╌>

When Liars Debate, The Truth Always Loses

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  lets-get-lost  •  11 years ago  •  56 comments

When Liars Debate, The Truth Always Loses

When Liars Debate, The Truth Always Loses

When Liars Debate, The Truth Always Loses

"Watching the second Republican presidential debate on CNN and its aftermath, millions of Americans learned again what we already know about the candidates: These people embellish, prettify, and fabricate their own biographies without hesitation, from Donald Trumps much-parodied boasting about his business acumen to Carly Fiorinas super-selective accounting of her tenure at Hewlett-Packard to Chris Christies highly romanticized account of his appointment and record as U.S. Attorney to Jeb Bushs wildly inflated claims about the Florida economy when he was governor.

But as Christie himself pointed out in a remark targeted at Trump and Fiorina why would anybody even pay attention to the tall tales told by these politicians (or the self-styled political outsiders, who sound exactly like politicians) about themselves? While the bickering is sometimes amusing and mostly annoying, does anyone believe that it matters?

For these characters to prevaricate endlessly about their rsums and achievements is neither surprising nor important. Of much greater consequence are the bat-winged lies they emit about issues that affect all of our lives, as well as the future of the United States and the world.

Evidently all of the Republicans on the stage at the Reagan presidential library wanted us to believe that Planned Parenthood should be shut down everywhere because its clinics sell post-abortion fetal body parts for profit. That is a false and outrageous accusation, disproved in the same videotapes that they cited as proof. Attacking the venerable womens health organization, Fiorina went even further, furiously describing a scene in those videos supposedly showing a fully formed fetus with legs kicking and heart beating while someone prepares to harvest its brain.

Such horrific practices, she declared, erode the character of our nation. What erodes the character of our nation, in fact, is Fiorinas blatant chicanery, repeated by her the next morning on ABC News. The video she claims to have watched does not exist , according to Vox.com reporter Sarah Kliff, who viewed all 12 hours of those videos.

What exist in reality are hundreds of thousands of women who will lose access to health care if fanatics like Fiorina and her fellow Republican candidates ever succeed in wrecking Planned Parenthood. Having harvested tens of millions of dollars from Hewlett-Packard for nearly wrecking the company, however, she doesnt need to worry about medical care for other people.

Nearly every Republican on that stage brayed his or her opposition to the Iran nuclear agreement and every one of them falsely described that deal. Typical was Senator Ted Cruz, who warned, We wont know under this agreementthere are several facilities in Iran they designate as military facilities that are off limits all togetherthe other facilities, we give them 24 days notice before inspecting them.

None of what Cruz said is true or relevant. All of Irans designated nuclear facilities will fall under continuous video and electronic monitoring in addition to physical visitation by inspectors from the International Atomic Energy Agency(IAEA), who will also monitor any movements of nuclear materials or equipment there. Hostile to scientific facts as they are, Cruz and his fellow Republicans are probably unaware of how easily as little as a billionth of a gram of radioactive dust could be detected by IAEA inspectors, as the Center for National Security at Fordham University noted in a factsheet.

These examples represent only a few of literally dozens of mendacious statements about crucial public issues, usually bordering on absurdity, broadcast by CNN with little contradiction onWednesday evening. Senator Marco Rubio insisted that we can do nothing about man-made climate change without destroying the economy, when every reputable study shows that the economy and the world will be destroyed if we do nothing. Christie promised to save Social Security from insolvency by denying payments to wealthy recipients, when that wont significantly improve the systems finances and the crisis he touted is overblown anyway. Trump insisted that life-saving vaccines cause autism, complete with anecdotal proof from an employee whose beautiful baby contracted a fever and then became autistic after being vaccinated.

Not only did Trump concoct that sad story, but there is little doubt that his own children, including little Barron Trump, have received proper vaccinations. (Manhattan private schools dont accept the unvaccinated.) Disgracefully, neither of the two physicians on stage, Rand Paul and Ben Carson, had the guts to forcefully contradict him.

Try as they will to reject Trump, he fits in perfectly among Republicans and not only because he worships money, spews xenophobic nonsense, and encourages callous bigotry. Like them, he relies on fabrications and falsehoods, manipulating the prejudices of ill-informed voters.

