Keynesianism Explained
Attacks on Keynesians in general, and on me in particular, rely heavily on an army of straw men on knocking down claims about what people like me have predicted or asserted that have nothing to do with what weve actually said. But maybe we (or at least I) have been remiss, failing to offer a simple explanation of what its all about. I dont mean the models; I mean the policy implications.
So heres an attempt at a quick summary, followed by a sampling of typical bogus claims.
I would summarize the Keynesian view in terms of four points:
1. Economies sometimes produce much less than they could, and employ many fewer workers than they should, because there just isnt enough spending. Such episodes can happen for a variety of reasons; the question is how to respond.
2. There are normally forces that tend to push the economy back toward full employment. But they work slowly; a hands-off policy toward depressed economies means accepting a long, unnecessary period of pain.
3. It is often possible to drastically shorten this period of pain and greatly reduce the human and financial losses by printing money, using the central banks power of currency creation to push interest rates down.
4. Sometimes, however, monetary policy loses its effectiveness, especially when rates are close to zero. In that case temporary deficit spending can provide a useful boost. And conversely, fiscal austerity in a depressed economy imposes large economic losses.
Is this a complicated, convoluted doctrine? It doesnt sound that way to me, and the implications for the world weve been living in since 2008 seem very clear: aggressive monetary expansion, plus fiscal stimulus as long as the zero lower bound constrains monetary policy.
But strange things happen in the minds of critics. Again and again we see the following bogus claims about what Keynesians believe:
B1: Any economic recovery, no matter how slow and how delayed, proves Keynesian economics wrong. See [2] above for why thats illiterate.
B2: Keynesians believe that printing money solves all problems. See [3]: printing money can solve one specific problem, an economy operating far below capacity. Nobody said that it can conjure up higher productivity, or cure the common cold.
B3: Keynesians always favor deficit spending, under all conditions. See [4]: The case for fiscal stimulus is quite restrictive, requiring both a depressed economy and severe limits to monetary policy. That just happens to be the world weve been living in lately.
I have no illusions that saying this obvious stuff will stop the usual suspects from engaging in the usual bogosity. But maybe this will help others respond when they do.
-------------------------------------
Tags
Who is online
114 visitors

I love the photo... and I think it's originally mine! A few years ago, I photoshopped St Paul's head onto George Clooney/Brad Pitt/whoever. Maybe somebody else did the same...
Oh, and... The seed is pretty good, too. It's pretty hard to meet St Paul on a level playing ground, so most of what we see is straw-man arguments. People are constantly taking him out of context, etc... But almot nobody argues with his near-daily blog posts.
There's a very good site called " Economist's View " that posts a daily lisk of links to pretty much everything that's going on in the econoblogosphere. There are spats all the time. Nobody argues with Krugman... not because "he's always right"... but because his views are very, very middle-of-the-road among the best economists.
When you say that Paul is middle of the road, do you mean that he accepts the fact that we live in a mixed economy?
One of my major issues with Keynesian economics is the concept of printing money. I think that it's a temporary fix that at first increases spending but then leads to devaluation, which causes inflation.
IMHO.
No. Bad choice of words. I should have said "conventional". Whether a country is socialist, social-democrat, or capitalist, it nevertheless obeys the same "laws of economics", just as those countries also obey the same "laws of physics". There is no "spectrum of ideas" as there is in politics. There is a "commonly accepted basis", and there are some people who think differently. Just like physics.
The difference between the two sciences is of two natures. First, economics is much younger. Second, economics is more complex, with many more impacting factors, leading to a significant "butterfly effect".
Krugman's economic theses are conventional. You get exactly the same discourse from Olivier Blanchard, chief economist at the IMF, not usually considered a liberal institution, and from Martin Wolff, chief economist at the Financial Times, hardly a radical newspaper.
People have a hard time distinguishing between Krugman the (very conventional) economist, and Krugman the liberal political pundit.
Re-read the seed. The circumstances when "printing money" is recommended are carefully circumscribed. The idea that Keynesians favor the printing press at all times is one of the staw-men Krugman is underscoring here.
Bob,
My response was basing it off of your words. And actually I was basing it off of Krugman the economist, not the pundit.
I read your article carefully, and I never said that Keynesians are in favor of printing money all the time. This is my bone with a specific aspect of Keynesian economics. I have my bones with Friedman economic, too, like his views on consumption, and government intervention.
