╌>

Money Makes Crazy

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  11 years ago  •  4 comments

Money Makes Crazy

Monetary policy probably wont be a major issue in the 2016 campaign, but it should be. It is, after all, extremely important, and the Republican base and many leading politicians have strong views about the Federal Reserve and its conduct. And the eventual presidential nominee will surely have to endorse the party line.

So it matters that the emerging G.O.P. consensus on money is crazy full-on conspiracy-theory crazy.

Right now, the most obvious manifestation of money madness is Senator Rand Pauls Audit the Fed campaign. Mr. Paul likes to warn that the Feds efforts to bolster the economy may lead to hyperinflation; he loves talking about the wheelbarrows of cash that people carted around in Weimar Germany. But hes been saying that since 2009, and it keeps not happening. So now he has a new line: The Fed is an overleveraged bank, just as Lehman Brothers was, and could experience a disastrous collapse of confidence any day now.

This story is wrong on so many levels that reporters are having a hard time keeping up, but lets simply note that the Feds liabilities consist of cash, and those who hold that cash have the option of converting it into, well, cash. No, the Fed cant fall victim to a bank run. But is Mr. Paul being ostracized for his views? Not at all.

Moreover, while Mr. Paul may currently be the poster child for off-the-wall monetary views, hes far from alone. A lot has been written about the 2010 open letter from leading Republicans to Ben Bernanke, then the Fed chairman, demanding that he cease efforts to support the economy, warning that such efforts would lead to inflation and currency debasement. Less has been written about the simultaneous turn of seemingly respectable figures to conspiracy theories.

There was, for example, the 2010 op-ed article by Representative Paul Ryan, who remains the G.O.P.s de facto intellectual leader, and John Taylor, the partys favorite monetary economist. Fed policy, they declared, looks an awful lot like an attempt to bail out fiscal policy, and such attempts call the Feds independence into question. That statement looks an awful lot like a claim that Mr. Bernanke and colleagues were betraying their trust in order to help out the Obama administration a claim for which there is no evidence whatsoever.

Oh, and suppose you believe that the Feds actions did help avert what would otherwise have been a fiscal crisis. This is supposed to be a bad thing?

You may think that at least some of the current presidential aspirants are staying well clear of the fever swamps, but dont be so sure. Jeb Bush appears to be getting his economic agenda , such as it is, from the George W. Bush Institutes 4% Growth Project. And the head of that project, Amity Shlaes , is a prominent inflation truther, someone who claims that the government is greatly understating the true rate of inflation.

So monetary crazy is pervasive in todays G.O.P. But why? Class interests no doubt play a role the wealthy tend to be lenders rather than borrowers, and they benefit at least in relative terms from deflationary policies. But I also suspect that conservatives have a deep psychological problem with modern monetary systems.

You see, in the conservative worldview, markets arent just a useful way to organize the economy; theyre a moral structure: People get paid what they deserve, and what goods cost is what they are truly worth to society. You could say that to the free-market true believer, to know the price of everything is also to know the value of everything.

Modern money consisting of pieces of paper or their digital equivalent that are issued by the Fed, not created by the heroic efforts of entrepreneurs is an affront to that worldview. Mr. Ryan is on record declaring that his views on monetary policy come from a speech given by one of Ayn Rands fictional characters. And what the speaker declares is that money is the base of a moral existence. Destroyers seize gold and leave to its owners a counterfeit pile of paper. ... Paper is a check drawn by legal looters.

Once you understand that this is how many conservatives really think, it all falls into place. Of course they predict disaster from monetary expansion, no matter the circumstances. Of course they are undaunted in their views no matter how wrong their predictions have been in the past. Of course they are quick to accuse the Fed of vile motives. From their point of view, monetary policy isnt really a technical issue, a question of what works; its a matter of theology: Printing money is evil.

So as I said, monetary policy should be an issue in 2016. Because theres a pretty good chance that someone who either gets his monetary economics from Ayn Rand, or at any rate feels the need to defer to such views, will get to appoint the next head of the Federal Reserve.

Money Makes Crazy , Paul Krugman, New York Times


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Eliminate the Fed!

Audit the Fed!

These are everyday slogans on the right. They are unquestioned TRUTH. Their desirability is graven in granite, among the tricorne crowd.

A short while ago, I posted an article asking for NT's conservatives to explain how they mean to implement this policy when (not "if") they acquire absolute power in this country. The reaction was depressingly empty: it seems that, beyond the bumper-sticker slogan, conservatives haven't the slightest idea of the consequences of their "policy".

Krugman says:

... monetary policy should be an issue in 2016. Because theres a pretty good chance that someone who either gets his monetary economics from Ayn Rand, or at any rate feels the need to defer to such views, will get to appoint the next head of the Federal Reserve.

The tricorne crowd is going to be very disappointed. They believe that they are about to come into power. They have shouted from the rooftops that "The US is not a democracy!". They will soon learn that they are among the disenfranchised. But I fear that their awakening will come too late.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

They have shouted from the rooftops that "The US is not a democracy!"

Well ... to be fair a republic is not the same as a pure democracy . The world hasn't seen one of those since ancient Athens ...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

The world hasn't seen one of those since ancient Athens ...

The world has NEVER seen such a thing, because its dangers are so obvious that no one has ever gone there.

"Pure democracy" is a purely imaginary monster that the Tea Party puppeteers use to frighten the tricorne crowd into forfeiting their rights.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

The world has NEVER seen such a thing, because its dangers are so obvious that no one has ever gone there.

It's dangers were not obvious in ancient Athens as Themisticles found out the hard way .

 
 

Who is online

Gsquared


86 visitors