Since someone took His toys from the sandbox and ran away ....
I crafted this response in a discussion on an article, but couldn't post it because the seeder decided to close it to comments rather than have rational debate.Question - does the severe possibility that god(s) don't exist have a severe impact on the POINT of this article? Yes, obviously it does. It's like asserting that there is a mystical reason why people die from cancer, instead of the very real reasons that people die from cancer - real reasons that we still have yet to discover and may never fully understand before we manage to wipe ourselves out completely. Humans can do evil shit to one another - that's a secular reality, and it's rooted in the physiological, psychological and social environment that permeates our existence, not the imaginary existence of the entity that is repeatedly referenced in his speech, in the form of "God" and "Him".Prayer Breakfasts are pure pandering bullshit, and they run afoul of the Separation of Church and State. I will attack them any time I please, since ultimately they only serve to ignite hostilities in the religious world. Religion is such a retarded concept that there is no way possible for one version to please all the people all the time. Governing mankind is hard enough, contaminating the recipe with a blob of shit like religion is contrary to common sense.
Tags
Who is online
104 visitors

If the words God's existence are in the title and religion is in the body of the article then YES it is fair to question the existence of God.....and NOT be off topic.
There is no such thing as a civil discussion about whether G_d exists on a forum such as NT. There are strong-minded, independent, volatile people here who cannot remain calm and respectful when this topic appears in a thread.
As for the president of the United States bringing it up in any type of conversation at all in a public address in this day and age and in this environment, it was ill advised.
Hal,
The thrust of the article in question was not religion, although it had a religion subtext. It was about this:
In other words, the hijacking of religion for a political purpose.
I am a firm believer in the separation of church and state, so I too, am not a big fan of these prayer breakfasts, but that was where that article was going.
Sometimes I have to wear purple...
Comments should be narrowly constructed and focused on the topic as the seeder sees the topic, lest he/she lose control of the echo chamber of discussion. But of course, on another seeder's article ancillary excursions of topic are warranted.
At least that is the double standard as some see it
Mimi,
I am going to try and correct that across the board on every topic. Thank you ahead for your help.
Robert,
There is no double standard. Each author can control the thrust of the discussion. Some like more open fluid discussions and others don't. Maybe, what we need is a disclaimer on each article by the author what is allowable?
Maybe we do, or maybe we can act and comment on the articles of others in a manner that mirrors how we want others to comment on out articles.
A crazy approach I know, but it might work
And the reference to double standard was in reference to commenting behavior, not moderation or rules enforcement
Robert,
Please see this comment:
I have had a pile of complaints and not by one member alone of derails on articles that are quite purposeful. This is covered in the CoC. Purposeful derails were never allowed here.
It is up to the members to notify me when a member makes a comment that is worthless/derail to the discussion of the article. And I agree with this:
Appreciate that feedback
I guess some request protection, er I meant support, from you more readily than others and that is okay with me.
Thanks for the perspective and responses to mycomments - always appreciate the advice and counsel.
What was the subject again?
This article alludes to the point I was trying to make on the article you mentioned in which someone argued there is only one God. Belief (or the lack of it) in God is just that. A belief. Some believe in one God, some in multiple Gods some in no God. People who believe in one God do not necessarily worship the same God. The Belief (whatever it may be) It is the conclusion of the person based on their knowledge of religion in every case. EXAMPLE: Based on your knowledge, you decided to have nothing to do with any of it. This is why it is folly to attempt to say everyone worships the same supreme being. As you have pointed out. Some do not worship any. The poster of the article closed it because he was silly enough to paint himself in a corner and couldn't deal with the reality that his normal strategy of fact denial, deflections and attempts to back up misguided opinions with more misguided opinions failed him. Evidently he is a sore loser.
Anyone who read the comments in the article knows who the idiot is John.
LMAO!
You are just pissed off because he made an entire article pointing out your stupidity and the fact that you are childish enough to close your article when you lose a debate....and he did it without violating COC.
Again, the point wasn't the breakfast. Read the article. And that is a big issue here. People never read the articles, but comment on the clip.
