╌>

The Dangerous Lie That ‘Bush Lied’ -- Some journalists still peddle this canard as if it were fact. This is defamatory and could end up hurting the country, WSJ. By: Laurence H. Silberman Feb. 8, 2015

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  11 years ago  •  131 comments

The Dangerous Lie That ‘Bush Lied’ -- Some journalists still peddle this canard as if it were fact. This is defamatory and could end up hurting the country, WSJ. By: Laurence H. Silberman Feb. 8, 2015

Some journalists still peddle this canard as if it were fact. This is defamatory and could end up hurting the country. By: Laurence H. Silberman Feb. 8, 2015

In recent weeks, I have heard former Associate Press reporter Ron Fournier on Fox News twice asserting, quite offhandedly, that President George W. Bush lied us into war in Iraq.

I found this shocking. I took a leave of absence from the bench in 2004-05 to serve as co-chairman of the Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass Destructiona bipartisan body, sometimes referred to as the Robb-Silberman Commission. It was directed in 2004 to evaluate the intelligence communitys determination that Saddam Hussein possessed WMDI am, therefore, keenly aware of both the intelligence provided to President Bush and his reliance on that intelligence as his primary casus belli . It is astonishing to see the Bush lied allegation evolve from antiwar slogan to journalistic fact.

The intelligence communitys 2002 National Intelligence Estimate (NIE) stated, in a formal presentation to President Bush and to Congress, its view that Saddam had weapons of mass destructiona belief in which the NIE said it held a 90% level of confidence. That is about as certain as the intelligence community gets on any subject.

Recall that the head of the intelligence community, Central Intelligence Agency Director George Tenet, famously told the president that the proposition that Iraq possessed WMD was a slam dunk. Our WMD commission carefully examined the interrelationships between the Bush administration and the intelligence community and found no indication that anyone in the administration sought to pressure the intelligence community into its findings. As our commission reported, presidential daily briefs from the CIA dating back to the Clinton administration were, if anything, more alarmist about Iraqs WMD than the 2002 National Intelligence Estimate.

Saddam had manifested sharp hostility toward America, including firing at U.S. planes patrolling the no-fly zone set up by the armistice agreement ending the first Iraq war. Saddam had also attempted to assassinate former President George H.W. Bush a car-bombing plot was foiledduring Mr. Bushs visit to Kuwait in 1993. But President George W. Bush based his decision to go to war on information about Saddams WMD. Accordingly, when Secretary of State Colin Powell formally presented the U.S. case to the United Nations, Mr. Powell relied entirely on that aspect of the threat from Iraq.

Our WMD commission ultimately determined that the intelligence community was dead wrong about Saddams weapons. But as I recall, no one in Washington political circles offered significant disagreement with the intelligence community before the invasion. The National Intelligence Estimate was persuasiveto the president, to Congress and to the media.

Granted, there were those who disagreed with waging war against Saddam even if he did possess WMD. Some in Congress joined Brent Scowcroft, a retired Air Force lieutenant general and former national security adviser, in publicly doubting the wisdom of invading Iraq. It is worth noting, however, that when Saddam was captured and interrogated, he told his interrogators that he had intended to seek revenge on Kuwait for its cooperation with the U.S. by invading again at a propitious time. This leads me to speculate that if the Bush administration had not gone to war in 2003 and Saddam had remained in power, the U.S. might have felt compelled to do so once Iraq again invaded Kuwait.

In any event, it is one thing to assert, then or now, that the Iraq war was ill-advised. It is quite another to make the horrendous charge that President Bush lied to or deceived the American people about the threat from Saddam.

I recently wrote to Ron Fournier protesting his accusation. His response, in an email, was to reiterate that an objective reading of the events leads to only one conclusion: the administration . . . misinterpreted, distorted and in some cases lied about intelligence. Although Mr. Fournier referred to evidence supporting his view, he did not cite anyand I do not believe there is any.

He did say correctly that intelligence is never dispositive; it requires analysis and judgment, with the final call and responsibility resting with the president. It is thus certainly possible to criticize President Bush for having believed what the CIA told him, although it seems to me that any president would have credited such confident assertions by the intelligence community. But to accuse the president of lying us into war must be seen as not only false, but as dangerously defamatory.

The charge is dangerous because it can take on the air of historical factwith potentially dire consequences. I am reminded of a similarly baseless accusation that helped the Nazis come to power in Germany: that the German army had not really lost World War I, that the soldiers instead had been stabbed in the back by politicians.

Sometime in the future, perhaps long after most of us are gone, an American president may need to rely publicly on intelligence reports to support military action. It would be tragic if, at such a critical moment, the presidents credibility were undermined by memories of a false charge peddled by the likes of Ron Fournier.

Mr. Silberman, a senior federal judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, was co-chairman of the Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass Destruction.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

presidential daily briefs

And Obama says "What's that"?

And now for the factchecks.org and Politifact copy/paste, but none of the videos of Clinton, Pelosi etc.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Actually it is the NY Times that morphed into the Daily Worker.

I read the Journal (as well as the Times) before Rupert and I see no difference. The Times however has crashed.

Your problem here is with Judge Laurence Silberman. You went after Murdoch because he is an easier target.

Laurence Hirsch Silberman (born October 12, 1935) is a senior federal judge on the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit . He was appointed in October 1985 by Ronald Reagan and took senior status on November 1, 2000. He continues to serve on the court. On June 11, 2008, Silberman was named a recipient of the Presidential Medal of Freedom , the highest civilian honor granted by the government of the United States. [ 1 ]

His government service includes stints as an attorney in the NLRB's appellate section, as Solicitor of the Department of Labor from 1969 to 1970, and as Undersecretary of Labor from 1970 to 1973. As Solicitor, he was largely responsible for developing the requirement of goals and timetables as an enforcement device for the affirmative action order. He subsequently regretted his stance, writing, "Our use of numerical standards in pursuit of equal opportunity has led to the very quotas guaranteeing equal results that we initially wished to avoid." [ 3 ]

He also led the development of legislation to implement "final offer selection" as a means of resolving labor disputes. [ 4 ] As Undersecretary, he repeatedly clashed with Charles "Chuck" Colson and tendered his resignation in order to compel the hiring of a black regional director in New York in 1972. [ 5 ]

As Deputy Attorney General of the United States from 1974 to 1975, Silberman was tasked with reviewing J. Edgar Hoover 's secret files, which he has described as "the single worst experience of my long governmental service." [ 6 ] Silberman has stated that "this country--and the Federal Bureau of Investigation --would be well served if [Hoover's] name were removed from the bureau's building. It is as if the Defense Department were named for Aaron Burr. Liberals and conservatives should unite to support legislation to accomplish this repudiation of a very sad chapter in American history." [ 7 ]

Silberman also served briefly as Acting Attorney General during the Watergate crisis , an experience he has described as awkward: "We were simultaneously carrying out President Nixon's agenda and supporting those who were vigorously prosecuting him."

