╌>

Eric Garner’s Daughter Posts Address of Cop at His Death

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  12 years ago  •  65 comments

Eric Garner’s Daughter Posts Address of Cop at His Death

One of Eric Garners daughters marked Christmas Day by spreading personal information about an NYPD cop who was present during the chokehold death of her father outraging officers still reeling from last weekends execution-style slayings of two policemen in Brooklyn.

Erica Garner tweeted that cop Justin DAmico was another officer that helped killed [sic] my dad, and directed her 5,000-plus Twitter followers to a Web page that lists addresses for DAmico and five possible relatives.

The information was viewed about 500 times before Garners stunning tweet was deleted following inquiries by The Post.

The move came less than a week after a gunman fatally shot cops Rafael Ramos and Wenjian Liu, following the shooters online post that said he planned to avenge the police killings of Eric Garner on Staten Island and Michael Brown in Ferguson, Mo.

It also came as cops were on high alert over dozens of copy-cat threats this week that have led to more than a half-dozen arrests.

An NYPD source said Erica Garners disgusting tweet poses grave danger to DAmico.

She clearly wants someone to go to the officers house and assassinate him in cold blood just like Ramos and Liu, the source said.

http://news360.com/article/272040653#


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Does this constitute "accessory before the fact" if the officer was killed in or near is home?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

John

One bad act does not justify another bad act (as you seem to agree)

This was irresponsible behavior.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I am sure there would be a huge commotion about her civil rights and imagine if she were stopped by a police officer for some legitimate reason

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    12 years ago

This was irresponsible behavior.

How do you describe the behavior of Justin D'Amico?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

John

So you agree her actions were irresponsible?

There are alsomany cops who know that some of their colleagues go past the limits of what is right and legal in dealing with the public, while the vast majority of sworn officers serve and protect with honor.

Until the general public realizes and accepts both of those points there will be unrest and distrust.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Bob

In my view and as I understand the facts, I would term his behavior as irresponsible, unacceptable in a public servant and likely illegal

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    12 years ago
For him and five "possible" relatives? If any of those people die at the hands of someone using this information, she should be held responsible. And if any of those people are not relatives, they should sue her for endangering their lives.
 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

jennilee

I agree

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    12 years ago

So... would it be reasonable to qualify the daughter's behavior as "irresponsible... and comprehensible"?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Bob

Comprehensible perhaps, but far from acceptable or action generally acceptable in a civilized society.

Comprehensible perhaps, but in my view likely criminally culpable if the officer is harmed - so if we are to comprehend why she did, I hope that she will be able to comprehend why she could be criminally responsible for harm to the officer.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Mickey

You seem to know a lot about what the police union is thinking. How do you come by that insight?

It sounds like you agree with what they are saying, but simply question the sincerity of why they are saying it. Is that right?

Thanks for the feedback and perspective

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    12 years ago

I agree completely.

Killing often leads to more killing. Vengeance.That's why it is better not to start.

And why it is all the more unacceptable to have the "defenders of public order" doing the starting.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

it is all the more unacceptable to have the "defenders of public order" doing the starting.

Equally unacceptable for those defending public order to be attacked/killed, but I get your point.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I'm going to fact check this; if it's accurate, then clearly such an action id wrong on a number of levels. Since I cannot find this story on any sources other than Fox, the New York Post and other such "news" outlets, I'll reserve my personal judgement.

When unarmed individuals of a particular demographic are killed by law enforcement, BUT, WHOSE SURVIVORS CONSISTENTLY FAIL TO HAVE THEIR DAY IN COURT LITERALLY, WHEN SUCH A PHENOMENON BECOMES EPIDEMIC IN PROPORTION, WHAT NAIVE OR BIASED FOOLS EXPECT ACCEPTANCE AND ACQUIESCENCE?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

Always appreciate your perspective

I agree that acceptance and acquiescence should hardly be expected in response to injustice, but this action is not an acceptable response in my opinion

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago
RIO,The acceptable response is a fair trial and a thorough investigation. When the acceptable response is denied institutionally, it leaves only an unlikely non-response or a litany of unacceptable ones.
 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

The "system", though flawed and unfair at times, is that we have chosen for our society. I agree that a solution in the legal system is preferable and it may yet come to that, but if what is alleged in this story is true - it is unacceptable in our society in my view.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

The "system", though flawed and unfair at times, is that we have chosen for our society.

