╌>

The median wealth for whites in the US is nearly $142,000. For blacks, it's $11,000

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  12 years ago  •  37 comments

The median wealth for whites in the US is nearly $142,000. For blacks, it's $11,000

shutterstock_111809090.0.0.jpg

Everyone knows inequality is growing in the US, but a new Pew report shows how stark that divide is by race and ethnicity: the median household headed by a white person has a net worth 13 times greater than the median black-headed household. And for whites and Hispanics, the gap is tenfold. In both cases, those gaps are growing.

FT_14.12.11_wealthGap2.0.png

Pew used data from the Fed's Survey of Consumer Finances, released every three years, to create this report , and it shows some staggering gaps in wealth notice that the chart above is logarithmic (i.e., it goes $1,000, $10,000, $100,000, etc.). To get a clearer picture of how much white wealth dwarfs the wealth of blacks and Hispanics, see the below chart.

FT_14.12.11_wealthGapBars.0.png

One other upsetting wrinkle: these gaps exist even regardless of income , as Demos' Matt Bruenig showed earlier this year. Likewise, he has shown that racial and ethnic wealth gaps exist regardless of education .

fig-1_6.0.png

Okay, so why is this happening? 2013 research from Brandeis University (and highlighted in Dean Starkman's June New Republic article) shows that the five biggest components in the growing gap between whites and blacks are (in order, from biggest to smallest) years of homeownership, income, unemployment, college education, and inheritance. Though the report focuses only on blacks and whites without separating out Latinos, it at least provides a window into how whole races or ethnic groups can end up with such huge wealth disparities.

Residential segregation is a big reason homeownership has created a big divide between blacks and whites, the researchers write, as it "artificially lowers demand" and therefore makes building equity tougher in a nonwhite neighborhood. And because whites tend to have more family inheritance and financial help, they also tend to buy homes earlier, giving them more time to build equity. Historic discrimination in mortgage lending added to this gap, as well as the fact that blacks have more of their wealth tied up in their homes than whites do. That means that when the housing crash came, it had a bigger impact on blacks than whites.

The intertwined racial gaps in income, employment , and education all add to this as well, making it harder to get the money with which to build wealth. Add to that the fact that blacks also tend to graduate college with more student debt than whites, and building wealth (even with a good education and a good job) gets all the harder. And as there are also employment, income, and education achievement gaps between Hispanics and non-Hispanic whites as well, the same factors might be at work in creating that wealth gap.

------------------------------------------------

The median wealth for whites in the US is nearly $142,000. For blacks, it's $11,000 , Vox


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    12 years ago

More than ten times as much...

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Wealth is a hard thing to define. Also from the Pew:

AUGUST 30, 2013

Black incomes are up, but wealth isnt

black-whiteAssets Since the 1960s, household-income growth for African-Americans has outpaced that of whites. Median adjusted household income for blacks is now 59.2% that of whites, up slightly from 55.3% in 1967 (though in dollar terms the gap has widened).

But those gains havent led to any narrowing of the wealth gap between the races.In fact, after adjusting for inflation, the median net worth for black households in 2011 ($6,446) was lower than it was in 1984 ($7,150), while white households net worth was almost 11% higher.And as NYU researcher David Low noted in a recent working paper , high-earning married black households have, on average, less wealth than low-earning married white households.

Exactly why income gains havent translated into wealth gains for blacks is something of a puzzle. Researchers have identified several possible factors less intergenerational inheritance, higher unemployment and lower incomes, differing rates and patterns of homeownership, marriage and college education without reaching any consensus on their relative importance. As Low commented, [t]here islittle quantitative understanding of why the black-white wealth gap exists,despite an almost embarrassing number of potential explanations.

black-whiteDebt We decided to examine the differing compositions of black and white household wealth with data from the Federal Reserves triennial Survey of Consumer Finances . We looked at average asset ownership and debt levels, rather than medians, so we could see how much each component contributed to total net worth. (Bear in mind that averages are skewed by households at the top of the wealth distribution, and that the average for any given asset class includes households who dont own those particular assets. Accordingly, these data say more about blacks and whites as groups than about the typical African-American or white household.)

Value of primary residence was the single biggest asset for both groups, but much more so for black households: On average, housing wealth accounted for 49% of black household assets, compared with 28% for the average white household. But the average home value was far lower for black households: $75,040 versus $217,150.