Gerald Ford appointed Silberman as Ambassador to Yugoslavia from 1975 to 1977. At the same time, Silberman also served as the Presidential Special Envoy for International Labor Organization Affairs. As Ambassador, he succeeded in freeing an American, Laszlo Toth, who had been falsely imprisoned by the regime as a "CIA agent," by putting pressure on both the Yugoslav regime and the State Department. [ 8 ] During the campaign for the 1980 presidential election , he was co-chairman of Ronald Reagan 's foreign policy advisors. From 1981 to 1985, he served as a member of the General Advisory Committee on Arms Control and Disarmament and the Defense Policy Board .

Silberman was on the short list of potential nominees to the Supreme Court on three separate occasions in 1987, 1990, and 1991. [ 9 ]

He was a member of the United States Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court of Review at the time of its first ever session in 2002. [ 10 ]

On February 6, 2004, Silberman was appointed co-chairman of the Iraq Intelligence Commission , an independent blue-ribbon panel created to investigate U.S. intelligence surrounding the United States ' 2003 invasion of Iraq and Iraq's weapons of mass destruction . In the wake of the resignation of Alberto Gonzales as United States Attorney General in 2007, Silberman was mentioned as a possible successor. [ 11 ]

Yet you think you know more about Iraq than Silberman. You probably also think you know more about relativity than Einstein. Mousy is a fitting name for a mouse in a land of giants.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

If an idiot wants to learn "what actually happened" he can go here to see what DEMOCRAT leaders were saying about Sadaam's WMDs:

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Of course I did not mean youGrin.gif so don't be blue.

But in interest of full disclosure of the record here is what Democratic leaders said:

"One way or the other, we are determined to deny Iraq the capacity to develop weapons of mass destruction and the missiles to deliver them. That is our bottom line."

- President Clinton, Feb. 4, 1998

"Iraq is a long way from [here], but what happens there matters a great deal here. For the risks that the leaders of a rogue state will use nuclear, chemical or biological weapons against us or our allies is the greatest security threat we face."

- Madeline Albright, Feb 18, 1998

"He will use those weapons of mass destruction again, as he has ten times

since 1983."

- Sandy Berger, Clinton National Security Adviser, Feb, 18, 1998

"[W]e urge you, after consulting with Congress, and consistent with the U.S.

Constitution and laws, to take necessary actions (including, if appropriate, air and missile strikes on suspect Iraqi sites) to respond effectively to the threat posed by Iraq's refusal to end its weapons of mass destruction programs."

- Letter to President Clinton, signed by Sens. Carl Levin, Tom Daschle, John Kerry, and others Oct. 9, 1998

"Saddam Hussein has been engaged in the development of weapons of mass destruction technology which is a threat to countries in the region and he has made a mockery of the weapons inspection process."

- Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D, CA), Dec. 16, 1998

"Hussein has .. chosen to spend his money on building weapons of mass destruction and palaces for his cronies."

- Madeline Albright, Clinton Secretary of State, Nov. 10, 1999

"There is no doubt that ... Saddam Hussein has invigorated his weapons programs. Reports indicate that biological, chemical and nuclear programs continue apace and may be back to pre-Gulf War status. In addition, Saddam continues to redefine delivery systems and is doubtless using the cover of a licit missile program to develop longer-range missiles that will threaten the United States and our allies."

- Letter to President Bush, Signed by Sen Bob Graham (D, FL,) and others, December 5, 2001

"We begin with the common belief that Saddam Hussein is a tyrant and a threat to the peace and stability of the region. He has ignored the mandated of the United Nations and is building weapons of mass destruction and the means of delivering them."

- Sen. Carl Levin (D, MI), Sept. 19, 2002

"We know that he has stored secret supplies of biological and chemical weapons throughout his country."

- Al Gore, Sept. 23, 2002

"Iraq's search for weapons of mass destruction has proven impossible to deter and we should assume that it will continue for as long as Saddam is in power."

- Al Gore, Sept. 23, 2002

"We have known for many years that Saddam Hussein is seeking and developing

weapons of mass destruction."

- Sen. Ted Kennedy (D, MA), Sept. 27, 2002

"The last UN weapons inspectors left Iraq in October of 1998. We are confident that Saddam Hussein retains some stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons, and that he has since embarked on a crash course to build up his chemical and biological warfare capabilities. Intelligence reports indicate that he is seeking nuclear weapons..."

- Sen. Robert Byrd (D, WV), Oct. 3, 2002

"I will be voting to give the President of the United States the authority to use force-- if necessary-- to disarm Saddam Hussein because I believe that a deadly arsenal of weapons of mass destruction in his hands is a real and grave threat to our security."

  • Sen. John F. Kerry (D, MA), Oct. 9, 2002

    "The terrorist threat against America is all too clear. Thousands of terrorist operatives around the world would pay anything to get their hands on Saddam's arsenal, and there is every reason to believe that Saddam would turn his weapons over to these terrorists. No one can doubt that if the terrorists of Sept. 11 had had weapons of mass destruction, they would have used them. On Sept. 12, 2002, we can hardly ignore the terrorist threat and the serious danger that Saddam would allow his arsenal to be used in aid of terror."

    John Edwards Sept. 12, 2002

    "Others argue that if even our allies support us, we should not support this resolution because confronting Iraq now would undermine the long-term fight against terrorist groups like al Qaeda. Yet, I believe that this is not an either-or choice. Our national security requires us to do both, and we can."--

    John Edwards Oct. 10, 2002

    "There is unmistakable evidence that Saddam Hussein is working aggressively to develop nuclear weapons and will likely have nuclear weapons within the next five years ... We also should remember we have always underestimated the progress Saddam has made in development of weapons of mass destruction."

    - Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D, WV), Oct 10, 2002

    "He has systematically violated, over the course of the past 11 years, every significant UN resolution that has demanded that he disarm and destroy his chemical and biological weapons, and any nuclear capacity. This he has refused to do" Rep.

    - Henry Waxman (D, CA), Oct. 10, 2002

    "In the four years since the inspectors left, intelligence reports show that Saddam Hussein has worked to rebuild his chemical and biological weapons stock, his missile delivery capability, and his nuclear program. He has also given aid, comfort, and sanctuary to terrorists, including al Qaeda members .. It is clear, however, that if left unchecked, Saddam Hussein will continue to increase his capacity to wage biological and chemical warfare, and will keep trying to develop nuclear weapons."

