Conservative Policies
Thank you, Senator Rubio!
What should those policies be? Let's hear from our NT conservatives.
------------------------------------
The topic here is conservative policy .
Please stay strictly on topic.
I understand that having been out of power for eight years, conservatives may have lost the habit of presenting policy, and may be leery of getting bushwacked. So... Red Rule: be polite -- constructive criticism only.
Tags
Who is online
108 visitors

Second attempt.
Please stay strictly on topic. Thank you.
Political people are starting to talk about tax reform more . [Want a link ?] Even if that did not fully "restore the American dream" it might at least improve the jobs picture .
The topic is policy. Please stay on topic.
OK. What taxes, reformed in what manner?
What happened to the first attempt? Commented last night, then poof!
Repeal the Patriot act.
Get rid of the Federal Reserve, Department of the Education, the Department of Homeland Security and the TSA.
End social security and return the money stolen from those forced to contribute against their will with interest.
Repeal Obamacare and get government out of our healthcare.
Close the majority of military bases around the world.
Cut government spending and balance the budget and eliminate the national debt through spending cuts.
Eliminate foreign aid.
Eliminate capital gains and death taxes.
Reform income tax with a flat rate of no more than ten percent.
Really end the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and really bring the troops home.
Eliminate all government subsidies for both corporations and individuals.
End the war on drugs.
End domestic spying.
Demilitarize our police forces.
Many of the US bases around the world are remnants from WWII and the Cold War. We could do without most of them.
The Saudi's bitch about our bases there, but they would scream their livers out if we ever even thought about leaving. They like having us there as scapegoats and to divert attention away from real domestic problems.
How about Dean's other idea...
Are you good with that one?
Excellent list, Dean. Thank you for breaking the ice. You have given us the headlines. Could we dig a little deeper? As everyone knows, the devil is in the details...
Repeal the Patriot act:Straightforward repeal? Nothing in it's place? I am not an expert on the Patriot Act, so I don't know the consequences of repeal.
Get rid of the Federal Reserve:Who would manage monetary policy? This is a case where simple repeal is not possible. There has to be a replacement. There is no country in the world that does not have a central bank.
Get rid of the Department of the Education: Does this mean "get the Federal government out of education"? Leave it entirely to the states?
Get rid of the Department of Homeland Security: Just the umbrella department, or also all the component parts?
Get rid of the TSA: How should airport security be managed? (I hate the TSA, too, as does everyone who flies... but I kinda don't want "nothing"!)
End social security and return the money stolen from those forced to contribute against their will with interest: Straight up repeal -- henceforth no national retirement system at all?
Repeal Obamacare and get government out of our healthcare: No replacement? Simply return to the situation before Obamacare?
Close the majority of military bases around the world: (I actually know a little about this, so I have more questions...) Where would you put the troops?Howwould you make up for the loss ofGermany's monetary contribution? Which bases would you leave open, or what process would you set up to make that decision?
Cut government spending: Which posts?
balance the budget: Why? (This is not a trick question. No family follows this rule, no company follows it, and certainly no country in the world follows it. Some years have deficits and some have surpluses. None are "balanced".) By what deadline should we balance the budget -- next year, in five years, ... ?
eliminate the national debt through spending cuts: Once again, "why"? (What is the economic -- as opposed to dogmatic -- imperative here? A family is considered to be in good financial shape if major loan payments (house and car, basically) are no more than 25% of the budget. Interest paid on the national debt is around six percent of budget.)
The national debt is about three time the federal budget. In other words, if the government were to continue collecting revenue at today's rate, while ceasing all payments... it would take three years to "eliminate the debt". What rate of resorption to you suggest?
Eliminate foreign aid: Foreign aid is about 1% of the Federal budget. So eliminating it is not a decision driven by economic considerations. It is a political choice. What is the reasoning, what are the intended consequences, what are the risks?
Many Americans think foreign aid is a significant portion of the Federal budget -- 25 or 40 percent... It is not. So this is a political choice, and should be justified on that basis.
Eliminate capital gains and death taxes: Capital gains taxes represent around $40 billion. Estate taxes about half that. Would you replace those revenues somehow, or would you increase the Federal deficit?
Reform income tax with a flat rate of no more than ten percent: I don't know the revenue consequences of this, but surely a very very big drop. Would you compensate somehow, or would you add to the Federal deficit?
Would you do anything with the Payroll Tax, which is three-quarters of Income Tax, but gets much less publicity, since the rich do not pay it?
Really end the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and really bring the troops home: Agreed!! No questions needed. I can see no negative consequences that we aren't going to get even if we leave troops there for another ten years...
Eliminate all government subsidies for both corporations and individuals: "All"?? Veteran's disability? Food stamps?
End the war on drugs: Agreed. Much like ending the Afghan and Iraq wars. There will be negative consequences... but less than if we persist.
End domestic spying: Including on terrorists? That isn't a trick question. It's not an easy call.
Demilitarize our police forces: I agree with the idea. How do we go about accomplishing it?
Once again... Thank you, Dean, for breaking the ice...
