Harvard’s President Stops an anti-Israel Boycott
Harvards President Stops an anti-Israel Boycott
By Alan M. Dershowitz, The Gatestone Institute, December 19, 2014
The Harvard University Dining Service has been rebuffed in its efforts to join the Boycott Movement against Israel. A group of radical anti-Israel Harvard students and faculty had persuaded the dining service to boycott Sodastream, an Israeli company that manufactures soda machines that produce a product that is both healthy and economical. But Harvard President Drew Faust rebuffed this boycott and decided to investigate the unilateral action of the Harvard University Dining Services.
I have visited the Sodastream factory and spoken to many of its Palestinian-Arab employees, who love working for a company that pays them high wages and manufactures excellent working conditions. I saw Jews and Muslims, Israeli and Palestinians, working together and producing this excellent product.
The Sodastream factory I visited was in Ma'ale Adumima suburb of Jerusalem that Palestinian Authority leaders acknowledge will remain part of Israel in any negotiated resolution of the conflict. I was told this directly by Palestinian president Mohammad Abbas and by former Prime Minister Salam Fayyad. Moreover, in all the negotiations about borders and land swaps, the Palestinians have acknowledged that Ma'ale Adumim will remain within Israel's borders.
Accordingly, although the factory is in an area beyond the Armistice lines of 1949, it is not really disputed territory. Nor does it pose any barrier to a two-state solution. Moreover, Israel offered to resolve its conflict with the Palestinians in 2000-2001 and in 2008, but the Palestinian Authority did not accept either offer. Had these generous offers been accepted, the dispute would have ended and Ma'ale Adumim would have been recognized as part of Israel. So the Palestinian leadership shares responsibility for the continuation of the conflict and the unresolved status of the area in which Sodastream operates. Punishing only Israeland Israeli companiesfor not resolving the conflict serves only to disincentivize the Palestinian Authority from accepting compromise solutions.
The students and faculty who sought the boycott of Sodastream invoked human rights. But it is they who are causing the firing of more than 500 Palestinian workers who would like to continue to earn a living at Sodastream. As a result of misguided boycotts, such as the one unilaterally adopted by the Harvard University Dining Services, Sodastream has been forced to move its factory to an area in Israel where few, if any, Arabs can be employed. This is not a victory for human rights. It is a victory for human wrongs.
I have no doubt that some students and other members of the Harvard community may be offended by the presence of Sodastream machines. Let them show their displeasure by not using the machines instead of preventing others who are not offended from obtaining their health benefits. Many students are also offended by their removal. Why should the views of the former prevail over those of the latter? I'm sure that some students are offended by any products made in Israel, just as some are offended by products made in Arab or Muslim countries that oppress gays, Christians and women. Why should the Harvard University Dining Serviceor a few handfuls of students and professors get to decide whose feelings of being offended count and whose don't?
In addition to the substantive error made by Harvard University Dining Services, there is also an important issue of process. What right does a single Harvard University entity have to join the boycott movement against Israel without full and open discussion by the entire university community, including students, faculty, alumni and administration? Even the president and provost were unaware of this divisive decision until they read about it in the Crimson. As Provost Garber wrote:
"Harvard University's procurement decisions should not and will not be driven by individuals' views of highly contested matters of political controversy."
Were those who made the boycott decision even aware of the arguments on the other side, such as those listed above? The decision of the HUDS must be rescinded immediately and a process should be instituted for discussing this issue openly with all points of view and all members of the university community represented. The end result should be freedom of choice: those who disapprove of Sodastream should be free to drink Pepsi. But those who don't disapprove should be free to drink Sodastream.
Economic boycotts should be reserved for the most egregious violations of human rights. They should not be used to put pressure on only one side of a dispute that has rights and wrongs on both sides.
*Alan Dershowitz, Felix Frankfurter Professor of Law, Harvard Law School (emeritus) and author of Terror Tunnels: The Case for Israel's Just War Against Hamas (Rosetta Books 2014)
Tags
Who is online
55 visitors

This is reported by The Gatestone Institute. According to one of the members of NT The Gatestone Institute is, in his words: a biased, anti Muslim, anti Palestinian, anti-Democrat , pro-Israel "think tank" catering to the opinions of right wing islamophobes.
Not only that, the NT member says that by posting stories by The Gatestone Institute I confuse neo con propaganda with something more objective or fair minded. So, in other words, this story has to be bullshit because my critic says that it must be propaganda.
So lets hear HIS biased side of the story, or at least a fair and honest report of what happened, that differs from the facts reported in this article. Lets see how fair minded HE is.
I see the President of Harvard University preventing a group from interfering with commerce.
But then, I'm not shooting the messenger, right?
Thanks, however, for your encouragement, guys. I'm going to start publishing as many articles from The Gatestone Institute as I can.
I see no prevention of Freedom of Speech, blue.
Just because a minority element "spoke" and decided that Soda Stream should be removed from the dining hall does not mean that element had the right to force either its opinion or decision on the rest of the campus.
The removal of Soda Stream impacted far more than the sensibilities of the anti-Israel group. There are in all likelihood political and economical factors as well as the obvious one which is not everyone enjoying the use of Soda Stream was allowed to discuss the issue and vote on its removal.
These BDS idiots playing at changing the world while attending institutions such as Harvard and other colleges and universities have no grasp of the realities of operating big business... which is what colleges are. While they are planning their next protest march about wanting their college loans forgiven at the expense of taxpayers who loaned it to them, they need to take time out to study the economic and real-world impact of trying to ban and boycott everything the Israelis have, do and will continue to contribute to the comfortable, better world we all enjoy because of the Jews and Israel.
What's your damage, blue? I didn't say they shouldn't "have the right to have their say." What I said was they need a dose of reality to balance out their fairy tales.
I'd love to see you address the rest of that paragraph instead of the just the first three words of it.
I have a sodastream. I don't understand your comment. And what part of the product do you consider crap? I am holding a sodastream V8 berry blend splash in my hand and it looks just fine and is certified kosher.
I don't believe that I have seen unbiased commentary for a real long time. Perhaps the last Huntley-Brinkley broadcast.
I was wondering if you could possible cite any bias free commentaries that exist today?
@aRTieA...
Congratulations! Enjoy one for me!
Their flavor packs use artificial sweetners, color dyes and other chemicals. It's crap.
They provide a variety of flavoring options for their products. This is common practice in the industry. They also include natural flavors - and from their web site:
Made from cane sugar and other all-natural ingredients, new SodaStream Sparkling Naturals make great-tasting `better for you sodas. Sparkling Naturals contain no artificial flavors, no artificial colors and no artificial sweeteners, and do not contain any preservatives, making them a perfect, sparkling, natural soda alternative for the entire family.
So I am wondering if you have choice why you think all their stiff is crap. Is it just sodastream or do yoiu have the same opinion about all carbonated beverage companies?
LOL...
We will have to agree to disagree on that one as I don't think you did. Didn't see a single comment about the miserable world they would live in if they truly refused to use anything invented or manufactured by Israelis.
The natural flavors could be healthier than the rest of the crap they are selling. I don't know what they are offering at Harvard. Much if what they sell is processed junk packaged as a healthy alternative. I don't drink Soda pop I think your better off drinking water and eating the whole fruit and vegetable.
They have the right not to use the Sodastream machineto show their solidarity with their cause-they really don't have a right to prevent others from making their own choice. Free Speech is the right to say what want (within bounds, more or less), not to prevent others from deciding on their own what they think and want.