President Obama Cherry-Picks Data and Exaggerates To Put Best Spin on Accomplishments
President Obama largely stuck to the facts in his State of the Union address, although he did cherry-pick data and exaggerate at times to put the best spin on his accomplishments.
Some highlights:
Obama made the inflated claim that "more than half of manufacturing executives have said they're actively looking to bring jobs back from China." A survey showed most "expressed interest" in it, but are not "actively looking" at doing it.
Obama exaggerated when he said the U.S. is "the only advanced country on Earth that doesn't guarantee paid sick leave." Canada and Japan also don't mandate paid short-term sick leave, which is what Obama is seeking for the U.S.
The president boasted that the U.S. has gained 11 million private sector jobs in five years. Yes, but that ignores his first 13 months in office and a net loss of public sector jobs. Total employment growth during his time in office is about 6.4 million.
Obama also boasted that "more of our people are insured than ever before." But that's based on an administration analysis that compares the second quarter of 2014 to years past. We don't have the full 2014 federal numbers yet.
The president delivered his sixth State of the Union address at a joint session of Congress on Jan. 20. But it was his first under a Congress controlled by Republicans. Much of his speech was devoted to the improving economy.
Obama made the inflated claim that "more than half of manufacturing executives have said they're actively looking to bring jobs back from China."
The president was referring to an August 2014 survey of 252 senior manufacturing executives in the U.S. conducted by the Boston Consulting Group. But the survey's findings don't exactly back up the president's claim.
While 54% of those surveyed "expressed interest in reshoring," only 16% said they are "already bringing production back from China to the United States," a 20% increase from the 2013 survey. And 20% of those polled said that "they would consider returning production in the near future," up 24% from 2013.
Obama also said that since 2010 "[o]ur manufacturers have added almost 800,000 new jobs." That's true enough, but there has been a net loss of manufacturing jobs during the president's time in office.
Since January 2010, the time frame used by the president, the U.S. has seen an increase of 777,000 manufacturing jobs, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics . But since January 2009, when Obama took office, the U.S. has seen a net decline of 321,000 manufacturing jobs, the same BLS data show.
In a recent study , the Information Technology & Innovation Foundation rejected talk of a "manufacturing renaissance," calling it a "myth," and noting there still is a long way to go. Even with the recent increase in manufacturing jobs, there are still nearly 1.8 million fewer manufacturing jobs than there were in January 2007, BLS figures show.
"Much of the growth since 2010 appears to be caused by a cyclical recovery as demand, particularly for motor vehicles and other durable goods, returns," the ITIF report said.
ECONOMIC GROWTH
The president fudged a bit when he said economic growth and job gains are the best in 16 years.
Obama: Tonight, after a breakthrough year for America, our economy is growing and creating jobs at the fastest pace since 1999.
Not quite.
As for how fast "our economy is growing," official figures from the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis put the gain in real gross domestic product at an annual rate of 5.0% in the third quarter of last year. Those are the most recent figures available, and they represent the best quarterly gain in some time. But not since 1999.
The BEA's figures show real GDP grew at a rate of 6.9% in the third quarter of 2003, and at 7.8% in the second quarter of 2000.
And as for "creating jobs," the White House has pointed to a preliminary figure of 2.95 million job s gained in 2014, which is the best since 1999 if it holds up when the BLS completes its normal revisions of job figures, which could go up or down.
But the president spoke in present tense saying the economy "is creating jobs" at the fastest clip since 1999. And by more immediate measures the pace is not quite the most rapid since 1999. BLS puts the gain in total nonfarm employment during the most recent three-month period (ending in December) at 866,000 jobs. That's a respectable number, but not the best three-month gain since 1999.
The BLS figures show other three-month stretches in 2010, 2006, 2004 and 2000 when even more jobs were added.
SICK PAY
Obama exaggerated when he said the United States was "the only advanced country on Earth that doesn't guarantee paid sick leave."
While Canada and Japan have social insurance programs that would cover an extended leave for cancer treatment, they don't have guaranteed paid leave for an illness that lasts a few days. And Obama made the claim in calling for "a bill that gives every worker in America the opportunity to earn seven days of paid sick leave."