The Republican rejection of reality which these candidates will act out in debate after debate for months to come inflicts grave costs on this country every day. It is hard to imagine the damage that will be done if one of these deceivers comes to power."

http://www.nationalmemo.com/when-liars-debate-the-truth-always-loses/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

"Fiorina went even further, furiously describing a scene in those videos supposedly showing a fully formed fetus with legs kicking and heart beating while someone prepares to harvest its brain.

Such horrific practices, she declared, erode the character of our nation. What erodes the character of our nation, in fact, is Fiorinas blatant chicanery, repeated by her the next morning on ABC News. The video she claims to have watched does not exist, according to Vox.com reporter Sarah Kliff, who viewed all 12 hours of those videos.

What exist in reality are hundreds of thousands of women who will lose access to health care if fanatics like Fiorina and her fellow Republican candidates ever succeed in wrecking Planned Parenthood. Having harvested tens of millions of dollars from Hewlett-Packard for nearly wrecking the company, however, she doesnt need to worry about medical care for other people."

from the article

___________________________________________________________________________________________

According to a Vox reporter, the video scene of a fully formed fetus with legs kicking as Planned Parenthood doctors prepare to harvest it's brain DOES NOT EXIST. So Carly Fiorina was LYING about seeing such a video.

"Back in the day" a candidate lying about something this important to their message would most likely be forced out of the race by overwhelming backlash public opinion. Today it is par for the course.

Why isn't all the media calling Fiorina a liar today?

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

Everyone can get healthcare now that we have this horrible Obamacare disaster. This fear mongering that if planned parenthood is defunded hundreds of thousands of women will lose access to health care is a total BS.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

everything she described is in the videos. The worst thing she can be accused of is condensing two different scenes into one.

What exist in reality are hundreds of thousands of women who will lose access to health care if fanatics like Fiorina and her fellow Republican candidates ever succeed in wrecking Planned Parenthood.

Now that is ablatantlie!. Kudos on demonstrating how it is done.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Let Carly Fiorina produce the video that she says Obama and Clinton need to watch. When she does that, I will look at it and see if what she says is in it is in it.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Here are two articles Sean that directly address what is on the videos.

Now tell us where is the one that Carly Fiorina was referring to ?

Carly Fiorina keeps getting a giant pass from the media on her debate lies. She was immediately and widely crowned the winner of the debate without reference to those lies, and now that fact-checks have started appearing, they're still going easy on her. Fiorina vividly described scenes from an anti-Planned Parenthood video, only the scenes she described don't actually exist , as far as anyone can tell.

According to CNN, this fabrication was "true but misleading." Except for the part where it was false. The New York Times has a special take on it as well, headlined Carly Fiorina Said to Exaggerate Content of Planned Parenthood Video . Said to? And check out how the article kicks off:

Carly Fiorina set off some fact-check alarm bells on Wednesday when she dared Hillary Rodham Clinton and President Obama to watch undercover Planned Parenthood videos that show dead fetuses. While the authenticity of the videos remains a subject of debate, Mrs. Fiorina appears to have exaggerated their contents.

That second sentence is a masterpiece of slippery reporter-speak. "While the authenticity of the videos remains a subject of debate" is a really indirect translation to "the videos are at a minimum secretly filmed and deceptively edited, possibly worse." "Mrs. Fiorina appears to have exaggerated their claims" is a serious understatement at best.

Either Fiorina saw a completely different video than anyone else saw and she hasn't produced it for the world to seea move that would not only let us evaluate the truth of her description but would match her stated desire to have everyone see how awful Planned Parenthood supposedly isor she went well beyond the bounds of what's generally considered to be mere exaggeration. And don't forget that her "exaggeration" was about videos the authenticity of which the Times acknowledges is "a subject of debate." So Fiorina took a seriously questionable source, went way beyond what even it purported to show, and the Newspaper of Record rewards her with a "said to exaggerate" and "appears to have exaggerated."

Lying pays, if you're a Republican. If you're a Democrat, the Times will rush to regurgitate Republican lies about you.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

IMHO, the GOP base doesn't mind being lied to. They want to hear theirtruth, whether it bears any relationship with reality or not.