A 2013 Brandeis University report noted that not only is home ownership lower among blacks than whites, but that black-owned homes tend not to appreciate in value as much as white-owned homes, which the Brandeis researchers attributed to residential segregation artificially lower[ing] demand, placing a forced ceiling on home equity for African-Americans who own homes in non-white neighborhoods. Blacks also tend to carry proportionately more mortgage debt, at higher rates, than whites. And, as a 2011 Pew Research Center report found, the housing crash was harder on blacks than whites (though both groups fared better than Hispanics).

Beyond housing, one striking difference between black and white household assets was the role of business ownership. Equity in businesses was the second-biggest asset class among white households, accounting for 18% of average assets, and grew 106% in value between 1983 and 2010. Among black households, however, business equity accounted for less than 4% of assets on average, and actually lost value between 1983 and 2010. After primary residence, the single biggest asset type for black households was other residential property, accounting for about 12% of average assets; but that asset class only grew 37% in value between 1983 and 2010.

Retirement accounts were the third-biggest asset class, on average, for both black and white households, and rose in value over the past three decades at similar rates. But black households, on average, started out with far less in their accounts: $1,496 in 1983, compared with $9,483 for white households.

The Brandeis researchers argue that, due to discriminatory employment patterns, black workers predominate in fields that are least likely to have employer-based retirement plans and other benefits, such as administration and support andfood services. As a result, wealth in black families tends to be close to what is needed to cover emergency savingswhile wealth in white families is well beyond the emergency threshold and can be saved or invested more readily.

Average household debt rose steadily among both whites and blacks from 1983 to 2007. But while white households debt continued to rise between 2007 and 2010, to an average $113,598, it fell among black households over the same period, to an average $53,199 mainly because of a decline in home mortgage debt. Overall, though, blacks continue to carry more debt relative to their household assets than do whites: 34.5% of average assets, versus 14.5% for white households.

It seems that while some issues such a the wide difference in black wealth plays a part in here with these numbers, it is only part of the picture.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    12 years ago

"Wealth", in this context, is a technical term, meaning "the total value of possessions". It carries no intrinsic notion of "how much". A poor person may own only the clothes they're wearing... but that would be their "wealth".

 
 
 
njmick
Freshman Silent
link   njmick    12 years ago

Take a ride through the streets of few Black neighborhoods around midnight then take a ride through a few White neighborhoods that should answer the question without all the technical brohah.Maybe because far to many Blacks don't stress family values, moralityand education.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

This isn't worth commenting on.

Pure political drivel.

Comparing medians?

Right.

Pointed out in the other article how math education has suffered over the years, this is a perfect example of it.

Comparing medians is statistically irrelevant. but it does make good political copy.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    12 years ago
Comparing medians is statistically irrelevant.

I have never heard that before. Could you explain, please?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

njmick,

That is a bit of broad brush, don't you think? First of all the concept of "White neighborhoods". There are loads of affluent black families living among whites. There is also a phenomenon of affluent blacks living in their own neighborhoods. So what you should be talking about is poor neighborhoods, in which there is both black ones and white ones, all who are there for different reasons, from lack of family values to not being able to make ends meet.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    12 years ago

Exactly why income gains havent translated into wealth gains for blacks is something of a puzzle.

Maybe I'm too literal, but this seems obvious.

Wealth is accumulated when disposable income is significantly greater than expenses, leaving a margin for savings/investment. When revenues are consumed by expenses, there can be no accumulation of wealth.

No?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

In statistics, the Median is the figure separating the upper half from the lower half. ie it's the exact middle.

Which is stated as $11,000 for blacks. Anyone see a problem with how they are using the data, or what their data consists of?

$11,000 median income

bottom half equals $0 to $10,999,

$11,000 median,

$11,001 to $22,000 as the upper half.

The US poverty line for a family of four in the US is currently about $24,000.

See the problem yet?

Did they take their data of black families solely off the poverty rolls?

$11,000 median cannot be correct especially when comparing against middle class America.

There are three black families on my block that make more than me, and I'm not poor by any stretch...

please explain this to me and I will explain statistically irrelevant in this context..

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    12 years ago

I don't think you're using "median" correctly.

bottom half equals $0 to $10,999,

$11,000 median

Right.

$11,001 to $22,000 as the upper half.

No! $ 11 000 to ... whatever the highest Black wealth may be.

The US poverty line...

The poverty line concerns revenue. The article is about wealth.

There are three black families on my block that make more than me, and I'm not poor by any stretch...

Please! You cannot seriously complain about statistics... and then cite personal experience...