A 2009 report by the Center for Economic and Policy Research , a group funded by various labor groups and foundations , examined policies in 22 countries "ranked highly in terms of economic and human development." It says in the first paragraph that the U.S. is "the only country that does not guarantee that workers receive paid sick days or paid sick leave," but it goes on to say that neither Canada nor Japan has a policy for financial support for short-term leave, for an illness such as a five-day flu. Those countries do have social insurance that would cover some of the pay for an employee needing 50 days off for cancer treatment. Those are the two scenarios examined in the study.
The report says that 11 countries guaranteed full pay for an illness requiring five sick days. Others paid for some missed time, but not all five days (and in a few cases not even one full day), because of waiting periods before the financial support would kick in.
Obama also said that the U.S. was the "only advanced country on Earth that doesn't guarantee paid maternity leave to our workers." A 2014 report from the United Nation's International Labour Organization found: "Only two out of 185 countries and territories currently provide no statutory cash benefits during maternity leave." The two countries were Papua New Guinea and the United States, both of which provide some kind of maternity leave but no requirement for paid leave.
The U.S. Family and Medical Leave Act requires 12 weeks of unpaid leave for new mothers who have worked for one year for employers with more than 50 workers. Employers may require a substitution of paid sick or vacation days for the FMLA leave.
However, the International Labour Organization report went on to say that the benefits in more than half of those 185 countries "were neither generous nor sufficiently long-lasting." It calls for 14 weeks of pay equal to two-thirds of previous earnings, a standard met by 85% of developed countries.
And not all women are eligible for benefits. "Only 28.4 per cent of employed women worldwide would receive cash benefits in case of maternity," the report said.
PRIVATE SECTOR JOB GROWTH
The president was correct when he said the U.S. has gained 11 million private sector jobs in the past five years.
Obama: And over the past five years, our businesses have created more than 11 million new jobs.
That's true as far as it goes. The economy gained 11,215,000 private sector jobs between February 2010 and the preliminary figures for December of last year.
Of course, the president said nothing of the 4,210,000 private sector jobs that were lost during the first 13 months of his tenure as president, due to the savage recession that was raging at the time he took office.
Overall, since Obama took office, the net gain in private sector employment is just over 7 million. And the gain in total employment during his time in office is lower than that just under 6.4 million. That's because of a net loss in government jobs , particularly in local school systems .
DEFICITS
In ticking off his accomplishments, Obama listed this one: "our deficits cut by two-thirds." That's accurate, but as we have written before, the deficits have fallen from high levels and are on pace to return to high levels .
When Obama took office in January 2009, the federal deficit for fiscal year 2009 was already on pace to be $1.2 trillion and topped $1.4 trillion by the end of the fiscal year on Sept. 30, 2009. Annual deficits remained above $1 trillion for three more years before dropping to $680 billion in fiscal 2013.
The U.S. finished the most recent fiscal year with a deficit of $483 billion roughly down two-thirds from what it was in fiscal 2009, as the president said.
But, as we noted in our quarterly report on Obama's presidency , the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office projects that annual deficits will soon rise again if Congress doesn't act. In a report it issued in August , CBO projected that under current law the deficit will rise above $500 billion in fiscal 2016 and hit nearly $950 billion by 2022.
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2015/01/21/fact-check-obama-state-of-the-union/21989675/?csp=eMail_DailyBriefing_52828775
Tags
Who is online
94 visitors

As most politicians do in all of their speeches to the people -
A lot of clapping and smiling from one side and a lot of dour looks across the way.
The pep rally is over and now the work begins as we wait to see if anything substantive is going to be accomplished, trough actual compromise, by both sides giving up a little of what they want and giving in on a little of what the other side wants on the key policy issues. If this give and take does not occur,
nothing substantive will be done.
John
I know you hate to read the articles and comments before you post your comments, but the comment above yours states that this approach is common to politicians.
John
I am not a ember of the Obama Fan Cl.b that you seem to chair and there have been several articles posted that praise the SOTU Address.
This is a different view of the pep rally address and while not a ringing endorsement, as you might pen, it is a fair look at the points the president made and the data on which those points were based.
As to whether you take m seed or my comment seriously - that is of absolutely no concern to me.
John
Absurd and annoying - exactly what your avatar evokes around here.
Comment on the article or not, but please cease to simply be annoying
Some views from citizens on the SOTU message - (letters to the editor USA Today). Positive and negatives views of where we are and where we are going
GASP! Who would have thought?!?!?!
