States Consider Requiring US Citizenship Test for Graduation
PHOENIX (AP) Arizona's new law requiring high school students to pass the U.S. citizenship test in order to graduate appears likely to be adopted in a handful of other states this year, though educators warn it's not a fix-all solution to the nation's dire knowledge of civics.
Fewer than a dozen states currently require students to take a civics exam, and passing it isn't necessary to graduate in all of them. In most states, civic education instead revolves around a one-semester U.S. history course.
Arizona on Thursday became the first to specifically require the U.S. citizenship test, a 100-question exam that tests knowledge of facts on subjects like the Founding Fathers, the Bill of Rights and U.S. presidents.
"This has been building for a long time," said Ted McConnell, executive director of the Campaign for the Civic Mission of Schools, a civic learning coalition co-chaired by former U.S. Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O'Connor. McConnell said he and others are wary that legislators are only skimming the surface of what students need to know.
"The folks who are civic educators and experts by and large are pushing for a much, much more well-rounded approach," said Paul Baumann, director of the National Center for Learning and Civic Engagement at the Education Commission of the States, a state-led research organization.
For years, education leaders have sounded the alarm on the state of civic education.
Just 13 percent of high school seniors scored as "proficient" or higher in American history on the 2010 National Assessment of Educational Progress. Voter participation in the most recent midterm elections was the lowest in decades, and even entertainers like Jay Leno have tapped into the country's weak civic knowledge with laughable pop quiz history tests.
The Arizona-based Joe Foss Institute has set a goal of having all 50 states adopt the U.S. citizenship requirement for high school students by 2017, the 230th anniversary of the U.S. Constitution. The institute says legislatures in 15 states are expected to consider it this year. The North Dakota House of Representatives overwhelmingly approved the same measure Thursday, but Arizona's proposal was the first to become law.
The Foss Institute promotes the test to state legislatures as a way to increase knowledge of basic government by students. The leader of the organization is former California U.S. Rep. Frank Riggs, who came in last in Arizona's Republican primary for governor after running a hard-right campaign focused on immigration and rhetoric against President Barack Obama.
The Arizona law requires high school students to correctly answer 60 of 100 questions on the civics portion of the test for those aspiring to become U.S. citizens. Passing is required to earn a high school or GED diploma starting in the 2016-17 school year.
Utah, South Dakota, Tennessee and other states have bills already presented or about to be introduced.
McConnell said he believes the Foss institute's projection that more than a dozen states will pass the requirement this year is accurate. Yet he and others who have been pushing for improved civic education sum up the effort like this: "Right problem, wrong solution."
"The leaders in the civics education field I've spoken about this with are generally concerned that this exam does not capture the full breadth and scope of the competencies and outcomes we're looking for students to develop," Baumann said.
Baumann said states that do have a civics exam other than Arizona test knowledge that the U.S. citizenship exam does not: Valuing equality before the law, the purpose of democratic government, and good citizenship practices.
The citizenship exam, by contrast, only requires "very basic knowledge of U.S. government," he said.
"We fear this test would take away the precious little time awarded for civic education now and drive instruction toward dry, rote memorization of facts that would quickly be forgotten," McConnell said.
O'Connor, the co-chair of McConnell's group, initially supported the Foss Institute's work but did not back the U.S. citizenship test requirement bill; judicial work precluded her from being involved in any legislative initiative. It was unclear whether she favored the test as a component of civic education.
The U.S. citizenship test requirement also comes amid a larger debate over concerns that testing required under No Child Left Behind and other laws has resulted in a narrowing of the curriculum taking away time from instruction in topics like civics. One Center for Education Policy study found that 27 percent of districts surveyed reported reducing time on social studies either somewhat or to a great extent.
http://news360.com/article/274730988#
Tags
Who is online
89 visitors

Not such a bad idea.
We had to take and pass Civics and Ohio History to graduate back in the day
And no one complained about it
And the vast majority of us understood basic governmental functions.
Not so today with the "Me" generation.
Quite frankly, all citizens should take this test before voting...especially politicians.
1stwarrior
Very true, but they can always google it so why should they learn it
Now that was funny
Thanks for sharing the lighter side
A P
Are you advocating putting external requirements on the right to vote?
It could be part of the incoming process, along with swearing in for the new members of the House and Senate.
