╌>

(Supreme) Court Rules Police May Make "Reasonable" Mistakes in Law

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  12 years ago  •  20 comments

(Supreme) Court Rules Police May Make "Reasonable" Mistakes in Law

The Supreme Court was forgiving of a police officers misunderstanding of the law Monday, ruling that it did not invalidate a traffic stop that led to a drug bust.

The justices ruled 8 to 1 that a North Carolina officer made a reasonable mistake when he pulled over a car with a broken brake light, which led to the arrest of Nicholas Brady Heien for attempted trafficking in cocaine.

It turns out that North Carolinas antiquated law requires only one functioning stop lamp, not two. But that doesnt mean that the search of Heiens vehicle violated the Constitutions protection against unreasonable searches and seizures, Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. wrote for the majority .

To be reasonable is not to be perfect, and so the Fourth Amendment allows for some mistakes on the part of government officials, giving them fair leeway for enforcing the law in the communitys protection, Roberts wrote.

He said the court previously has ruled that searches based on mistaken facts are not automatically unlawful, the limit being that the mistakes must be those of reasonable men.

Roberts added: But reasonable men make mistakes of law, too, and such mistakes are no less compatible with the concept of reasonable suspicion.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor was the lone dissenter. The decision means further eroding the Fourth Amendments protection of civil liberties in a context where that protection has already been worn down, she wrote.

Heien was in the back seat, a friend driving, when they caught the attention of Surry County Sheriffs Sgt. Matt Darisse in April 2009. Darisse thought the driver, Maynor Javier Vasquez, looked very stiff and nervous, so the officer followed for a bit. When he noticed the right brake light was not working, he pulled the car over.

He was writing a warning when he became more concerned. The two gave inconsistent answers about where they were going and acted suspiciously, according to Darisse. The officer asked if he could search the car, and eventually Heien, who owned the vehicle, agreed. In the side compartment of a duffle bag, Darisse found a baggie containing cocaine.

Heiens conviction was thrown out by a North Carolina appeals court. Since the states law did not require two working rear lights, the court reasoned, Darisses justification for the stop was objectively unreasonable.

The North Carolina Supreme Court reversed that decision. Other courts around the country are divided on the questions that arise when an officer makes a mistake of law.

Heien and those who supported his case pointed to what Roberts called the well-known maxim that ignorance of the law is no excuse.

They contend that it is fundamentally unfair to let police officers get away with mistakes of law when the citizenry is accorded no such leeway, Roberts wrote.

But he said the argument had only a certain rhetorical appeal.

Just because mistakes of law cannot justify either the imposition or the avoidance of criminal liability, it does not follow that they cannot justify an investigatory stop, Roberts wrote. And Heien is not appealing a brake-light ticket; he is appealing a cocaine-trafficking conviction as to which there is no asserted mistake of fact or law.

Roberts stressed that the exception applies only to reasonable mistakes and said an officer can gain no Fourth Amendment advantage through a sloppy study of the laws he is duty-bound to enforce.

Justice Elena Kagan, joined by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, filed a concurrence to emphasize that point. That means the government cannot defend an officers mistaken legal interpretation on the ground that the officer was unaware of or untrained in the law, she wrote.

The case is Heien v. North Carolina .

http://news360.com/article/270645376#


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

The case is Heien v. North Carolina and the basis for the reversal was summed up as -

But reasonable men make mistakes of law, too, and such mistakes are no less compatible with the concept of reasonable suspicion.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

It has been long standing legal policy that a police officer does not have to be trained in the law to do his job.

the claim here is that the search and subsequest charging for drugs was impermissable becasue the idea that the cop used for the stop was a misapplication of the specific law in the jurisdiction in question.

IE., the officer had no right to pull the car over, therefore everything that transpired was a miscarriage of justice based upon the officers lack of specific legal knowledge.

Hogwash.

Such a ruling would throw reasonable suspicion out the window as justification of police action for anything.

Rendering the police powerless unless there is a plain violation of law.

Our legal system cannot work under that severe limitation. An investigating officer must be allowed to go where the investigation takes him.

That being said, one must be ever vigilant to abuse of such authority. if abuse is apparent then the abuse must be corrected, if no abuse is intended or found to have happened then the results of plain investigation establishing a crime has been committed must stand.

Don't want to get caught? don't commit the crime. Would it have been an issue if there wasn't any drugs being hidden? no, they would have received their warning and be sent on their way.

It was their own actions that alerted the officer that something more was happening, at that point he has the legal right to inquire further.

yes it's a borderline case, and the review is good. but it does remind us to be vigilant on both sides because officer discretion can and is often abused.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

Writing alone in dissent, Justice Sonia Sotomayor criticized her colleagues for giving the police far too much leeway. One is left to wonder, she wrote, why an innocent citizen should be made to shoulder the burden of being seized whenever the law may be susceptible to an interpretative question. In Sotomayor's view, an officers mistake of law, no matter how reasonable, cannot support the individualized suspicion necessary to justify a seizure under the Fourth Amendment.