Disagree; we did not CHOOSE a flawed and unfair system; the "blueprints" for fairness is written in the Constitution, but, over time, we have allowed for its bastardization at the hands of corrupt and self-serving legislators who can be bought by big money and elected by those to whom they pander on the basis of race, religion, gender and special interests.

"Let them eat cake" breeds deep resentment and frustration, even rage when it persists and becomes the "rule"; when victims aren't even allowed "crumbs from the table," they will over time, by necessity, find a way "to eat" -- to survive.

Improper and illegal behaviors are just that, but when what is just and fair is denied to a victim, what alternatives remain other than "take it or leave it," or, "do what seems necessary to survive."

It's too easy and all to common to blame the victim by demagoguery, stereotyping, propaganda and lie campaigns and playing to the willfully ignorant or abjectly stupid. And that is where we are today.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

No suggested anyone should eat cake, you are hyperbolizing

The legal system, including the grand jury, is what I spoke of and it is what was chosen by our society and it has flaws that need to be corrected

I am not blaming he victim, I think the officer should have faced charges and still think he might, but I also think this young woman should face charges as well if she did what is alleged and harm comes to the officer.

Improper and illegal behavior is indeed just that and regardless of the intentions the consequences of those illegal and improper behaviors should be faced by those who commit them.

And that is where we are today

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    12 years ago

"Thou shalt not kill" is pretty straightforward...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

No suggested anyone should eat cake, you are hyperbolizing

Not at all; the metaphor is on-target. When justice is denied, a "take it or leave it," "like it or lump it," no-viable-alternative attitude is expressed by the powers-that-be, in essence, the victims are "starved" of that to which they are legally entitled.

I am not blaming he victim, I think the officer should have faced charges and still think he might, but I also think this young woman should face charges as well if she did what is alleged and harm comes to the officer.

I agree, that, if the woman did what she is alleged to have done, she should be FORMALLY CHARGED/INDICTED and TRIED UNLIKE WHAT TRANSPIRED WITH THE KILLERS OF HER BROTHER ironic isn't it?

Improper and illegal behavior is indeed just that and regardless of the intentions the consequences of those illegal and improper behaviors should be faced by those who commit them.

If you re-read my comments, you will see we agree on that. But in a system where a local D.A. gets to call for a grand jury in a matter involving local law enforcement, there is an inherent conflict-of-interests, and that constitutes a "rigged" game.

And THAT is where we are today.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

I disagree with the aptness of your metaphor which I see as hyperbole, but I get your point

Until the law is changed, the process we have is the process we have

And I agree THAT is where we are today.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I'll accept that we have found a middle ground, RIO.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

Indeed my friend as always you perspective and feedback is appreciated and even when we do not 100% agree or 100% disagree, I learn from you feedback.

Thanks

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

RIO,

Indeed my friend as always you perspective and feedback is appreciated and even when we do not 100% agree or 100% disagree, I learn from you feedback.

Thanks

And I learn from you as well and respect anyone who, like yourself, challenges me honestly.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Like father, like daughter. Criminality runs in the family.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Like father, like daughter. Criminality runs in the family.

The conservative "mind" -- where complicated thoughts go to die.

When's the last time you did something stupid and irrational -- like you know -- when a bunch of cops murdered your unarmed father for depriving his city of a penny's worth of cigarette tax money then watching the trial that didn't take place even after the medical examiner declared dad's death a homicide?

If Garner's daughter in fact posted the address which she denies then she was both morally wrong and possibly criminally liable.

But these one-line-feel-good pronouncements are just as incendiary as what they purport to condemn.

Pour gasoline on the fire and make yourself feel good for waxing thoughtless rhetoric.

Let us know the next time you don't get "your day in court." Rant about it so someone can accuse you of reacting to a tragedy compounded by a rigged game.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

even after the medical examiner declared dad's death a homicide?

Leave it to a flaming liberal to misrepresent what happened :



So in a medical examiners report homicide just means one person intentionally did something that led to the death of someone else. It doesnt mean the death was intentional and it doesnt mean it was a crime.