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    12 years ago

Let's see the gap between white middle class income and black middle class income. I bet it's not nearly as sensational as the title of the seeded article. The same probably holds true with "net worth".

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    12 years ago

Two points:

The seed is about wealth, not about income.

Second, "middle class" should be independent of race, shouldn't it?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

This is so ridiculous it's pathetic they are puzzled as to why there is a difference even with identical incomes and education. What would or should be obvious to such enlightened researchers is investment or in this case where does the extra money go that is above what is necessary to pay the cost of living.

Of course some people buy $50 to $100 shoes to wear and others spend $350 or more for their shoes. Some buy used cars or inexpensive autos getting the most for their buck. Others have to have BMWs if they have a dime left over to make that payment.

Some people furnish their apartments or homes modestly while others have the finest of everything in their homes even though it is not necessary and prevents them from having any extra money to either save, purchase a home or invest in some legal income producing idea.

Some have normal tires and rims, while some have tires and rims on their automobile that cost up to $7,000. Money management is more important than income. Some have it all now and have nothing later.

Even though blacks were much lower according to the graphs than whites they have steadily grown poorer since 2007 when the House was taken over by the Democrats, 2008 when the Senate was taken over by the Democrats and 2009 when the presidency was taken over by the Democrats. But don't feel bad for them. The whites have lost $50,000 of their wealth to the Democrats since 2007. We're all losing wealth in this country except for the welfare recipients and the elites.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    12 years ago

The seed is about wealth, not about income.

Hence my comment "The same probably holds true with "net worth".

Second, "middle class" should be independent of race, shouldn't it?

But "net worth" or "wealth" is not ?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Pat they are talking about net worth which is much more decided by money management than income. In what you're saying I believe you would be correct that equal black and white income and education would probably amount to very similar results in net worth.

There are just a more, percentage wise, low income blacks who have no idea how to manage what little they have as so many low income whites also have the same problem. The graphs are practically worthless as really comparing how people of equal income or even relative income manage their lives.

You'll notice blacks started losing their wealth around 2004-05 when the push to have everyone own their own home, qualifying even those who weren't qualified in spite of the warnings of what was to come, people like Barney Franks and Maxine Waters cried racism. Well you can't hold someone up without some foundation to support them. Mortgage brokers made a fortune and cashed their chips in while everyone else lost their butts. Whites lost mostly starting in 2007 and have made a little comeback, but the middle wealth still paid the price while the elites took advantage of it.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

What about $17 plus trillion dollars paid out since the beginning of the Great Society, wasn't that enough?

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    12 years ago

Single parent?

As a factor it's bogus. Think of all the two parent scenarios where the father is gone for 10+ hours a day or the father travels for business. The mother in these cases is a "single parent".

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    12 years ago

We're getting hung up on vocabulary, I think.

I know what "wealth" means in economics. I think "net worth" is more an accounting term, and I'm not sure what the difference may be between the two, if any.

When I say that "middle class" is race-independent, I mean that "middle class" is defined as "revenue between X and Y", regardless of race. I don't know how to differentiate between "Black middle class" and "White middle class".

"Median wealth", though, can be calculated for any group.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    12 years ago

i am curious what you would like to do with this inequity?

Dunno. I don't pretend to be knowledgeable on this.

I know that the collapse of the housing bubble hit Blacks harder than Whites, significantly widening the wealth gap, so perhaps there's something to be done there...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

The increasing gap should be laid at Obama's and the Fed'sdoorstep.

Theirpolicies for reducinginequality of income have increased inequality.

The President of Inequality (WSJ editorial)

Policies promoting equality over growth have damaged both.

Oct. 2, 2014 7:26 p.m. ET

Excerpts:

In the latest grim tiding of the public mood, merely 42% think the American dream that if you work hard, youll get ahead remains true, down from 53% in 2012 and 50% in 2010. According to the Public Religion Research Institute poll last week, the steepest declines in belief in the last two years were among people under age 30 (down 16 percentage points), women (14 points) and Democrats (17).

In other words, the most disillusioned belong to the coalition that elected President Obama. But before giving up on upward mobility, they ought to blame the policies he has enacted. Mr. Obama has been the best President for slow growth and inequality in modern history, as new economic surveys show.

ED-AS760_1incom_16U_20141002183907.jpg ED-AS760_1incom_16U_20141002183907.jpg

Start with the Census Bureaus annual poverty and income survey, which came out this month. Real U.S. median household incomeor the wages earned in the middle of the wage distributionwas $51,939, a 0.3% increase over 2012. But the 2013 figure is still 3.9% lower than the median income when the recession ended in 2009, and 7.9% lower than the median in 2007.

