╌>

The N-Word, Huck Finn, and You

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  hal-a-lujah  •  12 years ago  •  32 comments

The N-Word, Huck Finn, and You

I justfinished the audio version ofThe Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, by the legendary Mark Twain, and I was curious about how many times the N-word was uttered, so I googled it. Turns out it was written 219 times throughout the book, although it felt like more, to be honest.

A few years ago, an effort was made to republish the book substituting the word "slave" for the 219 N-words. I remember the controversy when it was current, but a fresh listeningofthe book reallyunderscores howdisturbing the language is.Literally every character in the book uses it multiple times, and it is quite clear that it isn't so much of a racial slur as it is a common descriptor ofa race that is considered sub-human. You get somewhat desensitized to the word when it is repeatedas often as it is in this book, but the context it is used in is what is really frightening. Anyone who tries to claim that slavery in America is misunderstood, and thatit was really more of a situation of indentured servitude, or that the majority of whiteslave owners treated their slaves with respect or compassion,needs to go back to writings of that period and rethink their position.

This article is old (1/05/11), but it is still interesting.

Nigger appears 219 times in The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn . A new version of the book aims to reduce that number by 219. Thats right. Mark Twains Adventures of Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn: The NewSouth Edition has replaced the word nigger with the word slave. The expurgated version comes to your local bookstore in a month or so.

Who is leading the charge to de-slur the most controversial classic of American literature? Some school board in South Carolina? Sarah Palin? Christine ODonnell? William Bennett? Liberty Universitys English department? The ACLU?

Not hardly.

Mark Twains Adventures of Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn: The NewSouth Edition , which splices both books into one, is the brainchild of Auburn University professor Alan Gribben, a perfectly respectable Twain scholar. His motivation? Years of teaching the novel to students from the South and personal experiences with the book in his new home state of Alabama. My daughter went to a magnet school and one of her best friends was an African-American girl, says Gribben. She loathed the book, could barely read it.

That got to him, but what really pushed him to recast Twains book was his involvement with Big Read Alabama, when he was asked both to write an introduction to the version that Alabamans would be reading and to travel around the state giving talks about the novel itself. He was shocked to discover how many teachers could not teach Huck Finn because of the racial slurs but also how many general readers were turned off by all 219 uses of the N-word. Astonishingly, it appears that John H. Wallaces claim that Huck Finn is the most grotesque example of racist trash ever written is actually being taken seriously.

So, Gribben decided to help create a version of the book that would make it acceptable to school boards and book clubs. He had elided nigger, and Injun goes the way of the buffalo.

To his credit, Gribben is aware that his scholarly reputation is on the line. Already, some high-profile Twain scholars have decried the book, likening Gribben to Thomas Bowdler, who bleached Shakespeares dirty scenes for more starchy readers. What Gribben sees as mainstreaming, others see as censorship.

And it does raise some absolutely fascinating questions.

What do Gribbens edits of Twain say about the sanctity of art? For example, if viewers suddenly find the David s penis offensive, would it be okay to deface the sculpture to make it less graphic? Violence against women is also abhorrent. Are we going to start altering rape scenes to make them less disturbing? On the other hand, is the real value of Twains book found in the repeated uses of the N-word or in the overall message of the book? If Huck Finn is primarily a repudiation of racism, isnt getting more people to read it a good thing? On yet another hand, isnt reading the new version with the N-words removed whitewashing the degrading connotation of slavery? Doesnt it make slavery seem less disgusting, therefore making the book more racist?

In his provocative book Nigger , Harvard law professor Randall Kennedy uses Huck Finn as a springboard for his study of the N-word in American culture and why censoring it can be dangerous:

I am addressing the contention that the presence of nigger alone is sufficient to taint Huckleberry Finn or any other text. I am addressing those who contend that nigger has no proper place in American culture and who thus desire to erase the N-word totally, without qualification, from the cultural landscape. I am addressing parents who, in numerous locales, have demanded the removal of Huckleberry Finn from syllabi solely on the basis of the presence of the N-wordwithout having read the novel themselves, without having investigated the way in which it is being explored in class, and without considering the possibilities opened up by the close study of a text that confronts so dramatically the ugliness of slavery and racism.

