The Promise and Failure of Community Colleges
There are two critical things to know about community colleges.
The first is that they could be the nations most powerful tools to improve the opportunities of less privileged Americans, giving them a shot at harnessing a fast-changing job market and building a more equitable, inclusive society for all of us. The second is that, at this job, they have largely failed.
When President Obama stood at Pellissippi Community College in Knoxville, Tenn., last month and offered every committed student two years worth of community college at the governments expense, he focused on the first point .
With open enrollment and an average price tag of $3,800 a year for full-time students, community colleges are pretty much the only shot at a higher education for those who dont have the cash or the high school record to go to a four-year university. And thats a lot of people: 45 percent of the undergraduate students in the country.
They are essential pathways to the middle class, Mr. Obama said. They work for parents and full-time workers, for veterans re-entering civilian life, and for those who dont have the capacity to just suddenly go study for four years and not work.
What the president chose not to emphasize is that precious few of the students at community colleges are likely to fulfill the promise and complete their education. Of all the students who enroll full time at Pellissippi, for example, only 22 percent graduate from a two-year program within three years. Just 8 percent transfer to a four-year college.
And thats hardly the bottom of the barrel. There are many community colleges with much worse records.
The presidents offer of a free ride should increase enrollment: White House officials estimate that the program, if approved by Congress, would lift enrollment by 1.6 million by 2026, bringing the total to nine million students from about seven million today. But thats the easy bit.
Whether his plan ultimately delivers on its promise, however, will depend less on how many students enter than how many successfully navigate their way out. Today, only 35 percent of a given entry cohort attain a degree within six years, according to government statistics .
And its getting worse. Community college graduation rates have been declining over the last decade.
Read more at:
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/18/business/economy/the-promise-and-failure-of-community-colleges.html?partner=rss&emc=rss&_r=0
Tags
Who is online
51 visitors

At current graduation rates,a lotof the president's "free" two years of community college will be wasted, at the college where the president unveiled his plan only 22% of those enrolling complete a degree within three years.
And other community college graduation rates are even worse.
And thus another good first step toward the solution of a problem, but much more to be done before tangible results will be realized.
Great idea, more needs to be done.
Sort of a derail to your seed though is that I think one of the best places to focus our efforts needs to be at the 4th through 9th grades. It is here where solid study habit are make or break for kids going forward. Solid math and language skills need to be learned, loved, and lived by students.
You and I always talk about improving the skill levels of tomorrows workers Robert. I think these are the grades where we lose to many kids. Education is an investment with a greater return than any "hot stock tip" from "The Street". America's future has always depended on what how we are teaching our kids in the here and now.
FLY
I hadn't thought about grade school and middle school. but when I saw this article I thought how successful our local VoEd high school has been in getting kids a high school diploma and a step into a job in the skilled trades, in the medical laboratory field, cosmetology, dental assistant, computer technology and security etc
A lot of the success is due to partnerships with local businesses - that could be a place to start with post secondary technical schools and community colleges.
It could be another step toward education reform that really works for the customer (the kids and the nation)
Thanks for the feedback and the perspective
RIO, those are really sad figures. It started me thinking about 4 year colleges and their graduation rates.
I found one article that in 2006 only 57% got their degree after 6 years. I can't imagine the studentdebtthe remaining43% have, and no degree.
It would seem that the problem extends to all levels of education.
I don't have an answer to this problem.
We have to figure out a way to get the potential employers, involved in curriculum development and teaching strategy but also involved in investing in the development and improvement of schools and the education process that supplies them with their generations of workers.
Sounds easy but everyone knows it is not.
One of the problems here in KY is that, even with community colleges that are so-called branches of the major universities, the classes taught are not accepted as credit at the university level. For example, one can take English at the community college level, but one has to take basically the same English course, at a major university in order to gain credit toward a degree. That's not right.
The rationale for this is that most of the teachers aren't as qualified as those at the major university level. Yes, and no. I have friends that teach at community colleges who have their masters, AND have practical experience. I also know many of the required courses that have a large population of students taking the course at the major university that are taught by graduate students. So, which is better? Someone who has their master's and practiced in their field or someone who is still studying-- at the graduate level?
Another problem I see here, is that many of the community colleges are private, and designed solely to separate the student from his money, rather than actually produce a degree-holding graduate. OR they offer degrees that are no available at a 4 year university. Like Chef School. We had a big stink here at one of the community colleges, where the school was teaching a medically certified program, and they lost their certification. The students, who had spent thousands of dollars, suddenly had no hope of attaining a certified degree, or to practice and with time, attain certification. Sad situation!
Here are some interesting statistics on graduation rates in KY from community colleges vs university.
Dowser,
I think that there needs to be a clear definition between 2 year tech schools and community colleges. Community colleges are usually either run by the state or a city and has a low cost. There are private 2 year tech schools that are very costly and don't seem to have high employment rates that they often advertise.
As Ms. Jackson pointed out, real community colleges are for all age groups, don't cost much and can have you working quickly, if you chose your major correctly.
Our state-assisted technical colleges have a pretty good graduation rate, here in Louisville. The state-run and university backed 2 year colleges are supposed to be staging points for the last 2 years of a 4 year degree-- but they don't always operate that way. Again, often the credits are not accepted.