OK, then... You're just... wrong.
In the specified conditions (economy in recession due to insufficient demand), increasing the money supply does not lead to either depreciation or inflation. There are numerous past cases to prove the point.
This is what Krugman calls a "zombie", a notion that can be disproved again and again, but cannot be kept from propagation.
I don't believe that either Keynesianism nor Friedmanism is the right answer all the time . There are likely to be sociological factors at play that effect which one might be more effective at any time ... or the 3rd main school of economics [whose name escapes me at the moment] .
Again, not what I said.
But whatever.
Petey,
The first thing you learn in economics, is the human factor. The reality of the situation is that you end up with a mixed economy. So when a school of thought comes along and says if we do Y, X will happen, it may or may not, depending on human nature and the condition of the mixed economy. This is why, sometimes adding money into the supply stimulates and at other times it causes inflation, i.e. the Nixon years.
I never got involved in all this high level macro-econ . I stopped with the laws of supply & demand which usually work fairly well , but even they don't work when you add substitution to the mix.
Instead of this screed against those opposing Krugman , I would like to see info addressing why the labor participation rate is remaining low for such a long time and why the current admin has been so incompetent about the obvious solution of tax reform . But I guess that's too much to ask .
What you said:
This is wrong. The fix is not temporary. It kick-starts a virtuous cycle which persists.
At the Zero Lower Bound, as we have been since 2008, it does not lead to devaluation and it does not cause inflation.
This is accepted as "reality" by conventional economists. There are outliers who disagree, just as there are outlier climatologists who disagree with AGW.
Debunking zombie ideas is the purpose of this seed. I tried to gently repeat Krugman... but in the end, it's hard to avoid being direct. I don't mean to be rude, or harsh... but how can one be gentle and polite when saying, "No, my friend, the Earth is not flat."?
Petey,
Was De revolutionibus orbium coelestium a screed against those opposing heliocentrism?
This seed doesn't mention any of Krugman's ideas. It recaps Keynes and some of the straw-man arguments commonly used against Keynes.
As for the labor participation rate... Ummm.... It has nothing whatsoever to do with the seed. You might as well want Joe Biden's recipe for apple pie...
I think what Perrie brought up is a valid criticism . Mentioning one extreme of economic policy [Keynes] without mentioning the other extreme [Friedman] is less than half of the story . Discussing economics in a vacuum seems like a waste of time to me . But if that's what you want I'll be happy to shut up & go away ...
Petey,
I certainly do not want you to go away . The fact that you almost always show up in my economics articles tells me that the topic interests you.
You said somewhere that you had trouble getting beyond supply-and-demand. Well... if you have a good understanding of supply-and-demand, then you have already made an excellent first step toward understanding Keynes.
A steady economy has an equilibrium between supply and demand. Companies make stuff. They pay their employees for making the stuff. The employees buy the stuff. A steady cycle .
Occasionally, a comet slams into that steady economy. In 2008, a housing bubble that was not particularly nasty in itself burst. It was only when the bubble burst that the world realized how far the banks had gone in leveraging the mortgages of that bubble to make all sorts of stock-and-bond purchases.
Rapid de-leveraging was the equivalent of a bank run, ripping through the immense "shadow bank" system that had grown up in the absence of regulation. Business credit evaporated, including the revolving credit that many, many, many totally innocent companies use every day.
Those innocent bystander companies died, throwing their employees into unemployment. Fewer employees meant less pay. Less pay meant less stuff being bought. "Diminished demand", in econo-speak.
Because there was less demand... even the companies that had not died had to cut back on production. They laid off some employees. So... there were fewer end fewer employees, and less and less purchasing of stuff.
The steady economic cycle had become a vicious, inward, dying cycle, destroying the lives of millions of people who had done absolutely nothing wrong! (Meanwhile, not a single banker went to jail... but that's a different topic!
) )
The important thing to see in this story is that it is a cycle , feeding on itself. If, at some point, we could erase the words "less pay, so less stuff bought"... then there would be no follow-on "so other companies laid off employees..."
Keynes's idea was to break the negative spiral by injecting money.