I get what Gribben is trying to do; Ive taught Huck Finn . I know its difficult. Those of us who devote our lives to books want people to experience the liberating power of great literature and courageous ideas. I love the way literature can be malleable, the way it can, as Wallace Stevens might say, find what will suffice. But, Kennedy is right, and thats why this new book rankles.

Look, we all hate the word. Twain grew to hate the word. Kennedy hates the word. I hate the word. Every time I typed it in this column I deleted it before going back and typing it again, angry I had to type it twice. But, this solution reminds me of treating the most obvious symptom instead of the lurking, chronic disease itself. This new book may be more of a feel-good pharmaceutical than an honest confrontation. And we dont even have the list of scary side-effects yet. For me, the Neosporined Huck Finn is not the right remedy for the injuries of slavery and racism; its a band-aid that doesnt cover the wound.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
What do Gribbens edits of Twain say about the sanctity of art? For example, if viewers suddenly find the Davids penis offensive, would it be okay to deface the sculpture to make it less graphic? Violence against women is also abhorrent. Are we going to start altering rape scenes to make them less disturbing? On the other hand, is the real value of Twains book found in the repeated uses of the N-word or in the overall message of the book? If Huck Finn is primarily a repudiation of racism, isnt getting more people to read it a good thing? On yet another hand, isnt reading the new version with the N-words removed whitewashing the degrading connotation of slavery? Doesnt it make slavery seem less disgusting, therefore making the book more racist?
 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago
It's ridiculous leave it the way it was written and tell those that have no respect for freedom of speech to kiss your rump.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Yes, this was commute fodder. However, you are wrong if you think that audio books are less satisfying than reading. I've listened to hundreds of them, and while I freely admit that the book versions of some of them are preferable, most of the audio versions are far more entertaining than what my brain can come up with in terms of character voices and inflection.

To be clear, I'm not taking a position that the verbiage should be changed. I'm just saying that I'm not someone who is easily offended, but listening to the language of this era is shockingly awful. Even if every instance of the word were changed, it would still be awful, but the N-word has a bite to it that really drives the cruelty of the language home.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
I also listened to the audio version of 12 Years A Slave, and you're right. Both books treat African Americans as equally subhuman. It's not the word "nigger" that is oppressive, it's the white man's perception of them as nothing more than property. When one dies, it's as unfortunate as a car dying, but so long as no whites were injured there is nothing to bemoan beyond the loss of some valuable property.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Huck Finn shows us the monster in the mirror. It won't be less of a monster just by covering our eyes and refusing to look at it.Calling blacksn***ers was a minor aspect of the way in which they were dehumanized and a reminder of why a wound cut so deeply takes so long to heal.To truly understand the racial issues of the present, we need to understand the past. Leave the book as it is.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
I do agree, but I also understand the dilemma of introducing this language in school systems. This isn't a word that any school administrator wants to deal with outside of the context of reading material, but how many snarky, immature students are going to push it by using it freely in the halls or on the playground, not mature enough to know what it feels like when their black peers hear it. How do you punish kids for using language you order them to read and report on? Many educators will deal with that by not including it in their curriculum.
 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    12 years ago
I am sure that most school kids are aware of the word. They hear it in music and movies, on social media, and when talking to each other.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
Huck Finn and many other books depicting this era have been in schools since the books were written and it hasn't been a problem. Kids can easily be taught that they are not free to harass or demean others simply because a character in a book or movie did it. The educators are there to educate and history is what it is. Educators don't seem to have a problem in fully recounting the Nazi atrocities against Jews because they present the Nazis as evil and Jews as victims. Do the same thing here.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Of course they are aware of it, just like they are aware of every curse word in the book. But how often do they get an opportunity to use it with impunity, because it's part of the curriculum? Would you want to be the principal that has ten angry African American parents on hold, wanting to know why their child has to sit in a classroom while the white kids around them discuss the subject of slavery by using the word "nigger"?
 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

I thought Twain was an abolitionist, and wrote the book to highlight the plights of the slaves. At least, that is what I was taught. It was supposed to be a lesson against slavery.

