╌>

Iraq - Now and a Century Ago

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  pokermike  •  11 years ago  •  5 comments

Iraq - Now and a Century Ago

"Those who do not remember the past are condemned to repeat it." -George Santayana

As a student of history, sadly it is common how often horrible mistakes are repeatedly made when history is ignored or minimized. The recent U.S. situation in Iraq is uncomfortably similar to the British experience there nearly 100 years ago. The U.S. after deposing Saddam Hussein in 2003 found itself in much the same position as the British in 1918 after the defeat of the Ottoman Empire in World War I: what to do with a broken region in chaos. I will leave it to fellow NewsTalkers to note the similarities while I attempt to describe the historical situation a century ago.

At the close of the war in 1918, the British found themselves occupying Mesopotamia (now Iraq) with a relatively small military presence yet hoping to bring order to a chaotic situation. It found itself with a Kurdish minority wanting an independent Kurdistan, a Shia south centered around Basra, and Sunni tribes in the Baghdad provinces. In addition, they had a large Jewish community which dominated the commercial life of Baghdad and a substantial Christian community around Mosul. Seventy-five percent of the population was tribal, described by the British Commissioner as "with no previous tradition of obedience to any government". His assistant, Gertrude Bell, was the leading Western expert on the Middle East who was warned "You are flying in the face of four milleniums of history if you try to draw a line around Iraq and call it a political entity...They have never been an independent unit....They have no conception of nationhood yet".

The British soon found themselves in a native uprising with British soldiers being massacred, abducted as hostages and murdered. The British High Command viewed the only solution to deal with the disaffected tribes was "wholesale slaughter". A British Colonel with much experience in the Middle East was sent in hopes of bringing about a negotiated agreement. Instead he attended a meeting with tribal allies, was tricked into sending away his armed escort, and then was shot in the back and killed by order of the tribal sheikh who was his host. It took the British nearly 3 years to bring about order, though suffering almost 2,000 casualties including 450 dead. The British Commissioner stated "What we are up against is anarchy plus fanaticism. The tribesman are out against all government as such and had no notion of what they were fighting for."

Public opinion soon turned against the whole British mission. The newspaper The Timesdemanded in 1920 "how much longer are valuable lives to be sacrificed in the vain endeavor to impose upon the Arab population an elaborate and expensive administration which they never asked for and do not want?" In a similar articleThe Timessaid "We are spending sums in Mesopotamia and in Persia which may well reach a hundred millions pounds this year [a trivial sum to what the U.S. has wasted there] in support of what it termed the foolish policy of the Government in the Middle East." Again in 1921 The Times questioned "while the government has spent nearly 150,000,000 pounds since the Armistice upon semi-nomads in Mesopotamia they can find only 200,000 a year for regeneration of our slums, and have had to forbid all expenditure under the Education Act of 1918".

This all sounds too eerily familiar to me. What do you think?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  pokermike    11 years ago

For those who might be interested in a similar look at the origins of the Israel-Palestinian conflict, I have posted an article in the Middle Eastern Affairs Group.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

It is history repeating itself.

I would add one other thing Mike, when your a colonizer, British, French, Spanish, Dutch, US, etc there is always going to be a payback from the people that were colonized.

Most of the countries mentioned have learned some hard lessons. The French especially so in the 1956 to 62 Algerian war.

The lesson to be learned is to ''keep your frickin nose out of other country business''.

Bush senior stopped short of taking Bagdad, I believe because he was aware that doing so, would have American troops there for a very long time, and increase the hatred towards the US. Bush Jr. didn't have the brain power to come to that conclusion.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Very interesting historic lesson here Mike . Thanks for posting this . It brings up many questions such as :

What exactly is a "country" and are they really necessary everywhere ? If you don't organize a region into a country does it revert into a Somalia or Yemen ?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

This all sounds too eerily familiar to me. What do you think?

It sounds like you have gotten it 100% correct to me.

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  pokermike    11 years ago

Two things prevent development of viable democracies in the Middle East: Islam and Arab culture. It is well-known that the blood feud between the Sunni and Shia divisions of Islam go back to the 7th century. Islamic countries do not fully respect the rights of religious minorities. At best, they are tolerated but always with a sword hanging over their heads.

Much of Arab culture is tribal in nature. It is often a zero-sum game where negotiation and compromise play little part. Simply, it is politics of a I-win, you-lose leading to tyrannies by Kings, Emirs, military dictators or Ayatollahs.

 
 

Who is online



115 visitors