Now... This is where Perrie's error comes in. (Perrie and many millions of others, of course!) If the economy were already suffering from inflation, then injecting more money would indeed make the inflation worse. The government would be on the horns of a dilemma, not knowing which would be worse: a continuing demand-insufficient recession, or galloping inflation.
But we do not have inflation. For the last several years, we have been "at the Zero Lower Bound". That means "very near to zero inflation". This is important, because zero inflation is accompanied by very low borrowing costs. (The reasons for that relation are clear, but not the immediate topic.)
Right now, US Treasury bonds, including 25-year bonds, pay less than two percent. In other words, the government can borrow money to inject into the economy at less than two percent! Considering that there is about one percent inflation, the US government can borrow at an effective rate that is roughly... zero.
Free money.
The US government could have free money to stoke the economy. Not doing this, as almost all competent economists now agree,iscriminally stupid.
But, sadly, we are governed by people who do not listen to the experts.
(A few days ago, Krugman wrote a column about Argentina, where there is inflation... and a budding recession. That column underscored the difference between Argentina's context and America's. It is not at all clear whether Argentina would suffer more from inflation or from a recession.)
Also... There's no free lunch. Keynes considered that when the economy is running correctly, the government should pay down the debt incurred in breaking the recession.
To put Keynes simply: the government should intervene to keep the economic cycle steady , adding money when the cycle stalls, and withdrawing money when the cycle is humming.
It's nothing more than "supply and demand"!
The whole point of this seed is to underscore the fact that Keynes is not considered "extreme" among economists. On the contrary, he is mainstream. Those who disagree with Keynes are the outliers.
We have a situation here that is very similar to climatology. The vast majority of climatologists agree on AGW, but climate policy is made by non-climatologists, including denialists.
There is very little debate today among independent economists about the means for managing a demand-insufficient recession. (Dissenting economists are almost exclusively employees of GOP/conservative think tanks.)
Unanimity among the experts does not always (often??) translate into policy...
(
Current economic policy ignores current economic thinking!
Don't you see the importance of that absurd situation?
Imagine each new doctor "inventing" treatments...
OK Bob , I will look over the details of what you said in more detail later . You said that Keynes is mainstream . Are you implying that Friedman's is the extreme theory ?
As to what you said about the cost of borrowing I expect that is correct BUT there has been an historic pattern in govt debt . The US goes to war and borrows money to do so . But when the war ends the government starts to pay back the federal debt . As far as I can tell that pattern does not appear to be being followed currently . Military expenses are down recently but the debt is still not being repaid . Is that a good idea ?
One more thing , here is Hayek's view of Keynes :
Petey,
I do not know of any "Friedman Theory", in the sense of a fundamental approach. He said many things on many occasions, but I do not know of any "theory" that could be recapitulated as I just did for Keynes.
That is not an easy question.
Military expenses are very Keynesian. They are "government intervention in the economy, propping up employment, and thereby building demand". So... cutting military expenses (or any other government spending) when the economy is fragile is a bad idea.
That said... I would vastly prefer repairing bridges to building F-35s.
And if the economy ever truly heats up -- you'll know it when salaries begin to rise significantly -- then we should indeed start paying down the national debt.
Keep in mind that there is no specific "defense debt". Pity 'bout that!
I think people would be outraged if they realized how much of the national debt was created to pay for a "conventional military" that is more powerful than all the world's other militaries combined... but which is incapable of defeating, or even fighting Daesh...
Don't get me started on military procurement! It drives me crazy!
Petey,
Competent economists do not consider Hayek to be an economist.
He said things about economics, but from what I have gleaned, his pronouncements are so much nonsense.
He is to economists what an alchemist would be to a chemist.
Bob ,
Nevertheless , when wars end there is a strong tendency to reduce military spending . That is the situation we are in .
No argument from me on that . Is that at the federal level or the local level ?
I've read exactly the opposite :
....
in an interesting exercise David Skarbek finds that Hayek is cited by other Nobel laureates in their Nobel talks more than any other Nobel laureate with the exception of Arrow. (The top six cite-getters are Arrow, Hayek, Samuelson and then tied in citations for fourth place are Friedman, Lucas and Phelps.)
It sounds like the joker in the pack is Keynes ... Apparently he does not concern himself with problems caused by the business cycle . Seems a bit too focused on unrealistic solutions ...
