NYC cops preemptively uninvite de Blasio to their funerals
December 13, 2014
The situation between New York City police and the Mayors office has clearly reached a critical point. While they have disagreed on several things in the recent past, there always seemed to be some level of cooperation remaining, or at least the willingness to maintain a public patina of such when the cameras were turned on. But after Bill de Blasios response in the wake of Eric Garners death, it seems that citys finest have had enough. A police union in the Big Apple has asked their members to sign a waiver stating their wishes that Hizonor refrain from attending their funeral if they pay the ultimate cost in the line of duty .
I, as a New York City police officer, request that Mayor Bill de Blasio and City Council Speaker Melissa Mark-Viverito refrain from attending my funeral services in the event that I am killed in the line of duty, the waiver states.
Due to Mayor de Blasio and Speaker Mark-Viveritos consistent refusal to show police officers the support and respect they deserve, I believe that their attendance at the funeral of a fallen New York City police officer is an insult to that officers memory and sacrifice.
Officers can download the form on the PBAs Web site and drop off a signed copy to their PBA delegates.
The mayor traditionally attends funerals for fallen officers.
This is deeply disappointing, the mayor and the council speaker said in a joint statement.
Incendiary rhetoric like this serves only to divide the city, and New Yorkers reject these tactics.
Its interesting that the Mayors office would choose to refer to this action as incendiary rhetoric while refusing to even address the concerns of the officers and their leadership after he essentially threw them under the bus. Yes, we all know that the Mayors wife is black, but standing in front of that many cops and saying that he warns his own son to be careful around them lest he be killed was clearly one step too far across the Rubicon.
Rick Moran caught this story before I did and shares his thoughts .
Ordinarily, the advice given by de Blasio to his son is sound, although then was not the time to say it and the way he said it implied he was in danger. Most of these recent police shootings are the direct result of people not doing what the police are telling them to do. Trying to be a hard ass and resist the police is extraordinarily dangerous. When encountering the cops, no matter what the circumstances and even if you think the police are in the wrong, cooperation with their wishes is not only smart, its the law.
Thats the message that black parents should be giving their children. When stopped by an officer, do as youre told, dont mouth off or talk back, and if taken into custody, dont resist. If you know its a mistake, keep your mouth shut until you get legal representation. These simple rules are a no brainer when dealing with the police and are virtually guaranteed to prevent the kinds of tragedies that have occurred in recent weeks.
Even beyond the concerns that Rick raises, this is far more than a case of dysfunctional politics in New York City something so unremarkable that it would never be worth a headline. What were witnessing here is, yet again, the breakdown of civil society and the weakening of the line between order and mayhem. As long as protesters were out there having their voices heard and the city presented a sympathetic, yet unified front which was willing to engage with them in a positive conversation, things could move ahead over this tricky terrain. But the Mayor has sent the message that he is not on the side of the police and sides with their accusers. He has let them know that the executive offices which are charged with leading law enforcement do not stand with the officers on the street and that they view them as the problem rather than the criminals. This will do nothing but embolden responses on the streets where the police already take their lives in their hands by the simple act of suiting up and heading out each day to do their jobs and protect the citizens.
At some point it will not be worth the time of the cops to keep showing up in the highest crime areas. And when they stop, lets see how much everyone enjoys that civil society with nobody around to enforce the laws.

Oh yes, crime has gone down in NYC, but it has gone down throughout the United States. The end of frisk and whatever didn't make the difference.
ALL LIES, THE PEOPLE HAVE A RIGHT TO PROTEST AND THEY ARE DOING IT PEACEFULLY, What this writer is disappointed in, is that the protest has been peaceful and their is nothing negative to report...
Is the key point here more that the Mayor of NYC has lost the faith and trust of the police force of his city?
No reasonable person is going to argue that there are not abuses of power by the police in NYC and other cities around the country, but open hostility between the police and the mayor does not seem a good thing for anyone, including the people who both the mayor and the police are expected to serve and protect.
