If Elizabeth Warren is So Anti-Wall Street, Why Does She Support the Ex-Im Bank?
December 15, 2014
Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) has a populist reputation of being anti-Wall Street. Last week, she nearly threatened to shut down the government because the Omnibus bill would repeal a section in the Dodd-Frank financial regulation bill that passed in 2010.
She gave a passionate speech on the Senate floor calling for her colleagues to oppose the government spending bill unless the provision was removed.
Democrats don't like Wall Street bailouts. Republicans don't like Wall Street bailouts. The American people are disgusted by Wall Street bailouts.
And yet here we are, five years after Dodd-Frank with Congress on the verge of ramming through a provision that would do nothing for the middle class, do nothing for community banks, do nothing but raise the risk that taxpayers will have to bail out the biggest banks once again...
Shes right to say that opposing Wall Street bailout is a transpartisan issue.
Im no fan of Wall Street bailouts.
FreedomWorks strongly opposed the $700 billion TARP bailout during the Bush administration. We stayed true to principle. Because we, in no way, believe that its okay for the government to give taxpayer dollars to big banks and corporations that made bad decisions.
One can say that the Tea Party movement gained momentum after the big Wall Street bailouts. Many people in the Occupy movement also took issue with the big bankers getting bailed out by Main Street. Elizabeth Warren has even taking credit for creating much of the intellectual foundation for what they [occupiers] do.
However, the Tea Party and Occupy movements often disagreed with each other on the right tactics and solutions.
As a libertarian, Im more likely to agree with the Tea Partiers who believe that big government and big business go hand and hand. You want to reduce corporate welfare and handouts? Then, reduce the size and scope of government.
I tend to disagree with Elizabeth Warrens approach. Its too big government for my tastes. If politicians are in bed with big corporations, I sense that giving government more power will only escalate the problem.
However, Im able to recognize we have the same end goalno more taxpayer-funded bailoutseven though our proposed solutions are different.
Though, I have to question: just how anti-Wall Street is Elizabeth Warren, actually?
For someone who constantly rails against corporate handouts, its surprising to learn that shes a supporter of the Ex-Im Bank.
A spokesperson for Elizabeth Warren told Bloomberg News in an email:
Senator Warren believes that the Export-Import Bank helps create American jobs and spur economic growth, but recognizes that there is room for improvement in the banks operations. She looks forward to reviewing re-authorization legislation if and when it is introduced.
FreedomWorks opposes the Ex-Im Bank because it loans out taxpayer money to big politically-connected corporations and banks.
Its not just groups on the right who are opposed.
Ralph Nader has said that the left and right must come together to end the Ex-Im Bank.
Senator Bernie Sanders (I-VT) called it corporate welfare at its worst in 2002. Rep. Alan Grayson (D-Fla.) has said the same. Then-Senator Barack Obama said , the Export-Import Bank that's become little more than a fund for corporate welfare during the campaign trail.
Yet, Elizabeth Warren backs the corporate welfare bank.
She even said , "The American people didn't elect us to stand up for CitiGroup during the recent Omnibus debate.
True. But this is odd since Citigroup is one of the greatest benefactors of the Ex-Im Bank.
The Heritage Foundation writes :
The No. 1 federal insurance program was the Export-Import Bank, with Wells Fargo and JPMorgan Chase both receiving more than $3 billion in such aid and Citigroup and Bank of America receiving more than $1.5 billion in taxpayer backstop insurance. (Remember, this doesnt include TARP money.) [Emphasis mine.]
Where is Elizabeth Warren standing up against corporate welfare when you need her?

She is a poser.
She talks a lot but when it comes down to it the true colors are shown. Just like Pelosi talks out against NSA spying then kills the bill that will stop it.
I wouldn't say I an anti-wall street but I am certainly against welfare and bailouts for wall street. I am pissed Bammy and Holder didn't go after a single person for the collapse. I am pissed more was not done to stop another collapse and now by "partisanship" they have ever scaled back the few rules that were put in place...and here you have the "anti wall street" champion voting for corporate welfare. She is a poser and the following she has are the ignorant who listen to her lies and either don't pay attention to, or pardon her actions.
Maybe she evolves 96. You know that is the new term for "lies" when it is politically convenient, or should I say politically beneficial.