    - Sen. Hillary Clinton (D, NY), Oct 10, 2002

    "We are in possession of what I think to be compelling evidence that Saddam Hussein has, and has had for a number of years, a developing capacity for the production and storage of weapons of mass destruction."

    - Sen. Bob Graham (D, FL), Dec. 8, 2002

    "Without question, we need to disarm Saddam Hussein. He is a brutal, murderous dictator, leading an oppressive regime ... He presents a particularly grievous threat because he is so consistently prone to miscalculation ... And now he is is calculating America's response to his continued deceit and his consistent grasp for weapons of mass destruction ... So the threat of Saddam Hussein with weapons of mass destruction is real ..."

    - Sen. John F. Kerry (D, MA), Jan. 23. 2003

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Most of those quotes are from 2002, after 9/11/2001.

The war began less than a year later and Sadaam was captured in 2003.

You are trying to rewrite history.

Those inspection teams operated concurrently with the war as well as before it.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
You'll never convince the tin-hat brigade, Len. They deny historical facts at will.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Says the guy who posts an article claiming that Bush/Cheney didn't lie.

The author was Justice Laurence H.Silberman, a senior federal judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia,co-chairman of the Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass Destruction.

But, genius that you are, you prefer to believe Mickey Mouse.

All I did was take note of the conspicuous gap between 1999 and 2001 and the lack of any of the UN's work in the quotes that YOU provided.

What gap? I saw no gap. I provided all the quotes that were in the liberal Snopes.com fact-finding site. I omitted none. You are welcome to produce others but I will not hold my breath.

If pointing out that omission equates my rewritting (sic) history rather than you, this conversation is over.

You ARE definitely trying to rewrite historybut if you do not want to back up your falsehoods so be it.

I notice you ignore the Bush/Cheney mantra that Iraq was responsible for 9/11, the biggest whopper of them all.

Show me where they said that.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

WMD Just A Convenient Excuse for War, Admits Wolfowitz
By David Usborne

Global Policy Forum , May 30, 2003

The Bush administration focused on alleged weapons of mass destruction as the primary justification for toppling Saddam Hussein by force because it was politically convenient, a top-level official at the Pentagon has acknowledged. The extraordinary admission comes in an interview with Paul Wolfowitz, the Deputy Defence Secretary, in the July issue of the magazine Vanity Fair .


Mr Wolfowitz also discloses that there was one justification that was "almost unnoticed but huge". That was the prospect of the United States being able to withdraw all of its forces from Saudi Arabia once the threat of Saddam had been removed. Since the taking of Baghdad, Washington has said that it is taking its troops out of the kingdom. "Just lifting that burden from the Saudis is itself going to the door" towards making progress elsewhere in achieving Middle East peace, Mr Wolfowitz said. The presence of the US military in Saudi Arabia has been one of the main grievances of al-Qa'ida and other terrorist groups.

"For bureaucratic reasons we settled on one issue, weapons of mass destruction, because it was the one reason everyone could agree on," Mr Wolfowitz tells the magazine. The comments suggest that, even for the US administration, the logic that was presented for going to war may have been an empty shell. They come to light, moreover, just two days after Mr Wolfowitz's immediate boss, Donald Rumsfeld, the Defence Secretary, conceded for the first time that the arms might never be found.

"WMD" were, according to Paul Wolfowitz himself, a convenient fiction. An intentional, misleading fiction. I think most people would use a shorter form: WMD were a lie .

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

"For bureaucratic reasons we settled on one issue, weapons of mass destruction, because it was the one reason everyone could agree on," is the only direct quote and it is far from proving your and the author's assertion. Everything else is the author's and youropinion .

Why don't you quote Vanity Fair directly?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

What is the Daily Banter?

All this is a bunch of cherry-picked out-of-context op-eds. I recognize one of them to be totally false:

You can read all sorts of comments about the NIE, which included the long-debunked story of Saddam Hussein trying to buy yellowcake uranium in Niger, right here. Didnt take much Googling at all.

It was verified, not debunked. Googling is like using computers. The operative phrase is GIGO, garbage in, garbage out.

At his press conference with President Bush in July, 2003,, Prime Minister Blair said, "In case people should think that the whole idea of a link between Iraq and Niger was some invention, in the 1980s we know for sure that Iraq purchased round about 270 tons of uranium from Niger." Then the White House declassified and released the portion of the NIE entitled "Iraq's Continuing Programs for Weapons of Mass Destruction." Iraq, the intelligence document says, has been "vigorously trying to procure uranium ore" in Somalia and Congo as well as Niger.

Joseph Wilson's claims vis--vis Iraqi pursuit of Nigerois uraniumfell apart as well. When questioned by the Senate Intelligence Committee on this topic, he acknowledged that a key assertion "may have involved 'a little literary flair.' "

"A little literary flair?" Following is an excerpt from a Wolf Blitzer interview withy Joseph Wilson:

BLITZER: All right. This is what the Intelligence Committee report writes in their conclusion:

"The reports officer from the CIA said that a good grade was merited" -- he said you got a good grade for your report -- "was merited, because the information responded to at least some of the outstanding questions of the intelligence community, but did not provide substantial new information."

He said he judged that the most important fact in the report -- that would be your report -- was that Niger officials admitted that the Iraqi delegation had traveled there in 1999, and that the Niger prime minister believed the Iraqis were interested in purchasing uranium, because this provided some confirmation -- a foreign government service reporting.

Basically...

WILSON: Again, again...

BLITZER: Let me explain to our viewers, because it gets a little confusing. Basically, the CIA officer concluded from what you told him that there might be an element of truth in these reports because you confirmed to them that there was an effort along the same lines in 1999.

WILSON: There were two meetings between Iraqi delegations and the Niger government. One was a trip to Niger by an Iraqi ambassador to the Vatican, which as it turns out, as most people have now reported on, was part of a trip to the region to encourage presidents to break the travel ban and travel to Iraq. There is nobody who has suggested that there is credible evidence that uranium was under discussion there.

The second meeting was between the prime minister and an Iraqi, who turned out to be the minister of information in the second Iraq war, on the margins of an international organization meeting in Algiers. And during the course of that meeting, actually before the meeting, the prime minister who took the meeting because a constituent asked him to, pondered whether or not uranium might be something to discuss...

BLITZER : But do you understand that this CIA officer told the Senate Intelligence Committee exactly the opposite of what you've been saying. He came away reassured that there might be some evidence of some sort of connection there...

WILSON: No...

BLITZER: ... based on your confirmation that...