Birtherism... Benghazi... or Planned Parenthood as Satan... One can only believe these things by stuffing one's ears and wearing a blindfold. But the GOP base believes!

The candidates are lying? No problem! They are telling their faithful what they want to hear.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Ummm... For the anti-PP people, "women's health care wouldn't be affordable" is the objective being sought.

If women can't afford contraception or abortion, they'll have more kids. That's what women are for, no???

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Let Carly Fiorina produce the video that she says Obama and Clinton need to watch. When she does that, I will look at it and see if what she says is in it is in it.

She'd have to find a way to make one, since one does not exist. Of course it was two lies in one, the second one being when she said she'd actually seen the scene in a video, when neither exists.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    11 years ago
Kind of funny coming from the party whose frontrunner is described as a liar.
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

She was asked about it again and still says she saw a video that showed that. The plan for her to try to get out of this is, you lie once and get caught, then insist the first lie was true, even when it's proven that it was a lie. Just keep lying the same lie over and over and over again. Hell in her fevered little mind she may have already convinced herself that there is a video that shows that, but there is not.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

The topic here is the GOP candidates' debate. When the Dems have their turn, we'll see how it goes.

We're not "describing" the Republican candidates as liars. We are underscoring actual lies. We're not expressing an opinion. We are pointing out facts.

(I realize that "reality" and "fact" are notions that rarely interest the GOP base...)

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Look at the seventh video 5:57 in to a post abortion baby lying in a dish with it's legs kicking.

Yeah America!

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Zombie ideas. You can disprove them again and again... and they just keep shufflin' on...

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Please. The videos contain exactly what she described. Go ahead and watch the seventh video, and be proud of what your tax dollars support.

It is amusing watching liberals mindlessly parrot their propaganda points without knowing what they are talking about though. Keep it up and don't bother your little head with the realities of how babies with beating hurts are killed.

It's amusing how so many of the most fanatical abortion defenders refuse to deal with the actual reality of what happens during in abortion. They just want to talk in pretty euphemisms like women's health and privacy etc etc.

Sticking scissors into humans with a beating heart is just too messy to talk about.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

And I'm calling Bullshit on this. Prove it! Post the video or segment! Her campaign people can't and neither can you!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Do you not understand the google?

Here's the seventh video.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I watched the video and it appears to be exactly as Factchecker.org and Vox says it is. You may not like that abortion is legal or that aborted fetal tissue is collected for vital medical research, that's a reasonable subject to debate, but the video you posted does not show what Carly says it does. It just does not. The truth is that Carly lied.

Fiorinaon Planned Parenthood

Carly Fiorina spoke out against Planned Parenthood regarding the controversial videos released over the last few months. The scene she described, though, does not exist in any of the videos.

Fiorina: I dare Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama to watch these tapes. Watch a fully formed fetus on the table, its heart beating, its legs kicking while someone says we have to keep it alive to harvest its brain.

We are aware of no video showing such a scene. The videos, released by the Center for Medical Progress beginning on July 14 , have focused on fetal tissue being collected for research and have shown some aborted fetal tissue. As we wrote before, the use of donated fetal tissue has been important in several areas of scientific research .

Fiorinas descriptionmatches up with one of the videos in a series the Center for Medical Progress has called Human Capital but only with regard to how an interviewee describes her experience. Holly ODonnell, an ex-procurement technician for StemExpress, a company that procures fetal tissue from Planned Parenthood clinics, relates a story of an intact fetus. She says that a Planned Parenthood doctor taps the heart and it starts beating, and then instructs her to remove its brain for collection.

The video does contain images of what appear to be intact fetuses, but they dont fitFiorinas description. In one, where a fetus does appear to move, there is a caption saying that the footage is from the pro-life Grantham Collection and Center for Bio-Ethical Reform ; there is no indication as to where the footage was shot.In the other, it was revealed after the videos release that the image was of a stillborn baby , rather than an aborted fetus.

Though we cannot verify if partor all of ODonnells story is true, thescene Fiorina dares others to watch is not present in any of the Planned Parenthood videos.

...

