly did so?
It will end when the indignation is expressed in a non-partisan, non-selective manner.
Are you able to specify? If not THAT'S ANUN-SUBSTANTIATED PRONOUNCEMENT.
Happy for your literacy; beyond that, do you have any content-related commentary?
A. Mac,
I'm curious to hear your take on why Hillary set-up her email the way she did?
Thanks
:~)
She went as far as to set up her own off-site private server.
Like I said. It is NOW against the law. It wasn't when she and the rest of the boobs did it. That doesn't mean they all didn't know damn well what they were doing was wrong.
I brought up the fact Bush did it didn't I? Do you think I did that because I thought it was OK he did something similar?
Larry,
I don't know why and I was clear on another thread, and, here again, if she has violated law or protocol she must be held accountable.
MY ISSUE IS NOT A DEFENSE NOR AN ALLEGATION; MY ISSUE IS THE SELECTIVE INDIGNATION OF THOSE WHO REPUDIATE CLINTON WITHOUT HAVING HEARD FROM HER (AND SHE NEEDS TO COME FORWARD) AND, WHO FAIL TO ACKNOWLEDGE THAT OTHER PUBLIC OFFICIALS HAVE DONE THE SAME OR WORSE REGARDING E-MAILS.
If we're going to attack the act, we need to do so even-handedly, not on a partisan basis.
If Clinton is guilty of destroying sensitive e-mails and or security breaches AND NO ONE AMONG THE RIGHT-WING ACCUSERS HAS STIPULATED ANYTHING SPECIFIC IN THE WAY ACTUAL BREACH THEY'RE JUST POLITICKING.
The other so-called "issue" is Obama stating that he learned of the e-mail situation like everyone else "from the news." I agree this was not a smart comment, nor do we know if it's truthful. But the usual right-wing suspects are calling him a liar on this, and throwing in the "liar" accusation on Obama in blanket fashion.
AGAIN his predecessor did not only similarly, BUT WORSE (I got invited to stop mentioning that on another thread).
Those who want to call out the ACTS but who selectively and on a partisan-basis only call out the ACTORS of one party are disingenuous.
Anyone care to specifically rebut that? Do it with particulars.
Anyone care for me to post the similar and more egregious acts of a Republican POTUS and Secretary of State?
I don't want to hear the shit complaint about a perpetrator whose guilt is somehow moot because he's no longer at the scene of "the crime." And since said perpetrator was never indicted, prosecuted or found guilty of the allegations that by-innuendo, is now the substance of the current right-wing Clinton/Obama shit fit they can't have it both ways.
I should have added she set up MULTIPLE private emails as well as an off-site private server. Not that it matters, like I said, she was careful to skirt existing laws and the law that now makes this illegal was not in place yet.
That is the bugger of it all, isn't it? There is no damn way anyone can tell and there never will be. She is smart I'll give you that. I wonder what she was hiding...
So you have nothing but speculation, and AGAIN, there is no evidence (and may never be) that any of the e-mails in question were destroyed UNLIKE IN THE PREVIOUS POTUS' ADMINISTRATION!
Wonder aloud all you like BUT IF YOU DO SO, DO SO WITH THE INTEGRITY TO DECLARE THAT YOUR SUSPICIONS ARE NOT BASED ON EVIDENCE, AND, THAT YOU WONDER WITH EQUAL SUSPICION ABOUT OTHERS WHO HAVE DONE WORSE WITH SO-CALLED "IMPORTANT E-MAILS."
Otherwise, this is a right-wing partisan attack.
I haven't invoked red box rules, just my personal caveats on my personal post.
All he needs to do going forward, IS TO PROVE IT.
Speculative until proven definitively.
But since you feel that strongly, what should happen to public officials who, in fact, based on evidence, destroyed sensitive e-mails?
Need the details?
Source and specifics, please.
You heard?
From whom?
