╌>

Kissinger on Iran -- Has the U.S. already conceded a new era of nuclear proliferation? WSJ Editorial, Feb. 9, 2015

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  11 years ago  •  10 comments

Kissinger on Iran -- Has the U.S. already conceded a new era of nuclear proliferation? WSJ Editorial, Feb. 9, 2015

One big question coming out of the Munich security conference this weekend is whether Iran and the U.S. can strike a nuclear deal before the next, and perhaps final, deadline in March. But the better question may be what happens if they succeedwhat happens if they sign an accord close to the parameters of the talks as we now know them? The Obama Administration may be underwriting a new era of global nuclear proliferation.

Thats the question Henry Kissinger diplomatically raised in recent testimony to the Senate that deserves far more public attention. The former Secretary of State is the dean of American strategists who negotiated nuclear pacts with the Soviets in the 1970s. This gives his views on the Iran talks particular relevance as President Obama drives to an accord that he hopes will be the capstone of his second term.

Former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger

On Jan. 29 Mr. Kissinger appeared before the Senate Armed Services Committee with two other former Secretaries of State, George Shultz and Madeleine Albright. Heres how he described the talks in his prepared remarks:

"Nuclear talks with Iran began as an international effort, buttressed by six U.N. resolutions, to deny Iran the capabilit y to develop a military nuclear option. They are now an essentially bilateral negotiation over the scope of that capability through an agreement that sets a hypothetical limit of one year on an assumed breakout. The impact of this approach will be to move from preventing proliferation to managing it." (The italics are Mr. Kissingers.)

Mull that one over. Mr. Kissinger always speaks with care not to undermine a U.S. Administration, and the same is true here. But he is clearly worried about how far the U.S. has moved from its original negotiating position that Iran cannot enrich uranium or maintain thousands of centrifuges. And he is concerned that these concessions will lead the world to perceive that such a deal would put Iran on the cusp of being a nuclear power.

Administration leaks to the media have made clear that Secretary of State John Kerry s current negotiating position is that Iran should have a breakout period of no less than a year. But as Mr. Kissinger told the Senators in response to questions, that means verification and inspections become crucial. "In the space of one year, that will create huge inspection problems, but Ill reserve my comment on that until I see the agreement," Mr. Kissinger said.

"But I would also emphasize the issue of proliferation. Assuming one accepts the inspection as valid" and "takes account of the stockpile of nuclear material that already exists, the question then is what do the other countries in the region do? And if the other countries in the region conclude that America has approved the development of an enrichment capability within one year of a nuclear weapon, and if they then insist on building the same capability, we will live in a proliferated world in which everybodyeven if that agreement is maintainedwill be very close to the trigger point."

Mr. Kissinger didnt say it, but those other nations include Saudi Arabia, which can buy a bomb from Pakistan; Turkey, which wont sit by and let Shiite Iran dominate the region; Egypt, which has long viewed itself as the leading Arab state; and perhaps one or more of the Gulf emirates, which may not trust the Saudis. Thats in addition to Israel, which is assumed to have had a bomb for many years without posing a regional threat.

This is a very different world than the one we have been living in since the dawn of the nuclear age. A world with multiple nuclear states, including some with revolutionary religious impulses or hegemonic ambitions, is a very dangerous place. A proliferated world would limit the credibility of U.S. deterrence on behalf of allies. It would also imperil U.S. forces and even the homeland via ballistic missiles that Iran is developing but are not part of the U.S.-Iran talks.

President Obama would claim the inspection regime is fail-safe, but Iran hid its weapons program from United Nations inspectors for years. Thats why the U.N. passed its many resolutions and the current talks began. Iran also hid its facility at Qum. All of this shows how difficult it is to maintain a credible inspection regime in a country determined to evade it. Or as Mr. Kissinger delicately put it, "Nobody can really fully trust the inspection system or at least some [countries] may not."

Our own view is that Mr. Obama is so bent on an Iran deal that he will make almost any concession to get one. In any case Mr. Kissingers concerns underscore the need for Congressional scrutiny and a vote on any agreement with Iran.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Doesn't anyone care about the most important issue facing this country?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Key paragraph:

"Nuclear talks with Iran began as an international effort, buttressed by six U.N. resolutions, to deny Iran the capability to develop a military nuclear option. They are now an essentially bilateral negotiation over the scope of that capability through an agreement that sets a hypothetical limit of one year on an assumed breakout. The impact of this approach will be to move from preventing proliferation to managing it." (The emphasis is Mr. Kissingers.)

That means Obama has retreated from denying the capability to merely delaying if for one year. ONE YEAR! So he leaves the coping with Iran's nuclear arms to his successor.

That is why Iran claims to have defeated us.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Iran HAS defeated the US with the help of your president. I'm just shaking my head at the probable consequences of the ineptitude of the US administration in this matter. The Iranians must be shaking their heads in laughter. If Iran were not a supplier of military supplies to terrorists I would not be concerned.

I think I'll watch the movie "On the Beach" again.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

If your so worried about the Iranians Buzz, Why don't you talk to your leadership there in China and get them to stop supporting the government with technology......

Oh, and consider passing that same word on to your next door neighbors in Korea....

I knew that Len was incapable of remaining objective on issues, I can't expect more from you?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Does your loyalty trump even considering what Kissinger said? Or is it because he's a Republican that he should be ignored? You consider it "subjective" if I agree with Kissinger and it is "objective" that you don't?

I don't agree with many things that China does, but since I want to live here in peace where I feel safer than I could possibly feel in America, I don't make a noise about it. I believe in "When in Rome...".

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

I read Kissinger's Autobiography back in 2005. I have respect for the man for what he has achieved in his lifetime, but I also have reservations with some of his negotiations, and what he has done in the shadows of American government for decades. Many of them when put in perspectives of the Nuremberg trials would have him possibly hanging from the end of a rope.

His involvement in the South Vietnamese pulling out of the Paris Peace talks in 68 (costing another 20,000 American lives, and who knows how many Vietnamese lives in the process)

Cambodia bombing in 69. Thousands dead.

Kurds being left to die after recruitment to overthrow Saddam in 72-75.

His support for the Shaw of Iran 71-76 in light of his brutal handling of political enemies.

Chile in 73

I have learned to take what ever comes out of Kissinger's mouth as being detrimental to the civilian lives of those he comes out against, and in some cases even in support of.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

I don't necessarily agree with everything he has done in the past, but I agree with him on this issue.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Fair enough answer Buzz.

Hope all is well with you...

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Thanks - still breathing. Smile.gif

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Having been in China on some bad air quality days, that's a very important statement.

Take care.

 
 

Who is online



81 visitors