Petey,
Let's be clear: I do not pretend to be competent in economics, beyond the simplest basics. I read a lot, from many different economists... but I don't have the math to follow when they go that way.
I try to collect a consensus.
I have no personal opinion of Hayek. I have read none of his works, and probably would not be competent to judge them if I did. I have however observed how he is perceived in the econoblogosphere.
(Truth be told: I know very little about any of the topics that shape our world. A few hundred years ago, an educated man could "know everything"... but not today... I read widely... but I cannot claim "expertise" in anything at all. I think that the best we can do, any of us dilettantes, is to try to find multiple sources that are worthy of some confidence, and then synthesize their content.
All of our "knowledge" is second hand. The best we can do is to try to master our choice of what "first hand" we trust.)
The economists I trust do not consider Hayek to be a significant thinker in their field.
Feel free to ignore my advice. Choose to believe whatever you wish.
Bob,
Then please explain the Nixon years?
In theory you are right. A small influx of cash does stimulate the economy. In practice, since human nature is involved, usually if a little works, than more is better. But it isn't. Because we works with a mixed economy, and there are other forces at play. It's like giving an extra dose of chemo.
And no I don't expect you to agree with me when you don't. But from day one when we met, you know I will respectfully debate with you, which I enjoy, but that is what I expect back.. even if you disagree. I am not flat earthist and I did graduate with a BA in accounting and economics, so I might know a thing or two.
And for the record, I lean Keynesian, but the reality is mixed markets.
BTW neat graphic.
You said you read the seed carefully... so I won't insist on Krugman having insisted on context...
(D'ya see what I just did??
) )
"Keynesian economics" are very ordinary macro... except in an extraordinary context called "Zero Lower Bound". Which is where we are...
I agree completely. But that's a critique of politicians' application, not of the theory itself. As Krugman constantly insists, paying down the national debt, when the economy is humming, is an integral part of Keynes. If politicians choose to reduce taxes when they should be raising them, Keynes is hardly to blame!
As for Nixon... I don't see any particular lesson to be learned from him. Paul Volcker's action at the Fed, on the other hand, was pure Keynes... on the bad side. To kill runaway inflation, he jacked interest rates way, way up... provoking (as any Keynesian would have predicted) a serious recession. But he did indeed succeed in bringing down inflation... and it has never gone up since.
It has never gone up since. That's the interesting part...
I'm sorry if I offended you... but it's hard to find a polite, gentle way of saying, "Nope... you're completely wrong!"
I had taken care to insist on the ZLB context, but you just plowed on... Saying "inflation is just around the corner" is precisely the biggest error that can be made these days...
I totally agree. So what I think is that we are talking at each other. You with strict theory, me with the actual practice.
BTW one could argue thatVolcker's action were not wrong. Nixon went overboard with the cash flow, and althoughVolcker's actions broughteverythingto a screaming halt, as you pointed out, inflation never has gone up. So maybe painfulmedicine.
Certainly. I'm a Volcker groupie.
I think we know better how to manage things today, but he did what he had to, back then.
I believe that citations from other economists is some strong evidence of credentials . If you don't you are ignoring one of the most important ways that academics show interest in another's work .
Is this "economy" measured by GDP or by labor participation ?
Petey,
By whatever. The principle is independent of the measurement tool.
Personally, I think GDP is a terrible instrument. Labor participation is important, but I doubt that any single instrument is sufficiently significant. A basket of instruments in needed.
For example, the big debate these days is whether the Fed should raise interest rates. IMHO, the important indicator in this case is wages. As long as they are stagnant, there's slack in the labor market, and no reason to raise rates.
There's no universal instrument.
Bob from here :
IMO paying down national debt should not involve economic measures like GDP etc . When the debt gets to be large [on a per capita basis] and the expenditures [such as war] have waned , it is time to pay down debt . There needs to be some semblance of a budget being followed . Sure , the US can borrow any amount she wants from anybody [sort of like Paris Hilton] but that is no excuse to pretend there are no limits at all .
Why?
Debt in itself is unimportant. Debt servicing is important. It's a bit more than 10 % of the Federal budget right now. That's hardly excessive.
If you could borrow money for zero interest, would you refuse it?
Economics is not a morality play.
From the perspective of individuals who must pay back the debt I disagree . Having no willpower to avoid excessive debt is a character flaw IMO .