I am left to wonder at times how, exactly, the courts define reasonable.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

"giving them fair leeway for enforcing the law in the communitys protection,"

THIS is what I want to see explained. What is "fair leeway" and how far does it go?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

NowhereMan

Thanks for the feedback and in depth perspective on the issue

Appreciate it

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Steve

Why?

He was unaware that one tail light working was sufficient and therefore made the traffic stop and the ensuing actions in good faith

That seems to be the ruling

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I would say that certainly meets the definition of "fair leeway"

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Something like what a reasonable person would deem "fair leeway" may be what they mean, but I am not a lawyer so I am only guessing

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

I understand what the ruling says. I also believe that the stop was a fishing expedition. But, that is only my belief.

But all of that aside, where did the cop get the idea that two lights were required?

I am still left with the question of how police are to enforce the law if they are not required to have knowledge of the law? True, no one knows all of the law, but you would think cops should have knowledge of those laws which they would be required to routinely enforce.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

Steve

Perhaps, as the SCOTUS determined, it was ignorance of the law on the part of the officer. It seems a most unusual law to me, since there seem to be two taillights on a car for a reason.

I agree that law enforcement officers should be knowledgeable of the law and I imagine that even the officer in question, knew quite a few statutes. He simply was unclear on this one.

Had the case been about an appeal of the citation for the broken taillight it would have been thrown out immediately, but the good faith mistake on the part of the officer was deemed a reasonable error by the court, and the reasonable suspicion which lead to the search was also ruled legal.

I get your opinion and I am sure others agree, but the court ruled the officer acted in good faith

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

The scope of this verdict in Heien v. North Carolina is not as menacing or as far reaching as the media portrays it to be. At issue was "unreasonable searches and seizures" and probable cause involving a "broken brake light."

The first thing to remember here is that the driver of the car owned by Nicholas B. Heien, (who was asleep in the back seat) gave consent for the search. This is to say that the police still cannot conduct a search of your vehicle or property without consent...and in the case the driver had the legal option of either consenting or refusing a search.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

A P

Good points

The stop itself was deemed a reasonable error due to lack of knowledge by the officer and the search was with the owner's consent, thus the evidence discovered is admissible.

Thanks for the persepctive

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    12 years ago

Rendering the police powerless unless there is a plain violation of law.

Without a plain violation of law, powerless police are preferable IMHO.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

"Reasonable Suspicion" cannot be removed from the equation, but the management and interpretation of what is reasonable will always be the challenge

Powerless law enforcement is not a desirable outcome in any circumstance in my view

Thanks for sharing your perspective

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    12 years ago

Powerless law enforcement is not my goal. Powerless police when there are no broken laws to enforce is totally different.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

I got that

I stand by

Powerless law enforcement is not a desirable outcome in any circumstance in my view

Reasonable suspicion to investigate is a key part of law enforcement and public safety in my view

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

What is the limit though?

We can't have police officers breaking down doors on any premise now can we?

Too many people will wind up dead both officers and citizens.

So what is reasonable suspicion, and at what level is action on that suspicion allowable.

Right now the borderline is any excuse to give rise to interaction with a citizen allows the officer to start an investigation, and any interaction with a police officer is an "Investigation" for the purposes of "Law Enforcement"

Cops are NEVER off duty.

This is becoming a source of contention in this country given the well publicized serious abuses and the sheer number of abuses reported daily.

Where do we draw the line?

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

N M

You example has nothing to do with this decision, this decision is about "making reasonable mistakes in law", i.e. doing something where an unclear understanding of what the law allows is reasonable. Your example is the opposite of that.

Where do we draw the line?

On a case by case basis, I guess - in this case the court decided that the mistake (stopping the car for one tail light being out) was a reasonable and acceptable mistake for the officer to make.

The search was with the consent of the car owner so there is no issue of overly aggressive police tactics there.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

The reply didn't have anything to do with the decision, it had to do with your statement...

Reasonable suspicion to investigate is a key part of law enforcement and public safety in my view

Maybe a bit off the article topic but on point with the statement. just one of those many ways a topic can stray away from specific topic but still be topical.

I didn't reference aggression in any way, was just wondering where the line should be drawn between absolutes on both sides.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    12 years ago

We can't have police officers breaking down doors on any premise

Sounds aggressive to me

And this decision has nothing to do with that sort of behavior.

There arefew, if anyabsolutes in life and there are certainly no absolutes in law enforcement, hence the case by case requirement and review to insure that "reasonable suspicion" is indeed reasonable.

In this case, once the stop was made (which the court has held to be legal), the officer asked for and received permission from the owner of the vehicle to search it, thus discovering the drugs. That the search was legal is indisputable, once the stop was deemed legal.

 
 

Who is online








55 visitors