Too bad we can't ask him.

As far as use of the word, it has a historical context-- Teach it that we find this offensive, this book is against slavery, and this is NOT how to behave.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
In an era where laws now enable the stop and frisk of a person on the street because they are black, and nightly news coverage of black men being choked, beaten and shot to death by police, and with prisons filled disproportionately with blacks who committed the same crimes as their free white peers, and riots breaking out all over the country to protest white people getting away with the murder of black people - I can certainly see why some degree of censorship of overtly racist literature might be considered prudent.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago
Black people have been abused by police and white people have gotten away with murder for 400 years. The only thing different is it's being caught on tape so white people can now see what black people have been complaining about. Good!There's a big difference between a book that depicts racism and one that advocates it. If educators are too stupid to know the difference or are unable to expose evil without promoting it, then they shouldn't be teaching. I doubt a single incident of police brutality or criminal conviction was due to a cop or juror reading Huck Finn or anything else assigned in a classroom. Don't whitewash history like a mindless made for TV movie.
 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

History teaches us about the past through facts of what actually happened, in hopes of understanding the rights, wrongs , mistakes and successes of those that preceded us.

Literature does the same thing except on moral grounds rather than factual ones.

To change it afterwards to make it more platable to a certain body of people is to change it's point.

Which is to educate.

Have we become so politically correct that we cannot look at our own societal history honestly?

Are we so morally corrupt that we cannot stand the lessons of our society's past?

Those books were written to establish the moral and societal history of a certain period of time in this country.

If we cannot deal with our own history from an honest perspective both morally and factually, we are doomed to fail as a society.

This is sad and wrong beyond all bounds of sanity.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
If we could bring back Samuel Clemens from the grave today, it would take very little conversation before the word "nigger" came out of his mouth. That isn't necessarily to say that he is a racist, it is to say that it's a word that has undergone a radical transformation over time with respect to appropriateness. His usage of that word in his literature wasn't intended to be a future historical reminder of how inappropriate things used to be, it was simply a snapshot in time. For all we know, his vision of the future would never include socially and economically successful black people, much less a black president.

There have been so many incredible authors since his time. Maybe it would be best to start exposing impressionable young minds to works of literature that are less controversial in their format, and leave the works that don't recognize the N-word as socially unacceptable to college curriculum.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Funny you should say that, since two of the main characters in this book are American rapscallions who pretend to be English royalty as part of their scamming operations.This is a novel intended to explore the depth of innocent juvenile creativity inspired by the mind of Tom Sawyer. It's not George Orwell.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
In the end, Jim the "runaway ni**er" is set free - but only because his massa died and put it in her will for him to not be resold into slavery.Tom and Huck knew Jim was officially free, but didn't tell Jim or the folks who had him locked up so they could find his owner and fetch the $200 reward they thought was on his head. While Tom and Huck genuinely wanted Jim to be free, they wanted the process of freeing Jim to be an adventure even more. Because of that, Jim had to endure months of being chained up in a room filled with rats, snakes and spiders - put there by the Tom and Huck to make the adventure more interesting.In the end, their adventure almost got them all killed, and Tom took a bullet in the leg that almost killed him. The whole time, Jim was the only person in the story worthy of consideration as a decent human being. Yes, he was freed in the end, but the story makes no mention of the fate of his wife and two kids who were torn from him long ago and split up and sold to different white people. Really, it's a bitter sweet story with some sickening undertones.
 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

Alan Gribben was not the first one to alter "Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn". John Wallace, a teacher at the Mark Twain Intermediate School in northern Virginia, published a version of "Huck Finn" about 20 years ago that used "slave" rather than "nigger". It didn't go anywhere.

Suffice to say, 'Adventures of Huckleberry Finn' is already the fourth most banned book in the US. I am against any and all censorship including the PCsanitizing of any book.