The private 2-year colleges, i.e. "Chef School", and some of the medical technician training schools, have lower graduation rates, OR they require 3-4 years to get a "degree" in the field chosen, and it is, to me, expensive. We have Jefferson County Technical College-- JCTC-- and they do well-- but they are state sponsored. We also have Spencerian College, and a whole slew of others that are private 2 year programs, that sometimes take 3-4 years to get through, and aren't necessarily degreed programs...
The Community Colleges here, (Like Jefferson County Community College-JCCC), are sponsored by University of Kentucky, (or University of Louisville, out and about in the state), yet are expensive-- the only savings is that the student can live at home and commute-- so they can save on room and board. Tuition rates are similar. They don't offer the higher level courses, but it's been my experience that they don't accept the credits on a one for one basis, when trying to transfer to the sponsoring university, anyway.
If one wants to become a plumber or electrician, for example, one attends the JCTC. If one wants to become a Chef, (and there are all kinds of chefs), one can attend Spalding University, Spencerian College, Indiana Wesleyan, etc. The medical technician degree came from one of those schools, and they lost their certification 1/2 way through many of the student's programs. If you want to live at home and commute, one can go to JCCC-- if you wish to finish your degree at UK. Here in Louisville, one can also attend University of Louisville, and commute.
Does that make sense now? Also there are all kinds of on-line colleges that have sprung up, offering "special" degrees in hotel management, book keeping, and a wide variety of subjects.
I had to study about the different certifications of colleges and universities in order to approve/disapprove of the educational requirements for certifications. Fortunately, few Community Colleges offer much in the way of geology courses or degrees, but there are quite a few private colleges that do so. It can be a nightmare to wade through all that to make sure a school is actually accredited.
Of course, I only really work with the requirements for a professional degree, accepting/denying applications for certification from 4 year universities and colleges... That being said, even some of the smaller colleges don't have the accreditation required to meet the requirements for certification in geology. It's tough to determine!
College accreditation is a big deal, and a labyrinth of shadiness blended with legitimate accreditation sources. They all sound wonderful, but when you read some of their requirements for accreditation, it's almost laughable, except that someone spends money to attend that college and gets "taken".
Kavika, when I was in 4th grade, (1964), our teacher told us that only 5 kids out of the class were likely to go to college and 1, maybe 2, would likely graduate. Well, that was an unusual class, because out of that class of 28 kids, almost 20 of them went to college, and there were several doctors and lawyers, (no Indian Chiefs, unfortunately)...
For many years, in KY, only 20% of all people working at non-trade jobs had college degrees-- and I don't think that's changed much. A 57% graduation rate, while low, certainly seems like an improvement to me, from when I went to school...
Looking at tuition rates for JCCC--
In-state tuition is $147/hour at JCCC. 15 hours = $2,205
University of Kentucky - in-state, full time student, per semester = $5,232
So there is a significant savings-- but if the credits don't transfer, then the savings vanishes...
Hi, Barbara! I just checked and the community colleges here don't offer those kinds of classes-- those are taught either by the technical colleges or as adult education courses through the Jefferson County Public School system...
I'd love to take a few classes myself-- and maybe pursue another bachelor's degree, (that is, if I could get my old brain to cook again)...
I took oil painting at the adult education in Daviess County, KY, and had a blast. I have no talent, just enthusiasm, but made glorious messes and had a wonderful time-- learned a lot, too!
B A Jackson
Excellent point, which I agree with
This is where the alignment of curriculum to local businesses, regional businesses etc needs and potential employment and tailoring of the curriculum to meet the needs will be a good thing.
A perfect opportunity for business and education partner to the benefit of both and more importantly to the benefit of the young
Thanks for the feedback
Dowser
As usual you are right, there is a place for the transitory curriculum for those that will go on to a four year school and a place for programs that are complete in two years as well.
There is also a great need for technical schools to prepare young people for good paying jobs in the trades and in professions where technical skills and certificates/licenses are more important than a four year college degree
Thanks for the feedback
Dowser
Rural Ohio has been and continues to have issues with the numbers going to college and the numbers graduating as well
We are seeing a resurgence of technical schools (high school and post secondary) preparing the young who do not want to go to college (ever or at this time) for positions in the work force
Dowser
If the courses or the instructors are not good enough for credit at a four year school, students should not be paying for them and the instructors should not be getting paid to teach them in my view.
Perrie
Excellent point
Some technical schools are better than others (as far as employment potential goes) but parents and children should take care in selecting them for sure
Excellent perspective from a professional which I appreciate
Dowser
Sounds like community colleges and technical schools in KY are set up much like they are in OH. We have Kent State branches all over the north and some branches of the other major universities spread around and like you said there is little real cost advantage other than living at home and we often see a requirement to "go on campus" the last year anyway for classes needed for degrees not offered locally.
The "pop up schools" are to be avoided in my view as they are a means of generating money and not education or skills for the students in some cases
M M
Whether it is free or not, if it does not provide meaningful education or a degree that facilitates the job search process then it needs to be fixed.
I don't know a lot about U of Pheonix, but I do know a few folks that completed graduate degrees on that route and it helped some of them along the career path quite well.
Indeed, Indeed