Is demonstrates a high degree of prejudice and favoritism to require high school students, the majority of whom would likely be United States citizens, to take a citizenship test when millions of illegal aliens are not required to do so before being granted citizenship in this country.
Robert G
A little comedy is always appreciated no matter what the topic.
Thanks for providing the stand up material.
scremminmimi
Are you suggesting that it is a bad idea to require high school graduates to know something about their country?
Or, are you suggesting that immigrants are getting legal status without benefit of the "process" provided for by U.S. law and that this is wrong?
Same here Robert, although Michigan History was a separate elective class. Students in Michigan were, at that time (1950's-1960's), required to pass a one semester American Government class and two semesters of U. S. History in order to graduate. It was still required when I started teaching American Government in 1976. The final exam for my Government class was taken directly from the citizenship test as given by the U. S. Government at that time. The requirements have since been watered down, not so much because of a lack of interest by the State Department of Education, but because there is only so much time available in High School and the Department would rather devote as much of that time as possible to Math and Science (and Football, of course).
TTGA
Well at least there are priorities, misguided though they may be in the eyes of many people.
Thanks for the feedback and the perspective on this topic
Wasn't "Civics" part of "Social Studies"?
We had it as a separate course when I was in school, but think as time went on you are correct what civics that is taught is likely incorporated into social studies.
Thanks for the feedback
The second part of your question, RiO.
It's just another reason why blanket amnesty should not be given to hordes of illegals. They should have to pass the Citizenship test as set down by law and be able to answer the basic questions about our country AND they should have to be able to speak basic English.
I don't know where all the articles went, but a couple of years ago there were numerous stories on MSNBC of fatal traffic accidents involving illegals, because while they could technically operate the vehicles they could not understand the illustrated street signs or adequately read the street signs. One Hispanic woman hit two grade school girls who had started across a highway in a crosswalk... she misinterpreted the signals about who had the right of way, and when the law arrived she was standing over the dead body of one of the girls, cursing her for being in the wrong lane.
Legal Options for an Undocumented (Illegal) Immigrant to Stay in the U.S.
An overview of the most likely ways for an undocumented alien to gain legal status in the United States.
Entering the United States without approval is illegal. So is staying in the U.S. without permission after your visa or other authorized stay has expired. Even violating the terms of a legal entry can make your stay illegal.
The U.S. immigration law offers very few options to go from being illegal or undocumented immigrant to a U.S. permanent resident (with a green card). We briefly describe the most likely possibilities below, but you should see an attorney for further help.
Option 1 Marriage to U.S. Citizen
Entering into a valid, bona fide (real, not sham) marriage with a U.S. citizen (of the same or opposite sex) makes you an immediate relative under the U.S. immigration laws. An immediate relative is theoretically eligible for a U.S. green card just as soon as you can get through the application process. However, your current illegal status could create problem s.
If you are in the United States illegally because you stayed past the expiration date on a valid visa, rather than having entered illegally (without inspection), consider yourself lucky: Your legal entry qualifies you for an exception, under which you should be able to apply for your green card without leaving the United States, using a procedure called adjustment of status.
If, however, your most recent entry into the United States was illegal for example, you crossed the U.S. border in secret, without stopping at an inspection point you have very little chance of adjusting your status to permanent resident based on your marriage. The exception is if you fall into one of the following categories, created by an old law called section 245(i):
Getting married to a lawful permanent U.S. resident (rather than a citizen) will also technically make you eligible for a U.S. green card, but because you face a long wait before a visa becomes available to you, your chances of adjusting status are even less (unless you fit one of the two 245(i): exceptions described above).
There is one last hope for people who cannot adjust status based on their marriage to a U.S. citizen or permanent resident: You can attend the interview for your green card (which is the last step in the application process) at an overseas U.S. consulate in your home country (called consular processing ).
However, at that point the consulate will penalize you for your illegal U.S. stay, with a time bar on returning to the United States. The penalty is either to spend three years outside the United States if you stayed in the U.S. illegally for six months (180 days) or more; or to spend ten years outside the United States if you stayed in the U.S. illegally for one year or more.
If you havent yet been in the United States illegally for six months or more, you might want to leave right away in order to make use of the consular processing possibility.
