Irrational Exuberance In Action: The 5% GDP Growth Number Is A Total Fraud
December 24, 2014
Look! Just in time for Christmas! That Obama guy finally got our economy back on track! Now get out there and spend, spend, spend!
At least thats what the media wants you to believe .
The U.S. economy roared into overdrive in the third quarter as consumer and business spending fueled the biggest expansion in more than a decade.
Gross domestic product grew at a 5 percent annual rate from July through September, the biggest advance since the third quarter of 2003 and up from a previously estimated 3.9 percent, revised figures from the Commerce Department showed today in Washington. The median forecast of 75 economists surveyed by Bloomberg projected a 4.3 percent increase in GDP.
Sounds amazing, right?
Its also too good to be true. But journalists arent known for their economic prowess. And theyre fully invested in proving Obamas success.
So heres the dirty little secret they arent telling you.
The Commerce Department fudged the numbers by inserting the entire years worth of ObamaCare spending into 3rd quarter GDP. Presto! Instant 5% growth!
Back in June, when we were looking at the final Q1 GDP print , we discovered something very surprising: after the BEA had first reported that absent for ObamaCare, Q1 GDP would have been negative in its first Q1 GDP report, subsequent GDP prints imploded as a result of what is now believed to be the polar vortex. But the real surprise was that the ObamaCare boost was, in the final print, revised massively lower to actually reduce GDP!
In laymans terms, they initially put ObamaCare in to make Q1 look less bad, then took it out when nobody was looking after they decided to blame their woes on the polar vortex.
Fast forward 6 months, and with a small uptick in actual consumer spending (probably due to those falling oil prices, for which, btw, Obama cant claim even one iota of credit), its time to reinsert the ObamaCare factor to really pump up the numbers.
Heres Tyler Durdens handy chart showing the Q3 GDP breakdown:
As you can see, without ObamaCare the consumer spending numbers would still be abysmal.
In short, two-thirds of the boost to final Q3 personal consumption came from, drumroll, the same ObamaCare which initially was supposed to boost Q1 GDP until the polar vortex crashed the number so badly, the BEA decided to pull it completely and leave this growth dry powder for another quarter. That quarter was Q3.
Our economy grew because the government forced 9 million people to buy health insurance.
What are they going to do for an encore? Force 9 million people to buy a car from Government Motors?
Because otherwise, the stock market rally thats going on right now is the very definition of Irrational Exuberance .
Oh well. As the saying goes, pay no attention to the man behind the curtain.

The reports on the radio have been that business spending is actually down by 1.2% over the last quarter despite the holidays. And consumer spending is entirely fueled by lower gas prices allowing consumers to spend more. The DJ reached a new historical high at over 18,000 for the first time in history, but the other indexes showed either modest growth or an actual decline. The European markets were uneven and the Asian markets were showing volatility in the range of up 1.5% to down 2%.
The volume was only slightly larger than the thickness of scrooge's paper napkins. IE. the value is total emotional speculation.
The brokers were looking for it to go over 18,000 and made it happen, but it's not real. They expect it to retract over the next few days to a more realistic figure.
But it does illustrate, the market is and can be manipulated to suit whatever the brokers want it to show.
Not a good sign at all.
Micky, I'm happy you feel the Economy is soo much better than it ever was, most think otherwise, and I still see the shuttered businesses everyday as I drive by. Besides, I was just reporting what was on the radio today.
As far as being lying fucks? do you really want to go there with as many proven lies the other side has spewed also?
I don't think the article was intended to go that way. And besides it's Christmas, couldn't we be generous for one day of the year?
What would it hurt?
Thanks Randy, you kill me. LOL
Mousie aspires to the Pulitzer Fiction prize.
Reality is whatever you want!
Up is down.
In is out.
If you wish it hard enough, Tinker Bell will live!
Yeah , the Dept. of Commerce is headed by someone whose very name expresses the value of the economic growth : Penny Pritzker .
That would be in China ... "Sweet & Sour Banks"