Why Native Americans Are Concerned About Potential Exploitation of Their DNA
Native Americans Are Concerned About Potential Exploitation of Their DNA
Until the advent of genetic genealogy, knowing your ancestry meant combing through old records, decoding the meaning of family heirlooms and listening to your parents and grandparents tell you about the good old days. For anthropologists and archaeologists interested in going back even further in time, the only reliable means of understanding human history were trying to interpret ruins or remnants of skeletons or other information uncovered at the site of remains.
DNA testing has changed all that, allowing us to delve far deeper into our past than before and with a much higher degree of accuracy. Although there are many issues stirred by DNA testing, none is more provocative than interpreting our family and tribal ancestries.
Nowhere is this more apparent than among the Native American tribes in the United States. I recently wrote about a large-scale genetic analysis among the American population by personal genetics and genealogy company 23andMe, using its extensive database to begin to decipher the ancestral origins of various ethnic groups in the United States.
Though the study involved more than 160,000 people, less than less than one percent of those who participated self-identified as Native American. Rose Eveleth, a journalist writing for The Atlantic suggests that this lack of participation may have a lot to do with how Native tribes perceive genetic testing:
But when it comes to Native Americans, the question of genetic testing, and particularly genetic testing to determine ancestral origins, is controversial. [] Researchers and ethicists are still figuring how to balance scientific goals with the need to respect individual and cultural privacy. And for Native Americans, the question of how to do that, like nearly everything, is bound up in a long history of racism and colonialism.
[] for Native Americans, who have witnessed their artifacts, remains, and land taken away, shared, and discussed among academics for centuries, concerns about genetic appropriation carry ominous reminders about the past.
Eveleth references the widely publicized case where the Havasupai Tribe living near the Grand Canyon sued an Arizona State University scientist for using genetic samples collected from the tribe to conduct research outside of the purpose of the original study. The crux of the issue was the consent form, which covered a broad range of uses for the samplesa fact that the tribes claimed was not explained to them appropriately.
Although the tribe won the case, reclaimed the samples and settled with the university for $700,000, the issue captured the front page of the New York Times and put every tribe in the US on notice regarding genetics research as Native American tribal research ethics expert Ron Whitener quoted in an article titled After Havasupai Litigation, Native Americans Wary of Genetic Research published in the American Journal of Medical Genetics Part A .
Around the same time that the genetics of the Havasupai were being studied, another high profile issue bought Native American tribes in conflict with researchers. The Kennewick Man, an approximately 9,000-year-old skeleton was discovered by accident in 1994 in Kennewick, Washington. The Umatilla Tribe, who were indigenous to the region, sought to reclaim the remains under the 1990 Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act to bury it in accordance with traditions. Anthropology researchers who wanted to study the skeleton however, argued there wasnt enough evidence to convincingly show that the remains were Native American and therefore should not be returned. This resulted in a widely publicized eight-year-long legal dispute between scientists and the government that ended in 2004 with the court ruling in favor of the archaeologists, a decision that the tribes were expectedly unhappy with.
Now, the issue has come under the spotlight once again with the Seattle Times reporting last month that preliminary DNA analyses indicated that the Kennewick Man was indeed of Native American ancestry.
RELATED: The Long Legal and Moral Battle Over Kennewick Man
This piece originally appeared on February 2 at the Genetic Literacy Project. Read the rest of the article here .
Read more at http://indiancountrytodaymedianetwork.com/2015/02/03/why-native-americans-are-concerned-about-potential-exploitation-their-dna-158993
Tags
Who is online
100 visitors

And we have a right to be concerned. Our graves have been robbed. Our culture has be taken.
The Kenniwick Man is the classic example. 9,400 years old and one scientist claimed that the skeleton was Caucasian because the skull was shaped like a Caucasian. So Kenniwick Man stayed in a vault while the tribes and US government fought of his remains. The court said there wasn't enough proof that he was Native American..
A couple of weeks ago the advanced DNA testing was completed and guess what!!! It proves that he is Native American. Now, are the remains of Kenniwick Man going to be returned for proper burial? Let's see what happens.
I would never allow my DNA to be taken for research by scientists. Their history with the tribes isn't good.
SomeIndians may feel differently about it, but past performance by scientists, government, museums have shown that they are not to be trusted.
Genetic research IMO is the biggest double edged sword humanity faces. Yes, genetic research has the potential to do wonderful things. It also has the potential to generate a push towards eugenics, or at the very least genetic discrimination and racism. Insurance companies are licking their chops in anticipation of the day that they can set their fees by what is in your DNA.