One trick some liberals use to obscure the uniquely bad performance of the Obama years is to go back to the height of the dot-com bubble in 1999 when real income peaked at $56,895 and compare it to 2013. But this conveniently ignores that real median household income rebounded smartly in the middle of the last decade. That rebound occurred after the Bush tax cuts on capital income and marginal income-tax rates became law in 2003.

As the nearby chart shows, incomes fell after 1999 through 2004 but then rose again for three straight years and nearly reached the 1999 level in 2007 at $56,436. The bottom fell out with the 2008 financial panic and recession, as you would expect. But the amazing fact of the Obama years is that incomes did not rebound with the recovery as they have in every other expansion. Only in 2013 did incomes begin to pick up modestly, five long years into recovery.

More at: ...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

Simple! Convert to Communism, confiscate all assets and redistribute them.Tongue.gif

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

If you don't adjust for age these stats are misleading ...

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

I gave the statistical definition of Median, median ANYTHING.

Your definition does not fit.

Wiki;

Dictionary.com;

Wolfram Math; (if you need technical explanations with equations and references to textbooks)

None of them say what you claim it to mean...

Income level is directly related to apparent wealth for obvious reasons.

There are two poverty line measures in use by the Federal Government, one is income based, the other is asset based. If you research it you will find I used the appropriate one, asset based because wealth is determined by ones assets minus liabilities.

All statistics are about personal experience, quantified personal experience, you know what an actuary is?

As soon as any black person buys a new car in this country, you can remove him from your chart.

Like i said, political hogwash...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    12 years ago

Your definition does not fit.

I don't understand. I gave no definition of "median".

I agree with the definitions in your links... OF COURSE. That is the definition used in the seed.

I am afraid that you are misunderstanding your own definition.

Income level is directly related to apparent wealth for obvious reasons.

I don't know what "apparent wealth" is. I have never heard that term used in economics.

Income is only loosely related to wealth. A person may have great wealth and no income, while another may have great income and no wealth. The first is an heir, dilapidating the inheritance. The second consumes all the income as it arrives.

the other is asset based.

I have never heard of this, and a quick Google found nothing. Could you please give me a link?

All statistics are about personal experience

That is just plain wrong.

As soon as any black person buys a new car in this country, you can remove him from your chart.

No. If a Black person can afford a new car, then their wealth is above the median, that's all.

-------------

Look, NM... I don't know what it is about this seed that set you off... but you need to be careful. You are expressing vehement opinions on topics that you do not really master.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

Look Bob, I have no animosity towards you or this thread, great animosity to what the article is attempting to depict.

You now claim you gave no definition, in actuality you did, using my depiction of the definition.

I don't think you're using "median" correctly.

bottom half equals $0 to $10,999,

$11,000 median

Right.

$11,001 to $22,000 as the upper half.

No! $ 11 000 to ... whatever the highest Black wealth may be.

That is where you redefined it.

If a black person can afford a car it places them higher on the chart by your definition, by the actual definition which you have agreed with it removes them.

Before you insult me again I have been nothing but civil and within the CoC. you've been caught in a mis-characterization, I was only the first to see it. you made it worse with your untenable definition of the basis of the study you posted.

Yes I have some strong opinions, but I prefer truthful debate rather than debate over slanted statistical presentations used to make a situation worse than it really is. Wealth inequality is a problem everywhere on the planet, skin color doesn't matter, nationality doesn't matter, location doesn't matter. People deal with wealth inequality in the slums of Africa and India much worse than anyone has it here.

You think I can't master it, or your better than me, try me.

Lets get right down to the nitty gritty now that you have admitted that you initial definition of Median was wrong, appreciate the honesty.

Your choice, end it here or take it where ever you want it to go.

No hard feelings.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Sorry to break it to you but Bob's explanation of "median" is accurate . The entire purpose of using median instead of average is to avoid the problems that come from highly asymmetric data . If you want an example ask for it ...

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

Bring it on. Make it a peer reviewed study please. not a political research survey site.

You still have to use median properly.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Make it a peer reviewed study please.

Nowhere Man ,

I'm not making myself clear . Scholarly journals are loaded with thousands of examples of the use of the term "median" . You can easily go on "Google scholar" and find them yourself . You might even find something on Wikipedia . I am not here to post links , only to offer the benefit of my post-graduate training in math-stat . If you are not interested in my experience then we are done ...