96SW6
All politicians do it, I found it interesting that the article presented the president's take on the issue, the actual data and the difference from spin to reality
And it played to the audience it was intended to play to, as each annual pep rally (aka SOTU Address) has done in the past.
Excuse me, but, what politician doesn't?
I'm glad I'm not president. No telling what I'd be called, or who would criticize me.
I've never served in the military-- not many women did, back then, when I was young. Therefore, I'd be labeled unpatriotic. If I was busy with everything and forgot to salute or bow or whatever to military people, I'd REALLY be called unpatriotic. If I stood with my hand over my heart during the pledge of allegiance, I'd be called out as old fashioned. If I added the words "under God", as I always do, I'd be called non-secular. If I said I thought that everyone should have some sort of safety net for health insurance, lo and behold, I'd be called a socialist. If I didn't, I'd be condemned for not caring. I mean, gee. There are only two more years to listen to all this BS, I'm worn out with it, already.
Give it a rest! Does every twitch of an eyelid mean that Obama is a traitor? Then, we'd better institute firing squads for traitorous activities, because the military does, on occasion, twitch an eyelid... It seems as if we all blink, on occasion... If we didn't, our eyes would dry up.
I don't know any politician, bank president, corporate CEO, or leader of some sort that doesn't exaggerate their accomplishments and try to put the best spin on things they can-- to make themselves look good, either to the voters, their shareholders, etc. Ever. This is normal, and I don't understand the outrage.
Dowser
A I noted in my first comment, you are correct it is a common practice amongst politicians.
Doesn't mean the exaggeration and selective data analysis shouldn't be noted, which is all the article did and is a fairly respectful manner and tone.
Not sure what set you off, but if it was me my apologies
Not you-- and I'm sorry! I just get so tired of all this...
Please forgive me-- yes, it is good to check facts and we all need to know which factoids are actually true, and which are not.
At the same time, no one gives the president credit for what he does do that is good-- and nit pick him to death. A lot of people did the same thing to Harry Truman, and look how he is regarded today.
You know, as well as I, that if God himself came down here to run the country, someone would have a fit over it. Sometimes, it is just mean-spirited nit-picking, and sometimes, it is a valid criticism. Those are becoming harder and harder to distiguish between, these days.
Take care and I am sorry. It just hit me wrong, and it is likely because I'm just a creep today. Today is a creepy sort of day... Please forgive me.
Do you see Lincoln's 1862 SOU as a pep rally. I see a humble man telling it like it was not fluffing his party or his own accomplishments. If anything he is concerned that he could be making mistakes. He acknowledges that there are smarter men that he is addressing you don't see Obama doing that.
Dean
No I guess I am not as old as you are, I did not see the 1862 SOTU Address.
President Obama took the same tact in delivering the SOTU Address as presidents of both parties have for as long as the SOTU Addresses have been televised (and perhaps before that) to ballyhoo his successes (actual or elf actualized only) and to promote his vision.
Nothing new and this is merely a critique of that address as previous SOTU Addresses have also been critiqued by supporters and opponents alike.
You have nothing to apologize for
I always appreciate and learn from your feedback
Take good care and hopefully giving me feedback and perspective on future articles.
I always stop by, dear friend, even if I don't say much. I always give your articles a like, too!
Sometimes, I have nothing to add that would be of value to the discussion. Rather to be thought a fool than to open one's mouth and remove all doubt.
That's what I was going to say. It's not limited to politicians, either. I exaggerate the hell out of my accomplishments, whether I actually have some (accomplishments), or not.
The sad thing is that it's time for this kind of thing to start dominating conversations everywhere. 'Obama Refuses To Trim Nose Hair!!!' 'Michelle Obama Returns From the Powder Room with The Back Of Her Dress Tucked into Her Panty Hose!!' 'The First Family's Dogs, Bo and Sunny,Poop in the Oval Office!!' Ok, I'll admit it, the last one is kind of gross.
Bingo.
Sister Mary
It looks like you have some breaking news there.
People in the public spotlight, are well in the public spotlight and get coverage, it is not limited to the first family.
What the pundits think of the SOTU Address is part of the news cycle and this article was not exactly a hatchet job on the president, what he said was presented and then critiqued.