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago

If what Fiorina says she saw isn't there, then she's either lying or delusional. Worse, she immediately doubled down on the statement the next day and said rest assured she saw what she said she saw. That's alarming. With regard to her history at Hewlett Packard (HP), she is regarded by some as one of the worst CEO's in history. On her watch, HP's stock prices tumbled more than 50% but she blamed it on the tech bubble not her ill-advised purchase of Compaq. She apparently spent company money lavishly on herself while firing 30,000 employees as the company tanked. The HP board wanted to get rid of her so badly that it gave her a severance package so large ($20-40 million) that it triggered a lawsuit by shareholders. Just the news that she was leaving caused stocks to rise 10%. Damn! Yet she's proud of her record and blames all the problems on something other than her poor decisions. That's not even including the damage she did to Lucent, her previous employer. Nobody has hired her since so she ran for the Senate in California. After losing in a landslide, she skipped leaving $500,000 in unpaid bills, mostly to her campaign staff, and only agreed to pay them 4 years later when she decided to run for president.

She may be just a tad beyond a liar.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

The really sad thing is that she's no worse than the others. Lying is not a problem for a Republican Presidential candidate.

Isn't that an incredible fact?

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    11 years ago

Truth, such a pesky little word!

The truth in this video is the fetus is a 19 week stillborn that had NOTHING, absolutely nothing to do with Planned Parenthood.

The truth is Carly Fiorina is a liar in regard to what she saw, unless of course she is privy to some secret footage the rest of the world hasn't seen.

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    11 years ago

Bob I will agree, lying is seemingly not a problem for any candidate...past or present.

I'm just really disappointed, no I'm freaking pissed, a conservative woman would blatantly lie over a woman's issue and then double down on the lie.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Professor Sonnenfeld (whose name came up in an argument between Trump and Fiorina at the debte about her time at HP) was on The Last Word with Lawrence O'Donnell last night and said that nearly all of her claims at the debate were simply not true or stretched the truth. He said she was a terrible CEO and one of the worst things ever to happen to any HP stockholder. He said that she, basically took their stock money and made it worth less then half of what is was when she started there. He said she fired whole groups of executives if any of them so much as questioned any of her decisions. As for her saying he was a Clinton lackey, he said he has never met Bill or Hilliary in person and has never come close to working for either of them. He did say he has advised some GOP candidates in this election on financial policy. He wouldn't say who, but it does leave one to wonder if Trump was one of them.

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    11 years ago

Maybe Fox News will have Professor Sonnenfeld set the record straight for their conservative listeners....NOT :)

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Fiorinas descriptionmatches up with one of the videos in a series the Center for Medical Progress has called Human Capital


Game, set, match.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

iorinas descriptionmatches up with one of the videos in a series the Center for Medical Progress has called Human Capital


You are arguing that the video is misleading. Fiorna's description of the video is accurate, as even factcheckers attest.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Maybe the very phony "Center for Medical Progress" put together an animated film just for her? She lied and then lied about it being a lie.

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    11 years ago

I'm arguing SHE didn't see what she claims she saw.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Even The fact checker cited by Randy said her description matches up with the video. so unless fact checkers on liberal sites are now part of the vast right wing conspiracy....

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Even The fact checker cited by Randy said her description matches up with the video.

No. No it does not! Where does it say that?

Fiorinaon Planned Parenthood

Carly Fiorina spoke out against Planned Parenthood regarding the controversial videos released over the last few months. The scene she described, though, does not exist in any of the videos.

Fiorina: I dare Hillary Clinton, Barack Obama to watch these tapes. Watch a fully formed fetus on the table, its heart beating, its legs kicking while someone says we have to keep it alive to harvest its brain.

We are aware of no video showing such a scene. The videos, released by the Center for Medical Progress beginning on July 14 , have focused on fetal tissue being collected for research and have shown some aborted fetal tissue. As we wrote before, the use of donated fetal tissue has been important in several areas of scientific research .

Fiorinas descriptionmatches up with one of the videos in a series the Center for Medical Progress has called Human Capital but only with regard to how an interviewee describes her experience. Holly ODonnell, an ex-procurement technician for StemExpress, a company that procures fetal tissue from Planned Parenthood clinics, relates a story of an intact fetus. She says that a Planned Parenthood doctor taps the heart and it starts beating, and then instructs her to remove its brain for collection.