You know, I believe it was Stalin or one of those Utopians who said tell them what they want to hear, because winning is the most important thing and once you win you just do what you want.
It's hilariouos how even Wall Street's biggest enemy can be twisted into Wall Street's bestest buddyby people who have nothing better to do than complain about everything, while offering no solutions whatsoever and muttering that government needs to be small enough to drown in a bathtub.
Well fair is fair. Name a couple of people on the left who have shown the outrage since or before the torture report came out publicly to the world who have shown the same outrage for all the innocent children who have been killed by some guy playing a video game in Colorado.
I think quite a few people have shown some outrage about Wall Street not having a single conviction, but what about the members of Congress who said they didn't see a single problem with giving all those loans to people who didn't qualify and thought it was a bad idea to scare the people.....
Government needs to be big enough to protect us, not big enough to rule over us.
Senators Vitter and Sessions
Billion Dollar Corporation GE is mega supporter of the Democrat Party. GE makes large profits from the Ex-Im Bank. Therefore Senator Warren supports EX Im.
Tiptoeing around the CoC, I see.
Douchebaggery knows no limits...
Not so pointless...these policies are as much to blame as the wall street crooks.
How about Ron Paul and his kid. Actually all Libertarians were against the bailouts, you just don't pay attention.
Freedom Works is a right-wing bullshit purveyor.
Educate yourself before being the shill for an organization with a euphemistic name that sounds patriotic but is neocon.
Obviously you accepted the headline without knowing the realities.
Come on Amac. Obama himself said EX-IM was "corporate welfare". Of course, that was before he became president. The EX-IM bill protects corporations in foreign countries with our tax dollars and encourages them to move manufacturing out of the US.
In fact, the bank is a conduit for corporate welfare that primarily benefits multi-national corporations, the top 10 of which profited from 75 percent of Ex-Im financing in FY2013. These major beneficiaries include Boeing ($91 billion market capitalization); General Electric ($267 billion); Bechtel (2013 revenues: $39.4 billion); and Caterpillar (2013 sales and revenues: $55 billion).
Its tough to convince Congress or the public that such titans of industry cant manage to access private financing, especially when more than 98 percent of all U.S. exports receive no Ex-Im subsidies. Consequently, proponents are painting the bank as the salvation of small business.
In fact, Ex-Im provides export financing for about one-half of 1 percent of Americas small businesses, according to calculations by Mercatus Center economist Veronique de Rugy. The fraction of smaller businesses that do receive aid is artificially inflated by the banks expansive definition of small, which includes firms with as many as 1,500 workers, as well companies with revenues of up to $21.5 million annually. Even the banks own annual report shows it consistently fails to achieve the congressionally required level of authorizations for small businesses.
Proponents claim that financing deals for multinational corporations benefit the small businesses that operate as suppliers. That assumes that the economic activity subsidized by Ex-Im would not occur absent bank financing. But U.S. exports hit a record-high $2.2 trillion in 2013, up from $1.4 trillion five years ago, reflecting no shortage of private export capital. Moreover, several of the largest beneficiaries operate financing subsidiaries of their own.
Finance costs are only one among a variety of factors that affect a foreign purchasers choice of supplier. Availability, reliability and stability all play significant parts in purchase decisions. U.S. firms are certainly capable of competing successfully without corporate welfare.
To the extent that ExIm does finance deals that the private sector supposedly snubs, taxpayers are justified in questioning whether they should be saddled with risk that private investors deem unacceptable. It is also difficult to reconcile bank officials assertions that they alone assist higher-risk exporters but still manage to offer competitive rates and generate profits.
In some cases, ExIm financing actually puts small businesses and U.S. workers at a disadvantage by providing overseas competitors with billions of dollars in financing at artificially low rates. Recently, for example, the bank approved $694 million in financing for U.S. equipment to develop an open-pit iron ore mine in Australia (owned by the countrys richest woman). The deal was consummated despite warnings from the United Steel Workers, the Iron Mining Association, and all four senators from Minnesota and Michigan that the subsidies would jeopardize thousands of U.S. mining jobs.
The closer the expiration deadline nears, the more insistent will advocates claims become that ExIm is necessary for small business and a sound investment for taxpayers. The facts say otherwise.