If you have already spent more than six months in the United States illegally, then talk to an immigration lawyer. You may qualify for a waiver, (legal forgiveness) allowing you to reenter the United States right away after your consular processing interview, but this waiver is hard to get. You would need to prove that your being denied the immigrant visa (green card) would cause extreme hardship to one or more of your U.S. citizen family members.
Option 2 Service in the U.S. Military
If you serve honorably and on active duty with the U.S. Armed Forces during one of the wars or conflicts named below, the law allows you to apply for U.S. citizenship. You dont even have to go through the usual step of applying for a green card first.
You must, however, enlist (sign up) while on U.S. territory, such as the Canal Zone, American Samoa, Swains Island, or a noncommercial U.S. ship.
The conflicts that qualify you for immediate U.S. citizenship include:
Option 3 Cancellation of Removal
If you are arrested by the immigration authorities, you might be able to avoid removal, and receive a U.S. green card, if you can prove all of the below:
Dont attempt to apply for cancellation of removal on your own it is only available if you are already in immigration court proceedings. Youll definitely need a lawyers help in this situation.
Option 4 Asylum
You can apply for the right to stay in the U.S. if you qualify for asylum and apply within one year of your entry or the expiration of your authorized stay.
Youll need to show that you have been persecuted, or fear future persecution, in your home country, based on your race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group.
The process involves submitting an application, together with detailed documentation of your membership in the group that you claim and the persecution that you faced or fear.
If you are granted asylum, you can apply for a green card one year after your approval, and for U.S. citizenship four years after that. (If denied, you will be deported.).
Option 5 Temporary Protected Status
If you come from a country that has recently had a civil war, environmental or natural disaster, or other trouble that makes it unsafe for its citizens to return there, the United States may offer whats known as Temporary Protected Status or TPS.
This is not a green card, nor does it lead to a green card. However, TPS would allow you to stay in the United States legally for a set amount of time (maximum 18 months), and to receive a work permit while youre here. See the USCIS website ( www.uscis.gov ) for details and the list of currently eligible countries.
by: Ilona Bray , J.D.
...
I know this may sound controversial, but IMO they shou,d have another requirement first-- in order to graduate, the student must have some degree of literacy-- at the very least a third grade reading level. (Critical thinking skills would be nice as well-- but there are few if any teachers in the school system who have actually mastered that themselves. Well-- perhaps that's no reason to stop them from teaching it. And I'm sure the teachers' unions would agree
Highly Insulting, I bet you're not from the United States...
Dietrich
Your generalization about the qualifications of teachers is neither accurate nor useful in discussing the topic at hand.
Poor reading ability is certainly a problem in secondary schools in many areas and needs to improve, as does the basic communications and critical thinking skills with which our children enter college or the workplace
CM
I agree - generalizations about the quality of educators are rarely accurate or useful in a discussion
scremminmimi
The topic is the education process not the immigration process
Once the children are in the school system, regardless of how they arrived in the country, there should be certain, specific graduation requirements (maybe this one and probably many others) that all must attain to achieve a diploma.
Reading, writing, communication skills, critical thinking, mathematics.....all must have minimum levels of achievement if the diploma is to mean anything, but more important if our children are to truly be prepared for college or the workplace.
CM
The topic is education, not immigration
Thanks for the info though
Cerenkov
As I said to Dietrich above, there needs to be minimum achievement levels in several academic areas in order for a child to receive a diploma for graduating from high school.
Reading and math must be first priorities and by using subjects like music and art to teach them in integrated curricula, all other subjects can also be integrated.
I wonder how many government officials could pass such a test.
A Mac
A fair question
Somewhere up above I mentioned that it should be part of the swearing in process for newly elected officials, with remedial classes for those that fail and a requirementto pass before they can participate in the legislative process.
Thanks for the feedback
Education of the "whole" child is critically important to their future success and socialization, minimum achievement levels must be incorporated into the education process.
A high school program for participation and trying is much more dangerous to the childrens' future than the participation awards for activities.
I know it is RI and I apologize for getting off topic, but I thought Mimi's thoughts were it was easy to go from Illegal status to citizenship status which is common thinking for a lot of Americans and wanted to get the record straight.....
And, therein lies the problem...
Have you heard of the Regents Exam??? I don't know about other states but it is a requirement in NYS for graduation..