Criminally negligent homicide, on the other hand, is a class E felony in New York State.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

It is a minor point and one that I am positive you are aware, but a homicide (death at the hands of another) is not always a crime and does not always lead to or require a trial, eg. justifiable homicide.

The simple fact that a coroner/medical examiner determines that a death was a homicide does not directly entail that it was murder.

By the way you point above about doing something stupid 0 is a very good point.

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    12 years ago

Was tweeting the information a rational thing to do...no.

Did she hack into the NYPD data base for the address....no.

Are names, addresses, previous addresses, age, phone number and relatives available online....yes.

Is she grieving the death of her Dad...yes.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Medical Examiner Rules Eric Garner's Death a Homicide, Says He Was Killed By Chokehold

...

...

Is it a homicide or not, Petey?

Petey wrote

homicide just means one person intentionally did something that led to the death of someone else. It doesnt mean the death was intentional and it doesnt mean it was a crime.

Homicide not a crime?

DEFINITION: " the deliberate and unlawful killing of one person by another; murder."

The medical examiner ruled Garner's death a homicide, indicating that his death was caused by the intentional actions of another person or persons; however, the designation of homicide by itself means neither that the death itself was intentional nor that a crime was committed. [27]

And that's why we have trials to determine whether the designation, in individual cases, constitutes if a crime was committed. By rigging the game, we never get to determine that.

Further

Pantaleo was the subject of two civil rights lawsuits in 2013 where plaintiffs accused Pantaleo of falsely arresting them and abusing them. In one of the cases, Pantaleo and other officers ordered two black men to strip naked on the street for a search and the charges against the men were dismissed . [46] [47] [48] [49]

And

The NYPD Cop Who Put Eric Garner In A Chokehold Has A History Of Allegedly Violating Black Men's Right

Read more: ...

Recall how Trayvon Martin and Michael Brown's pasts were used to "blame the victims.'

Turnabout is fair play.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Petey wrote

Try again . I did not write that . It was a quote from the article from Time . Your understanding of the terminology is faulty ... and inflammatory .

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

It is a minor point and one that I am positive you are aware, but a homicide (death at the hands of another) is not always a crime and does not always lead to or require a trial, eg. justifiable homicide.

Given the history of the officer involved, a trial was in order.

If Trayvon Martin's alleged past and Michel Brown's as well were somehow germane to their deaths, then the officer's past is fair game as far as intent/motive/predisposition in Garner's death.

A homicide is often adjudicated on such "minor points."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I know where the quote originated.

You apparently don't wish to address the rest of my comment.

You appear easily inflamed.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

I am not disagreeing personally, but the fact that the grand jury failed to find that murder or manslaughter took place, even though the death was found to be a homicide, implies that in the view of the justice system (flawed though it may be) a murder did not occur.

A homicide is often adjudicated on such "minor points."

Again my minor point, homicides are not all adjudicated in court only those determined to be murder or manslaughter.

I also agree with your point on germaneness (or non-germaneness) of past conduct should be the same for victim and doer.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Lynne

Is she grieving the death of her Dad...yes.

A great point, with which I agree 100%

But if harm comes to the officer as a result of her action (if it indeed occurred as it seems it did) then she is likely criminally liable is the point I made a while back

Thanks for the perspective and feedback.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

but the fact that the grand jury failed to find that murder or manslaughter took place, even though the death was found to be a homicide, implies that in the view of the justice system (flawed though it may be) a murder did not occur.

The prosecutor has not to my knowledge released the GJ transcript so we don't know what evidence was and was not presented, nor, in what manner.

Staten Island is one of the whitest communities in the U.S. and the inherent conflict-of-interests regarding local prosecutors and the police departments on which the regularly rely, together scream for a Special Prosecutor. And the video speaks for itself.

homicides are not all adjudicated in court only those determined to be murder or manslaughter.

And questionable non-indictments often sidestep such charges because of conflicts-of-interests.

There is an inherent conflict of interest in giving local prosecutors so much control over the decision whether to charge police for allegations of bias or excessive use of force and a compelling need for an independent special prosecutor to handle such cases from start to finish.