DeBlasio spoke the truth as he saw it and that's what is pissing off President of the PBA Pat Lynch, they have never had a Mayor stood to their faces and tell them what is what, we the Citizens of NYC pays their salaries, they work for The City, not the PBA (which is their union) Commissioner Bratton has pledged to "Weed out" corrupt officers and I hope they start soon, we need an atmosphere of mutual respect in NYC not the NYPD acting like the Gestapo and everyone bowing at their feet, Most police officers are good decent people doing their jobs and been respectful, but there are those that act like thugs and they need to be gone...The regular citizens should not be treated as terrorists, when there is a need for addressing terrorism then act appropriately, until then, be a police officer...
Agreed CM.
People seem to have forgotten that there was a time when the cops proclaimed that it was "Giuliani time".
I don't lovede Blasio, but the warning he gave his son, is pretty much spot on.
Thanks Perrie...
I will try to stick to the subject of the thread, which is that the police officers do not want DiBlasio at the funerals of fellow officers... nor themselves.
If that is what they wish and the family of the fallen are of the same mind... the publicity-seeking mayor should stay out of it. What is he going to say for his little speech?
Mimi,
First, of course the officer has the right to have the mayor there or not. That isn't the point. The PBA seems to have forgotten that the police work for the people of NYC. This is nothing more than grandstanding. Had de Blasio said, to disrespect cops, I would understand this reaction. He didn't. And in too many NYer's minds are moments like "Giuliani time" ( Abner Louima ) and Amadou Diallo.
I have a lot of friends who are NYCPD and I am very aware that their jobs are not easy. But they would also be the first to say, that there are cops that go out with a chip on their shoulders. Most of the NYPD is made up of goodofficers, but it is the bad ones that have set up this level of distrust.
Although your comment is true Perrie, I have to say the bad apples in the basket have brought this attitude on as much as anything from the policemen. Yes, de Blasio is correct in telling his son to do the right things and be careful. If the thugs on the streets had not nurtured this distrust from both sides then de Blasio wouldn't have to tell his son to be careful. He would just tell him to obey the law and you will be alright.
There are bad policemen and good policemen, but to hear someone condemn the police and never say a word about the reason the innocent have to be extra careful because thugs have promoted a reason to have to be careful.
Think of it like some areas of town you wouldn't want to go. Maybe those areas have a bad reputation. That doesn't mean everyone in those areas are bad, but they suffer from the reputation the area has gotten by the bad apples anyway.
I think addressing that would have been a little nice to hear instead of blaming everything on the police.
The President of the PBA Pat Lynch is Lying, De Blasio did not say anything negative about the NYPD, this is a copy of DeBlasio's speech sent to my E-Mail
Eric Garner's death was a terrible tragedy that no family should have to endure. For many across our city and our nation, yesterday's grand jury ruling compounds feelings of grief with dissatisfaction and anger.
As we reflect on the weeks leading up to yesterday's decision and prepare our path forward, I want to share a snapshot of our short- and long-term plans to improve the relationship between police and the communities they serve.
First, this is not the end of the story -- only the end of a chapter. The NYPD and the Justice Department will initiate their own investigations.
Second, New York City owns a proud and powerful tradition of expression through non-violent protest. Demonstrations and free speech are valuable contributions to debate, but violence and disorder are not only wrong -- they are counterproductive.
Frustration is understandable. Centuries of racism precede us. But working together, we can turn from that history and make a profound and lasting change in the culture of law enforcement and bring police and community closer together.
We've already begun to make progress.
We've dramatically reduced the overuse and abuse of stop-and-frisk, initiated a comprehensive plan to retrain the entire NYPD to reduce the use of excessive force and to work with the community, reduced arrests for minor marijuana possession, and given officers body cameras to improve transparency and accountability.
And we know there is much more to be done.
