Senator Says Common Core Contains Anti-American History, But It Doesn’t Have History Requirements
Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY)
CREDIT: AP PHOTO/JOSE LUIS MAGANA
Last week, Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY) took a shot at the Common Core State Standards in an email to supporters claiming they contain anti-American propaganda, revisionist history that ignores the faith of our Founders.
But while the Common Core is a set of math and English standards, it does not have a history, civics, or social studies curriculum. The only readings the Common Core requires are the Declaration of Independence, the Preamble to the Constitution, the Bill of Rights, and Lincolns second inaugural address.
Pauls strategy may not play well in his home state of Kentucky, which was one of the first states to adopt the Common Core. The state has seen its college and career readiness rates jump by over 25 percent since their adoption.
Support is strong elsewhere as well. Forty-five states and the District of Columbia decided to voluntarily adopt the standards in 2010. While there have been three states that have dropped the standards since, and there are real concerns about how often the Common Core-aligned tests should be administered and how they should be used for things like school accountability, student promotion, and teacher evaluations, the standards themselves still enjoy a broad and diverse coalition of support. Business groups like the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the Business Roundtable, teachers unions , civil rights groups , military leaders , and numerous education groups have all voiced their strong support and continue to advocate for the standards.
And just this past Sunday, President Reagans former Secretary of Education and conservative talk show host Bill Bennett had this to say : Here is what you can really dodownload the standards themselves. The Common Core standards Not what someone said the standards were. Not what Google reported. Not what some citizens group decided was Common Core, but the actual standards themselves You tell me whats wrong with saying kids should learn how to parse and diagram sentences, memorize, read the Declaration of Independence. Thats what I want to know.
At the same time, however, some Republicans continue to push wildly incorrect Common Core storylines such as claims that the Common Core will turn students gay , were informed by the Muslim Brotherhood , and are a communist plot .
Senator Says Common Core Contains Anti-American History, But It Doesnt Have History Requirements
by Will Ragland , ThinkProgress
Tags
Who is online
114 visitors

Rand Paul is an interesting person. He lies constantly -- this is just one instance among dozens -- but his faithful are... faithful.
"Tell us what we want to hear and we will follow you!!"
In every element of physical measurement we have standards. We do this so that everyone can understand the quantity of what is being measured. This goes from Nautical Miles, to voltage, to temperature.
Do you not think its a good idea to standardize teaching and measure the results using a standardized approach? We have been using ACT and SAT scores for decades. MCAT exams for med school, BAR exam for lawyers and the PE exam for professional engineers. These are all standardized tests based upon standards for learning achievement.
So what the hell is all the fuss about?
If you have standards and measures, then you have pertinent data for making decisions.
If you have no standards and no measures, then you have no data... and you are free to fantasize whatever you wish!
Conservatives want no data.
And Rand is a libertarian..... what does that tell you?
It tells me what I already knew: libertarians are even more impervious to reality than conservatives.
From a teacher's POV, common core sucks. It prevents teaching. But what Rand Paul did is just a lie, topped off with another lie:
Our founders made it abundantly clear that they didn't want faith as part of this nation's foundings.
Oh! Rand Paul lies?!
I am shocked!
Perrie,
From the teachers perspective..... what is it about common core that you have problems with?
Don't candy coat your response either. I would prefer your answer with the "Bark On".
You are being rational.
Thinkabout it...
Fly,
Let's start with this article:
Common Core isn't much.
It is more than many children get.
That is the contradiction that must be resolved.
I moved through it Perrie...... now what?
I saw nothing new here pro or con that hasn't been at issue for decades. Do we want to teach to tests....never. What do we do about the really gifted student.....we/they will do the same as we have always done. Get them into advanced classes, or they will take time outside of the classroom to gain the additional they seek. Are we going to teach to a test, sure, but we have been doing that with the ACT/SAT for decades as well. Developing critical thinking skills while making use of the basic building blocks found in learning is what we are after in the long run. Common Core, or whatever you want to call it can from what I see, get us there if we want it to.
My take is that Common Core is attempting to set a federal benchmark for the nation related to math, science, and language arts. This in itself is a worthwhile goal in order to get as many kids and public education programs to a minimum standard of proficiency. Now if the program is going to be all about purchasing computers and testing equipment without providing the basic tools to the educator needed to teach, then this is just another boondoggle to fill a private firm's pockets with federal dollars.
The very problem with Common Core is that it is so limited. Teachers are not teaching more science, social studies, critical thinking, but we are teaching for a specific test. That doesn't make for a more rounded individual.