Trials are transparent, grand juries are opaque and secretive. When someone dies and there are unanswered questions, secrecy does not serve justice.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

What was or wasn't done has no bearing -A true bill was not delivered.

I am not saying that was just or the right decision, but it was the decision that we have.

Another grand jury could be convened, or a preliminary hearing held in the future but for now no determination of murder or manslaughter was made.

I am not arguing that a conflict interest may exist when police officers are involved in crimes, but at this point that is the system and until we change the system or it changes itself over time - that is what it is today.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

What was or wasn't done has no bearing

RIO,

I completely disagree; what was or wasn't done/presented to a GJ in a secret process, has every bearing on the outcome.

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA    12 years ago

RIO, I guess I'm trying to determine whether she'd be legally culpable since the info is usually public knowledge. Tweeting the information is not a crime. Even if she specifically meant for someone to take action, if done without her knowledge is it on her?

Most conservatives will decry, guns don't kill people, constitution protects speech, people need to be responsible for their individual actions and yet the latest threads seemingly hold "others" responsible for actions we've seen of late.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Sorry, but no amount of grief is excuse for a blatant attempt to incite violence against one cop and five other unassociated people. If one can't see that, our society may be doomed.Thanks for allowing me my rhetoric. The Constitution would be pleased.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Here is what was in your comment when I responded to it :

Homicide not a crime?

DEFINITION: "the deliberate and unlawful killing of one person by another; murder."

Try reading what was in the article I quoted . Your definition is nothing but semantics . Stop playing inflammatory games . Also stop adding to your comments after they've been replied to ...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

What are you doing about your brain inflammation ?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Mickey

Being the third man into a disagreement s not helpful

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Cerenkov

That is the main takeaway from this story for me.

The young woman is grieving, but made a poor choice and could (not likely) be held to account for that choice if the officer were killed or hurt because of her action.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Lynne

Your point is why I have said that she "could" be found liable as an accessory before the fact - it would not be a slam dunk case for sure.

Your second point is also true - no one but this young woman is responsible for any action that might result from the action that she took, in my view of course.

Thanks for the perspective and the feedback

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I didn't say it was excusable, in fact, I said, if in fact it happened, the opposite was the case. But I also gave you the context in which the alleged act occurred, and, in other comments, talked about the injustice of a rigged "legal process."

Garner's daughter has denied the account given by the media; thus, until such time if any she is indicted (ironic) and convicted, there's the assumption of innocence, and, if you're a Constitution strict constructionist, you have to apply the 6th and 14th Amendments to the adjudication of Garner's death.

Nor do we know what information was given to the GJ which was convened in Staten Island, a white borough with a large police officer resident population. Was the officer's racist history presented? Why hasn't the transcript been released?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Try reading what was in the article I quoted . Your definition is nothing but semantics . Stop playing inflammatory games . Also stop adding to your comments after they've been replied to ...

Try grasping the perspective I gave in conjunction with the homicide charge. Without a trial and transparency, we'll never know what level of homicide was involved. You're content to not know -- I'm outraged under the circumstances, that we may never know.

The prosecutor has not to my knowledge released the GJ transcript so we don't know what evidence was and was not presented, nor, in what manner the "prosecution" proceeded.

Staten Island is one of the whitest communities in the U.S. with a large number of police officer residents. Then, there's the inherent conflict-of-interests regarding local prosecutors and the police departments on which they regularly rely; together these facts scream for a Special Prosecutor. And the video of Garner's killing speaks for itself.

And the non-indictment makes one wonder ifinformation was given to the GJ regarding the officer's racist history a question (among others) that would be answered if the transcript was released.

There is an inherent conflict of interest in giving local prosecutors so much control over the decision whether to charge police for allegations of bias or excessive use of force and a compelling need for an independent special prosecutor to handle such cases from start to finish.

Trials are transparent, grand juries are opaque and secretive. When someone dies and there are unanswered questions, secrecy does not serve justice.

As for yelling "inflammatory," you're a real tinder box wanting information and asking relevant questions shouldn't set you on fire, rather, IT SHOULD BE DEEMED A QUEST FOR LIGHT RATHER THAN HEAT.

As for adding comments, I'll post the addenda separately. Since you scrutinize that thing so closely, whether separate or connected, you're reading them anyway aren't you?