O SO WITH THE INTEGRITY TO DECLARE THAT YOUR SUSPICIONS ARE NOT BASED ON EVIDENC
JESUS CHRIST.HAVE YOU EVER HEARD OFCIRCUMSTANTIALEVIDENCE??? THERE'S REALLY NOOTHER POINT TO GOING THROUGH THEEXPENSEOFINSTALLINGAPRIVATE EMAIL SERVER OTHER THEN THEABILITYTO CONTROL WHATDATA IS SAVED AND WHAT IS DELETED.
Lest I be accused of being partisan
Please inform me what other Secretary of State set up their own private email system to avoid following the regulations in place. And regulations were in place, ask the Ambassador under Clinton who was fired for using private email to conduct government business.
Common knowledge?
Just post one link to one of these media reports, Mike.
But Mike, I gave that information to you yesterday.
It seems
This is what I mean when I say the indignation is selective.
Give us something specific.
Wrong-is-wrong-is-wrong regardless of the perpetrators.
But allegations based on speculation and, made on a selective basis, are not proof and are particularly offensive when purely political and made personal.
LET'S HAVE SOME SUBSTANCE!
Thanks. I haveread a fewarticles now, and agree we need to consider the findings of further investigation before passing judgement. I also agree that it provides a perfect hothouse for partisanship and politicking. What is more concerning to me at this momentare the implications for security risks/leaks that may have happened due to the infraction.
Yes.
Have you?
You mean, none that you know of?
Substance, Sean the venomous attacks are speculative and, yes, based on circumstantial "evidence."
And technically,Circumstantial evidenceisevidencethat relies on an inference to connect it to a conclusion of fact.
What you infer is not proof.
Any or all BUT ONLY IF THERE IS PROOF AND DUE PROCESS.
So far, you have provided evidence of neither.
That is anUN-SUBSTANTIATED PRONOUNCEMENT. It's also a platitude and a cliche. If he's got the goods, let him put them ON THE RECORD where he has to own his allegations THAT IS,SHOULD HE HAVE THE INTEGRITY AND EVIDENCE TO MAKE THEM FORMALLY!
Let him pursue formal charges based on probable cause and protocol. That's where we leave politics and enter integrity.
estion were destroyed UNLIKE IN THE PREVIOUS POTUS' ADMINISTRATION!
I couldn't let this passb since you wrote this: "allegations based on speculation and, made on a selective basis, are not proof and are particularly offensive when purely political and made personal"..
LET'S AT LEAST BE ACCURATE! The Bushadministrationdid notdestroy emails, yet you still make that accusation without any proof. The fact that all 22 million that were supposedly missing due to an archiving issue were recovered. They obviously weren't destroyed and there is no evidence anyone even tried to do so.
That how we play ball in America, Sean. FYI, EVIDENCE IS PROOF!
If you can't prove it it's not evidence and the opposite is also true.
It is NOW against the law. It wasn't when she and the rest of the boobs did it.
The operative words are, it wasn't when she did it. So get angry. Get pissed off. Scream, if you like too. But she did nothing illegal and other Secretary's of State have done it to varying degrees too, from both parties.
By 2016 only the extremely hardcore right wingers, who few listen to and would not have voted for her anyway, will care. It's already an old story.
Mike,
From one of your links
Appears to have, possibly, a prominent (un-named) member of the hacking community
I'd love to ask the jury to consider that iron-clad "evidence."
Your source, Mike.
NOTE: Because you did not name any individual(s) per se, your comment regarding stupidity and intelligence is deemed a generic one descriptive of a phenomenon.
Understood and NP.
Oh, so it's a lot like the Clinton e-mails EXCEPT IT HAS NOT BEEN PROVEN THAT ANY OF HERS ARE MISSING! Unlike the Bush e-mails which are still MISSING.
Let's go a it deeper
Anything close to this kind of info on Hillary?
But Mike, remember yesterday?
Opinions are welcomed but when they are clearly that but offered as fact, it's not a court of law, it's the court of public opinion.
I'm sorry you take this personally; it's a debate. We disagree. That's all.
Right. Her actions must be excused. She is the democratic hopeful of 2016.