WILSON: ... I think...

BLITZER: ... there was this meeting in '99.

WILSON: I think it was important for everybody to understand that we needed to continue to monitor Saddam Hussein and his ongoing interests in uranium. Notwithstanding that, the allegation that was backed by these documents later turned out to be forgeries, was not sustained by the evidence that it was out there.

At the meeting in Algiers, uranium was not raised. It was not a subject of conversation. Now,let me just say...

BLITZER: But is there any other export that Niger has?

WILSON: But it was not raised as a subject, so it is hard to get from there to saying that we have learned or the British government has learned that Iraq has attempted to purchase significant quantities of uranium from Africa.

Now let me just share a couple of things from you. One, on October 2, the deputy director of the Central Intelligence Agency...

BLITZER: October 2, of?

WILSON: Of 2002, 2002.

BLITZER: Before the war?

WILSON: Before the war, before the State of the Union address -- said to the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, he testified that one thing where I think they, the British, stretched a little bit beyond where we would stretch it, is on the points about where Iraq was seeking uranium from various African locations.

On October 6, 2002, the director of Central Intelligence called the deputy national security adviser to outline the CIA's concerns about this assertion. He testified, the director of Central Intelligence, on July 16, 2003, that he told the deputy national security adviser the president should not be a fact witness on this issue because the reporting was weak.

BLITZER: I assume you believe and everybody else believes the original source of a lot of this information were British intelligence reports. Is that right?

WILSON: I don't know.

BLITZER: But that's...

WILSON: I don't know, and I have... BLITZER: ... it's what I've...

WILSON: ... never, I have never known.

BLITZER : In the Butler report, the British version of the Senate Intelligence Committee report that came out this week, they say this. They say: The British government had intelligence from several different sources indicating that this visit was for the purpose of acquiring uranium. The intelligence was credible.

This is a reference to the visit in 1999 by Iraqi officials to Niger.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

A third option is that you are confused, malicious or both.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Sources, please.

There were forged reports about such seeking in 2002 but the 1999 one was real.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

The main problem with the war is that Rumsfeld tried to do it on the cheap.

He took the originally-proposed plans and cut the resources severely.

Had he followed the 1990 Bush-1 policy of massive power it would have been over more quickly without Iraqi asset loss.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

You are trying to rewrite history.


It's funny that he accuses Bush of lying in the same thread he claims the inspection teams were working between 1999 and 2002. To top that off, he block quoted an entire page and couldn't support his claim that Bush ever claimed Iraq was responsible for 9/11. Par for the course.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

All that came to pass is due to the creation creation of the Project for the New American Century.

All the lies, fabrications, death, and wasted trillions of dollars stems from the Neocon development of that program in June of 1997. It is a matter of record that some of the the principal participants, and signatories to the plan were"

William Kristol, Robert Kagan, Elliott Abrams, John "Jeb" Bush, Dick Cheney, Frank Gaffney, Lewis "Scooter Libby, Dan Quayle, Donal Rumsfeld, Paul Wolfowitz

Here is the "Statement of Principles" from PNAC"

[What we require is] a military that is strong and ready to meet both present and future challenges; a foreign policy that boldly and purposefully promotes American principles abroad; and national leadership that accepts the United States global responsibilities. Of course, the United States must be prudent in how it exercises its power. But we cannot safely avoid the responsibilities of global leadership of the costs that are associated with its exercise. America has a vital role in maintaining peace and security in Europe, Asia, and the Middle East. If we shirk our responsibilities, we invite challenges to our fundamental interests. The history of the 20th century should have taught us that it is important to shape circumstances before crises emerge, and to meet threats before they become dire. The history of the past century should have taught us to embrace the cause of American leadership .

Keep in mind that this is from 1997. Four years before W. Bush took office.

On September 20, 2001 (nine days after the September 11, 2001 attacks ), the PNAC sent a letter to President George W. Bush , advocating "a determined effort to remove Saddam Hussein from power in Iraq ", or regime change :

...even if evidence does not link Iraq directly to the attack, any strategy aiming at the eradication of terrorism and its sponsors must include a determined effort to remove Saddam Hussein from power in Iraq. Failure to undertake such an effort will constitute an early and perhaps decisive surrender in the war on international terrorism.

This is all a matter of public record. Grab your mouse, and do your own search. Some very well known figures have blood on their hands all from fabrications needed for the US to go to war with Iraq.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Fly,

Excellent post.

I would add that most of these people were from the Neo-Conservative movement, disciples of U Chicago's Leo Strauss. Strauss contended that the masses are incompetent to run a country, and therefore must be guided by more competent people. In particular, there is no obligation to enlighten the people -- only to obtain their adhesion.

The guides owe no loyalty to the people, only to the nation.

In this context, the use of the WMD lie, to unify the American people for a war that they would not have wanted had it been labeled "Restructuring the Middle East" is easy to understand.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

I wish I could confirm that, but I bet I know people that were stationed at DG that can confirm those stockpiles...... if I can track them down.

I didn't know about those logistical details, but I can see how it happened.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
I agree with Len. That there were multiple motivations does not make any single one of them necessarily untrue.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
No I wouldn't expect him to "know all the facts". Intelligence doesn't work that way.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

The funny thing is, the NYT and other liberal outlets were blasting the administration for having too many rationales for war in the run up.

After no weapons were found, WMD suddenly became the the only reason.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

A huge power vacuum came about in Iraq after disbanding the Republican Guard.

Even in WWII, we used German, Italian and Japanese military personnel to keep the trains running, and and the lights on in the country.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Of course the Bush administration didn't lie. To believe they did you'd have to believe in a conspiracy encompassing different administrations, political parties and sovereign countries. The arguments in this thread are proof enough, as they consist mainly of conclusory opinions unsupported by any facts. Intent is what differentiates mistakes from lies and almost 15 years after the fact there is no evidence that the administration knew there were no WMDs in Iraq as this thread amply demonstrates.

Bill Clinton made much more elaborate claims about the Iraqi WMD programs than Bush did, and Clinton made the vast majority of those statements while inspectors were still in Iraq. In 1999 they left, not to return until days before the war. When the inspectors left, it was the unanimous opinion of the Bill Clinton, the CIA, and every foreign intelligence service that I'm aware of that IRAQ was actively pursuing a WMD program. The statements made by the Bush administration were fully consistent with this understanding, which is why the CIA director called the case a "slam dunk."

Now, after invading the country, we know that the statements made by Bill Clinton were obviously false. The world's intelligence organs were wrong. It wasn't a conspiracy, it was a mistake.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Nice try Sean....