But then again, I have to point this out: be clear what clip from an article you want to emphasis. It is not totally illogical for Hal to go to religion when the actual point is at the very bottom of the clip.
Hal,
Had you looked at the article you would have seen this:
The article isn't about religion, but the impact of those who are so pious, yet forget their own history.
Hummm... Something just hit me, that I have to comment on the other article.
John started the discussion on his own article with me on his opinion that all people worship the same God. That is what I was referring to.
Here is a link:
...
Comment removed for CoC violation [ph]
I don't think so...
Echo chambers are the death of a site. After everyone has patted themselves on the back, the discussion is over. There is nothing gained from discussion.
Let me clarify. From the CoC:
Hal's is running the article here as he sees fit. It is a more open discussion. John gets to define the scope of his article. You and any other member has the choice to participate of not.
No matter what the president does or does not do, there are going to be people and groups that are going to scream their livers out complaining about it.
We see it here on NT EVERY DAY! What a waste of energy.
Hal
You are indeed
We have enough echos on most seeds already that shout and rant the partisan talking points from their respective sides of the aisle.
I am advocating that people discuss issues in an open and direct manner, without placing their views as the limits on what and how issues will be discussed.
Perrie,
I was not dissing NT... neither the site nor the people... when I said that G_d was a subject that could not be discussed here in a civil manner because of the strong personalities of the members here.
It's an observation I've made, and it is one of the reasons people of my generation were told to never discuss religion or politics in public.
Even the angry, sometimes hateful back and forth comments of the articles on race don't have quite the elemental savagery of discussions about G_d.
from the middle of the article
"If we are properly humble, if we drop to our knees on occasion, we will acknowledge that we never fully know Gods purpose. We can never fully fathom His amazing grace. We see through a glass, darkly grappling with the expanse of His awesome love. But even with our limits, we can heed that which is required: To do justice, and love kindness, and walk humbly with our God."
this quote alone implies that there is a God. and that opens the discussion to refute this belief by others. I saw no red box rules posted any where. It would appear to me the seeder is crying over his or her own short comings....
I was talking about our discussion.
I am a master Mason, have been for a number of decades, No, we are not part of any conspiracy to take over the country, planet or anything else.
While in lodge we have a rule, we do not discuss religion nor politics.
Why?
Because religion and politics are full of blathering idiots that cannot see beyond their noses, or think beyond their own little worlds.
Many very intelligent people mind you, they just become so absolute under the spell of religion and politics.
One persons absolutism is any number of persons sheer stupidity.
And that works for each and every one of us.
Politics is the art of governing to the shifting masses.
Religion is the art of governing to shifting beliefs.
You see the similarities? when you realize the similarities, you see why you cannot mix the two.
Both have their uses, both abuse people.
Neither should rule or control anything.
This was the point of the Founders of this country.
It was also the point of the enlightenment.
So in actuality, for all the progress of the modern world, we as a people are even more backwards that those from the 17th and 18th centuries.
Government is needed in the real world, but it shouldn't dictate.
Religion is needed, but it shouldn't control.
That is what this country was founded upon, someday we will get back to it.
Mimi,
I didn't think that you were. I realize that passions do inflame on these topics but they don't have to get personal in nature. I haven't ever seen you do that.
Never had a doubt.
"It is your lack of evidence that is all I need to know." ... What a novel concept....
science experiment: a person blind at birth has never seen any colors. present evidence to the blind person that the color BLUE is real.....
LR,
I was trying to think of the perfect way of putting it, but that was it simply done. Bravo.
The other thing is that there are negative particles and negative numbers, all of which are real.
Agnostic does make the most sense, since you can neither prove or disprove god.
But everyone is free to believe what they like.
You can't prove the color blue to a blind person. You can give them an approximation, but they will never have the true concept.
Who says that is god?
An infinite universe. No proof.
A new moon around Jupiter, there was no proof for thousands of years. It was there all along.
Just because our silly little minds can't think of a way of proving something doesn't mean it isn't there... or that it is.