Where do we stop? To Kill a Mockingbird and Of Mice and Men, both use the word "nigger". Do we allow for the expurgation of those books too?

To allow it even once is not permissible.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
I agree, no book should be banned, including the Anarchist Cookbook. I also would agree that it may be time to replace certain literature in public school curriculum with less controversial works. If kids want to read them, or if parents want their kids to read them, then get familiar with your public library and insist that the original versions be shelved there. There's an enormous amount of worthy literature out there, and it only grows with time. With racial relations being what they are at this moment in history, who needs a reason to increase the tension in the buildings you trust to keep your kids safe in?
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Lol - you just had to go there.
 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    12 years ago

As far as use of the word, it has a historical context-- Teach it that we find this offensive, this book is against slavery, and this is NOT how to behave.

41.gif 41.gif 41.gif 41.gif 41.gif

Yes, he was freed in the end, but the story makes no mention of the fate of his wife and two kids who were torn from him long ago and split up and sold to different white people. Really, it's a bitter sweet story with some sickening undertones.

Yes! It is "literature". It is "life truer than life". Two boys wanting adventure and getting in over their heads. A world that isn't always kind and sweet...

Without Dowser's "context", a modern teen-ager cannot understand the book, but given that context, it will surely speak to most of them. That's why it is a "classic"...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    12 years ago

If we cannot deal with our own history from an honest perspective both morally and factually, we are doomed to fail as a society.

Very true.

If we construct a fantasy past, to fit what we would like our ancestors' society to have been -- regardless of what that past really was -- then we cannot understand the facts that we meet. We are our ancestors' descendants, as they really were, and we will always do best to try to know them as fully and factually as possible.

"Understanding" them does not mean "agreeing with" them. But we have a better chance of understanding ourselves if we understand our past.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    12 years ago

This is a novel intended to explore the depth of innocent juvenile creativity inspired by the mind of Tom Sawyer. It's not George Orwell.

41.gif 41.gif 41.gif

Yay!!

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Not once in the entire reading of this book did I get the impression that the book was against slavery. Slavery was just part of the landscape. There was no talk or allusions towards the inherent immorality of owning a person as property. You got the sense that Jim "earned" his freedom, not that every slave should be free.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
"READING ''Huckleberry Finn'' one comes to realize all over again that the near- burned-out, throttled, hate-filled dying affair between whites and blacks is still our great national love affair, and woe to us if it ends in detestation and mutual misery."Ain't that the truth.
 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

Hal, did you feel sorry for Jim? I know I did. I felt that his life was ruined by his two "friends", just because he was a slave.

In that case, it helped me to see slavery up close and personal, and how it affected someone that I thought was special. You are right, the only character in the book that behaved well was Jim, the lowly slave.

In which case, Twain made his point. Jim and all the other slaves were human beings, undeserving of such treatment.

Really, it's a bitter sweet story with some sickening undertones.

Yes it is. For the time it was written, it was a lesson about the evils of slavery-- how power corrupts even the innocent, and those sickening undertones were a glimpse of society at that time. I'm glad that we're a bit past that-- although I wonder how much.

As far as Tom being shot in the leg and almost dying-- well, you can't do wrong and get by. He deserved it for treating his friend Jim so badly!

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
I feel it did not go far enough to draw a conclusion that slaves are human beings that are undeserving of their treatment. At the end, the doctor who treated Tom had some good things to say about Jim, who risked his freedom to come out of hiding and help the doctor deal with Tom, but it felt like it pained him to say anything good about a black man - like such a situation bordered on the paranormal. Then all the white folks who heard this bizarre revelation decided that it would only be right to treat the runaway ni**er with some compassion, so they quit beating him and locked him away with bread and water. I'm just not getting a sense of moral epiphany here.
 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

Perhaps it isn't illustrated in the book as well as it is in our own hearts... I'm sure there are other classics that could be used to illustrate the point that slavery was a horrible thing-- Uncle Tom's Cabin was also reflective of the times, a classic, and illustrated the evils of slavery.