Care to refute the stands, statements, and emails surrounding the members related to the Neocon Project for the next American century? Many signatories to PNAC that were in the W. Bush Cabinet?

No opinions needed, as there are plenty of records of fact that are available at the click of your mouse.

Premeditated is the word you are searching for rather than mistake.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Can you point to anything in the neocon project that demonstrates Bush Cheney etc knew that no WMD's existed in Iraq?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Len, Cerenkov, Sean,

Google the subject, if you want to know how things actually went down. Your memories are playing tricks on you... to say the least.

That there were multiple motivations does not make any single one of them necessarily untrue.

...

The funny thing is, the NYT and other liberal outlets were blasting the administration for having too many rationales for war in the run up.

The primary cause cited by the administration was WMD, to the near-exclusion of everything else. At first, they tried to sell an al Qaeda connection, too, but even their friends quickly abandoned that nonsense. The real reason, "remaking the Middle East", was never cited at all, until well after the invasion.

Google it. It's history. You can try to rewrite it... but its going to be a tough job.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Of course the Bush administration didn't lie. To believe they did you'd have to believe in a conspiracy encompassing different administrations

No. Not at all. The administration people were something like a dozen long-time colleagues, from the Neo-Conservative movement. They were like-minded, needing no "master-mind" to all be pulling in the same direction.

"Other parties"? No. Lots of Democrats supported the war... because the President of the United States was telling them that Saddam had WMD. The same is true of other countries, with the exception of lap-dog Blair.

You cannot blame the Democrats and foreigners for not having assumed that the President was lying through his teeth!

every foreign intelligence service that I'm aware of that IRAQ was actively pursuing a WMD program

The ONLY intelligence services that thought Saddam was anywhere close to WMD were the Americans and Brits... ans even there, they were "convinced" by their political masters' desires rather than intelligence data. There was doubt throughout the CIA. Remember that the UN Security Council refused to vote in favor of the American invasion -- none of the members were convinced by America's arguments.

There had been wide international support for the invasion of Afghanistan. There was even more widespread condemnation of the Iraq invasion.

The world's intelligence organs were wrong. It wasn't a conspiracy, it was a mistake.

Pure revisionism! The "world's intelligence organs" were right, because they did not think Saddam was anywhere close to WMD. Only George Tenet's sockpuppets at the CIA -- a portion of the CIA -- believed in WMD. British intelligence did not, but Blair ignored them.

There was no conspiracy, in the sense of a cabal and midnight meetings. There was "general agreement" among a couple dozen people at most, that "Saddam has WMD" would sell an otherwise undesirable war to the American people.

It was not a mistake. It was a lie.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

What was wrong with the overall strategy was that there was no plan for what to do after the invasion was complete.

This is the most astonishing fact of all!

These Neo-con people wanted a war, to remodel the Middle East to their liking... but they made no plans at all for how to do it! Remember the after-thought vice-roy, Paul Bremer? No, of course not. Nobody remembers him...

No plans were made for... prisoners! This is stunning. A sweep operation does exactly that: sweeps up people! Then comes the hard part, deciding what to do with them. No organization or process had been foreseen, to make those decisions, so we still have prisoners at Gitmo who "may" have been innocent bystanders.

Remember the looting of the National Museum? Nothing planned to protect it.

Remember the electrical stoppages? Nothing planned to keep the power plants running.

Incredible incompetence...

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Spot on Bob.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

ts of Democrats supported the war... because the President of the United States was telling them that Saddam had WMD


You mean Presidents, the plural.

u cannot blame the Democrats and foreigners for not having assumed that the President was lying through his teeth

I don't blame the Democrats for believing Bill Clinton. You are aware of the claims he made, which the invasion proved false, right?

heONLYintelligence services that thought Saddam was anywhere close to WMD were the Americans and Brits


And the French, Germans etc.. But they are all in on some neo-con conspiracy too right?

ven there, they were "convinced" by their political masters' desires rather than intelligence data.

So now you are alleging that Bill Clinton manipulated the intelligence services? Sorry, not buying it.

emember that the UN Security Council refused to vote in favor of the American invasion --noneof the members were convinced by America's argument


What does that even mean? Opposing the invasion is not proof that they didn't believe Iraq had WMDs. The UN Security Council would oppose an invasion of North Korea, that doesn't mean North Korea doesn't have WMDs.

ere was even more widespreadcondemnationof the Iraq invasion.

So what? You just keep piling on theirrelevancies.

he "world's intelligence organs" wereright, because they did not think Saddam was anywhere close to WMD

False. France, Germany, Isreal etc all thought he had an active program.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

I agree about N.k. My only point is that UN disapproval would not be evidence that NK doesn't possess WMD's. As you point out, there are many sound reasons for the UN not to support the invasion of another country. The no immediate threat argument is what opponents to the focused on in the run-up to the Iraq war.

Bob is trying to use the UN vote to show that the world didn't believe Saddam had WMD's, which is unsupportable.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

You are missing the point Sean. It didn't matter, they already had plans to invade Iraq WMDs or not.

On September 20, 2001 (nine days after the September 11, 2001 attacks ), the PNAC sent a letter to President George W. Bush , advocating "a determined effort to remove Saddam Hussein from power in Iraq ", or regime change :

...even if evidence does not link Iraq directly to the attack, any strategy aiming at the eradication of terrorism and its sponsors must include a determined effort to remove Saddam Hussein from power in Iraq. Failure to undertake such an effort will constitute an early and perhaps decisive surrender in the war on international terrorism.

The White House lied as to why they invaded Iraq. WMDs were just the excuse.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Just remember, that Slick Willie wasn't in the White House, nor gave the go to invade Iraq.

Nice try at deflection though.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Frown.gif

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

he "world's intelligence organs" wereright, because they did not think Saddam was anywhere close to WMD

False. France, Germany, Isreal etc all thought he had an active program.

You're joking, right? France led the fight at the UN, against the invasion of Iraq. Germany was on the Security Council, and very clearly stated that they would vote against the invasion.

Sean! This is straightforward history. Google it!

-------

As for Bill Clinton... he was no longer President! Hey!! He was no longer in the loop. His successor said, very clearly, "Saddam is very close to getting the Bomb!" So Clinton, like millions of other duped Americans, supported the invasion.

You are putting the people who were lied to, on the same level as those who did the lying! That's crazy!

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Please, Sean...

Step back two paces, and breathe deeply. Relax...

You are, I think, taking all of this backwards. You are starting from the presumption the the Bush administration "made an honest mistake", and then finding every possible argument to support that thesis.

Let's try to start with no presuppositions at all:

  • The Bush administration contended, very clearly, that Saddam was close to a nuclear capability.
  • There were in fact, no WMD, not even close.
  • So... either they made a colossal mistake, or they lied.