Think Gattaca.
''It also has the potential to generate a push towards eugenics''...That is something the US has done in the past. No reason to think the some will notpush for it again.
Good point on the insurance companies FLY.
Kim Tallbear has written a fantastic book on the SERIOUS why's that DNA testing is becoming such a hot market dealing with Native American ancestry.
Sorry for the long quote, but it will give you a glimpse of what we're going to be facing more of -
Has DNA testing changed things more recently?
I think the root cause of recent changes isn't DNA testing, but gaming. Because Native American reservations don't necessarily have to adhere to all of the laws of the states in which they're located namely gambling laws during the 1970s and 80s some tribes started building bingo halls and casinos on their land. In some of the more successful gaming tribes, individual members receive dividends on a monthly basis. In a very few tribes, I've heard of payments in excess of $1 million a year. With that kind of money, you are going to get very rigorous DNA testing.
Also, people tend to think any tribe with a casino gives out huge per capita payments, so tribal enrolment directors all over the country are bombarded with applications.
So how do tribes use DNA testing to determine membership?
It depends. The tribe I'm enrolled in does DNA testing to trace parentage, but only on new applicants. However, some tribes will go back and test everybody. Of course, in any population where you do that you're going to find misattributed paternity. And some tribes dis-enrol descendants: say your biological father is not who you think he is, then you can get dis-enrolled. This has happened in some tribes in the US.
Is this dangerous for tribal identity?
All a parentage test does is say whether your parent is your biological parent or not. I feel that's dangerous in the long run because there is a conflation going on in people's minds of parentage testing with genetic-ancestry testing. People think that there's a DNA test that can prove if somebody is Native American or not. There isn't.
Which members of tribal communities are most affected by the use of DNA tests?
We have a lot of adopted children in our communities. That's a result of the Indian Child Welfare Act, which gives enrolled tribal members the first right to adopt Native American children. The forcible out-adoption of native children used to be part of US policy, so the Act was a way of keeping children in our communities and close to their culture. I think we should enrol adopted children as well biological children. I would also like to see us go back to enrolling spouses. We should look at it as citizenship. Countries allow for immigration and have laws that deal with naturalisation of new citizens. I think tribes should do that too.
So tribal identity is about culture as well as biology?
I want to be careful with the argument that it's culture versus biology; it's also political authority versus biology. We have debates amongst ourselves about whether being Native American is about being a citizen of your tribe a political designation or about culture and traditional practice. I tend to come down on the side of political citizenship. It's true that it's about much more than blood culture matters. But our political autonomy matters too, and that helps produce a space in which our cultural traditions can thrive.
Do genetic tests that claim to prove Native American ancestry worry you?
I worry about the way Native American identity gets represented as this purely racial category by some of the companies marketing these tests. The story is so much more complicated than that.
Why do you think the idea of ancestry testing is so seductive?
There's a great desire by many people in the US to feel like you belong to this land. I recently moved to Texas, and many of the white people I meet say: "I've got a Cherokee ancestor." Lots of non-profit groups have also sprung up calling themselves Cherokee tribes, but they're more like clubs they don't have tribal status in the way that federally recognised tribes do. It's more like, "Do you identify yourself as Cherokee in your soul and your spirit?" That worries us in a land where we already feel there's very little understanding about the history of our tribes, our relationships with colonial powers, and the conditions of our lives now.
Great article, Kavika. Thanks for the information.
Two good articles 1st.
The information about before WWII that adopted children would become members of the tribe, is quite true. I have a problem with the blood quanitive being used by tribes. Indian is Indian no matter how much Indian blood you have. To me, it's simply following the dominant society rules. They are not our rules. There in lies my problem with it. Once again we are allowing the government to tell us what is an Indian and what isn't. Some of this has lead to dis enrollment of members. NOT a good thing at all.
Money, as mentioned in the links is a main driver of DNA testing,many thinkthat you'll be rich if youget enrolled. (not true).
As the article and later in my comments, Ido not want to become a lab test for scientists, their record with tribes is less than stellar.
Thanks dd, happy that you enjoyed it.
I have a question of ignorance for you Kavika.
Are Native Americans, or their tribes able to track back their linage as we of European descendants do or try to do? Could you enlighten me a bit about how this sort of history is recorded. If you think this would derail your seed, we can take this discussion off-line if you want, but it might be a learning opportunity for many on NT.