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

If you got it flaunt it.

Seen a lot of people claim it, then refuse to produce.

I accept no online claims of credentials as valid until proven.

so I guess we are done.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Vox is MSNBC with a mask on. This is the kind of stuff they want you to center your attention. I remember when they first announced they were going to let us say open as Project X.

In January 2014, Vox announced it had hired Ezra Klein , who formerly served as the editor of the Washington Post ' s WonkBlog , to be the founder of a new website covering news and politics, codenamed "Project X" and later adopting the simple name Vox. Klein explained in an announcement on The Verge that he felt that current news websites did not provide enough context to the stories they cover, and that he aimed to create a news website that would be "as good at explaining the world as it is at reporting on it". [ 28 ] [ 29 ] Project X officially launched as Vox on April 6, 2014; its goal is to cover stories dynamically without succumbing to the "incremental" coverage used by traditional outlets, and to "[deliver] crucial context alongside new information" through "cards" that can be accessed through highlighted words within articles.

Klein serves as editor-in-chief of Vox ; among its initial staff members are his colleagues from the Post , including Melissa Bell , Matthew Yglesias , and Dylan Matthews .

Thought that was really cool how they were going to explain it to you so you would know how to think.

Klein is editor in chief at Vox, and formerly wrote for and edited Wonkblog at the Washington Post . He frequently provides political commentary on MSNBC 's The Rachel Maddow Show , Hardball with Chris Matthews , and The Last Word with Lawrence O'Donnell . He is a former contributor to Countdown with Keith Olbermann . On March 14, 2013, The Week magazine reported that Klein was among those being considered to host MSNBC's yet-unnamed 8 p.m. weekday prime-time show that would replace The Ed Show . [ 12 ] Ultimately, the time slot was filled with All In with Chris Hayes .

Oh he has a lot of credentials and awards, but they are all from the most liberal organizations. So I would say MSNBC has ventured out of the studio and disguised themselves and is now known as "Vox". You think they're trying to cash in on Fox News success?

So as you're reading this article you have to consider this is a conglomeration of The Washington Post, Rachel Maddow, Chris Matthews, Lawrence O'Donnell, Keith Olbermann, Ed Schultz, Chris Hayes, The American Prospect (dedicated to liberalism), The New Republic and The Nation all put into one. There's more. I'm just tired of typing.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Wait till your father gets home !

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

I accept no online claims of credentials as valid until proven.

From where I sit , you are too uneducated on this subject matter to be able to make a judgement about what I know . If all you want is a debate , start it yourself . I may or may not participate .

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    12 years ago

Mr Petey Coober.

Didn't you say this?

If you want an example ask for it

Didn't I say this?

Bring it on. Make it a peer reviewed study please.

Didn't you say this?

You can easily go on "Google scholar" and find them yourself . You might even find something on Wikipedia . I am not here to post links , only to offer the benefit of my post-graduate training in math-stat .

You claim to expertise, is out the window if your not willing to back up the claim. You offered, I accepted, you ran away.

I guess in your world this give you license to insult people such as this.

From where I sit , you are too uneducated on this subject matter to be able to make a judgement about what I know .

You right, I haven't a clue what you know and what you don't. YOU offerd a demonstration of your knowledge and expertise. I accepted the kind offer in the spirit of debate. YOU punked out.

I'm sorry that you were unaware that I do not instantly give people credit for knowledge or even common sense when they are unwilling to walk a mile in my shoes.

I am decidedly educated enough to know when I have bested a coward. You stuck your two cents into a discussion offering support for one side out of the blue. your refusal to carry through is your problem.

It doesn't give you the right to insult me for using my educated common sense.

You done now? Or do you want to do another little parting shot...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

The mother in these cases is a "single parent".

Not when he bring a nice big paycheck home which these single parents will not see.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    12 years ago

Do you have any substantive criticism of Vox?All you have done here is list a lot of progressive voices -- most of whom are not in any way related to Vox -- and screamed in terror...

You have not demonstrated a single factual error by the Vox team. As your (unidentified) Wikipedia extract says, Vox does context as well as day-to-day instantaneous reporting. That context is important to understanding.

Oh wait... "facts"... There's that word again! And we all -- particularly the radical conservatives among us -- know that facts have a decidedly liberal bias.

And of course, the BEST thing: Vox rhymes with Fox!!

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Team White is doing well!
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Handicap system?
 
 

Who is online



Sean Treacy
Tacos!
CB


92 visitors