Paul Wolfowitz, one of the essential architects of the war, said in 2003 that no one had really ever believed the WMD story, but that it had been used because it was sure to gather popular support. (Don't take my word for this -- Google it. It was all over the press at the time.)

Colin Powell himself later recognized that he had been misled into making his decisive speech:

This is not opinion, Sean. This is history. These are events that are recorded. You can look them up, any time you wish.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

I'm not sure that is quite right Slarti....Mostly, but not quite.

The intelligence that we had was that the Iraqi Scud-Bs were reinforced to handle the mass of a nuke payload as shipped by the Russians making that delivery system nuke capable. The same is true of the domestically manufactured Scud-Bs. Iraq didn't have the engineers capable of redesigning the top of the missile so the nuke capable design was duplicated. Lots of additional weight for nothing, but still could handle up to a 80kt warhead if Saddam and been able get his hands on one.

I know.... I'm picking at fly-poo.

Hope you're good.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

I have no idea what point you are trying to make. Advocacy groups favored deposing Saddam since the first gulf war.

There's no "lie" anywhere.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Your problem is you think history started in 2001. Your conspiracy theory become preposterous when you remember what happened in between the first Gulf War and the inauguration of George W. Bush.

Bill Clinton made the same claims that George W. Bush did. Explain that.

said in 2003 that no one had really ever believed the WMD story

Now that is a lie, assuming you actually used google. Otherwise, you are terrible mistaken. Here's what he said in 2003:

"Wolfowitz insisted in the interview, and in Singapore on Friday, that there had always been three major concerns.

"One was weapons of mass destruction, second was terrorism, and the third ... was the abuse of Iraqis by their own government," Wolfowitz said at the sidelines of the Asia Security Conference in Singapore.

"And in a sense there was a fourth overriding one, which was the connection between those first two, the connection between the weapons of mass destruction and terrorism."

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

He killed Iraqis over these "lies" too.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

You do understand that why its possible for a country to believe Saddam had WMDs and also oppose an invasion, right? The opposition was based on the lack of an imminent threat and the success of containment, not the absence of WMD programs.

C'mon use Google and find a NYT article from 2002 or 2003 in which both France or Germany declare Iraq had no WMDs. Should be so easy since its history right?

e was no longer President!

Um.. I was talking about what he said when he was President. We know now his statements werecompletelywrong.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Your problem is you think history started in 2001.

I have lots of problems, but history isn't one of them. What happened in 2001 is Mr Bush became President.

Are you aware that in Singapore -- a couple monthsafter his first quotes hit the media -- Wolfowitz was in "walk-back spin" mode? Did you make a "mistake" here... or (like the Bush administration back then) are you trying to cheat?

Once again, Sean... This is history. Fact-checking takes only minutes.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Bob, you are dealing with someone that is use to denying facts. You can rub his nose in them, you can hold him down and force feed them to him, and all he will do is deflect using circular logic at best.

Remember the first rule of being a conservative.....

"Have no shame, and take no blame!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Fact-checking takes only minutes

How cute. I provided an actual quote, you did not. And you blather about fact checking after you make up a quote from Wolfowitz. I'm still waiting for a sourcesupportingyour claim that Wolfowitz stated that "no one had really ever believed the WMD story."

C'mon Bob, theInternet isa wonderful thing. Fact check yourself and show me thatquote. Or did you just invent that quote like you did some of the other facts you are relying on in this thread?

I've also noticed yourcontinuingrefusal to deal with Bill Clinton's statements aboutIraq's WMD program. Sad to see your ridiculous conspiracy exposed, huh?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

I wish I could expect better from you, but the pattern is obvious. You regurgitate some some half baked left wing theory that you can't defend or even appear to understand. When called out you start pouting and name calling. It's happened before and it'll happen again with you, I know.

If you want to attack me, at least do it directly. I can at least respect that. This whining to a third party just demeans you.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Len,

He lied. There were no WMD's. That is what people do once they get into the White House. What are you trying to prove with this article?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

What people here do not get is the difference between erring and lying. As Justice Silberman wrote:

The intelligence communitys 2002 National Intelligence Estimate (NIE) stated, in a formal presentation to President Bush and to Congress, its view that Saddam had weapons of mass destructiona belief in which the NIE said it held a 90% level of confidence. That is about as certain as the intelligence community gets on any subject.

Recall that the head of the intelligence community, Central Intelligence Agency Director George Tenet, famously told the president that the proposition that Iraq possessed WMD was a slam dunk. Our WMD commission carefully examined the interrelationships between the Bush administration and the intelligence community and found no indication that anyone in the administration sought to pressure the intelligence community into its findings. As our commission reported, presidential daily briefs from the CIA dating back to the Clinton administration were, if anything, more alarmist about Iraqs WMD than the 2002 National Intelligence Estimate.

Saddam had manifested sharp hostility toward America, including firing at U.S. planes patrolling the no-fly zone set up by the armistice agreement ending the first Iraq war. Saddam had also attempted to assassinate former President George H.W. Bush a car-bombing plot was foiledduring Mr. Bushs visit to Kuwait in 1993. But President George W. Bush based his decision to go to war on information about Saddams WMD. Accordingly, when Secretary of State Colin Powell formally presented the U.S. case to the United Nations, Mr. Powell relied entirely on that aspect of the threat from Iraq.

Our WMD commission ultimately determined that the intelligence community was dead wrong about Saddams weapons. But as I recall, no one in Washington political circles offered significant disagreement with the intelligence community before the invasion. The National Intelligence Estimate was persuasiveto the president, to Congress and to the media.

So Pres. Bush erred. For examples of presidential lying we need look no farther than
President Obama who, as a serial liar, knows he is lying. And everyone else knows it too.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
Do you believe that an international conspiracy involving George bush, bill Clinton and our allies existed to invent the existence of Iraqi WMD in the mid 90s so george bush could lie about them and invade Iraq in 2003? Awful nice of bill Clinton to lie about Iraqi WMDs to set the stage for George bush.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Then how come you never criticize Obama but instead are one of his groupies.

Comment removed for CoC violation [ph]
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Talk abut REAL lying:

Axelrod: Obama Misled Nation When He Opposed Gay Marriage In 2008

A striking admission of political dishonesty from the keeper of the Obama flame Barack Obama misled Americans for his own political benefi

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

We invaded Iraq because they invade Kuwait, not because of WMDs. Then Bush promised the Kurds to back them, if they attacked Saddam, which they did. He didn't back them and they 10's of 1000's of them died in Mustard Gas attacks.