Best regards as always my friend.
Another fine example of why you should always question the government. The government can't be trusted.
Lot of information to digest in that article, 1st. Thanks.
Yes they are FLY. Much of it will be oral history of the family and the tribe. Starting with the Dawes Act of 1890, where Indians were required to ''register'' as Indians, changed the whole structure of who we are. Many Indians today can trace their ancestry and a significant amount of ''Indian blood'' but are not considered Indians by the US Government.
Some go to old Church records, andmarriage certificates to determine if one of their ancestors was Indian.
To say the least, it is confusing, but anytime that the government becomes involved, especially in making laws that concern a persons identity it's going to become a fiasco.
There are no other people in the US that have to prove what they are.
The old saying, ''Trust the government, ask an Indian'', rings very true 96.
There is also an article dealing with the young Montana Native youth who is/was 12,600 years old. They conducted testing on him and found him to be a "brother" to a young Siberian youth who is/was 24,000 years old. The researchers said there was so much overlapping that they could have been brothers.
Now the down side. We have always said that we have always been here, and it has been proven that we were here before any other human. However, the latest supposed links of DNA "show" that we have "descended" from Siberian/Euros within the past 50,000+ years. In fact, our DNA structures are linked to only four Siberian women/mothers within the past 60,000+ years. Interestingly, the Aboriginals of Australia are also linked to those four mothers and two African mothers.
As a physical scientist, I understand genomes and the DNA structures. I also understand, based on archaeology/anthropology, that Lucy "may" have been the mother of all human kind (wonder who her mother and father were and who their mother and father were and who . . . . . . ) and that was from 1.7 million years ago. Yes, all peoples, supposedly, are linked to the African "cradle of life" (Professor Leakey term).
Therein is my concern. "Some" scientists are now attempting to downgrade/downplay the importance/significance of the Native American peoples by purporting that "we" are descended from Euros, hence we are not significant nor special nor unique. But we are. We may have migrated from elsewhere, but for at least 40,000 years, we were the ONLY humans in the Western Hemisphere and we carved myriads of nations, cultures, traditions, heritages that are found no where else in the world. AND, we continue living those cultures, traditions and heritages, something the other societies don't do.
Are they now going to start calling us Euros????
1st, the ''Seal Hunter'' theory is one of the latest theories to claim that euros have been here for thousands of years. The claim is that they are from the French/Spanish region of Europe.
With regard to the Aboriginals of Australia. For many years it was claimed by scientists that the had only been in Australia between six and ten thousand years. With the discovery of the ''Mud Lake Man'', it's been determined that they have been there for at least 50,000 years.
Also DNA testing of the girl found in a cave in Mexico, dated to 15,000 years ago, was determined to be Native American.
It gets more interesting with the discovery of the Native DNA in the Easter Island people.
Are we Euro's...I think not.
VEY interesting stuff Kav....thanks for posting this!!
How 'bout/what if - WE crossed the Atlantic in our canoes and met with the Neanderthals and Cro-magners and started a population boom???? The DNA would be the same in sequence, right?????
Your welcome Nona.
Yes it would be the same DNA in sequence. In fact, that has been my contention all along. I've even written a couple of articles on it.
Leave it to the Indians to find the "truth"
I think the two of you are going to be insufferably please with yourselves for quite sometime.....
We don't speak with ''forked tongue''.
Yes, we're embarrassed - see our "Red faces"???????
Insufferable FLY!!! No way. Really insufferable, YES.
LOL 1st, is that an Indian joke?
How many generations can some of these oral histories go back do you think?
What color do your faces turn when your mad? (please...joke)
Kind of like asking what color does a Smurf turns when it holds it's breath?
They can go back for hundreds and hundreds of years FLY.
The Ojibwe have had a written language for over a thousand years. It is recorded on birch bark by the Midewiwin (Grand Medicine Society) and tell of all the important events and keeps track of the history of the Ojbiwe.
The family records are not kept this way.
1st..
The people that we are descended from are hardly Euros. They are Mongolian. In other words...asian.
And it little matters in the course of the discussion of who were the first people. We are... and our DNA proves that we are the first people.
Many nations kept records on hides - for thousands of years. One of the best known is a Crow buffalo hide - said to be 1,000 years old.
Yeppers - leave it to the Euros to get their geography screwed up - 'member Columbus?
Who...AKA... "Wrong Way"? Well there are Indians, and then there are Indians.
