Britain’s Success Story
Simon Wren-Lewis asks how good British economic recovery which is being touted as a wonderful success story really has been. Not very, he says. Indeed. Heres a comparison of the UK with two other major economies since 2007:
Austerity triumphant. Or, maybe not.
Part of this is the growth rate fallacy no matter how badly an economy has done over an extended period, you proclaim success afnter a year or two of good growth. As Wren-Lewis likes to say, on this basis the ideal policy is to shut half the economy down for a while, then start it up again that way you get 100 percent growth. Also, hitting yourself in the head with a baseball bat is a great idea, because it feels good when you stop.
But surely were also seeing the ideological bias of many in the news media. France is supposed to be a terrible failure, because it still believes in a strong welfare state and so it is reported as a failure, never mind the numbers. Austerity in Britain is politically approved, so it is pronounced a success on the shakiest of grounds.
Its all pretty depressing.
Britains Success Story , Paul Krugman, New York Times

Facts? Facts? Who needs facts?
We know that austerity works!
Are you saying austerity is never justified ?
Looking at the chart, its obvious that the U.S, has done much, much better than the UK. But we've also done better than France, as well.
That since the best improvement has been in capitalist U.S., capitalism is obviously the best system of all?
(Or, if you don't believe that capitalism could possibly be superior--- perhaps America's success can be ratinalized by saying that its all because of Obama-- which proves that Obama is a Socialist after all!
)
A joke:
Why doesn't Bob answer that himself ? Are you Krugman ?
Never? That's kinda general. "Never say never..."
What seems very clear, from all that has happened since 2008 in America, the UK, and the eurozone... is that austerity is rarely effective, and often destructive.
Wrong.
Nor do I mind if you post silliness. No problem!
Of course, if you (or anyone else) post silliness, I will name it...
K,
Why are you wasting everyone's time?
Before I discuss this more I would like to find out under what conditions austerity is justified . Care to expand on that ?
I think that Krish is being ironic, Bob.
US's recovery is either due to capitalism or Obama's socialism is the joke.
I would say that it has to do with cheap energy and that economies have natural cycles. When you have hit rock bottom, all you have is to go up... the rate may vary.
I think most economists would agree that Volker's recession was what finally killed inflation in the 80s. That was a context of high inflation and full employment. Businesses needed employees, so they offered higher pay... and then passed the added cost on to their customers: wage/price spiral.
Volcker intentionally broke business's capacity to pay more, stopping the spiral.
We have not seen those conjugated conditions (full employment and high inflation) since the 80s, and there is little reason to believe that we will see them again any time soon.
Yes, and that is an important idea. It is the answer to those who claim that austerity has succeeded: when an economy has been stripped to the bone, it must necessarily begin to gain weight...
*** sigh ***
Obviously austerity isn't the answer. If it was, we all would have let those banks and financial houses fail when we hit rock bottom. We made the choice to invest in them. But then the public grew cool on any type of investment, which I found odd.
The one country missing from the graph is Germany, who was very gung ho on austerity. I would have liked to have seen their rate of recovery.
I don't agree with this characterization. First, "we" didn't decide much of anything. Bush and then Obama decided stuff, with the complicity of Congress. There was very little public debate.
Second, "we" did not "invest". "We" "threw money at". If "we" had invested, "we" would have obtained equity...and control! That would in fact have been reasonable... so of course that is not what "we" did. "We" gave away the money, and left control to the good folks who had crashed the bus in the first place.
Bob ,
I found that quite interesting and sensible . But it implies that no other conditions warrant austerity . Is that what you're saying ?
There is a lot to be said that "THEY" crashed the bus deliberately.
"THEY" came up with the idea of "TO BIG TO FAIL" also with all the disaster scenarios they could think of.
The one thing that sticks out in the financial crash of the thirties? those with hard money did very well, those with paper money (margin) did very poorly.
Those living on the the cusp, took it the hardest.
In that respect, the crash of 2007-8 did the same thing, except with the complicity of government. I wouldn't limit the people implicated in such to just Bush and Obama, I would add Clinton into that mix, cause he and his cronies created the environment for it to happen.
We have to have some measure of austerity, meaning limits, along the line of Glass-Stegal, if anything to prevent rampant greed of those with hard cash from trying to take it all.
I'm sorry, Petey, but I don't feel competent to give you any greater precision. I know a little theory and a little history... but I am an amateur, still.
I don't know about "deliberately", but certainly with total indifference. And as you say, they engineered the context that allowed their indifference.
If they are not guilty of vehicular homicide, they are at least guilty of homicide by negligence...
I will accede to being a rank amateur . I know a bit about micro-economics and the ideas of Malthus [which have not been born out by history ] . Other than that I'm clueless . Taking a stab in the dark , I would suggest that when too many people outrun what the general economy is doing they are ripe for austerity ...
Ah! If only we could apply austerity to those few who deserve it. Unfortunately, they usually get away unscathed, while a bunch of innocent bystanders get wasted...
If I'm not mistaken , most of that damage is mitigated in the US by social safety nets . I'm not sure what happens in other countries : Greece for example ...
Not at all! America's safety nets are the weakest in the developed world.
You may remember that the Republicans filibustered to death an extension of unemployment benefits... and American unemployment benefits were already among the shortest and most limited.
While American taxpayers shoveled money to the banks that caused the mess, millions of nobodies lost their jobs... and then their benefits ran out... and then they lost their homes...
Very rare in Europe.
I'm not sure it is that simple . Do you think it would be better to let the big banks fail ?
Of course not. But we the taxpayers should have gotten an end to "too big to fail". In fact, we got nothing.
I like the sentiment . I'm not sure how to implement it ...
Several possibilities:
- government takes a majority, then sells by "small enough to fail" units
- "living wills": banks must plan (numbers) their own demise for the next time
- massive layoff with no benefits, of all senior management (they'll be more careful next time
- ...
I thought you said you were an amateur !
Yes. I don't know the formulas, and all that. When Krugman puts up his "wonkish" tag, I know that there are going to be formulas and graphs and references to "famous economists" I've never heard of. That's when I know I'm an amateur.
Ah the limitation of the written word... when I said "invest", I was being sarcastic. It was selective government propping. But none the less, it was still government money spent and in no way having to deal with austerity. I think that NWman got what I meant more (or maybe not?
Oooops.....
No biggie!
I think part of the joke is calling Obama a Socialist (but that's another discussion)..
I think many people let their perceptions be coloured by their political bias. So many Democrats would say that the economy is improving, and Obama gets the credit for that. Many Republicans would say its not improving, and that's because of Obama. (Or, perhaps, they would say the economy is improving despite Obama-- and that its the business community that is causing the improvement).
From what I've read, there's no doubt the economy has been improving for awhile now. Also, its been gradual. I don't really know what caused that. (I believe this started before the plunge in oil prices.)
Recently the rate of improvement seems to be picking up considerably, and probably thats due to cheap oil.
I would say that it has to do with cheap energy and that economies have natural cycles. When you have hit rock bottom, all you have is to go up... the rate may vary.
What do you ean by "hard money"? Gold and commodities as opposed to "paper money". or paper money as opposed to "margin money"?
Isn't that always the case?
(Although I'm not sure what you mean by "Living on the cusp"???)
What type of limits?
Well, I don't have a lot of money, but I can't see how anyone can take it away. (Except if someone actually phyically robs me). I am cautious with my money...
I was curious about the actual numbers. Found some interesting numbers:
1. France's youth unemployment rate is 24.30%.
2. France strikes record unemployment high, again