The video does contain images of what appear to be intact fetuses, but they dont fitFiorinas description. In one, where a fetus does appear to move, there is a caption saying that the footage is from the pro-life Grantham Collection and Center for Bio-Ethical Reform ; there is no indication as to where the footage was shot.In the other, it was revealed after the videos release that the image was of a stillborn baby , rather than an aborted fetus.

Though we cannot verify if partor all of ODonnells story is true, thescene Fiorina dares others to watch is not present in any of the Planned Parenthood videos.

Where does it say that? In fact it specifically says that what she described in the video did not match up with the video. They (Factchecker) says:

The video does contain images of what appear to be intact fetuses, but they dont fitFiorinas description.

Did you bother to read what they said?

Fiorinas descriptionmatches up with one of the videos in a series the Center for Medical Progress has called Human Capital but only with regard to how an interviewee describes her experience.

That is not saying that they said anything other then " We are aware of no video showing such a scene." which means she lied.

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    11 years ago

This is what SHE SAID...is it true?

"Watch a fully formed fetus on the table, its heart beating, its legs kicking, while someone says, 'We have to keep it alive to harvest its brain.' "

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

I watched the entire video that you posted, Sean and what Carly said she saw is not on it. No where. And Factchecker says it's not, not that it is. If you are trying to say that Factchecker agrees with you and/or Carly, that statement is also a lie.

Do you have reading comprehension problems Sean? Can you actually read on an adult level? There are schools you could go to that could help you acquire these skills that you seem to be missing. There are far too many Americans who are functionally illiterate, so if you are it's something that you shouldn't be ashamed of, unless you do not seek help for it.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

"thescene Fiorina dares others to watch is not present in any of the Planned Parenthood videos."

THAT is "game set match" Sean.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

but only with regard to how an interviewee describes her experience.

That's also game, set, match Sean. Factcheckers says you are wrong and if you say it says that what Carly said was true, was true, then you are telling a lie.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Sean is trying to spin a hopeless situation the best he can. Doesn't work.

The absolute kindest thing you can say about Fiorina is that she carelessly repeated what she heard someone else say about the videos without checking it out for herself. Now she is caught telling falsehoods.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Sean is trying to spin a hopeless situation the best he can. Doesn't work.

Spin is all he has. Then again, spin hell, many of his statements in this thread are out and out lies.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Lol. The leftist candidates don't lie? Clinton is one endless lie...
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

So, because you think Hillary is a liar, then that means Carly wasn't? Or that it's OK for her too? I don't think Hillary lies, at least not any more then the average human being does, yet here we have complete and undeniable proof that Carly told a lie and then lied about it again. So because you don't like Hilliary, you're going to give Carly a pass?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

The leftist candidates don't lie? Clinton is one endless lie..

Not during the Republican candidates' debate. That's the topic here.

If you want a different topic, you could seed it.

Oh wait! You never seed anything. ... Why is that, C? Do you read nothing but NT?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Hope springs eternal!Smile.gif

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago
If Fox is "fair and balanced", then they should put Sonnenfeld on. Alternatively, Trump could just read quotes from Sonnenfeld at his rallies and in Fox interviews until Fox interviews Sonnenfeld.
 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

The truth in this video is the fetus is a 19 week stillborn that had NOTHING


Now you are lying. The fetus in the video at the part referenced by Fiorna was a baby who survived an abortion and left in a metal bowl to die.

The "stillborn" baby (who was actually born prematurely and died in his parents' arms) is pictured 3 full minutes later in the video.

By your own standards, you are lying. Maybe climb down off your pedestal before you start calling others liars next time.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

In the video in question, a technician is talking about harvesting the brain of an alive, fully formed fetus. While she tells her story, there is footage of another baby of roughly the same gestational age as the one whose brain she harvested. This baby is seen still kicking and its heart still beating.

While it is obviously not the same baby as the one she harvested the brain of, the footage helps viewers to understand what a 19-week old baby looks like when hearing the testimony of an ex-employee who harvested brains from babies of the same age. Illustrating stories with appropriate images is a common journalistic technique, one used by all media outlets.