Perrie, you have the right group of people, but are incorrect on one important item. The Mongols descended from us. This is a fact. Do you think that they became great horsemen by a correspondence course. Geez....
Impressive gentlemen.....
The concept of genetic testing to prove Native American ancestry is one that is discussed more frequently in recent times, but there are many problems with the idea. Perhaps foremost of these problems is that to make a genetic test the arbiter of whether someone is Native American or not is to give up tribal sovereign ability to determine membership and relations. But even taken on their own scientific terms, the tests cannot do much to identify who is and who is not Native American. This is because they yield many false negatives and false positives (they readily misidentify non-Native people as Native, and misidentify Native people as non-Native), and the positive results they do yield at best are only probabilities, not certainties. If these were medical diagnostic tests, they would never be approved or adopted.
But the most important argument against this type of testing to establish tribal affiliations is that biology (and genetics) track just part of our tribal inheritance. These DNA tests treat Native American biology as though all Indians were essentially the same. But in reality, our traditions make us who we are, not just our biology.
Mother horse - everybody knows that.
This seed is really going down hill.......love it!
So you guys are ultimately responsible for the invention of gunpowder then!
That sure as hell came around and bit you in the ass now didn't it...
700,000 years later...... Now you've got me looking up things again.
North America. A skeleton was found buried in theYukon Territory that has been dated to 700,000 years ago.
LOLOL, education of ''Little Tree''...
As a General once said (can't remember his name) Retreating!!! No, we're just advancing in another direction.
That's true in every culture isn't it? Every culture has so much to offer if people would just stop judging and take the opportunity to embrace and learn.
So much damage was done to the NA culture by we Europeans, it makes me sick. I remember that our Jr. High history teachers warned us before the Shawnee Mission guest speakers arrived that we would be shocked at some of the unvarnished history they were going to share with us.
I remember this book....Wasn't that writer the same guy that ended up being a member of the KKK and wrote speeches for George Wallace? I think so.
Hi Robert,
You of course have missed the point as usual. First off, the Indians were correct in claiming that he was of Indian race. There is that act of 1990 ''Grave Protection and Reparation Act''. It's a law, aren't those pesky things. Guess why that Law existsRobert.
The courts decided there wasn't enough proof that the remains were Native American. Now what in the world else could they have been?
As a supporter of laws in this country Robert, I would have thought that you would have been supportive of our claim.
So you see we were not impeding science, simply following the law.
Yes, it is preliminary, but if you read all the reports, you would have seen that very little chance of his not being Native American with further testing.
Now, were did I say I reject DNA and science. I do believe, that in your rush to try to one up me, you didn't see, or didn't want to see who made that comment. ''Fools rush in'' seems to fit you Robert.
Of course you failed in more than one way Robert. You should research the skeletons found in Alaska, 11,500 years old, also the child's skeleton in Montana, 12,400 years old. The DNA was tested in conjunction with the tribes and science moved forward, with the help of Indians. Both of these were much older than the Kenniwick Man. That should give you a clue, or perhaps your clueless.
It is fortunate that your BS is always pointed out to our members. Keep up the good work.
I don't believe so FLY, I'll have to research it.
Your total lack of history is astounding Robert. Please don't think you have any knowledge of how I think or what I do, support or agree with, or not agree with.
''But you do harm in your obvious need to ensure that science concludes your beliefs. In your need to disregard anything that does not fit your beliefs.''
Now that really is the kettle calling the pot black. You of all people cannot accept anything out of your very small view of the world.
You, as always show your ignorant, myopic view of everything that you don't agree with.
''NO ONE concluded that the remains were not "Indian," prior to scientific study.'' Really, you didn't read all the subject matter on this.
Indian myths, really Robert, your bias is showing. Not that unusual though, you wear your ignorance like a crown.
Robert, I don't assume anything, your the one that does the assuming, and it really makes an ass out of you.
I see plots and conspiracies everywhere I look..LOLOLOLOL, this coming from a someone that is a malcontent that's obsessed with Obama, Chicago and Blacks, or anyone that has a different point of view.
Good try, but a fail for you again.
An answer to what Robert. I think that the answers are there, but since your to blind to see them, I'll explain it to you. If the tribes were given control of kenniwick Man, and he would receive the proper burial, the chances are good that the tribes would have worked with the anthropologists in DNA testing. Just like they have done with Montana Boy and the children in Alaska.