A couple of disruptive pictures were posted. It was easier just to start over, with more insistance on "On-topic".
Alternatively... all of it is possible... I don't think we can draw any conclusions at all. Dean has given us an excellent list of policy ideas. They deserve thought. Each one has a cost and each has consequences, intended and collateral. It is only by examining them in more detail that they can be evaluated.
Yes, I am aware of the rights-infringement aspects. I think we would all be happy to see them go. (Well... maybe not some guys in dark suits, driving black Suburbans...)
I wonder if there are bits that should be kept, though. Or perhaps scrap everything, and then pass the bits we want piecemeal?
Could you please provide me with charts showing this? I didn't realize that when we send aid to earthquake victims, or tsunami victims, or food to those fleeing Syria, we were invading. And if you have such contempt for us, why do you live here?
Red Rule: be polite -- constructive criticism only.
Please... both of you.
Thank you.
Rephrase:
Could you please provide me with charts showing this? I didn't realize that when we send aid to earthquake victims, or tsunami victims, or food to those fleeing Syria, we were invading.
Bob,
In the future, you can just get me and I will remove them for you.
OK maybe the Department of Ed, since each state could do that for themselves, but Homeland security? You must be feeling very safe. The TSA needs an overhaul but is also necessary. You need theFederal Reserve.
Spot on Fly!
To actually answer Perrie's question:
... from Wikipedia .
Yes, but...
In some countries, US aid is a significant part of preventing starvation.
Aid is aid. No one is taking any phone calls in the camps full of Syrian refugees.
So while the rest of the world is giving aid, is only American aid tainted? If one of the world's richest countries isn't giving aid, then cries would be that we didn't care. So it's a kind of a damned if you do/ damned if you don't scenario.
Personally, I don't see any "damned if you do" side at all. I cannot think of anyone, anywhere in the world, who is protesting (non-military) American aid.
Well, yes... some Americans protest it.
That's kinda vague. Do you have any numbers, links, ... ?
We did fine without a Federal Reserve for 137 years. We survived without the homeland security and TSA for 225 years. I think the Department of Education has done more damage than good.
In fact, Dean, America had a central bank before it had a constitution . The "Bank of North America" was created in 1781.
Don't misunderstand. I am not defending "everything about" the Fed. There are lots of things about it that are not optimal. But you cannot simply say "get rid of it". There must be a central bank.
So the questions become, "How to you structure your central bank, and what missions do you confide to it? How much independence should it have, and how do you ensure that independence?"
If we eliminate TSA, what becomes of airport security? I remember a time when there was, basically, nothing. I also remember a time when a plane exploded every other week. What do you recommend?
I can easily imagine the elimination of the Department of Education, and its devolution to the states. I just wanted to be sure that that is your idea: the Federal government get out entirely.
(Once again, none of these questions is a gotcha. I appreciate your coming forward to engage a conversation.)
Nonya,
As an example, I suggest that you google "US aid to Jordan".
The Dept of Ed has two purposes. One is to give money to the states for ed and the other is curriculum and evaluation. Handing money out to the states doesn't require a social office. Curriculum and evaluation might be needed, but often falls into the wrong hands, "Common Core" being proof of that. If just left to the states, some would do away with evolution, etc. On the other hand, each state understands it's own needs... so maybe the Dept of Ed should just set requirements for the states... and enforcement, which wouldn't need a big staff. Say a staff of 10 for requirements and 2 for each state for enforcement. In 2007 they had a staff of over 5,000 and an annual budget of $32 billion. Kind of over kill?
Dean,
All great ideas, unfortunately, the last guy that tried to push them was labeled a crackpot by the R&D's and MSM. (the establishment hates these ideas)
Interesting. I have rarely seen any objectively credible critiques of non-military aid. Nothing is perfect, but...
Interesting subject... but not the subject of this conversation.
Yea right, none is siphoned off due to corruption. And Pakistan is using our aid to jointly produce and buy fighter jets from the Chinese. Saudis are getting ready to doing the same along with Burma. Your statement is WAAAAAAY off the mark. Not even close.
...
...
...
...
...
I did not say that I thought it a good idea. I said I can imagine the application of this policy.
It might be useful to try this policy. Either it works or it doesn't, but we would have an end to idle speculation.
I hope we can discuss them calmly here.
Red Rule, John. Constructive criticism, only.
Thank you.
5 pages of discussion going on... no one is walking by, just picking on an item.
So yours is SS so:
The Urban Institute, a non-partisan research institute in Washington, produces statistics on this topic annually. Institute researchers figured out what people turning 65 in various years have already "paid in" to the system and what can expect to "take out" after they reach age 65. (See our charts below)
Because marital status and family income can significantly affect both the amount paid in and the amount paid out, the institute offers its calculation for various types of family units. To make the final amounts comparable to what might have been done with the tax money had it been invested privately, the institute adjusted all dollar figures at 2 percentage points above the rate of inflation. (The authors note that different assumptions for long-term returns on investment would change the results.)