I don't feel that Huckleberry Finn should be banned. It certainly reads a lot better than some of the books I had to read as 'required reading'. But, it is still a very good book that offers a glimpse of many moral delimnas that could expand a young person's thought processes.

I've read a lot of books that were contemporaries of Huckleberry Finn , just because that was what my grandparents had in their bookshelves. Girls of the True Blue comes to mind. Yet no one else but me has likely read that one, by an obscure author. Twain's lessons were always more palatable than most books of the time, simply because they were funny-- but he also told his stories with a moral twist, irony, bitterness, and contrasts. Many of his books and short stories make one ponder a LOT of things. Again, Was It Heaven? Or Hell? is one of those stories.

Did you know that Twain was a close friend of Grant? He helped support him during Grant's final illness, giving him money to live on, and then, rallying the sales of Grant's book after his death, so that Julia, Grant's wife, would have something to live on... Twain used to sit next to Grant on the front porch of their mountain home, where the air was cleaner for Grant to breathe, and smoke a cigar, blowing the smoke on Grant to comfort him, at Grant's request. I can't find the picture that I want to show their friendship, but this illustration will have to do:

2778_discussions.jpg?width=550

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Twain was a wealthy and highly successful business man of his day. I think that would help explain his reluctance to go too far in defense of abolition. Slaves were a large part of how the rich got rich. It would be like Mitt Romney writing a book, where the underlying theme is how the wealthy need to do more to lift the poor out of poverty. They may dance around themes like this is in their own terms, but generally speaking it's empty rhetoric.
 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    12 years ago

So, you don't like Mark Twain/Sam Clemens and want to ban his books?

Clemens didn't own slaves. He made his money by writing-- he worked for it. Maybe the people that bought his books or bought the magazines that had his stories in it had slaves, but he didn't. So, if he didn't own slaves, how are his writings that illustrated the evils of slavery empty rhetoric? And one must always consider one's audience, when writing something for publication. Perhaps he couldn't go further, and people still buy his works.

He died old, alone but for one daughter, having out-lived the rest of his family. He was sad and bitter at the end.

I think it is really hard to apply today's moral standards to those people of the past. It's easy to say that Elizabeth I was NOT the merciful ruler that everyone thought she was, (torture was common, burning at the stake was acceptable punishment for heresy, etc.) but given the circumstances under which she lived, she was.

I feel that if you teach Twain's works as a part of a larger historical backdrop, the book holds up well. If not, then it is, on the surface, a despicable depiction of the use of a bad term.

BTW, my Grandmother called people of African-American descent Darkies. Does that mean that my Grandmother was a bad person, or a product of her times? (born in 1891, tended to by a servant who had been a slave.) Just because we know better now, doesn't mean we've always known better...

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Ban his books? Absolutely not. I'm just interpreting what I read, and I do see merit in selecting less controversial literature for educating young impressionable minds, simply because there is so much of it to choose from. Let the public libraries and book stores be the source for things like this.

As far as Clemens goes, I don't see him as being any more racist than his contemporaries, nor do I see him as the poster child for abolition. I also doubt that he would want to be seen as anything he wasn't. He did not own slaves, but the high society that he was a part of relied on slavery every bit as much as the one percent relies on tax loopholes today.

Clemens was much more than an author, by the way. He was extremely successful in the printing and publishing field, as well as the field of investing. His writing was not the major source of his wealth. He made a fortune in the development of the printing press, which at that time was about as important of an invention as the personal computer is to our generation.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   seeder  Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Btw, my grandpa called them "nigras". It is what it is, I don't fault him for it now, although it always made my eyes pop open when I heard him say it as a child. One hundred years from now, people may be aghast that we called people who fix our toilets "plumbers". Who knows what the future has in store.
 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    12 years ago
If we could bring my grandmother back (and I wish I could) she would refer to an African American as a colored person. Others would refer to them as negros, niggras, or blacks. We cannot go back in time and change the way people used words. Nor should we. Do we have to also change the name of Scarlett's Mammy?
 
 

Who is online








55 visitors