Finally, in recent weeks, protesters and activists have adopted a phrase that should never have to be said, but that the stains on our country's history demand we say: Black Lives Matter.
When invoking this refrain, we must be mindful that issues surrounding policing and civil rights are not just an issue for people of color, they're not just a problem for young people, and they're not just a problem for people who get stopped by police. They're a problem for all Americans who care about justice.
As Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. said, "Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere."
Together, we must work to make this right, to work for justice, and to build the kind of city and the kind of country we need to be. And we will.
Thank you,
Bill de Blasio
Mayor
I stand corrected CM. Thank you.
You're welcome Six...
I saw something like this in your comment above, but it is neat the way you can actually hear it from the horse's mouth, even though it is short, it is what he said.
Didn't see this in your comment above either. And not a word about the reason his son had to be very careful because of the thugs that had produced this, but all about racism instead.
I guess he can't say anything here or any of his little speeches because he may be afraid he'll get mugged.
I believe the officer should have gone to court, but when a person as big as Garner refuses to co-operate with the police after having been cited 32 times and it was the businesses who called the police in the first place, remember?
I would like to hear someone who is black actually tell the black community we have a problem. We're giving ourselves a bad reputation by allowing thugs to ruin it for we the innocent. We call the police, but we put them in an awkward position, because when they kill, accidentally or not, a black it is automatically considered racism.
I personally think the policemen used too much force, but I agree with the idea that the government killed Garner for their taxes. He was big but in bad health and died on the way to the hospital with a heart attack. They should have just written him a ticket. Yes it was an unnecessary death, but where is the outrage for all the other blacks killed? There is no outrage because racism can't be used, so their black lives don't matter, simply because of the lack of outrage.
So far I haven't been able to find the so-called speech you received in your email. I guess that is your filtered version.
Whether you like it or not it is not racism that killed Garner, it was excessive force by one policeman that contributed to his death and his lack of co-operation. But in de Blasio's actual videos it is racism, centuries of it.
John, that is not my misunderstanding in the least. Misconduct produces a bad reputation.
And sometimes people who look like the thug have to endure skepticism because of thug actions, even though they are innocent of the misconduct.
Such is the case with Garner. The police are not trusted as much now as they were before the actions of the over aggressive policeman.
All policemen are trusted less because of his actions even though they may be completely innocent of any such action themselves.
Well, The E-Mail I received was part of the speech, I heard it and then received an E-mail of the Speech, I don't know if it was also in the Daily News, I know what I heard and the so-called speech I received...
Six, would have appreciated you giving a link so that I could see where you are getting your information, showing 0.29 seconds of a speech is not information and well as 3.22mins and another 4.03mins..
That's OK CM, it was good as I read it. I know how difficult it is to actually tell people these days, the police may not always be what you want because like anything else there are good and bad policemen, but somewhere along the way it has to be acknowledged the young black men need to think about their brothers and sisters when they commit that crime and the effect it has on all of them as well.
So the innocent young black man can walk down the street with his pants down if that is the style and not scare the little lady waiting for the bus because the last time she saw someone like that coming toward her he punched her in the face and stole her pocketbook.
Six, I don't deny that some of these black guys are "THUGS" I have said it myself, I despise some of them, but, there are those that are not thugs, same as those Police officers that I respect and whenever I get a chance to talk to any of them on the streets, I go over and say thank you just the same way I say thanks to the Veterans of wars, but, The PBA Lied on DeBlasio Pat Lynch is trying to put divisions between the NYPD and the Mayor's office, The People of the City of New York pays our police officers, not The Police Union...
Zackly CM.
I understand your point of view, Perrie, and agree with most of it. My feeling on the Garner death is that the policeman should have had to face charges on the use of a restraint method that had been disallowed, and because he used it, he should be dismissed from the Force.
It is my feeling he would have used this method on any person of any color and this was not a racial issue, and de Blasio could have refrained from turning it into one for his political purposes.
Six, from the Washington Post:
New York Mayor Bill de Blasio pens an open letter after the Eric Garner decision: There is much more to be done.
