Gay marriage is NOT marriage equality by Red Shadow
There is a big fight over gay marriage and gay marriage advocates seem to be winning. The final answer will likely be given by the United States supreme court this summer. No one can say for sure how the court will rule on this issue.
Gay marriage proponents say there should be marriage equality for all people but this is not true marriage equality if it applies only to gays. If gay marriage is legalized nationwide there will still be several classes of people who cannot marry the ones they love. True marriage equality would allow anyone to marry anyone without any restrictions.
I have no position on gay marriage. My only position is that each state should decide on marriage rules for their own state.
Tags
Who is online
106 visitors

Any civil comments are welcome.
ANY civil comments are welcome.
It sounds like you have some definite examples in mind . Which ones ?
I know of about 8 but would like to hear from others.
The most obvious would be more than two people or close relatives.
My main point is gays are not the only ones who cannot marry.
Another point is that lesbian couples are radically different from male homosexuals . They are practically 2 different species .
Consenting adults who are gay should be allowed to marry. It provides them with all the rights that other married folks have.
I find it an odd time that we live in. Gay people fighting for the right to get married, while loads of people are having families and feel no need for marriage.
Gay marriage advocates were quite compelling in their arguments for marriage equality and eventually managed to win over most folksto their cause. If incestual pedophiliacs wish the same right to marriage equality, then it's up to them to launch their own campaign, though I imagine such an endeavor would meet with less success.
In marriage EQUALITY any number of people could marry.
Allowing gay marriage may or may not be right to allow but it is not equality because it legalizes only one type of marriage while still criminalizing other types.
I don't care either but each state should be able to decide.
This reminds me of why I moved to Florida.
Same sex could be used rather than gay.
You devoted all of 8 sentences to this so called 'article', one of which is; "If gay marriage is legalized nationwide there will still be several classes of people who cannot marry the ones they love." If you can spare us an additional sentence or two, perhaps you would care to explain what 'several classes' of people you're referring to.
H.
Learn to count.
Explain the difference between 2 gay men marrying and 3 gay men marrying.
I would not read a dumb article.
Good points.
I would not have children without being married.
I listed two.
I will find a bigger list.
I think 8 sentences made my point.
"Learn to count. Explain the difference between 2 gay men marrying and 3 gay men marrying."
The difference is any number other than ONE,Comment removed for CoC violation [ph],. Seriously, I think the only reason idiots like you pose questions like this, is to try and dumb people down to your level. Trying to equate a consenting same sex couple to more than two people or things is like trying to compare apples and rubics cubes. I swear, I may have to leave this forum, since articles like yours are becoming too common here, and they serve only to drag members into the quicksand of idiocy where you thrive in.
That is an interesting point . Do you think that should be a requirement for a couple having their own offspring ?
Here's another interesting comparison : equating a lesbian couple to a male homosexual couple . They are so completely different they could be considered different species ...
No. Each should choose on having children.
Trying to equate a consenting same sex couple to more than two people or things is like trying to compare apples and rubics cubes.
This same reasoning was used to oppose interracial and gay marriage.
Hal\
You don't deserve a response.
cala lugi col mit dar.
common law marriage
clan marriage
line marriage
arranged marriage,
blood test
contract marriage
IQ test
age requirement
others
Red,
Most of those are allowed by law already. In fact, common law marriages just happen automatically.
Age requirements are there to protect the young.
They did away with blood tests.
I am still confused with your point.
Florida does not recognize common law marriage.
Each one I listed is illegal in at least one state.
A ban on interracial marriage was said to protect purity of the races.
Banning gay marriage was said to protect sanctity of marriage,
I do not say these were good reasons.
To avoid side issues limit it to gay or multiple marriage.
To allow one and not the other is not equality.
I am pointing out hypocrisy, not advocating for either side.
If a man can marry another man how can equality and fairness forbid him from marrying 2 men.
You should consider that the downgrading of marriage may be specifically due to the push for homosexual marriage. ("Gay" is a PC term.)
When marriage loses its significance why bother?
IOW why shouldn't polygamy be legalized?
If gay marriage is legal so should polygamy be.
If the supreme court legalizes gay marriage this summer there is no doubt a trio will sue for the right to marry each other.
And very likely they will win
So what?
As far as I can tell making plural marriages illegal was more about the better established branches of Christianity taking a swipe at the newer, upstart LDS church than for any real problem with them. After all the Biblical "traditional" marriages were often the plural types, that is until those were made illegal here in America in the mid 1800's.
The only reason for the Government to not recognize, (officially record), a marriage between consenting adults is if that marriage is somehow a detriment to the State.
The only detriment of a marriage between 3 or 30 adults I see would be, How the hell will the Governments untangles the 1,000+ benefits that have built up over time as the Government has sought to encourage family units because families are a proven benefit to this Nation".
When plural marriages are once again legal I see a growth industry for Lawyers working out things like, "Who gets survivor benefits", "Who's entitled to insurance coverage on family plans", "Who makes medical decisions", "Who gets American citizenship benefits", etc.
Personally I believe anyone who claims they're worried about some future time where three or more grown folks might be getting married because 2 folks can do so now are being a bit disingenuous about their true concerns.
My opinion only of course.
h
You are on my ignore list.
Mormon religion started in 1830.
Plural marriage was illegal from the start of the US,
Other than that, good comment.
My opinion is I, don't care who marries who.
I really don't know much about "marriage" so I am unqualified to discuss this subject . All I do know is that it is a legal contract between 2 people . Exactly what the contract terms are I am unsure about . Can anyone address those points ?
Petey Coober
That helped a little :
I'm gonna take a stab & say that historically marriage developed as a way to provide for the progeny that result from sexual activity . Obviously such a requirement does not apply to gay couples since the sex will not result in progeny.
Thoughts ?
I think marriage is more for the benefit of children.
Legal gay marriage is a new concept.
Many states now bar gays from adopting children.
That will likely change if gay marriage is legalized nationwide.
Oh but you do, your whole post is your position. You're naturally entitled to your position/opinion, just don't say you don't have one.
Correction : marriage WAS more for the benefit of children. Now with the advanced birth control technology it is hard to say exactly what marriage is "for" .
I should have been clearer.
I am not for or against gay marriage.
I am not for or against polygamy.
I think each state should set its own marriage rules.
It was and is for the benefit of children but these days it's also for spousal rights and benefits.
This is one institution that should have a national, legal paradigm. Married couples should be free to move from one state to another without having to worry about their legal status.
I'm inclined to agree with that approach but there are already existing conflicts that way . Perhaps there should be "conservative" marriage and "liberal" marriage which would be both legally recognized in all states ?
Married parents have federal tax and other benefits.
Very true.
That is a good point.
I will think about that.
I either don't understand your concept or your concept is simply absurd.
If that was to me Pat , I can honestly say I don't understand it myself . I'm floundering around trying to make some sense of things ...
Thanks Red Shadow.
Since I've only held acasual interest in the subject I was basing most of my comment about the timing ofa National band of Plural marriages on my understanding of the "Morrill Anti-Bigamy act" of 1862;