Three Ways to 'Do Something' About Poverty
Last week, after Mitt Romney talked about poverty, President Obama mocked him : "That's great! Let's go do something about it!"
Well, Romney's not running after all , so Obama will have to aim his sarcasm somewhere else. But for those inclined to take him up on his challenge to "go do something about it," there are lots of opportunities. As Vice President Joe Biden also said last week , "the past six years have been really, really hard for this country." So what can we do to make things better? Here are some ideas on easing poverty and income inequality that just might work.
Immigration: Yes, we're a nation of immigrants. But it's also true that when you allow a lot of low-skilled immigrants in from Mexico and Central America, you push down wages for low-skilled American citizens. You want to help poor workers in America? Cut down on the number of people competing for their jobs. (The well-off understand the impact of competition, which is why nobody's talking about opening up immigration to unlimited numbers of foreign lawyers, doctors, dentists, accountants or, God forbid, pundits. As Reihan Salam observed in Slate last week, the upper-middle-class is hyper-vigilant about protecting its turf from competition. Likewise, Silicon Valley firms are always trying to relax visas for tech workers so as to push American wages in that sector down, because that's what immigration does to wages.
Education: Yes, Obama's free community college program is a start. But if Republicans in Congress want to make hay, they should also require that every college receiving federal funds which is pretty much all of them accept community college credits 100% for purposes of transferring. This would substantially help lower-income students trying to get four-year degrees. On a further note, we could go national on something like former Texas governor Rick Perry's plan to make it possible to get a four-year college degree for $10,000 . Already, 12 Texas colleges have signed on. (Sens. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., and Mike Lee , R-Utah, have some additional ideas, too.) Meanwhile, at the K-12 level, we need to promote school choice, and alternatives such as online and home schooling, that can offer students better education than failing public schools, at lower cost. If education is a key to alleviating poverty and income inequality, then schools should be run for the benefit of students, not the benefit of teachers and administrators.
Job licensing: As Slate' s Salam notes , pervasive occupational regulation is one of the ways that the upper-middle class keeps the middle and lower classes down. In the Internet world, people still sing the praises of " permissionless innovation ," but in the real world, "permissionless employment" used to be the rule. Now it's becoming the exception. In the 1950s, only one in 20 needed a license for employment. Now, according to a recent report in The New York Times, it's three in 10. These include things like taxi drivers, hair braiders and teeth whiteners. President Obama's budget includes money to analyze this problem, but I see no need to wait. As the Times notes, occupational licensing is touted as a protection for consumers, but in practice it mostly just protects the licensed from competition, protection for which they reward politicians with votes and donations.
The right to employment is protected by the Constitution's Fourteenth Amendment , which also grants Congress the power to pass " appropriate legislation " to protect rights. Congress should act to make state licensing laws subject to strict judicial scrutiny, and should also require states to recognize each other's professional and occupational licenses so as to enhance mobility and opportunity. Why should a dentist, lawyer or psychologist much less a barber who wants to move to California or Florida have to ask permission from a state board to practice her profession?
Well, President Obama challenged us to "go do something about" the problems of poverty and inequality in America. Here are three ideas that Congress could enact now. Will the White House get behind them if they do? I can't imagine why not.
http://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2015/02/02/mitt-romney-poverty-obama-mock-sarcasm-hard-immigration-education-column/22694973/
Tags
Who is online
127 visitors

These seem like three places the two sides should be able to work something out that provides some of what both sides want on the issues and in the end will benefit the middle class and the entire country.
Since I serve on a Board that licenses geologists, perhaps I can address at least part of this issue... Our Board exists to make sure that everyone performing geological services in the state are qualified to do so. It is against the law to practice as a geologist without being licensed, or under the direct supervision of a licensed geologist. This is to ensure public safety and well-being. Our board is self-funded, meaning that the licensing fees pay for our Board services-- we receive a contribution from the state of about 1/3 of our total budget, but if we get too much money in the bank, we are subjected to "sweeping" funds from our account, a yearly bugaboo. If we get sued, we have to have the money to pay...
This is to ensure, also, that geologists within the state meet specific requirements-- one can't just go hang out a shingle. As a minimum, they must have a geology degree, (you wouldn't believe the number of people who used to practice geology without a geology degree), they must have completed at least 30 hours of class work, (45 quarterly hours), they must have 5 years of supervised experience, and they must adhere to strict ethical guidelines. They must also pass a two-part exam that proves their competence and it is a HARD exam.
We "police" our licensees, in that if we receive a complaint, we can subpoena their records and take them to court for unethical or dishonest behavior, and can request criminal charges for negligent practices.
Why is this important? Because there are plenty of people out there who would call themselves a geologist, and they aren't. A geologist can kill hundreds if not thousands of people, (our professional insurance is on par with doctors.) They must have a certain degree of competence before they are unleashed on an unknowing public.
Most people don't know doodley squat about geologists and what we actually do. Nor do they know if they're being fleeced. Nor can they guess if they are getting decent service. We defend the public against those who are negligent, dishonest, or just plain crazy. Somehow, this seems very different to me than a hairdresser or barber, although I can see that they need some special training on health issues.
I think that there are about 30 states with licensing requirements, now. Strange how some of the states, like Texas, don't require geologists to be licensed... Yet they have the most oil and gas work going on... Louisiana has just begun licensing.
Dowser
I think that geologists are not the group most think of when they think of undue license requirements and over regulation of career fields.