She did nothing illegal and it's a long way to 2016. It will be a non-story within a week or so (and is quickly becoming one now) and it will be barely, if at all, mentioned in the Presidential elections in 2016. That's politics for you in the 24 hour news cycle.
There's going to be a lot more news of all kinds between now and then that will drown this like most of the folks on the Titanic.
Wouldn't you think POTUS would notice, in his "To"and/or "From"headers, the difference between .gov and .com???
In fact, if he corresponded with her, he would have had to enter her address in his address book.
How out-to-lunch can POTUS be?
First Obamas people asserted, as usual, that he only found out about Clintons use of a private email address from the news. Then it turned out that the White House had known about it all along.
Now the fallback position is that Obama is completely ignorant of how the internet works. But he still wants to control it.
One might reasonably think that. But is it not also possible that they were trading "personal" rather than "official" e-mails?
And this is from the linked article you provided, Len.
And AGAIN, I'm not taking a side of either innocence or guilt knowing the Republicans, if there's evidence, they'll pursue it. And you must admit, that all of the "evidence" the Republicans allegedly had on Fast and Furious, the IRS, Benghazi went nowhere from a legal standpoint. All these lawyers in office and they can't make their cases? That would imply incompetence or political grandstanding, Len.
Don't you think with all the endless allegations, at least one would have gone somewhere?
And AGAIN, AGAIN, if there is wrong-doing here, why weren't previous perpetrators of like wrong-doing indicted, tried or convicted?
Your honor, please instruct the witness(es) to answer the question.
Agreed, Len; but it strains credibility even more when the accuser hasn't GONE ON THE RECORD SATISFYING THE BURDEN OF PROOF!
If Gowdy had the goods, don't you think he'd make the charge formal?
Please, Len, that's a reasonable question. Is it real or is it political grandstanding (at least to this point)?
One might reasonably think that. But is it not also possible that they were trading "personal" rather than "official" e-mails?
So you assume all correspondence between POTUS and SecState was personal? I know the drill; I cannot prove otherwise. Right?
Now we need to subpoena Obama's email to see the interchange.
They found one perp; Sen. Menendez. Do you think that, had he not opposed Obama on Cuba and Iran, he still would have been charged???
Len,
Time to stop being so indignant when a batch of our republican congressmen write a love letter to Iran.
What does that have to do with this???
If you can keep your mind when everyone else is losing theirs you just do not understand the problem.
NT and the news media are not courts of law though you try to make it sound like they are. Everything in due time!
No, Len, I don't assume anything, I responded to your
with a possible alternative to what your comment presumes to be what one SHOULD think!
You and the others that have bashed Clinton for what you have decided, WITHOUT ANY PRESENTED EVIDENCE .ARE THE ONES MAKING THE ASSUMPTIONS AND ALLEGATIONS!
And until that transpires AND THERE IS SOMETHING CONCRETE that results, condemning Clinton and calling Obama a "liar," and, as one member (on another thread) called Obama, "a piece of human excrement," YOU AND THE RIGHT-WING SMEAR CAMPAIGN ARE ONLY PROVING WHAT YOU DENY WHEN CALLED OUT "Obama-haters."
No proof, demagoguery, character assassination NO FORMAL CHARGES, NOTHING BUT VENOMOUS HATRED!
Grasping for straws in the conflation box? The issue remains your accusations without supportive evidence.
And what is different about this particular Democratic President who never went through this kind of lying character assassination? Character assassination that no other President of either party has had to endure in modern American history? What is "different" about him?
But, Len, you and the gang have already indicted and convicted the parties in discussion here. So if NT and the news media are not courts of law -- and they are not -- why are you playing judge and jury?
This is how you boys play the game all the time. Post, comment, accuse then attack viable rebuttal by attacking the members who try and have point-counter-point discussions. And when you can't defend your untenable positions, you suddenly find logic and reason to defend your lack of same.
Everything in due time, Len?
How about you follow that concept instead of bashing from a position of weakness and trying to tap dance your way out?
At least you, Len, don't try to bully your way out.
Can't say that about some of the others here.
Thanks for proving my point