That's the issue now isn't Hal.....
Those of us that grew up in the 50s, 60s and 70s read of the history of a United States which outlined a country founded upon secular beliefs.
Those that grew up in the 80s, and 90s learned the manipulated history of the United States as rewritten by the religious right after being empowered by the Reagan Administration.
History books have always been written from the jaded perspective of the writer. Worse yet is that the further back in time we go, the details and truth of the times being written about are lost or at the very least misunderstood. The bible is a perfect example of those two points.
On the other hand, if you could snap your fingers and have every religious person disappear, leaving only atheists, agnostics, Deists and pantheist types, would the removal of religion cause the county to not be able to function? Only in the sense that many of those people removed held key secular positions that are critical to how a society functions, yet those positions having nothing to do with theism themselves. It is therefore not a true statement that "religion is needed."
This is an insidious conversation, because JR thinks he is entitled to make rules like "by definition God exists outside the parameters of "nature"." By definition?! You can make up any old imaginary concept, then make up a definition for it, and then suddenly it can no longer be contested? WTF is that? It reminds me of this:
Furthermore, if I insist that there IS a 1995 nickel on the moon, it is not your burden to prove me wrong, it is my burden to prove me right.
"Sorry, but the burden is definitely on the one making the extrordinatingclaim and that would be you."....to a religious person, the Extraordinary claim would be there is NO God. so the burden of proof would then in your words fall upon YOUR shoulders. I'm sure that if you had any scientific PROOF there was no God you would have posted it by now,....wait, you say you can't prove there is NO God,....., so much for extraordinary claims requiring extraordinary PROOF.
some thing to think about when asking for proof or making claims that you can't back up, ...you can draw all the pictures of unicorns you want, that just doesn't make them real.....
"Any irrefutable proof that a god exists otherwise ya got nutin'. You say he's there. Show me. Prove it. I don't have to prove that a nothing exists. Because there is nothing there to prove doesn't exist." ...Got nothing? I have faith. but I am not trying to convince you there is a God or convert you to religion. I am only trying to point out just how stupid it soundas for some one to ask another for proof of something that they them selves can not prove is NOT real. So far your arguments, all of them have been FLAWED....
"if I insist that there is a 1995 nickel on the moon, you wouldn't believe me"...Hal, you need a better analogy, one that will work....
"And I have knowledge..." then MM share it with us. put up or shut up.....
The pope has asked to addressed Congress.
Now that is an appearance that I do not feel is appropriate. He may feel he is on a par with heads of state and rulers of world nations, but he nothing more than a religious leader of an imaginary religious country that houses a religious order and is protected by Italy. He has no place in Congress.
Waiting to see where this one will go.
Yes, technically, he is. But it is only an illusion.
He is nothing more or less than the symbol of a powerful religious order; his "country" is nothing but an illusion held together by the good graces of Italy, whose inhabitants have never known poverty, unemployment difficulties, health management crisis, major crime, housing shortages, education and child management issues, or even had to negotiate union labor crises.
The only thing he has to talk about is his god, which is a personal belief issue, and illegal alien amnesty, which is of personal interest to the catholic church because it means money in the offering plates.... and that makes his speech a pitch for money for the church thinly veiled as a plea for human rights.
MM. If you want to say YOU THINK there is no God or you believe there is No God then I can believe you. But you are saying you KNOW there is no God as a matter of fact without any way to prove it. Your word is just not enough to believe as fact in this world.
I'm still waiting for you to produce evidence on the color blue being real.....
what made your analogy suck was your date on your nickel. the last manned moon landing was in 1972 so it would be impossible for a 1995 nickel to have been left on the surface of the moon....
YOU KNOW ,....YOU KNOW ....YOU HAVE KNOWLEGE ,...stop it, my sides are hurting from laughing so hard.you sound like a broken record. Its all you have left to argue with, I KNOW so that makes it a fact. no proof, NO scientific evidence just I KNOW. ...
.
have a nice day....
you said "It is your lack of evidence that is all I need to know."" and that statement was PROVEN to be FLAWED.