In reality, the bank is little more than a conduit for corporate welfare. Although a select group of American businesses do profit from the subsidies, their good fortune is not whats best for the nation as a whole. Rather than recommit to the governments risky and inefficient finance scheme, lawmakers should focus on reducing tax and regulatory barriers to exports.
Wall street journal estimates this corporate welfare will cost US taxpayers 2 BILLION this year
Posting what this government agency is SUPPOSED to do is ridiculous. Especially when we can see what it is actually doing.
I did not take a position; I stated the history and purpose of the entity itself.
If conservatives are so opposed to CORPORATE WELFARE, THEY SURE DON'T VOTE THAT (ALLEGED) IDEOLOGY INSTEAD THEY TAKE THE MONEY FROM THE CORPORATE LOBBYISTS, TAKE OUT LEGISLATION FROM BILLS THAT PREVENTS THE RIGHT OF WALL STREET BANKS TO RISK SAVERS' ASSETS AND GET BAIL OUTS WHEN THEY LOSE THOSE ASSETS UNDER THREAT OF SHUTTING DOWN THE GOVERNMENT!
Be critical of your own as well as others.
Actually, the only ones that voted against it were conservatives and Libertarians. Granted enough Republicans who are neither conservative or Libertarian voted for it to pass it, and I am not happy about removing the regulations either. As usual, we are getting screwed by the DUOPOLY. Things are the way they are because that is the way BOTH sides want it.
Libertarians voted against it. What's to criticize? (I don't call Republicans "my own"
)
In one of the comments I made here, I suggested that Senator Elizabeth Warren quit the Democratic party as it is no different than the Republican party...except in rhetoric as they are both beholden to the monied interests that control them.
At any rate, I came across this article in HuffPo entitled; Elizabeth Warren Attacked By Club For Growth For Supporting Export-... and in it found these two interesting paragraphs;
Warren's office gave the same statement to .Bloomberg in July. Liberals once decried Ex-Im as a corporate welfare agency, since a tremendous amount of the bank's business assists just a handful of very large companies, including Boeing and General Electric. While some continue to criticize the agency, including activist Ralph Nader and Rep. Alan Grayson (D-Fla.), nearly all Congressional Democrats have closed ranks in defense of the agency. Former Rep. Barney Frank (D-Mass.) and Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) have both said they think the issue will help Democrats win over big business.
Politics is quid pro quo or give and take. In this case, Warren had to cede to the wishes of the majority of Democratic party in regards to the Ex-Im Bank. The nature of the political beast often forces people to compromise on one thing in order to gain on another.
While the poorly educated and ignorant may see Warrens' actions as a surrender of her idealisms, such is not the case.
You just can't admit the government policy of forcing banks to give housing loans to people who couldn't afford them was the primary reason for the meltdown. It is you who have nothing to offer due to your lack of objectivity. If I am the all purpose anti-government then that would make you the all purpose government whore.
It really is that simple and really is sad some can't handle the truth.
You should be asking yourself why no one was even indited over the crash. Sure the Dems put on a good show but that is all it was. WTF difference does it make who Obama ordered to distribute our tax money to financial giants that just trashed our economy?
That is fundamentally incorrect; the banks bet on failed mortgages, broke them up into pieces and invested the pieces in derivatives and knew if tanked, they would be bailed out, being deemed "too big to fail."
General Electric
Top Recipients
$351,340
$1,994,000
LOBBYING: $12,480,000 (2014)
REVOLVING DOOR
87 out of 119 General Electric lobbyists in 2013-2014 have previously held government jobsTOP ISSUES LOBBIED, 2014
MEMBERS WHO OWN GENERAL ELECTRIC SHARES: 72
...had the government not pushed bad loans the banks would not have had so many failed mortgages to bet on in the first place, Would they? Sorry. There is no way to shirk the governments blame in this clusterf*ck. I am not saying they deserve all the blame. Just the blame for being very foundation of the meltdown in the first place.
Former employees of subprime mortgage lender indicted by Cuyahoga County grand jury
4 Indicted in $10 Million Subprime Mortgage Fraud
Feds charge Bear pair with fraud over $1.4bn sub-prime collapse
Not quite that simple, 96.
Twenty-five people at the heart of the meltdown ...
...
I stand corrected. However, considering the damage it is laughable you could only find 3 examples, even of these three, one was prosecution by state not fed. I do admit it is nice to see at least a few people were charged with something...Not so comforting considering the number of people charged though.