You're willingness to accept the outcome of a rigged process burns me up you know like it inflames me.

OOOPS!

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

Would you agree that, generally, grand jury proceedings are secret and the basis of the decisions and the details of the evidence and deliberation are seldom released to the public.

We are in agreement on the unjustness of the grand jury decision in this case, but the whether all grand jury processes should be open to the public (during or after the session) is an entirely different question to be decided.

The applicability of the 6th (speedy, public trial, right to counsel) and the 14th (equal protection and due process) are the same in this case as any other, but since no indictment was returned no criminal trial will occur at this point.

The possibility of a federal prosecution and/or a civil litigation is however still quite real, though not an easy hill to climb either.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Would you agree that, generally, grand jury proceedings are secret and the basis of the decisions and the details of the evidence and deliberation are seldom released to the public.

I would but would quickly add that the reasons for secrecy are antiquated. And the inherent conflict-of-interests that I've noted, call for transparency, or, better yet, a process that forces recusal and the appointment of special prosecutors.

The applicability of the 6th (speedy, public trial, right to counsel) and the 14th (equal protection and due process) are the same in this case as any other, but since no indictment was returned no criminal trial will occur at this point.

While correct, that's a circular argument; the reasons for no indictment are hidden. Plaintiffs should be given their "day-in-court" as well as defendants.

While all states have provisions in their laws that allow for grand juries, roughly half of the states don't use them. Courts often use preliminary hearings prior to criminal trials, instead of grand juries, which are adversarial in nature. As with grand juries, preliminary hearings are meant to determine whether there is enough evidence, or probable cause , to indict a criminal suspect.

Unlike a grand jury, a preliminary hearing is usually open to the public and involves lawyers and a judge (not so with grand juries, other than the prosecutor). Sometimes, a preliminary hearing proceeds a grand jury. One of the biggest differences between the two is the requirement that a defendant request a preliminary hearing, although the court may decline a request.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

While correct, that's a circular argument; the reasons for no indictment are hidden. Plaintiffs should be given their "day-in-court" as well as defendants.

Question:

Are you advocating doing away with findings of probable cause? or the need for such?

Would sure as hell speed things along, but it would also give power to the government to charge for any reason at all, or no reason if it suits them.

The Grand Jury is guaranteed by the constitution no less, and is there to see to it that the government cannot charge a person of a crime without good reason. A preliminary hearings known as an arraignments were added as a procedural change later to speed things along, particularly when there is more than sufficient evidence to state that the accused committed the crime without taking away a citizens right to hear the charges that are being claimed against him. They are not adversarial in nature, they are but a formality actually.

You advocating that we go straight to trial against someone, or that a public outcry should be able to overrule the constitution and remove a persons rights to probable cause?

What are you arguing?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Are you advocating doing away with findings of probable cause? or the need for such?

No; I'm advocating doing away with the secrecy and the failure to release the transcripts.

but it would also give power to the government to charge for any reason at all, or no reason if it suits them.

It already has such power

"As a practical matter, a federal grand jury will almost always return an indictment presented to it by a prosecutor. This is the basis for Judge Sol Wachtler's famous saying that a prosecutor can get a grand jury to 'indict a ham sandwich.'" Solomon L. Wisenberg, " Federal Grand Jury Crash Course "

...

RE:

The Grand Jury is guaranteed by the constitution no less, and is there to see to it that the government cannot charge a person of a crime without good reason.

Would that not be an even stronger guarantee were the process transparent?

You advocating that we go straight to trial against someone, or that a public outcry should be able to overrule the constitution and remove a persons rights to probable cause?

What are you arguing?

I'm advocating that the GJ process be everything it is currently, BUT OPEN TO PUBLIC SCRUTINY EITHER FROM START TO FINISH, AND/OR, BE MANDATED TO RELEASE ALL TRANSCRIPTS WITHOUT EDITS OR REDACTIONS.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

Well, if the Grand Jury makes a presentment where the grand jury informs the court that they have a reasonable suspicion that the suspect committed a crime. (known as a "True bill") the evidence presented automatically goes to the defense in discovery. Without returning a true bill, the jury has rejected the charges filed so there will be no evidence to turn over. It is a protection for the accused.