Others assertthat the baby was stillborn, a falsehood that goes back to The Hill, which made this claim in a story in August :

The anti-abortion-rights group targeting Planned Parenthood is acknowledging that its most recent video used an image of a stillborn baby that was made to look like an aborted fetus. The Center for Medical Progress posted a new link on its video late Thursday, adding that one of the images was actually a baby named Walter Fretz, born prematurely at 19 weeks.

This is inaccurate on multiple counts. The video shows two different babies, neither of whom are stillborn. One was animage of Fretz, who was not a stillborn baby, but was born born prematurely at 19 weeks and died in his parents a... This image of Fretz appeared during the 8:59 minute mark of the video, where he appears to be wrapped in a blanket and have a clip on his umbilical chord to keep it from getting infected.

Earlier in the video, around the 5:56 mark, there is footage of another baby boy around the same gestational age as Fretz who is not stillborn either, but a baby who survived an abortion and was left in a metal bowl to die. In the footage, he kicks his legs and twitches his arms during the final moments of his life, and a pair of forceps lays beside him.The footage was provided by The Center for Bio-Ethical Reform , a pro-life organizationheadquartered in Lake Forrest, California.

...

Keep spinning propaganda bought and paid for by Planned Parenthood though.

Fiorna's "lie" consists of saying "it" instead of "a baby" during a live, extemporaneous speeech. That's it.
 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    11 years ago

Keep spinning propaganda bought and paid for by Planned Parenthood though.

Back at ya Sean, back at ya.

What your own site is telling you is that the images, (spliced in for propaganda purposes only), have so far not been attributed to PP and that Fiorina was lying about what she saw in the taps.

From your link:

One was an image of Fretz, who was not a stillborn baby, but was born born prematurely at 19 weeks and died in his parents arms. This image of Fretz appeared during the 8:59 minute mark of the video, where he appears to be wrapped in a blanket and have a clip on his umbilical chord to keep it from getting infected.

Earlier in the video, around the 5:56 mark, there is footage of another baby boy around the same gestational age as Fretz who is not stillborn either, but a baby who survived an abortion and was left in a metal bowl to die. In the footage, he kicks his legs and twitches his arms during the final moments of his life, and a pair of forceps lays beside him. The footage was provided by The Center for Bio-Ethical Reform, a pro-life organization headquartered in Lake Forrest, California.

As regards the organizational affiliation of the abortion facility in which this termination was performed, our access agreements forbid the disclosure of any information which might tend to identify the relevant clinics or personnel with whom we work.

About as accurate as a hit piece going something like;

Anti-Choice father convenience his daughter that abstinence only is the only thing she needs to know about the birds and the bees.

279_discussions.jpg?width=422

Picture comes out of nowhere & has no context, situation & dialog are fictitious. The whole meme is meant only to generate hate, just like the videos that started off as lies and then have folk lying about the lies.

Sheesh, the world we live these days.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

(spliced in for propaganda purposes only)


Like documentaries of the holocaust often use stock footage of concentration camps to illustrate a survivor's testimony.

Glad to see you busted out the Holocaust Denier tool kit to convict someone of lying. As you well know, pictures are almost always used to illustrate a speaker's verbal story in documentaries. It goes with the territory of video being a visual medium. It takes a special kind of dishonesty, like that of a Holocaust denier, to claim that stock illustrative footage somehow constitutes a "lie".

Does PP perform abortions on second trimester fetuses? Then this happens. Funny how scared defenders of abortion are to deal with the actual reality of what abortion entails. Own the barbarism as acceptable to you, but don't pretend it doesn't happen.

Fiorina was lying about what she saw in the taps.

Except she wasn't. All she needed to do was substitute "a baby" for "it" while speaking off the cuff. That's some "lie" and I know you and the other people making that accusation don't hold democrats to anywhere near that standard.

The hypocrisy of people calling that a lie is astounding, considering how often their own posts are riddled with those sort of mistakes. Any mistaken preposition, object or tense is enough to label one a monstrous liar, apparently. Except the people so happy to judge Fiorna would never hold themselves to that standard.