You said "I have knowledge", ...yet you refuse to share any of it with us, scientific or any other knowledge....
And you say I KNOW" as a matter of FACT with no way to back it up.....
"I have to prove nothing, because one can not prove a negative." really? try this
3-5=a negative 4 are you telling us negative numbers don't count????
magnets have negative posts that repel the positive side....proof positive that negatives can be proven.....
the negative post on the battery of a car is real. need proof? just cross the positive post with a wire from the negative side and watch the sparks fly
Lol. Leave math to the professionals, LR.
I shouldn't have added that last paragraph, Randy, and apologize for doing so. It is merely my personal opinion and has no basis in fact. I admit to a negative bias against the catholic church... not the majority of the people who worship as Catholics, but the ruling authority.
The first paragraph stands. Unless he is addressing Congress because he feels his "country" is in some kind of peril from another sovereign nation and he fears invasion, or unless there has been famine or disease with which he needs help for his people in Vatican City, he has no business addressing the US Congress on spiritual matters, or in telling us what to do about any of our domestic problems.
so now you want to go with science,...OK I can do that. You said (more than once if I might add) I KNOW and you said I HAVE KNOWLEGHE. OK lets put some of that KNOWLEGE to the test.Or is that just bullshit.
Scientifically speaking tell us where creation started. Please supply proof.
"The Big Bang is the most popular theory..." really? do you even know what theory means......now you can call impasse....
"Reply by Mickey Mouse 9 minutes ago
Certainly, for this discussion they are commonly held beliefs by science that have been proven to be correct through much experimentation. In science there are many theories, that while they use the word in their title..."
MM you called impasse over 46 minutes ago. like you comments I KNOW and I HAVE KNOWLEGE, you don't seem to understand the meaning of the words.....
"I called an Impasse on my discussion with John...", ...BULLSHIT, just scroll down four comments where you answered my comment with your big bang theory crap then called impasse!!!!!
Burden of proof is both a legal rule and standard, both absolutes.
You are applying it to a philosophical argument and demanding they hold to a high standard that even you do not believe or will hold yourself to when making your own unprovable arguments.
Your argument is a duplicitous one when you refuse to hold the same standards you make others hold to.
But then we have come to expect that from you John.
Religion IS needed, if only to give faith and hope to people that have none. Afterall we are emotional beings for the most part. Without something to hold onto emotionally we lose our humanity.
Agreed, and a very reasonable position to take.
Every time I see the title, of this article I initially think it is a discussion of vintage toys for the sand box, and cherished memories of Tonka Trucks, plastic shovels and buckets come to mind as I drift mentally to the yard behind Grandma's house.
And then reality returns...
Anyone want to talk about the toys of youth, which had no batteries, no Bluetooth?
The point of the article was that I wanted to bring life back into a murdered discussion. It appears that others were happy to join in the resurrection.
I once had a red fire truck peddle car. legs were not long enough to reach the peddles....lol
We had dogs and that kept the cats away for the most part
If you think you accomplished something with the article, then tat is all that is necessary.
I still wish it was about the toys of our youth, but no one could really argue much about that so it probably would not be that popular
L R
I had six brothers - I remember we built a "racecar" out of scrap wood and the wheels of a couple of old farm carts that rode really well down the hill, but was a little lacking in the braking department.
Lots of bruises, scrapes and good times with that toy
It's up on the forum
I look forward to your memories of better days
Holy crapola ! John Russell has just captured Hal's absurd belief system in a nut shell . Well done , John !
There is no god. Never was. Let's move on past that mythology for our own good.
Atheism is also mythology ...
I once had a peddle vehicle too but it was an army jeep. I loved it and was the envy of the local 5 and 6 year old set.
I blame it on Perrie . She put this piece in the list of top content .
Even though I'm not a fan of organized religion, to some extent I think of it as a necessary evil.
If people want to organize into religions groups fine, as long as they stay peaceful and don't try to get their beliefs into the government and public schools.
Of course slamming Hal was just icing on the cake ...