Kenniwick Man was a threat? I didn't know that, was he a threat to you?
When it comes to BS, your the King, wear your crown proudly.
Whatever you want to believe Robert, but you are starting to sound angry and paranoid about this.
Robert, thehuman body and looks change through out the course of history. Remember you were once Black.
I understand how tribes decide on the fraction of someone's ancestry that is native American , based on their lineage . I wonder how that could be verified or supported with genetic testing ... if possible .
With a strong accent.
We've to skeletal remains of "mini-horses" here in NM that are 230,000 y. o.
All you wanted to know 'bout Asa Carter FLY -
Agreed Robert. True, many in the Indian community don't want DNA intrusion into their lives, cultures, traditions or heritage. But in instances where the Indian community has requested, in accordance with law, the remains of an Indian and the scientific world provides them with results of their DNA testing as verification that the Indian community was correct - that's a good thing.
The Indian community would have "NEVER" had DNA testing done on Kennewick - because, they "knew" Kennewick was Indian. No other decision could have been made.
That is an interesting question Petey and, as explained by Kim Tallbear, throughout history, members of tribes intermarried with members of other tribes/nations, so there is no "specific" genome that sez - yup, yer Chickasaw. But, the markers of other areas such as, believe it or not, "O-" blood, traits of diabetes, dark hair, eyes, pigmentation, etc., etc can put the findings in a ballpark area where "science" can say - hmmmm - that person has many of the characteristics of an Indian person, let's check other things such as - age, location, depth/type of burial, etc..
There have been a few comments relating to why Indians would "prefer" that DNA testing not be performed. Yes, it is intrusive, yes, it is against our beliefs to harm the body for "no reason" (not all Indians are scientifically curious), yes, we hold the body and its spirits sacred and "demand" that they remain united, and, to use an ol' adage, why damage a perfectly good body just to find out where it's from? The Arizona tribes/nations have had issues with scientific curiosity because the use of the information obtained was NOT as was told to the tribes/nations. That is the craw in our throats - we were and are lied too time and time and time again, so, yes, it pisses us off when we're lied to again.
However, but . . . . you'll note in all the articles posted regarding DNA testing of remains found in highly remote areas, the Indian peoples had no issue with trying to determine the origin of the remains. BUT, if the remains were determined to be Indian, we ask that all testing stop and that, according to federal/state law (Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act, the remains be turned over to the Indians for their care and re-internment - per custom/tradition of the tribe/nation.
Damn if I wasn't right about something for a change.....!
I remember reading the book in my senior year in high school of 1978. At the time I thought it was really a pretty good book, and I agreed with much of it from about being centered with nature.
I joined the Navy in 81, and I met a guy that was Wichita (for the most part), and I mentioned I was born in Wichita, Kansas. We hung out together for the remainder of boot camp, and I brought up the book. He (Dale Greenfeather) went on to tell me it was all a hoax. That Carter was a member of the KKK from Alabama and wrote segregationist speaches for George Wallace. Man that sucked. I really enjoyed the book. Screwed and didn't even get kissed!
But, if you read other books that he wrote - "Outlaw Josie Wales" and a few others, he was quite promotive of the Indian way. Guess he just didn't like the South
The seven tribes/nations, initially, agreed to some testing to help determine which of the tribes/nations he descended from. But, after it was shown that the testing could not make that determination - that's when they wanted the testing stopped. The tribal/nation representatives were the "spiritual" leaders of the community and, as such, looked at the remains totally differently than did the "scientific" leaders in the Indian community.
No, they were not trying to "impose" their beliefs on Kennewick Man, they were trying to educate the scientific community. Kennewick already had his beliefs - 9,000 years ago.
Which is exactly what happened with Montana Boy, and is happening with the Alaska children. Their DNA was tested, found to be Native, and returned to the tribe for burial.
Both the scientists and the tribes were satisfied with the procedure. Much was learned and our customs were treated with respect.
Being lied to, time after time by both the scientific community and the government does not sit well with us Robert. Also, your calling our beliefs, ''myths'', as ifyouare some self proclaimed expert, speaks to your arrogant biasattitude.
Interesting point Kavika that has not been "mentioned" is - what if - what if the scientific community started digging up cemeteries throughout the country to conduct DNA testing for determinations of - whatever. How would the dominant community react?
They would piss their pants 1st.
I posted an article around a year or so ago, where the Ojibwe purchased some land to build a rec center on. They found out that there was a possible Catholic cemetery buried under it. They chose not to go through with the purchase out of respect for the ancestors of the people buried there.