In New York State , Regents Examinations are statewide standardized examinations in core high school subjects required for a Regents Diploma . Regents diplomas are optional and typically offered for college bound and non-disabled students. Most students, with some limited exceptions, are required to take the Regents Examinations. To graduate, students are required to have earned appropriate credits in a number of specific subjects by passing year-long or half-year courses, after which they must pass Regents examinations in some of the subject areas. For higher achieving students, a Regents with Advanced designation, and an Honor designation, are also offered.
Purpose
The Regents Examinations are developed and administered by the New York State Education Department (NYSED) under the authority of the Board of Regents of the University of the State of New York . Regents exams are prepared by a conference of selected New York teachers of each test's specific discipline who assemble a test map that highlights the skills and knowledge required from the specific discipline's learning standards. The conferences meet and design the tests three years before the tests' issuance, which includes time for field testing and evaluating testing questions.
NYSED also sometimes refers to elementary and intermediate grade statewide standardized tests as Regents Examinations.
"At the close of each academic term, a public examination shall be held of all scholars presumed to have completed preliminary studiesTo each scholar who sustains such examination, a certificate shall entitle the person holding it to admission into the academic class in any academy subject to the visitation of the Regents, without further examination." [ 1 ] [ 2 ]
The legislatures intent in establishing the Regents Examination system is described in the ordinance. The central idea of the legislation was to create an educational control system that could be used to regulate the flow of funds to the well established academy system of schools that existed throughout the state of New York. This goal would be accomplished by:
The new class of students would be called the academic class, and those students who qualified for admission to it by sustaining a process of examination would be known as academic scholars. Academic scholars, and the institutions with which they were affiliated, would receive recognition and privilege under New Yorks school funding formula. [ 1 ]
The focus of the ordinance was on assessing student achievement in the preliminary, or elementary curricula. In essence, the examinations were being positioned in the primary role of gatekeeper between the primary and secondary schools of the state of New York. The need for a gatekeeper examination system was due in part to the states 1864 school funding formula, which allocated public funds to private academies based on criteria that included the number of enrolled students. Typically, the academies used money distributed from the state literature fund to offset operating expenses, and any expenses in excess of funds received from the State were passed on to students and their families in the form of rate bills. Under this system, individual academies could realize economic advantages by lowering academic standards and enrolling less qualified students. In 1864, during a time of war, the New York legislature became concerned about this issue of who was and who was not qualified to be enrolled in the common, mostly private academies of the state and also in the rare, public high schools of the state. The timing of the legislatures concern and actions in 1864 may have been related to two conditions that existed during the Civil War: the militarys need for young men of fighting age and a period of fiscal austerity in school funding. [ 1 ]
History
The first Regents Examinations were administered in November 1866. In 1878, the Regents Examination system was expanded to assess the curricula taught in the secondary schools of New York, and the Regents exams were first administered as high school end-of-course exams. [ 3 ] From the original five exams (algebra, Latin, American History, natural philosophy, natural geography), the State Education Department expanded the Regents Exams offerings to forty-two tests in 1879; tests were administered in November, February, and June. Throughout the 1920s and into the 1930s vocational education Regents Exams were approved and administered. These included, but were not limited to, agricultural science, costume draping, and salesmanship. [ 2 ] By 1970 the number and types of Regents Exams changed to reflect the changes in high school curriculum: vocational exams were discontinued, and the sheer number of exams were either dropped or consolidated as the curricular emphasis trended toward comprehensive examinations rather than the singularly focused tests of the past. This trend continued into the twenty-first century, with the cancellation of foreign language exams in 2010 and 2011.