Now that is lying for you.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Sorry Len, not the same. No one died for that liel but they did from Bush's.

They all lie, but the extent of harm is the issue.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Lie are lies.

Whatever you do don't actually read comments you are replying to . Just feel free to ignore what was said previously . After all , your ignorant views are all that really matters [in your ego inflated view ] . Meanwhile the rest of the world is reading your comment and thinking you are "short a few cards" in your deck ...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

I'm done, Sean. You simply ignore my answers, and then claim that I haven't answered. Kinda pointless...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

How many have died, and will die, from Obama's wasting Bush's victory by withdrawal?.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
Yes the failure to support the marsh arab revolt was a tragedy, but it had nothing to do with supposed "lies" about WMD in Iraq

Do you believe Clinton, Blair, Chirac etc were all involved in a lie about Iraqi possession on WMDs?
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
I'm asking you to provide a cite for the blockbuster claim that Paul wolofotiz supposedly said no one believed that the Iraqis had WMDs.

Why is that so difficult? Seems like it would be big news and go a long way towards proving your case. Of course, we both know why you won't. He never said any such thing you don't want to admit it. You either lied or made a grievous mistake. Own up to it.

Your responses consist of lies/mistakes ( wolofitz, the fact that other counties believed Iraq had WMD, including France ) and a refusal to explain how president bill Clinton wasn't lying when he made the same allegations george bush did.

Not much else to discuss.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

How many will die from Obama's "peace in our time" re. the Iran nuclear negotiating breakthrough?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Talking about "no plan," withdrawal, giving `most of our blood-soaked victory to IS is less of a plan.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Bush's victory

MISSION ACCOMPLISHED

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Exactly, Bob.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Feel free to live your life in the Pub-Teapers bubble Sean. Me, I prefer fresh air and sunshine.

FYI, the properties of that bubble you live seem to only work one way as nothing from outside of "conservative world" makes it in, and only conservative world mantras make it out.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

It was accomplished till Obama magically turned the victory into a defeat.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

We are still in Germany, Italy, Japan, S. Korea etc., etc.

The military of the United States is deployed in more than 150 countries around the world, with nearly 160,000 of its active-duty personnel serving outside the United States and its territories and an additional 88,000 deployed in various contingency operations. US troops are spread across the globe: approximately 66,000 are stationed in Europe ; approximately 80,000 in East Asia and the Pacific region; nearly 4,900 in North Africa , the Near East , and South Asia ; over 1,600 in the Western Hemisphere ; less than 400 in Sub-Saharan Africa; and less than 100 in states of the former Soviet Union . [ 1 ] Of those in Europe, most of the military personnel are located at installations activated during the Cold War , by which the US government sought to challenge the Soviet Union in the aftermath of World War II . [ 2 ]

Contact the Joint Chiefs of Staff with your nonsense.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

In the context of the Iraq-Iran war, on 16 and 17 March 1988 an estimated 5,000 people were deliberately killed and thousands wounded as a result of chemical weapon attacks by Iraqi forces on the town of Halabja, near Sulaimaniya, reportedly after Kurdish armed opposition forces had entered the town. Most of the victims were civilians, many of them children and women. The Iraqi Government denied responsibility for the incident and stated that Iranian forces had carried out the killings. In August of the same year hundreds of unarmed Kurdish civilians were deliberately killed and thousands wounded when Iraqi armed forces attacked Kurdish villages in the north.

This was the end of Pres. Reagan's term and just before HW Bush beat Dukakis.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

MISSION ACCOMPLISHED
MISSION ACCOMPLISHED
MISSION ACCOMPLISHED
MISSION ACCOMPLISHED
MISSION ACCOMPLISHED

If you repeat it to yourself enough... maybe it will be true!

That's what they say about Peter Pan...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Bob has been asleep for six to eight years.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

I did not provide alternate reasons and either did Judge Silberman.

Read the seed instead of making things up.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

How about you chew on some facts Len....

Silberman does not mention that the commission he chaired did not even investigate whether the Bush administration manipulated intelligence. Senate Republicans refused to allow the commission to investigate this matter, fearing it would harm Bushs reelection prospects. Indeed, Silberman himself wrote in the report at the time , Our executive order did not direct us to deal with the use of intelligence by policymakers, and all of us were agreed that that was not part of our inquiry.

Not enough for you eh..... Try this about a second Senate investigation" .

Phase II report , which came out a few years later. That report, which was endorsed by two of the committees seven Republicans and all its Democrats, concluded, the Administration repeatedly presented intelligence as fact when in reality it was unsubstantiated, contradicted, or even non-existent.

There is plenty of truth out there. Now all you have to do is be open minded enough to let it sink in.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Cherry picking will get you nowhere.

Can Obama withstand an inquiry into his distortion of intelligence which is ten times worse than Bush's?

Workplace violence.

Never mentioning "radical Islam"

Random shooting of some folks at a French deli.

You don't need a special blue-ribbon-committee investigation to see that this emperor has no clothes.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Did Iraq have it in 1981 when bombed by Israel?

Does Iran have that capacity? Is Obama doing anything significant about it?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

You mean Israel bombed Iraq for nothing?

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

No the Osirak reactor in Iraq was NOT suitable for creating plutonium for bomb making, per Richard Wilson, professor of physics/Harvard after inspection of the damaged reactor in December of 1982.

In fact the reactor was designed by French engineer Yves Girard to be unsuitable for making bombs.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Were you born in 2000; is the 21st your century? W. Bush did not initiate the hostility to Satan Insane. His father, in the 1991Gulf War, and Bill Clinton, who signed into law H.R. 4655, the Iraq Liberation Act in 1998 followed by the Operation Desert Fox extensivebombing led intothe actions after your birth.

How come you do not mention Halabja, the first frightful act of Saddam's Anfal campaign, a genocide that consumed almost 100,000 Kurds in all? And that was just ONE instance. Did you hear about the plastic shredder that Insane used to toss his enemies into and used the remains for fish food? Ordinarily he tossed the victims in headfirst. But if he was particularly mad at someone he would toss him in feet first and enjoy the screaming on the way through.

Paul O'Neill's evidentignorance of all this (I did not read his book but you fail to mention the 1990slead-in), plus his big mouth in other respects, led to his firing.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

What Wilson thought is irrelevant. What Sadaam and Israel thought were decisive.

Israel did not have Wilson's opportunity to inspect the facility, did they?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

While prattling about "context" you assert that "the basic parameters of every single reactor design in the world is available to other nations through the IAEA," as if either any nation can build a bomb or, no IAEA reactor can do so.