To bad that the ''scientific community'' and some here on NT don't have the same moral compass.
See if you were a King, then you get a proper burial if your bones got misplace.. like with King Richard III. Found in a parking lot, after DNA proof of who he was, he was buried at Leicester Cathedral.
So that clears things up. Dead anglo king, gets a proper burial. Dead indian... not so much...
Not that things were better for blacks here. Do you know how many black cemeteries there are covered over in NYC?
And in Oxford England, when they threw the Jews out, they turn their cemetary into a park.
I guess you have to be part of the "in" crowd to get respect in death.
So true Perrie. When stationed in San Fran, there was a housing community being built and they "came across" 1,100 Indian burials. No consultation, they just uprooted them and placed them in a "mass" grave a few miles off site. The tribes/nations found out about it and the State "allowed" the tribes/nations to conduct ceremony - period.
Cultures Robert - cultures. The Egyptian mummies were not Muslim - Ra and Isis were not from Mohammed - in fact he hadn't even been born at that time, so the description doesn't work.
The Indians are simply - very simply - asking "dominant" scientists to respect our culture and traditions - period. So, if we say something is "sacred" to us, we ask/expect others to take that into meaning and understand that, indeed, something is "sacred" to us. Nothing "savage" or "ignorant" about that.
You're implying then that the Catholic church that has a sliver of wood that they "claim" came from the cross of Christ makes them ignorant savages? After all, there is no verifiable scientific proof that their BELIEF is true.
Science is the problem here because the Indian heritage and beliefs have proven to science that things have happened - for which the scientists have no explanation but do accept that - yup, it happened just as the Indians said it did.
The embarrassing part Robert is "acceptance".
Scientists, in many parts, cannot "accept" the beliefs of some, including Indians. However, all concerned are expected to accept the "beliefs" of the scientists. Einstein's Theory of Relativity STILL hasn't been proven, but, scientists swear it is true because it is their belief that it is true.
The seven tribes/nations in the Colville area "belief's" that Kennewick Man was Indian should have been given the same respect and acceptance by the scientists as the Theory of Relativity is given - the Indians "knew" Kennewick was Indian, just as scientists "know" the Theory of Relativity is true.
Ignorance is in the eye of the beholder. If your mind won't accept it, it's an ignorant thought.
You are saying the Indians are stupid because of their beliefs or desire that others understand that that is their belief??
Kinda crossed the line Robert.
Oh, no, I understand about the "Demand" to be accepted, especially from the scientific community.
The Indian community is no different.
I live in both worlds - I am a physical scientist by training and occupation and an Indian by birth who also believes in his culture, traditions and heritage.
The scientists want to go past the point of "oh, yeah, it's an Indian". They want to know what he ate, when he ate it, why his incisors are worn on one side and not the other, did the weather cause his moles/warts, did he develop calluses from using an axe, knife, bow and arrow, carrying rocks, how did he carry rocks, etc..
The Indian community already knows that information and it is shared in our oral histories that, after the scientists "study" the remains/artifacts, they determine - "hey, the Indians were right about what he ate, where he slept, the tools he used, etc.."
But, from a spiritual/religious aspect, the Indian community places great respect on the dead and the afterlife. The scientific community does not - period. As Kennewick was one of the "people", it was up to the Colville tribes/nations to decide what his fate should be - not the scientists.
Conclusion - blocked thought processes. Would you react the same if it were your g-g-g-grandfather/mother?
The history, for the most part, of the Kennewick man was known and told to the scientists by accessing the "ancestral history and genetic history" through the tribes/nations oral history. Guess what - the scientists are finding the stories to have been true and all they are doing is substantiating that information.
Robert, did you miss the part where others, Montana Boy and Alaska Children are being studied/DNA tested,with the help of the local tribes?
They are much older than Kenniwick Man, by a couple of thousand years. We have no problem with the way it's being done. You seem to have a huge problem with Kenniwick Man, and of course stupid, backward, non scientific Indians or anyone that doesn't agree with you. Having a culture/language/customs/ancestors that werespect is part of us. If you can't understand or accept that, well tough shit Robert.
Indians have aproblem with, backward, bias/bigoted assholes, who love to hear themselves talk. Perhaps it's in the asshole's DNA. Scientists would only have to go back a couple of generations to discover the ''stupid gene'' thatmanifests itselfwith certainmalcontents.