Income Growth by Income Level under Democratic and Republican Presidents, 1948-2005
Income Growth by Income Level under Democraticand Republican Presidents, 1948-2005 , byLarry M. Bartels, Princeton University
╌>
Income Growth by Income Level under Democraticand Republican Presidents, 1948-2005 , byLarry M. Bartels, Princeton University
As Sgt Friday said, "Just the facts, Ma'am... just the facts..."
Another look at the facts of the matter
The bottom four quintiles' annual growth rate seems unaffected by Republican or Democrat in the White House.
Just the facts - I like that.
Look at the scales.
Bbbbut the author is from Princeton ! He couldn't be biased , could he ? [insert vomit here ]
I did look at the scales
Average incomes at $83Kseem unaffected, to any significant degree,by the occupant of the White House and for mean incomes in lower groups the effect is even slighter over the 40 plus year period
Petey...
The world is not black and white. It's shades of grey. Princeton is surely not perfectly honest, but on the other hand, there are a ton of folks who spend a ton of time fact-checking everything that comes from there. Between Princeton and Breitbart...
OMG! A political scientist!
That is prima facie proof that everything he writes is crap!
I agree and thus the up and down (what little there is) was not affected to any significant degree by whether a democrat or republican was in the white house.
Correlation is not causation.
It is correlation.
Anyone who hopes to draw deep truth from a graph is kidding themself... OTOH, correlation deserves thought.
I'm not so sure that this accurately reflects what has happened to the middle class.
Buying power has been greatly affected in my lifetime. When I was a kid, if you made $100,000/yr, you could buy a mansion, and have a new car every year. Of course, said mansion cost $100,000, and a new car, luxury model, cost $2000. Now a comparable home is $500,000, and a comparable luxury car is $60,000.
We made a little less money in the mid 1990's but could purchase a whole lot more with it. Of course, no mansion, no luxury car, but if we wanted a couch, we could go buy one. Now, a couch is a purchase we'll put off for awhile.
Another thing is that the percentage of disposable income has drastically changed. Back then, health insurance didn't eat up so much of a family's budget. We have been spending $800/mo for health insurance for the past several years-- up from $250/mo. in the mid 1990s. Yet our salaries are not appreciably larger, nor is the buying power of that dollar as good.
Not being a creep, or not trying to be, but I don't honestly believe this reflects what is truly happening...
Note: we had friends who made all that money, but we didn't.
I'm not trying to link this to a specific president-- I think that a lot of this is going to happen, no matter who is president.
Yes, post WWII America was very different, and we can't go back to that. Yet, I would hope that at least SOME of these issues can be addressed so that the middle class is more growing and economically prosperous. I think too many people are losing ground these days. Nor do I see any relief in sight for most of us.
Actually, it agrees with you. Look at the scale. And the period.
If you want overall growth by quintile, then RiO's graph is what you want.
Stagnation is what I see... Maybe I'm reading it wrong.
2% growth in 50-60 years isn't much, is it?
Why not?
I think we've let the genie out of the bottle, so to speak-- Once these corporations have had a taste of all these profits, they're never going back to reasonable profits. It is fashionable nowadays to screw over your customers and employees-- those that screw them over the worst are the biggest winners, and hailed for being fabulous businessmen-- not the scumbags they are. Reasonable profits, taking care of one's customers and employees is for the weak, or losers with a capital L.
Can we go back to a more moral business environment? Doubt it. Can we turn back the clock to where we all sit on the porch at night, wave to our neighbors, and listen to the radio all night? Even to where we just watch TV? Doubt it. Can we ever go back to a time when it was safe to leave your door unlocked, allow your children to walk to school safely, or to care about your neighbors in a neighborly way? Doubt it.
Time have changed too much. Women have to work to just make ends meet-- and there are many who would deny them equal pay for equal work-- not much of an issue, post WWII. An Issue only for war widows. Those that wish to keep women out of the workforce don't seem to realize that their paychecks are often all that stands between their children and hunger. And this is true for both married and unmarried women.
Has our technology brought us much joy? Yes and no. 100 channels on TV and there is still nothing to watch. Cell phones are fabulous and I'm grateful for them-- but even with an excellent company, there are many areas that just don't have any coverage, by any company. So what good does it do? Most of us are so taken up by our children's activities, we have no time to do anything else, much less 'keep house', cook nice meals, (I'm talking a standard meat, 2 veggies, hot bread, and dessert), or do anything like sewing, gardening, car washing. My husband works 12-14 hour days. By the time he gets home, he's exhausted. I've retired, and don't have all that much time, or energy, either. My 16 year old is in band and I'm constantly running him back and forth.
Yup. I long to go back in time and sit on Grandma and Grandpa's front porch, and watch the fireflies, and wave at the Misses Brame across the street. I would love to turn on TV and have some reruns of I Love Jeanie or Mission Impossible on it to watch. Something cute, funny, and un-taxing. (As in NOT the slop on tv these days...) I would love to turn on the old Capeheart and hear the liquid pools of mono music it produced... I still have it, but there are no tubes to use to fix it.
Doubt it will ever happen. Definitely not to go back in time, but to capture that serenity again, to share it with my son-- not going to happen. He's too busy trying to keep up with band...
I don't think that time ever existed. But there was a time when corporations were limited by various kinds of government action -- anti-trust, bank regulations, ... Since Eisenhower's "military-industrial complex" warning, corporations have purchased Congress... so I guess your question becomes, "Can we go back to a time when there was a power to limit corporation excesses?" And the answer is, probably... no.
That is the best question of all! What good does our "stuff" do us?
I dunno...
:-(((
What happened to 2006 and 2007 and 10 months of 2008. Left out how convenient. Shows that graph is crap. If you are cautious of what you ask for you will already bypass the true issue in the last 20 years.
Economy Crash wall street crash 2005-October 2008. Gee why did the Republicans want to stop the election of 2008??? Because of Market/economy crash. Huge corporations going bankrupt. Bush bailing out Corporations with no payback plan. When did that change that Corp had to pay money back, huh 2009 ring a bell.
Who started tax breaks for companies shipping jobs overseas. Pres RR which politicians have blocked all attempts to stop these tax deferments in last 6 years. Conservatives not Democratic politicians. John Boehner ring a bell. Republicans for those of you who cannot figure it out. Trickle down is a fallacy.