How do you know what Satan was up to? Do you think he wanted the reactor, as Iran asserts, merely to generate electricity?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Sounds like you cannot answer my last messsage.

And I rely on you for nuclear expertise.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Bush didn't lie. He made a decision to believe an intelligence estimate. Simple.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

I have always referred to him as Satan Insane because the name fit. I could refer to you as "fartblast" but I would not do that though some of your messages suggest it.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Folks here consider an error the same as a lie except for Obama for whom neither errors or lies reduce their adulation.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

And all this from someone just a few short days ago said he would put his technical expertise up against mine anyday.

Oh and Len.... FYI, part of that radiation biophysics class I took in college covered multiple reactor designs. Oh, and another thing Len.... I might or might not have a little more than just fledgling knowledge of "Non-Conventional" munitions.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Hell, I'd be happy if he could tell us what graphite is and what it is used for......

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

I smell the stench all right. But when I look, the color is blue.

Are you defending Satan Insane?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

All what?

When I went to college it was all classified. But I can learn/copy/paste from the Internet as well as anyone.

I will tell you about graphite if you tell me about the mass of photons and the gravitational attraction of light.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Wow , these comments go on & on . Here's what's important about Bush . What he did had positive effects . Because of his Iraq incursions we now have the Kurds & Peshmerga to counter ISIL . No one else in that region has the ability to deal with them ... Will you who decried Bush earlier now admit that what he did accomplished something ? Apparently that is asking too much of the ideologically driven ...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

I congratulate you for keeping your eye on the ball unlike the showoffs.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago
Right. Because The other "secular" dictatorships have fared well so well. Given Obama's history in Egypt, Syria and Libya, he would probably have favored radical Islamists like ISIS when they invariably tried to overthrow saddam or his succesor son.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

then we more than likely would not be dealing with ISIL in the first place

In that case we would have had more al Qaeda & Taliban to deal with ...

nor would it be likely that we would be dealing with a civil war in Syria.

What makes you think that is not a desirable goal from the US perspective ?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Well I got my degree in '53.

When I got my MS, transistors were not yet commercial and all my circuit-design courses were vacuum-tube based.

I presume you are a nuclear physicist. I am an EE and spent my career developing microwave phased-array antenna systems, not nuclear reactors.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Then we likely would have been negotiating a nuclear threshold with him in addition to Iran.

The bottom line is that, after false starts, we won the war. Then Obama removed virtually all troops from Iraq and Afghanistan, providing an opening for former Iraqi officers to join IS, and to retake a big part of Iraq and Syria. Now the Taliban are surging in Afghanistan.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Photons are considered to have zero mass and no charge, but as we currently understand them they exhibit the dual properties of both particles and waves. The fact that light waves which, consist of photons are bent by objects with mass are proof that they have at least some of the properties consistent with the effects of gravity exhibited on particles. The bending of light around black holes or even distant suns is well documented and actually used in celestial measurement of the mass of distant bodies.

On the other hand, Young's "double slit experiment is clear proof of photons (visible light in this case) act in waves as the their interaction can cause cancellation due to being out of phase with one another.

In classic physics we were taught that photon emissions occurred as the orbital electrons in an atom moved from a higher state to a lower state, with the reverse also being true.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Close but no cigar.

You failed to explain how a particle with zero mass is attracted by gravity.

Did anyone ever weigh a photon?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Was the war between Iran and Iraq undesirable?

A war between bad guys is not undesirable except for the fallout of innocent victims; the broken eggs of the omelet.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

You said that about 1981. Assuming you are correct why do you thing they would not have developed/purchased it by 2003?

Do you think Israel did not know what you know/knew when they bombed Osirak?

1981: Israel bombs Baghdad nuclear reactor

The Israelis have bombed a French-built nuclear plant near Iraq's capital, Baghdad, saying they believed it was designed to make nuclear weapons to destroy Israel.

It is the world's first air strike against a nuclear plant.

An undisclosed number of F-15 interceptors and F-16 fighter bombers destroyed the Osirak reactor 18 miles south of Baghdad, on the orders of Prime Minister Menachem Begin.

The army command said all the Israeli planes returned safely.

The 70-megawatt uranium-powered reactor was near completion but had not been stocked with nuclear fuel so there was no danger of a leak, according to sources in the French atomic industry.

Mortal danger

The Israeli Government explained its reasons for the attack in a statement saying: "The atomic bombs which that reactor was capable of producing whether from enriched uranium or from plutonium, would be of the Hiroshima size. Thus a mortal danger to the people of Israel progressively arose."

It acted now because it believed the reactor would be completed shortly - either at the beginning of July or the beginning of September 1981.

The Israelis criticised the French and Italians for supplying Iraq with nuclear materials and plegded to defend their territory at all costs.

The statement said: "We again call upon them to desist from this horrifying, inhuman deed. Under no circumstances will we allow an enemy to develop weapons of mass destruction against our people."

The attack took place on a Sunday, they said, to prevent harming the French workers at the site who would have taken the day off.

There have been no reported casualties.

The Osirak reactor is part of a complex that includes a second, smaller reactor - also French-built - and a Soviet-made test reactor already in use.

Iraq denies the reactor was destined to produce nuclear weapons.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Back to the present issue of whether Bush lied; here is a recent excerpt from a 2012 Washington Post article on Iraqi nuclear capabilities after Osirak:

Iraqs nuclear efforts also went underground [after Osirak]. Hussein allowed the IAEA to verify Osiraks destruction, but then he shifted from a plutonium strategy to a more dispersed and ambitious uranium-enrichment strategy. This approach relied on undeclared sites, away from the prying eyes of inspectors, and aimed to develop local technology and expertise to reduce the reliance on foreign suppliers of sensitive technologies. When inspectors finally gained access after the 1991 Persian Gulf War, they were shocked by the extent of Iraqs nuclear infrastructure and how close Hussein had gotten to a bomb.

Ultimately, Israels 1981 raid didnt end Iraqs drive to develop nuclear weapons. It took the destruction of the Gulf War, followed by more than a decade of sanctions, containment, inspections, no-fly zones and periodic bombing not to mention the 2003 U.S. invasion to eliminate the program. The international community got lucky: Had Hussein not been dumb enough to invade Kuwait in 1990, he probably would have gotten the bomb sometime by the mid-1990s.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Obama "evolves" not lies.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Very good points, Peter.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    11 years ago

Much better Slart, though you left it to thereader to close the loop.

While photons have no mass they have energy. That is why lasers can do surgery. So from Einstein's equation energy is an equivalent of mass -- effective mass -- and is also attracted by gravity.

No one has ever weighed a photon because they never stop -- always traveling at light speed.

 
 

Who is online



114 visitors