It is a protection that has been extended to the jurors themselves and given the law that a juror cannot disclose what was said before the jury, grand juries are always held in secret.

From Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press ...

Grand juries summon witnesses and documents with subpoenas. Witnesses, including custodians of documents, report on the scheduled date not to a courtroom, but to a hallway outside the room where the grand jury is sitting. The witness must enter the grand jury room alone, without his or her lawyer. No judge presides and none is present. . . . Inside the grand jury room are sixteen to twenty-three grand jurors, one or more prosecuting attorneys, and a court reporter. . . . The witness is sworn, and questioning commences, all to the end of determining whether there is adequate basis for bringing a criminal charge. (Internal citations omitted.) (In re Dow Jones & Co., Inc.)

Grand jury proceedings have been held in secret since the 1600s. The secrecy rule, adopted from England, has become an integral some say essential part of the American criminal justice system. There is no First Amendment right of public access to grand jury proceedings. Participants, except witnesses, are forbidden from disclosing matters related to the grand jury, even after the grand jurys activities have concluded.

The U.S. Supreme Court in 1979 identified several reasons for maintaining such secrecy. First, without the assurance of confidentiality, many prospective witnesses would hesitate to come forward willingly, knowing that the people against whom they testify would find out about it; second, those who did come forward would be less likely to testify fully and frankly because they would be vulnerable to retribution and inducements; third, people about to be indicted might flee, or try to influence individual grand jurors to vote against indictment; and finally, it protects those who are accused, but not indicted, from public scorn. (Douglas Oil v. Petrol Stops Northwest)

It does go on to say.....

Before an indictment is issued, reporters may file a motion for access with the judge who is presiding over the grand jury, media attorney Jim Lake of Holland & Knight said. Post-indictment, the media may move to intervene, or become a party to the case, to assert the publics interest in disclosure of grand jury materials. In states like Florida, where courts are covered by the state open records law, journalists may request a copy of the transcripts if they were released to the defense during discovery, Lake said.

Alternatively, the press may simply ask to be heard without formally intervening. Los Angeles Times attorney Susan Seager of Davis Wright Tremaine recently tried to oppose the sealing of grand jury transcripts in the murder case against music producer Phil Spector, but was silenced by the judge who said she had no standing a position Seager disputes.

Its very clear under California law, and I would argue under the First Amendment in any court, that the press has standing to ask for grand jury [transcripts] to be unsealed once they become court records, Seager said.

As I understand it such requests have been made and hearings are being held, but without the records being presented to a court, the prosecution is under no obligation to release them. In the Mossouri matter, the records were presented to the court and were immediately released after the Grand Jury finished it responsibilities. The New York matter it never ever went to a court because the Grand Jury was an investigative jury, not a probable cause Grand Jury. Therefore the records were never court documents and the Prosecutor has no obligation to release them.

I understand the politics of it and the desire of certain people with political motivations to get a hold of said documents and rip them (and the prosecutors) to shreds to justify what ever they think should be right.

personally the rules are the way they are for a reason, and not every desire to know should be granted, particularly when that desire to know will compromise witness safety. Since we do have people that are calling for killings and more murders.

Sometimes absolute transparency is NOT a good thing.

If you think it is, then you think that revealing the cops address on the internet is a good thing, especially when there have been calls for his assassination.

That I cannot go along with, might as well as give everyone a license to enact their own justice, which is no justice at all.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

I would but would quickly add that the reasons for secrecy are antiquated.

Perhaps and I have no argument that the process needs to be reviewed, but is there also not a danger that people would be hesitant to com forward and testify before a grand jury if they knew that their testimony would be made public?

Throwing the baby out with the bath water is not the answer in my view

The accuser is not guaranteed a speedy trial, that guarantee rests with the accused.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

It is a protection that has been extended to the jurors themselves and given the law that a juror cannot disclose what was said before the jury, grand juries are always held in secret.

Due process concerns have yielded to goals of government efficiency and that's an affront to justice being served. The origin of a grand jury's function was to be a powerful tool for a monarch it's obsolete in that regard and transparency would not need to erode juror protection their names and faces could be kept private in an otherwise transparent procedure with severe penalties for any individual or entity compromising that tenet.