No one disputes that some professions do and should require licensing and oversight of qualifications, but at some point.........as you point out in your comment other fields likely need much less in the areas of licenses etc
For example (and not picking on New York for any reason) the state of NY licenses 130 occupations including shorthand reporter, athletic agent, racetrack exercise rider, groom, interior designer, librarian, ......
Even in some states, the license is really just a fee... We have comity with about 24 states. Their requirements are the same as ours, and if they are licensed in that state, then we accept their licenses, and usually, after checking, license them in our state.
I don't know what the requirements are for licenses for other professions in the state. Other than, if you are an exterminator, you have to be licensed, (required by the feds), to use certain pesticides. I've studied for that test, but since I don't practice pest extermination, I haven't tried to take it. It is mainly about how pesticides work, etc. I think they need to include a bit more environmental stuff in the educational portion. But then, I would. Most people who handle pesticides are qualified to do so-- but some of the licensed pesticide applicators don't even read the directions on the package.
I've certainly known hairdressers who needed a course in health safety. And I would want a licensed electrician to do my wiring work... In some cases, it is really necessary. Maybe in others, it isn't. Yet, one does want to feel safe that the hot dog you buy from that vendor on the street isn't going to give one botulism...
I promise that I'm not trying to derail your article. I can only really address the one issue.
Note: I'm all for state universities accepting 1 on 1 credit for community college courses. It really bugs me that the state supported community colleges that are affiliated with a particular college do not accept those hours on a 1 on 1 basis. People enter that college thinking they will be, and they're not.
Dowser
I learn stuff every time you comment and that is why I participate on NT
Others want to "win" the argument, but I am satisfied to exchange information and learn things, offer opinions and sometimes poke fun at the ideological warriors who must win at all costs.
I truly appreciate your feedback
I do not dispute that there are professions that need to be regulated and licensed but I also offer that there are many that do not and that the red tape impedes competition and entry into career fields at times.
Thanks again
I agree with you! Red tape seems to be the order of the day! And yes, it does impede people with few resources in getting jobs!
I looked up the barber licensing fees here in my city and it's $50/year, plus you have to pass an exam. A brief health exam-- a written exam, not a physical... I think they charge that so they can pay for the training in health...
I do not approve of licensing those who do not need to be licensed. i.e. "Sanitation Engineers", (not civil engineers), day laborers, etc. Restaurant licenses, even for street vendors, can be prohibitive, yet they must meet certain standards of health. I'm trying to think of a service I use that isn't licensed-- restaurant servers... bank tellers... cashiers... I pump my own gas, like we all do. My husband changes the oil... He is a certified technician for Lexus and BMW, but he isn't licensed. I don't want more red tape, any more than you do... But, by that same token, there are certainly professions that I want the people performing the service to be licensed.
I always enjoy talking with you-- even when I'm wrong! That says something, maybe?
I always enjoy talking with you-- even when I'm wrong! That says something, maybe?
That says a lot and I feel the same way - not needing to be "right" all the time and actually discussing things -- what a concept.
Yep. This, to me, cuts across ideologies.
I don't want any more red tape-- but in certain professions, licensing is a good idea.
Now, onto community colleges! and immigration!
Exactly
Licensing for professional engineers is a must. Structural engineers, combustion engineers, reactor engineers.... anyone that is allowed to sign off on a design that if it fails can result in loss of life.
The PE (professional engineering exam) is a meat grinder. It needs to stay that way too in order for people to sign off on certain types of designs.
Fly, our geology law was modeled after the engineering law. Our test only has about a 30% pass rate. It's tough!
And yes, I agree that it needs to be that way! I'm just glad I don't have to take it...
I've been out of school so long, I'm unaware of some of the latest theories...
No arguments on engineers from me.
How about
A school librarian has to have a college degree-- i.e. special training. I don't know about regular librarians. I would imagine that a public library librarian would make more $$ with a degree-- but then, again, I don't know about just someone who would shelve books or check out books.
The others seem ridiculous, but I don't know their requirements for qualifications, either... Maybe they can make more $$ if licensed. I know of several interior designers who have college degrees, (friends of my step-daughter's), but don't ask me who hires them... Having looked at some of the houses for sale lately, I wonder who on earth decorated them... (Meaning, not to my taste.)
Dowser
I agree
Degree requirements (education) and a license are two very different things and the list I cited does not state that it is school librarians only.
I always thought that if I got bored in retirement, I could go and get a minimum wage job at a library... But then again, if they require a degree, I'm out of luck!
I wonder who licenses horse grooms? Then, I googled it. Of course, KY licenses horse grooms. Or certifies them, anyway. No previous experience necessary, but offers two classes. Do you think that some of these careers offer certification as a way to get more $$ for their workers? My husband doesn't get more $$ from being certified, (not a higher hourly rate), but then, because he is certified and works on the expensive cars, and fixes them according to the company standards, (BMW and Lexus), he does make more money... I just wonder.
Do you care if I start a new thread with my next comment?
I think getting money out of people and subtly keeping some potentially qualified people out of the jobs is exactly why some of these certifications, license etc exist
Not sure I agree, on what do you base that assertion?
I don't agree at all. It is for the protection of people and it insures a level of excellence in a field.
The Board I'm on is charged with ensuring public safety and protecting consumers. I haven't noticed an increase in my pay just because of licensure...
But then, I'm not an engineer.
RIO, in response to your statement above, I think so, too. Especially horse groomers, and I mean no disrespect for them...
Perrie
I agree, but it can be overdone and in areas where it is not really needed as noted above
I think we are on the same page on this one
Thanks for all the feedback, expertise and perspective - it helped me better understand the issue