Police officers feel like they are being thrown under the bus, Patrick J. Lynch, president of the Patrolmens Benevolent Association, said at a newsconference Thursday.
But de Blasios willingness to publiclysympathize with Garners grieving family and angry protesters is partly explained by the fact that he was speaking from his experience as the father of two black children and as a progressive Democratic mayor, the first elected in New York innearly 25 years.
LINK TO LETTER:
MiMi. DeBlasio did not turn it into a racial issue, Pat Lynch police union did..
CM, I believe the Fox News excerpts are from the speech DeBlasio gave at the Mt. Sinai United Christian Church on Staten Island after meeting with clergy. It's over 18 minutes long and predictably sounds quite different when not taken out of context.
Thanks for the link to that video Lynne...
There are bad black young men and good black young men
Evil occurs when good people do nothing. It's the same way in most neighborhoods and communities. All of the good black people know who the bad apples are, the ones that step way over the line or have a nasty chip on their shoulder, but almost none of them do or say anything because they are fellow black people and blacks just don't do that. How can people have confidence in a black community if the blacks themselves allow young bad black men to commit crimes over and over and use racism from whites as the reason or excuse? The time needs to pass for one good black to condemn the bad actions of a young bad black man. This black barrier has to be broken down, the black code has to to be gotten rid of and the Al Sharptons of the world and other race baiting groups are the biggest proponents of defending bad young black men.
It's time for some good black people, church leaders and community leaders and even some black politicians to show some guts and clean their neighborhoods up. Until all of the the bad young black men have been shown the door and condemned there will never be trust of young black men who many are completely innocent and wouldn't hurt or rob anyone. And it all starts with the good black people showing some real guts. Really show some pride in the virtues of their race by getting rid of those who are giving them such a bad name!
Thank you Lynne for putting the link up. It was a very nice speech and seemed to cover everything much better than the ones I put up.
It seemed he did get to a little more in this speech, "change is as good as the people we represent".
As I said I think the officer should have gone to court and over reacted too aggressively and his actions make the people trust all police a little less than before Garner.
The same holds true when you see knock out games, rioting and burning businesses down, taunting and beating an elderly white man on a bus makes people a little less trusting when they see a black man coming down the sidewalk.
It will take both sides, but I don't think it is racism in this case or many others, it's conditioning in my opinion. Although I know there are racist on both sides, it seems it's only racist when a white person commits the atrocity.
I really think it is conditioned prejudice more than anything. By pushing the word racism so much today, I don't see it so much here, but evidently many see it in the northern states a lot more.
Wow Randy, how low can you go? So you liked that? Anyway, my point is not so much as show them the door as be good parents and do everything you can to help prevent them from getting involved in bad activities. Basically setting the best example of what you want your child to become as an adult. I know it is not easy and you're right, there are bad policemen, I agree. Getting rid of them and showing them the door as well.
I think you are probably correct CM. I read Lynne's link and it was a good speech and the part that I was looking for was in the speech, "Change is as good as the people we represent". I was wrong in my accusation that he didn't say anything like that. It was subtle, but I hope it was understood. Now to rid the country of bad policemen and for the people to take it upon themselves to be the good people they represent and not use racism as an excuse for bad behavior unless it is warranted.
What a load of trash-any dumbass knows that resisting arrest leads to confrontation and more times than not someone gets hurt or dies from that confrontation.
He sees himself as a monarch not a mayor. Once again, people electing people in abeauty contest mentality as opposed to real thought on what an individual can and will do as a Mayor-they end up with this moonbat as a mayor.
The smarter way to do it is to call the police chief and leadership into your mayoral office and lay down the law. If there's an issue, then their resignations will be regretfully accepted. to play this out in the newspaper is nothing but grandstanding and a grandstanding response form the PBA. Time to act as professionals, both the mayor and the police leadership. But it's easier to play the press instead.