I'm not advocating "absolute" transparency. Identities and related information could be supplanted with aliases or generic replacements. That would in no way rig the game in the way a conflicted prosecutor could.

There's no reasonable expectation of justice when a prosecutor should recuse himself but does not.

That's the one element that potentially renders a given GJ, a dog and pony show.

Even the appearance of impropriety destroys credibility.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

but is there also not a danger that people would be hesitant to com forward and testify before a grand jury if they knew that their testimony would be made public?

Witnesses are subpoenaed in trials they do so in such public forums all the time. GJ secrecy can prevent a witness, hostile or otherwise from putting on-the-record, what needs to be known in the interest of justice.

The accuser is not guaranteed a speedy trial, that guarantee rests with the accused.

I believe I put "day-in-court" in quotation marks, I intended it to be metaphorical.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

T he origin of a grand jury's function was to be a powerful tool for a monarch it's obsolete in that regard

From the Legal Information Institute , Cornell University Law School;

Grand juries are a holdover from hundreds of years ago, originating during Britain's early history. Deeply-rooted in the Anglo-American tradition, the grand jury originally served to protect the accused from overly-zealous prosecutions by the English monarchy.

Obsolete?

Grand Juries

The grand jury assesses whether there is adequate basis for bringing a criminal charge against a suspect. The grand jury is a kind of buffer or referee between the Government and the people. United States v. Williams, 504 U.S. 36, 37 (1992).

The Supreme Court takes the opposite view.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A Mac

It seems when I point out an inconsistency in a point you make, you term it a circular argument.

The simple fact is that there is no constitutional guarantee to a speedy trial for anyone except the accused.

I am not sure that I agree that the need for secrecy is totally antiquated, but there are solid reasons for at least some revisions to that policy I will agree, but you should also agree that the lack of secrecy will deter some from providing open and honest input to the grand jury process for fear of retribution after the fact.

Thanks for all the feedback, I have thoroughly enjoyed it and managed to broaden my view of this particular case and grand jury proceedings in general

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

What view does the SCOTUS take regarding a prosecutor's conflict-of-interests? We don't have a monarchy, and, given the technological means of "putting-it-out-there," I'd prefer we see all the cards out on the table (UNLIKE WHAT WE HAVE WITH BROWN AND GARNER). In those situations, the de facto local "monarchs," the local prosecutors, because of the privacy aspect, are rightly suspected of having rigged the outcomes.

Fiat justitia ruat caelum is a Latin legal phrase , meaning

" Let justice be done though the heavens fall. "

The maxim signifies the belief that justice must be realized regardless of consequences.

If anyone has a problem with that, spell it out for me.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

AMac

In atheorectical sense yes, but the practical matter is the reality of today (not what should be) and that is what I mean by "has no bearing"...

The grand jury process is currently a secret process, in general, that is the reality

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

The simple fact is that there is no constitutional guarantee to a speedy trial for anyone except the accused.

I said I used it metaphorically, i.e. victims and/or their survivors, in questionable circumstances, should not be denied the right to a transparent investigation and deliberation process that might give them a "day-in-court," a trial in the light of day to determine innocence or guilt of an alleged perpetrator.

the lack of secrecy will deter some from providing open and honest input to the grand jury process for fear of retribution after the fact.

If that be the limiting factor, all trials should themselves be closed and private why one system of inquiry and not another?

We disagree my friend.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

We disagree my friend.

And that is okay, thanks for all the back and forth

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

But the one problem is, and it takes, me at least, right back to the start, there are some people that would like the power to open and expose anything they can for their own ends.

I understand Fiat Justitia, I respond with the Clean Hands Doctrine.

Under the clean hands doctrine, a person who has acted wrongly, either morally or legally - that is, who has 'unclean hands' - will not be helped by a court when complaining about the actions of someone else.

At this point in my view the issue is Res Judicata given the intentions of the askants or the interests of the potentially harmed. Politics should never come before jurisprudence.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

You forgot the stupid emoticon with the shit-eatin grin . Here : Grin.gif

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Well thanks to both of you (Mickey and Petey) for sharing your valuable perspective on this issue.

 
 

Who is online



JohnRussell


69 visitors