According to the institutes data, a two-earner couple receiving an average wage $44,600 per spouse in 2012 dollars and turning 65 in 2010 would have paid $722,000 into Social Security and Medicare and can be expected to take out $966,000 in benefits. So, this couple will be paid about one-third more in benefits than they paid in taxes.
Write an article. Start a conversation. I will participate.
Social security is a failed program that discourages people from saving for their retirement because government is taking their earnings. The long term projections for social security show it on an unsustainable path. Your solution is to raise taxes even more and steal from one to give to another. It is a burden on employers and is part of the reason we are not competitive in a global economy and very little is produced in the USA any longer. You believe those that do well and are successful should be stuck carrying the weight of fools, I don't.
I don't feel that way. A progressive tax puts a burden on those that do well. With a flat tax rate the burden is shared equally. Equality is what we are striving for. There is no reason a successful man should be stuck carrying the weight of a fool in a free country.
Whipping is off-topic.
C'mon, people! Let's focus on the topic.
Dean suggested "eliminate SS". That is a policy. We have often heard Dean's reasons... but those are NOT policy.
"Do you have an alternative, or do you want no national retirement system at all?" is a policy question.
Please... Let's try to get a clear platform, rather than repeat debates we have heard a hundred times.
Yes, none of us get out of this alive. I'd rather die a few years sooner than stick another with carrying my dead weight. Often doctors prolong life well after there is any quality of life left. They do it for financial gain rather than the good of the patient.
John,
Red Rule:be polite -- constructive criticism only.
The wisdom of policy is not the topic here, only its applicability and consequences.
Thank you.
Aid is always INTENDED to be good and to help. Unfortunately, in many instances, this is not the case.
Unwittingly, our outpouring of clothing and shoes (among other things) to Africa put the people who normally make and sell these things out of a job. This is why poverty rose so drastically from our efforts to help.
This is just one of many examples. So yes some Americans protest it, but many do this because they understand the negative impact of aid. They understand that handing our aid willy-nilly usually hurts more than it helps. Sadly, most people do not have any idea of the negative aspects of aid.
It is important aid is given in a responsible, informed, and intelligent manner, and that is not happening in most cases.
John and Dean,
Please, let's not get bogged down with the same old same old. We have heard these arguments, from both sides.
Let's move on a step: conservatives control Congress and may soon control everything. Let's look at what they may decide, and what the consequences would be.
Thanks.
I am not my brothers keeper. Government steals our earnings and gives them to others. I oppose that. I have no problem with voluntary charity. What government is doing is creating a society of vegetables living off the backs of others.
Spot on. Seen it happen hundreds of times.
John,
Be polite. Don't force deletions.
Thanks.
I'm game. I am sure I can dig up 100 more on why Liberalism sucks just as easily.
John, please STOP!
Eliminating subsidies may or may not be a good idea, but it is certainly a plausible policy.
Please stop the insults, and let's look at the application and consequences.
Thank you.
Subsidies for corporations is what is ridiculous. Some of the ones for individuals are as well.
Dean,
Flat tax on the surface seems far, but in practice it isn't.
I will give you an example. Let's set the flat tax at 10%
Guying making $25,000 a year would pay $2,500 bring his income down to $22,500 or $1875/mo. or $468/weekly. That is making more than $10 min wage. That $2,500 represents an additional $208 a month or $52 a week which makes the weekly take home $520, which makes a big difference for a family of 4.
Now lets take a guy making $100,000. 10% will net them $90,000 a year or $7,500 a month. The $10,000 paid in taxes represents only $833 a month.
There is a huge difference in living on $676 a month and $7,500 month. So that 10% can be very life threatening for many.
Dean, I respectfully disagree social security discourages people from saving without statistical data to support the claim. Many of our senior friends have "saved" for retirement only to watch their individual accounts become decimated during the last recession.The financial products available are no guarantee of any income, it's a crap shoot at best. People are screwed over left and right by those who are selling the products claiming to guarantee yourretirement dreams!
Personally, I'd like to see the social security program revamped/restructured with enough staff in place to properly oversee ALL programs. Many of our well intended safety nets are fraught with fraud, time to get tough and ferret it out! Billions are wasted every year in Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, Aid to Dependent Children, Disability, Veteran's Administration, etc.
BF
Everyone circumstances are not the same. Yeah, if you have no kids those are things you can do provided that you go to a community college, which if you take away their funding would go away... and then you couldn't afford college, right? You see, the issue is what we value. Defund everything and we end up with a stupid needy populus. We may as well be Bangladesh. If you did it, like I did it, we did it when we were young, without kids, and going to a state school.
On the other hand, I have been on the flip side of that equation, with 2 kids and an unemployed husband, who tried working a shit job and going to night school. Guess what, it didn't work. He was just damn lucky to find another job that didn't pay nearly what he made in the music business. That is what happens to the lucky ones. Oh and BTW, I went back to work during that time, but if it wasn't for the grandparents, it wouldn't have paid, since child care is so expensive. So single parents are totally screwed.
The flat tax is not fair. I used to think that it was until I had to work with incremental income. Walk a mile in those shoes and you might think differently.