In 1979, Regents Competency Tests were introduced for disabled students, and in 2000, New York State Alternative Assessments (NYSAA) program was first administered allowing students with severe cognitive disabilities to complete a datafolio-style assessment to demonstrate their performance toward achieving the New York State learning standards. [ 3 ]
Exam requirements
Local Diplomas are offered by New York State school districts for students who did not pass the Regents Diploma requirements. For students entering 9th grade in September 2008 and thereafter, the Local Diploma is only offered to disabled students, and the rest of the students must attain at least a Regents Diploma. Advanced and Honors designations are available for exemplary students. In addition to the Regents exam requirements, there are additional requirements for attaining a Regents or Regents with Advanced Designation Diploma, which are described in a NYSED handout titled "General Education & Diploma Requirements", [ 6 ] and are codified in Section 100.5 of the Part 100 Regulations of the Commissioner of Education . [ 15 ]
Most students are required to achieve a score of 65 or higher on Regents Exams to pass. Students with disabilities are required to achieve a score of 45 through 54 out of a possible 100 on a state Regents exam. [ 16 ] However this only qualifies for a local diploma as long as they compensate with a score of 65 or higher on another Regents exam. [ 16 ] Students with disabilities still must earn minimum 55 scores on Regents exams in Comprehensive English and math. [ 16 ] NYSED considers a score of 75 to 80 to indicate college readiness, [ 17 ] with a score of 75 to 85 being a cutoff for admission for some selective colleges and universities and a score below 75 being a threshold for placement in remediation for some schools, including CUNY schools. [ 18 ]
Regents Diploma exam requirements
Passing the following Regents exams with a score of 65 or better is required for a Regents Diploma:
Regents Diploma with Advanced Designation exam requirements
Passing the following Regents exams with a score of 65 or better is required for a Regents Diploma with Advanced Designation:
Additional honors designations
The New York State Board of Regents offers the following honors to students with exemplary academic performance:
Exemptions
Alternative public schools
During the 1990s, some alternative assessment schools, similar in character to charter schools , were founded in parts of New York in an attempt to provide a way for students to graduate from high school without taking any Regents Exams. Usually, the substitute graduation assessement involved would consist of the review and grading, by a panel of teachers, of an academic portfolio a collection of the student's best work from all his or her years at the school. From such a "portfolio examination" would be issued a "Regents equivalency" grade for the areas of Math, English, History, and Science, and a "Regents Equivalency" diploma would be awarded to the student at commencement.
However, by the end of the 1990s all of these self-labeled "alternative schools" had been forced to adopt some or all of the standard Regents Exam requirements, and today these schools must fully participate in the Regents testing program.
Private schools
Though all public schools are required to follow either the Regents Exam system or some form of alternative assessment, private schools may or may not follow either of these systems. The vast majority of private schools actually do use Regents exams and award Regents diplomas, but some, usually academically prestigious private schools, do not. These schools' argument is that their own diploma requirements exceed Regents standards. Schools run by the Society of Jesus , such as Canisius High School , Fordham Prep , McQuaid Jesuit , Regis , and Xavier and the Society of Mary (Marianists) , such as Chaminade and Kellenberg , have not used Regents exams for decades. Additionally, some other schools like The Masters School , The Ursuline School , The Hackley School , The Harvey School , Long Island Lutheran Middle & High School , Manlius Pebble Hill School , and Nichols School not associated with those groups do not use the Regents system.
Allowable substitute examinations
Some Advanced Placement exams and SAT subject tests are allowable by NYSED as substitutes for the Regents Examination for that subject (e.g., AP American History in place of the U.S. History and Government Regents). NYSED has approved a limited number of allowable substitute exams and has published required scores for the exams. [ 22 ]
Regents Competency Test (RCT)
Regents Competency High School tests , or simply RCT's , [ 23 ] are exit exams given to identified special education students with Individualized Education Programs or students with a 504 plan seeking a high school diploma but cannot pass the standard Regents exams. Like the Regents Examinations, the RCT is provided and overseen by NYSED, and is designed and administered under the authority of the Board of Regents.
jwc
It is a "test" not a "textbook"
No one said it would be easy or likely
Now that is a big piece of data
Thanks for the link as well
NO worries
The problem discussed is important for all children who will live, vote and prosper in the U.S. - native born or naturalized
RIO...Sarcasm or Not, its important information, I have heard it stated that NY has the lowest graduation of High Schools, I suppose that may be if they are not up to the requirements, they will not graduate or maybe just with a certificate that's not worth much..
I thought it would be a good idea, a way of weeding out the numbskulls...
You guys are making me laugh and with the rain we are having, its a beautiful day LoL!!!
jwc
Actually the students might study and read several books, textbook and otherwise.
The topic of the article is the test, not a textbook in Texas or anywhere else
Get over yourself.
CM
Good point, the rain here in NE Ohio is in the process of changing over to snow as I type this.