Do conservatives have "policies", or nothing more than "bumper-sticker slogans"? ... by Bob Nelson
A while back, I tried to get a conversation going about what we should expect when the conservatives achieve total control of all branches and levels of government in America. The discussion was pretty good , but such a vast subject inevitably went off in too many directions.
Among other things, Dean Moriarty posted an excellent list of conservative policies. I n three further articles based on Dean's list and my own line-by-line reaction to it , I tried to stay more tightly focused :
- Conservative policies -- Eliminate the Fed
- Conservative policies -- Get rid of the Department of the Education
- Conservative Policies -- Get rid of the Department of Homeland Security and the TSA
The result was very disappointing, with almost no input from NT's conservative members. I have often accused conservatives of having only slogans, without substance... but I hoped that upcoming obligations to actually govern would bring them to think a little deeper.
- The fact that every country in the world has a central bank is a pretty good indication that one is necessary... so if we get rid of the Fed, what will replace it? No answer .
- The Department of Education does some fairly essential stuff, like college loans. If the Department is eliminated, what happens to those loans? No answer .
- Does "get rid of DHS" mean "get rid of the component parts"? Or just shift them to other departments? No answer .
- Does "get rid of the TSA" mean no more airport security? Or what? No answer .
These are headline conservative policies. No one disagreed with their presence at the top of Dean's list. But it seems that conservatives -- those here on NT, at least, have no idea how they will be applied. It's amazing!
Ah, well... I'm going to keep trying. Our conservative members must realize that they are going to run every aspect of this country in a few years at the outside. They must think beyond slogans to actual application.
Or do they intend to just have confidence that the Koch brothers and Sam Brownback will take good care of them? They mean to return their confidence to the "trickle-down" leaders...??
For today:
"End social security and return the money stolen
from those forced to contribute against their will with interest"
------------------------------------------------
The topic here is " How to apply the policy? What will be the consequences of application?".
The topic is NOT whether or not it is a "good idea".
Tags
Who is online
104 visitors

Red Rules are to be posted in the first Reply:
Straight up repeal -- henceforth no national retirement system at all?
How do we know who never wanted to contribute? How do we pay their reimbursement?
Wait a minute here. I contributed very willingly and think Social Security is an great program. But if reason fails to prevail and they get rid of SS, I still expect to paid back, with substantial interest. Why should only those who claim to hate SS be paid back?
Good question... I hope someone will try to answer.
Since it is within the body of the article, that makes it topical.
And you won't get any.
You had us posting to one of those, with very salient comments, particularly about the DOE and how it was created. I was there and involved when it was. we thought that how it was created and why was reasonable to understand when discussing if it should be shuttered.
You decided that it was off topic and had the whole thread deleted.
At that point, speaking for myself, I decided I wasn't going to post on your articles where you only want your perspective discussed. That makes for a very useless stilted conversation that educated people feel is a useless waste of time. I personally know of others Liberal, Conservative and Independent that have decided not to participate on that basis.
I'm sorry, they seemed like good topics, but way too restricted to have a good discussion of the issues involved.
That's the way it goes.
Meta is by definition off-topic.
Please stay on-topic.
Thank you.
Well it is in the OP.
but anyway, trying to be a nice guy I figured I would let you know.
So, now you know.
Your welcome.
Off-topic.
Do you have anything to say about implementation of "End social security and return the money stolenfrom those forced to contribute against their will with interest"?
A person working all their life at a subsistence salary could never retire. Do you agree that this would be the case?
For today:
"End social security and return the money stolen
from those forced to contribute against their will with interest"
No thanks , not interested . There are other conservative policies which are far more important and which the current administration won't get involved in . By controlling the extent of the discussion to be this focused means little useful discussion will happen . This is clearly designed to make certain GOP members look bad . Please identify which ones you have a beef with Bob . Then we can dispense with the pretense that this is a meaningful discussion ...
Meta is off-topic.
Thank you for indicating that the suppression of Social Security is of little importance to you. That is significant. Most conservatives at least give it lip service.
First flaw: in that you would be missing the employer's matching amount.
Second flaw: SS makes a steady amount. All those instruments mention, vary from year to year and even from quarter to quarter.
Lower than 1.3%, because that is today's best IRA rate.
No one protested when Dean presented his list. We hear "get rid of the Fed" or "get rid of Social Security" all the time. You and I may think these are crazy ideas, but a very large portion of what is going to be the permanent ruling party within a few years, wants these things.
In the interest of everyone, we should at least try to get them to think beyond the slogan level.
You are assuming the employer would add what is now SS contribution to the employee's salary.
I see no reason to imagine that the employer would not simply keep that money, with the employee's take-home remaining constant... and therefore inadequate for building a retirement.
I'm not a conservative, I'm a Libertarian, but I will respond to the "end the Fed" portion of this. First of all, I'm not sure but I'm going to assume that other countries' "central banks" are not privately owned. The Fed is. Since our Constitution does not allow for a Central Bank, I'm going to say that the first issue would be to change that. Then, end the fed. We do not need (and for MANY years did not have) our money controlled exclusively by a private entity.A government should not be a money-making venture. The Fed is a FOR PROFIT corporation.
On the other hand, I trust a bunch of money--grubbing professional bankers with my money a lot more than I trust the morons in Congress.
Republicans have over the last 25 years done a great job of getting elected. They are very good at that. But when it comes to governing over that same period of time, they really didn't, and still don't have a clue as to how to help America and Americans. It may very well be that way by design.
In fact, Flynavy, there is little difference between the Republicans and the Democrats except for Talking Points. Neither intends to actually DO anything.
Slarti
Excellent point, but interjecting fact into the discussion, as they "there you go again"
I expect that the distinction (fact)you point out will be largely ignored
Polly.....You're back!!
Long time no see, and glad to have you back even if for just awhile.
Polly,
I'm afraid that I did not understand what you are recommending.
We must have a central bank to manage our economy and / or monetary policy. Every country in the world has one. If you want a "public bank", then please describe its operations:
Unless we know that the replacement will be better... we might want to keep the devil we know...
Personally, I don't like the idea of a central bank staffed and directed by Jeb Bush or Chris Christie...
In all fairness, we are usually given only 2 choices: thedemocrat moron or therepublican moron.
I don't see any "Democratic morons" calling for the end of the Fed, while offering nothing in its place...
False symmetry is... false.
Because most democrat morons are "getting ready for Hillary". Seriously dude, a republican with a "D" after her name is still a republican. Do you guys actually now what liberalism means anymore?
And seriously, dude... if you think there is no difference between Hillary and Jeb, you are a fool.
Perrie, Bob's calling me a fool. Is he allowed to do that? I didn't call him names.
Excellent !!
Hah! I knew that was you Mr. Burns.
yes we do need someone to regulate the money to authority to coin money and to regulate its value are in theConstitution itself. my problem is with the federal reserve being a for profit corporation, even though it is a quasi-governmental entity. my other problem is with the Fed being able to issue money on behalf of the government, lend it to them and then charge them interest. its sort of like your kid running up your credit card over the limit and making you responsible for paying the interest, the overlimit fees and the principle, too. thefed needs to be not for profit. it has to answer to someone or something. i dont have all the answers but the inhere t problem needs to be addressed. the fed should not be entirely owned by 7 i ternational banks. that is an inherent conflict of interest. maybe the u.s. govt should just take 51% ownership.