╌>

The Appalling Talk of Boycotting Netanyahu -- Congress has every right, and even an obligation, to hear the Israeli leader speak about the Iranian threat.- WSJ by Alan M. Dershowitz 2/23/2015

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  11 years ago  •  6 comments

The Appalling Talk of Boycotting Netanyahu -- Congress has every right, and even an obligation, to hear the Israeli leader speak about the Iranian threat.- WSJ by Alan M. Dershowitz 2/23/2015

As a liberal Democrat who twice campaigned for President Barack Obama , I am appalled that some Democratic members of Congress are planning to boycott the speech of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on March 3 to a joint session of Congress. At bottom, this controversy is not mainly about protocol and politicsit is about the constitutional system of checks and balances and the separation of powers.

Under the Constitution, the executive and legislative branches share responsibility for making and implementing important foreign-policy decisions. Congress has a critical role to play in scrutinizing the decisions of the president when these decisions involve national security, relationships with allies and the threat of nuclear proliferation.

Congress has every right to invite, even over the presidents strong objection, any world leader or international expert who can assist its members in formulating appropriate responses to the current deal being considered with Iran regarding its nuclear-weapons program. Indeed, it is the responsibility of every member of Congress to listen to Prime Minister Netanyahu, who probably knows more about this issue than any world leader, because it threatens the very existence of the nation state of the Jewish people.

Congress has the right to disagree with the prime minister, but the idea that some members of Congress will not give him the courtesy of listening violates protocol and basic decency to a far greater extent than anything Mr. Netanyahu is accused of doing for having accepted an invitation from Congress.

Recall that President Obama sent British Prime Minister David Cameron to lobby Congress with phone calls last month against conditionally imposing new sanctions on Iran if the deal were to fail. What the president objects to is not that Mr. Netanyahu will speak to Congress, but the content of what he intends to say. This constitutes a direct intrusion on the power of Congress and on the constitutional separation of powers.

Not only should all members of Congress attend Mr. Netanyahus speech, but President Obamaas a constitutional scholarshould urge members of Congress to do their constitutional duty of listening to opposing views in order to check and balance the policies of the administration.

Whether one agrees or disagrees with Speaker John Boehner s decision to invite Mr. Netanyahu or Mr. Netanyahus decision to accept, no legal scholar can dispute that Congress has the power to act independently of the president in matters of foreign policy. Whether any deal with Iran would technically constitute a treaty requiring Senate confirmation, it is certainly treaty-like in its impact. Moreover, the president cant implement the deal without some action or inaction by Congress.

Congress also has a role in implementing the presidents promisemade on behalf of our nation as a wholethat Iran will never be allowed to develop nuclear weapons. That promise seems to be in the process of being broken, as reports in the media and Congress circulate that the deal on the table contains a sunset provision that would allow Iran to develop nuclear weapons after a certain number of years.

Once it became clear that Iran will eventually be permitted to become a nuclear-weapon power, it has already become such a power for practical purposes. The Saudis and the Arab emirates will not wait until Iran turns the last screw on its nuclear bomb. As soon as this deal is struck, with its sunset provision, these countries would begin to develop their own nuclear-weapon programs, as would other countries in the region. If Congress thinks this is a bad deal, it has the responsibility to act.

Another reason members of Congress should not boycott Mr. Netanyahus speech is that support for Israel has always been a bipartisan issue. The decision by some members to boycott Israels prime minister endangers this bipartisan support. This will not only hurt Israel but will also endanger support for Democrats among pro-Israel voters. I certainly would never vote for or support a member of Congress who walked out on Israels prime minister.

One should walk out on tyrants, bigots and radical extremists, as the United States did when Irans Mahmoud Ahmadinejad denied the Holocaust and called for Israels destruction at the United Nations. To use such an extreme tactic against our closest ally, and the Middle Easts only vibrant democracy, is not only to insult Israels prime minister but to put Israel in a category in which it does not belong.

So let members of Congress who disagree with the prime ministers decision to accept Speaker Boehners invitation express that disagreement privately and even publicly, but let them not walk out on a speech from which they may learn a great deal and which may help them prevent the president from making a disastrous foreign-policy mistake. Inviting a prime minister of an ally to educate Congress about a pressing foreign-policy decision is in the highest tradition of our democratic system of separation of powers and checks and balances.

Mr. Dershowitz is a professor of law emeritus at Harvard Law School and the author of Terror Tunnels: The Case for Israels Just War Against Hamas (Rosetta Books, 2014).


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Logic is blowing in the American wind.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Since much of what Netanyahus speech is going to be about the negotiations over Iran's nuclear program, I suggest you take a look at the discussion we had yesterday related to it. It was a pretty good one. Informative.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

The only people you laughingly consider "objective" are those who toe the line, A to Z, with your Leftist nonsense.

Even voting for Obama twice does not immunizeDersh from Russell's Leftist invective that demands 100% conformity to the Party Line.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Words are scary. Letting an ally talk in public is just un-american.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

While we have one president, he is president, not king. Congress is a coequal branch of government. Article l, Section 8 of the Constitution, provides that The Congress shall have Power To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations. Article ll, Section 2, states that the president shall have Power, by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties. Commerce and treaties are key facets of foreign policy rightfully within Congress purview.

The real problem, that flame conspicuously sends away, is that President Obamas foreign policy towards the Middle East is increasingly opposed even by his own party. This month the Senate Banking Committee passed a bill, by a lopsided margin, that would place new sanctions on Iran if no agreement limits its nuclear program by June. Democrat Sen. Robert Menendez (N.J.), the senior Democrat on the Foreign Relations Committee, co-sponsored the bill with the support of at least 13 other Democratic senators. Menendezs allies are deeply skeptical, that Obama will obtain adequate concessions from Iran.

A Gallup poll shows that 77% of those polled see the development of nuclear weapons by Iran as a critical threat. The Obama leadership and its NT groupiesare evidently not among them.

Iran continues to prohibit the IAEA from visiting sites connected to possible military dimensions (PMDs), including Parchin, a military complex dedicated to research , development, and production of ammunition, rockets, and high explosives. Airborne-obtained images from Parchin suggests Iran has been camouflaging the site to disguise weaponization activities.

Iran has frequently concealed its nuclear activities, refused inspections and violated its commitments.In 2002, the IAEA revealed that Iran was in violation of the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT). For 18 years Iran had secretly developed technologies to produce highly enriched uranium. In 2003 Iran signed the Tehran Declaration with Britain, Germany, and France and agreed to suspend enrichment during negotiations, and comply with the IAEA. Two years later, however, the IAEA referred Iran to the U.N. Security Council for non-compliance of the NPT due continued enrichment and failure to cooperate with the IAEA. Iranian President Rouhani boasted in 2013 that he and the regime utterly flouted a 2003 agreement with the IAEA in which it promised to suspend all uranium enrichment and certain other nuclear activities.

Obama evidently wants a paper agreement with Iran regardless of consequences. Democrats with this view could be called Chamberlain Democrats.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

The Syrian government has been the target of a proxy war (not a civil war) funded by Saudi Arabia and Qatar with an assist from the U.S., Israel, Egypt and Turkey at least.

Intellect that you are, how did you fail to see that Syria's main support is Iran?

 
 

Who is online


72 visitors