Pretty much so, and that you can blame on government not listening to teachers, administrators and parents. "No kid left behind", left tons of kids behind, just trying to learn test taking skills. Time they could have used to actually develop those critical thinking skills we all need. Teachers gave tons of feedback about that, and instead of saying... well, maybe stop the stress of test taking and actually spend time learning might be the way to go ( btw, skill dropped during this period)they added even more testing. It is a boondoggle to fill a private firm's pockets with federal dollars.
Remember most of us took about 4 standardized tests in our 12 year so school and most of us are better educated, and more rounded than this generation.
What were they..... Iowa Basic Skills Tests?
Are these tests no longer being used and the data collected for analysis?
Totally agree Fly...
Leave it to Rand Paul to open mouth, insert foot, in his bid for more power...
50 years ago, I attended 7 different elementary schools in 4 different states. No matter which school system I was in, I was behind somewhere, and being a very small person, the "powers that be" always wanted to put me back a grade, to I could catch up on something. Either it was adding two digit numbers, or it was cursive writing, or it was the fact that I had studied Missouri history, rather than Kansas history, et. al.
I have been all for some sort of standards, but not what this has become. I believe that it has been destroyed in its administration.
My question is this: What importance is this? While it is a good idea, it has become a rallying point for political entities to use for their own personal gain. Let's ignore the real inequities of education and nit-pick over what is revisionist and what isn't.
Common Core goals should set specific, general standards-- no more, no less. It is too detail oriented, and needs to be more general. I'm not at all thrilled about testing as a measure of success-- in real life, how many tests must one take in order to succeed? I can't think of a single test I had to pass to be a successful geologist. In my case, either I found the water, (success), or I didn't, (failure).
Common Core should, instead, be labeled Common Sense-- and there is surely a lack of that going around.
Let's all quit falling victim to these yahoos that would divert us from the real issues we are facing, by obfuscation, (sort of like calling the dogs in for a biscuit, and then yelling SQUIRREL), and begin electing people with a plan to fix our problems. Let's all stop yelling about whose fault it is, and start yelling for someone to find solutions to our problems.
Every person in the country is part of a special interest group, somehow, and of some type. We've all got to do what is best for everybody, not just the select few. Either we work together to find ways of fixing our problems, or we just sit here and yell at each other, which is just what many of the politicians out there want us to do...
But if it is as Perrie says, a program where rather than enriching the classroom and getting teachers the tools they need, it goes to purchasing testing equipment supplied by a private corporation, then it is a waste of money.
1) Teachers need a proper environment, and the proper tools to teach with.
2) Involved parents will make a bigger impact in learning than all the tax dollars we could ever hope to spend on education.
3) We need to find a way to get the best and brightest to spend time teaching our most critical resource...... our kids.
So much for my soapbox speech.
Leave it to Rand Paul to open mouth and insert foot, in his bid for more power...
50 years ago, I attended 7 different elementary schools in 4 different states. No matter which school system I was in, I was behind somewhere, and being a very small person, the "powers that be" always wanted to put me back a grade, to I could catch up on something. Either it was adding two digit numbers, or it was cursive writing, or it was the fact that I had studied Missouri history, rather than Kansas history, et. al. My father wouldn't hear of me repeating a grade, just so I could learn the one thing they thought was deficient in-- and strangely enough, I learned what I needed by staying after school and studying that particular subject, or Daddy taught me. I stayed in the top of my classes, no matter what grade I was in...
I have been all for some sort of standards, but not what this has become. I believe that it has been destroyed by its administration. Great idea, but poor in practice.
My question is this: What importance is this? While it is a good idea, it has become a rallying point for political entities to use for their own personal gain. Let's ignore the real inequities of education and nit-pick over what is revisionist and what isn't. Let's forget that kids in Arkansas don't have enough pencils, and yell that they don't somehow meet the standard for Maine state history.
Common Core goals should set specific, general standards-- no more, no less. It is too detail oriented, and needs to be more general. I'm not at all thrilled about testing as a measure of success-- in real life, how many tests must one take in order to succeed? I can't think of a single test I had to pass to be a successful geologist. In my case, either I found the water, (success), or I didn't, (failure).
Common Core should, instead, be labeled Common Sense-- and there is surely a lack of that going around.
Let's all quit falling victim to these yahoos that would divert us from the real issues we are facing, by obfuscation, (sort of like calling the dogs in for a biscuit, and then yelling SQUIRREL), and begin electing people with a plan to fix our problems. Let's all stop yelling about whose fault it is, and start yelling for someone to find solutions to our problems.
Every person in the country is part of a special interest group, somehow, and of some type. We've all got to do what is best for everybody, not just the select few. Either we work together to find ways of fixing our problems, or we just sit here and yell at each other, which is just what many of the politicians out there want us to do...