Karl Rove will rot your brains.
Get current Warren-bashers! You're running with the demagogues. It's bad enough you spread lies, BUT THESE ARE OLD LIES THAT YOU KEEP ALIVE!
LOL so they are 60 repub and 40 dem this year, the couple years before it was the opposite. GE is very good at keeping both parties in their pocket. You won't get an argument from me on that point.
You said there were none and you Warren has been grossly mischaracterized in this thread. Are we having a discussion or a demagoguery-fest?
I'm not the one who stated the GE was a Democrat subsidiary. I simply corrected the record.
More on the Meltdown.
Thank you for proving my point that the government laid the foundation for the meltdown.
From your article:
Bill Clinton, former US president
Clinton shares at least some of the blame for the current financial chaos. He beefed up the 1977 Community Reinvestment Act to force mortgage lenders to relax their rules to allow more socially disadvantaged borrowers to qualify for home loans.
In 1999 Clinton repealed the Glass-Steagall Act, which ensured a complete separation between commercial banks, which accept deposits, and investment banks, which invest and take risks. The move prompted the era of the superbank and primed the sub-prime pump. The year before the repeal sub-prime loans were just 5% of all mortgage lending. By the time the credit crunch blew up it was approaching 30%.
George W Bush, former US president
Clinton might have started the sub-prime ball rolling, but the Bush administration certainly did little to put the brakes on the vast amount of mortgage cash being lent to "Ninja" (No income, no job applicants) borrowers who could not afford them. Neither did he rein back Wall Street with regulation (although the government did pass the Sarbanes-Oxley Act in the wake of the Enron scandal).
Senator Phil Gramm
Former US senator from Texas, free market advocate with a PhD in economics who fought long and hard for financial deregulation. His work, encouraged by Clinton's administration, allowed the explosive growth of derivatives, including credit swaps .
In 2001, he told a Senate debate: "Some people look at sub-prime lending and see evil. I look at sub-prime lending and I see the American dream in action."
According to the New York Times, federal records show that from 1989 to 2002 he was the top recipient of campaign contributions from commercial banks and in the top five for donations from Wall Street. At an April 2000 Senate hearing after a visit to New York, he said: "When I am on Wall Street and I realise that that's the very nerve centre of American capitalism and I realise what capitalism has done for the working people of America, to me that's a holy place."
He eventually left Capitol Hill to work for UBS as an investment banker.
Others
Christopher Dodd, chairman, Senate banking committee (Democrat)
Consistently resisted efforts to tighten regulation on the mortgage finance firms Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac . He pushed to broaden their role to dodgier mortgages in an effort to help home ownership for the poor. Received $165,000 in donations from Fannie and Freddie from 1989 to 2008, more than anyone else in Congress.
Of course corrupt wall street folks followed, and took advantage of, this lead. I think that would pretty much be expected don't you?
dennis,
We have agreed on this many times but when an intentional or inadvertent mischaracterization is posted, I will correct it.
I also said I stand corrected, but I don't agree on Warren being grossly mischaracterized.. BTW that comment was for Hal, the comment thanking you for showing the government was responsible for the foundation of the meltdown was for you. (with exerts from your article) I am really going to have to try to remember to put names on replies.
When I claim a mischaracterization has occurred, I always give the specifics and a correction.
No problem with remembering to put names it's an open forum.
dennis,
As always, I advocate public elections no corporate, union or private money! And Boobus americana needs to get off its dead ass and vote on election day and stop voting race, religion, gender and special interests.
The 2014 mid terms had the lowest turnout in the last 42 years.
Disgraceful!
Things are the way they are because that is the way BOTH sides want it.NOT TRUE
This is no longer true. Yes we are to blame for some of it but not to blame for politicians rigging the game after they got elected. How may times have you voted for someone who did not keep a promise. My answer is every time. These politicians know they have stacked the deck so that now only the rich and corporate/MIC connected can get elected and can do whatever the hell they want after the election.
This problem is a symptom of a government hat has grown out of control.
If it weren't for the fact that we are offered two puppets produced from the same corporate mold I would agree with you.
The 2 party system has made laws making it nearly impossible for a third to emerge and this was done decades ago. I fear it will take more than votes to change this.