Let alone a fact like calling an aborted baby a stillborn baby which some people and "factcheckers" did to try and discredit Fiorna. Now that everyone knows that is a lie, where's all the vitriol directed at the people who spread it? I guess that lies sit nicely with them.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Being pro-choice is, because it's their body, not yours or mine. I have never personally met anyone who is pro-choice that is pro-abortion. I am pro-choice, but I certainly hate abortions. The thing is that I can't get pregnant so I will never have to face that choice, but women should and must have a right to make that decision. To be able to make that choice.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Except she wasn't.

Except she was. She said she saw a video of something that did not happen. There was no fetus kicking while someone said we have to keep it alive until we can harvest it's brain. That never happened. That is what she said she saw, but there is no video showing that in any manner, so she is lying. It does not appear on any of the tapes, even the ones you've provided. The person telling the story doesn't even say that happened. If someone says they saw something, but they really didn't see it, then it is a lie. The tape she described does not exist.

I asked you to post proof and the video you posted as proof only proves that what she said she saw isn't on the tape you posted as proof. By you're own posting you have proven that she was lying. What she says she saw does not exist. What you posted does not show what she says she saw. That makes her a liar.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Fiorna's "lie" consists of saying "it" instead of "a baby" during a live, extemporaneous speeech. That's it.

That statement is 100% a lie. The tape she says she saw does not exist.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Let alone a fact like calling an aborted baby a stillborn baby which some people and "factcheckers" did to try and discredit Fiorna

But you said that Factcheckers proved that what she says she saw happened. Now you change and say it didn't. So tell me, were you lying then or are you lying now?

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    11 years ago

Last I knew only woman can conceive therefore making any issue regarding her bodya womanissue. Jeez!

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    11 years ago

The truth in this video is the fetus is a 19 week stillborn premie that had NOTHING

There Sean, I've corrected my statement. Evidently my bad having read the information without realizing it was a lie, but I guess that still makes me a liar (by my own standards &on the pedestal I'm standing). Ok, I can own that.

Doesn't change the fact Fiorina lied, she did not see what she said she saw. She didn't say she read about it or was told about it...said she saw it. So again, unless she has a secret video recording the rest of us haven't seen she lied.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Now you are lying. The fetus in the video at the part referenced by Fiorna was a baby who survived an abortion and left in a metal bowl to die.

And you know this, how? Because an anti-choice website said so? Did you see it die? Did the video show it dying? I didn't see that happen. Neither did you or Carley. So how do you know it's not alive and well?

Did anyone say the words that it needed to be kept alive so they could harvest the brain? That's what Carly says it shows and says. Where does it it show and say that happening? Are you the only one hearing voices in your head (other then Carley) that are telling you "someone" said it needs to be kept alive because we need to harvest it's brain? I sure didn't hear it, but you say Carley was not lying when she said she heard those words.

Is she the only one hearing voices that are not there or are both of you? Is she just hearing voices and you just want to believe her so much that you think it says that, even though it clearly does not? What else are these "voices" telling you? Are they speaking to you only in your head or do you think you audibly hear them (it makes a difference in your diagnosis). Are they telling you to do bad things? Are these voices telling you to harm yourself or others? Do your lips move when repeating these voices to yourself? Again it matters for your diagnosis and what medications you should be trying in order to make the voices stop. I personally have never heard voices, but I imagine it must be very frightening. There is help for it if you seek it out.

Where did the video of the fetus come from? Was it in a Planned Parenthood clinic? Is it even claimed that it was, because I sure didn't hear that either? Did you hear them say it was in a Planned Parenthood clinic? The captioning on it says it came from stock footage from the Grantham Collection and Center for Bio-Ethical Reform .

Do they claim the fetus that was moving died? Do they claim it was from a Planned Parenthood clinic or even an abortion provider in America or somewhere else in the world? They made no such claim as to where it comes from and (considering the fact that they are refusing to say where it came from) it certainly casts a lot of suspicion as to it's actual origins. Can you yourself show any evidence that it was even from a PP clinic? If so, please do.

Be specific and thank you.

 
 

Who is online







102 visitors