╌>

What Constitutes Individual or Group "IDENTITY"?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  a-macarthur  •  11 years ago  •  5 comments

What Constitutes Individual or Group "IDENTITY"?

By definition, "IDENTITY" is

The fact of being who or what a person or thing is

the characteristics determining this

Currently, much is being said, written, discussed and debated with regard to the identity of the entity known as "ISIS" or "ISIL"; along with debate on how to deal with its very existence, itsreligious identity seems to be a hot debate as well.

I've posted several articles regarding how I personally think ISIS should be taken out, and, have commented frequently in articles debating whether or not ISIS is an "Islamic" entity, or instead, a militarized amassing of criminals and barbarians using "religion" Islam in particular as a cover, as an opportunistic facade intended to give a "higher-calling-God-validated" justification and credibility appearing to murder and mayhem.

Does ISIS have a legitimate claim to a Muslim identity? I don't believe that can be satisfactorily answered with a simple "yes" or "no," and here's my reasoning.

If there are, in fact, tenets of Islam that advocate and/or imply that the "killing of infidels" is a mandate, a requirement that can or must be used to establish Islam's place in this world (and possibly the next), then HERE ARE MY QUESTIONS:

IF ISIS/ISIL is acting as ISLAMIC DOCTRINE (allegedly) REQUIRES, thus making a case for the "ISIS BEING ISLAMIC" side of the debate by logical extension, WITH REGARD ALL THOSE WHO IDENTIFY THEMSELVES AS "MUSLIMS," but who do not believe it is moral/ethical/legal/holy to kill "infidels," etc. can they belegitimately identified as "Muslims"?

Is IDENTITY a phenomenon and manifestation of BEHAVIOR, a genetic attribute, or something altogether different?

Can it be deemed "hypocritical" to "talk-the-religious-tenet-talk" if the talker fails to "walk the walk"? In other words, is "identity" more about what one says about himself, or, how one lives his life?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   seeder  A. Macarthur    11 years ago

This in not about your politics, it's about your ability to think and express yourself regarding a philosophical question with real life, everyday implications.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Good questions, A. Mac!

I often wonder if the Koran is like our Christian bible, in that it is filled with contradictions, with rules and laws that are seemingly arbitrary. It seems that many religious leaders pick out one or two obscure tenets to push, and ignore the rest.

I believe that you're right in that it is a group of barbarians that are warping the good parts of the Koran to fashion their own, self-serving, goals. And that it is not confined to just one religion-- Muslim. It is wide-spread and, perhaps, a human characteristic to appeal to a higher power for the permission to do evil.

Can't answer the question about identity. Especially for ISIS. My own identity is rather confusing. Perhaps it is a genetic trait that we need to be social creatures-- or to surround ourselves with people. I try to imagine what it would be like to be thrust into a situation where no one is at all like me in any way. What could I learn? What could I teach? This makes for interesting late-night ponderings, when I can't sleep.

I think all of us, each and every one, is hypocritical. We all "talk the talk", but it is impossible to truly "walk the walk". It is a goal to try to reach, but not one that is easily met in most of our circumstances. I wonder if the saints themselves had trouble. I mean, most of them were in cloistered communities where pretty much all they did was work and pray. If they went to live in a cave somewhere, perhaps they could do it-- but the simple introduction of other people would make it much more difficult to actually "walk the walk".

I must say this, though. Just about everyone I know is truly trying to be a good person. None of us are good all the time, but most people I know try hard.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

When talking about Abrahamic religions, there needs to be a sharp delineation between two of the three.

Judaism contains a lot of law (613 to be exact and the 10 commandments), but the stories told in the Torah/Old testament are meant as parable. That is why there is the Talmud, or Judaic legal discussion and debate on what the storiesmean. They are not meant to be taken literally.

When taking about the New Testament and the Koran, we are talking about two men, each who said actual things. Now one can say that they meant what they said to be thought about and interpreted, but they are not parable. There is no supplement like the Talmud to discuss these matters, so each minister or Imam does that for their congregation.

So, is radical Islam, Islam? I would argue, yes, but also caution that it is NOT the only form of Islam. What this particular brand does, is focus on what makes anyone who differs in their version of Islam, the other, and therefore makes it easier to think in very radical terms of what to do with them... which of course is rid themselves of them. The Koran is very specific about what to do with an infidel. Now I have heard some Muslim scholars say that infidel means idolaters, which is different than non-believer. When they refer to a believer, they refer to one who believes in god... meaning Jews and Christians. There is a lot more interpretations like that leads to Muslims who are extremist and those who are not.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

My philosophy is rooted in empiricism .

Does ISIS have a legitimate claim to a Muslim identity? I don't believe that can be satisfactorily answered with a simple "yes" or "no,"

From what I perceive the Muslim religion stimulates the development of extremist elements [perhaps due to the way the Koran is written ] . Islam appears to inspire violent competition in the contest for which group is the true Islam . And since that arises out of Islam itself , this warfare will continue in perpetuity . I don't see any end to this tendency in Islam . Even if ISIL is defeated there will always be another fringe element which attracts followers with violent intent .

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

When they refer to a believer, they refer to one who believes in god... meaning Jews and Christians.

I'm not sure which "they" you mean . In some Islamic countries they kill Christian citizens just for being Christian .

 
 

Who is online


42 visitors