╌>

Raiding Native Sacred Places in a Defense Authorization: Everything Wrong with Congress

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  kavika  •  12 years ago  •  43 comments

Raiding Native Sacred Places in a Defense Authorization: Everything Wrong with Congress

Re: Raiding Native Sacred Places in a Defense Authorization: Everything Wrong with Congress

12/10/14

The San Carlos Apache Tribe (Tribe) has worked for the past decade to shine light on the Southeast Arizona Land Exchange that would transfer Oak Flat and nearby lands in the Tonto National Forest lands held sacred by my Tribe and many other Native Americans to a foreign-owned mining corporation for certain destruction. Sadly, this Land Exchange has been airdropped into the FY15 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) at the eleventh hour, as Congress prepares to bring the 113 th Session to close.

RELATED: San Carlos Apache Leader Seeks Senate Defeat of Copper Mine on Sacred Land

Hundreds of tribal governments, tribal organizations, and others have joined San Carlos Apaches in opposition to the Land Exchange because it would transfer public federal lands that encompass a known Native place of worship to a private mining company. Because of this opposition, the majority of Members of the U.S. House of Representatives opposed the Land Transfer. House Leadership twice pulled it from consideration because this misguided Land Transfer lacked the votes for passage. The Senate Committee with jurisdiction over the bill also refused to move it forward.

In the face of this opposition, certain Members of Arizonas delegation forced a closed-door deal to include the SE Arizona Land Exchange into the National Defense Authorization Act of 2015. The Land Exchange was included in Section 3003 on page 1,103 of a 1,700-page bill that was unveiled after 11:00 p.m. the evening before it came up for consideration. This exemplifies everything wrong with Congress.

Before the U.S. Senate takes final action on this breach of trust, on behalf of the San Carlos Apache Tribe, I respectfully urge Senate Leaders to strike Section 3003, Southeast Arizona Land Exchange, S. 1847, the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) prior to passage. If the Senate fails to protect our place of worship, I additionally ask that the Administration veto this measure.

Section 3003 would direct the Secretary of Agriculture to convey over 2,400 acres of the Forest, including Oak Flat, to a mining company called Resolution Copper, which is owned by the foreign mining giants Rio Tinto PLC (United Kingdom) and BHP Billiton Ltd (Australia). The Forest, established in 1905 from Apache ancestral homelands, is named after the Tonto Apaches who were forced from the Oak Flat area in the 1870s and imprisoned at Camp Verde Reservation. The Reservation is located 15 miles from Oak Flat. During the winter of 1875, the Apache prisoners of war were forced marched to San Carlos Reservation by the military. Over one hundred Tonto Apaches died during that winter March. It seems that history is repeating itself.

Oak Flat is a place of irreplaceable beauty. President Eisenhower specifically withdrew the Area from mining through a Public Lands Order. President Nixon reaffirmed withdrawal. However, Rio Tinto/Resolution Copper seek to develop and operate the largest copper mine in North America in the Oak Flat area. Resolution Copper plans to use the highly destructive block cave mining method to remove one cubic mile of ore the equivalent of 1,400 stadiums 7,000 feet beneath the surface of the earth without replacing any of the earth removed because it is the cheapest form of mining. Resolution Copper itself admits that the surface will collapse creating a crater visible from outer space and destroying forever our place of worship.

No one knows exactly how and where the earth will collapse as a result of Resolution Coppers underground mining on this scale. Resolution Copper has never addressed what would happen if the inevitable collapse damages or causes the collapse of Highway 60. Highway 60 is the only direct highway from Phoenix to eastern Arizona. The economic repercussions for the citizens of Arizona would be immense and potentially devastating.

The Transfer and resulting mine will forever alter the regions water quality and water supply. Copper is one of the most water-intensive forms of mining in existence. Add block cave mining into the factor, and the need for water further intensifies. The U.S. established the Tonto National Forest in 1904 to protect the regions watershed. This protection will also turn to dust with the Land Exchange.

Section 3003 fleeces the American taxpayer and undermines national security. Rio Tinto drafted the appraisal provisions in the bill, ensuring that it will benefit to the greatest extent possible at the expense of the American taxpayer. The beneficiaries of the Land Transfer Resolution Copper Mining and its parent corporation Rio Tinto will reap billions in American taxpayer resources. They are earmarked to reap these benefits without any guarantee that the copper remains in the U.S. Resolution Copper Project Director, Andrew Taplin, admitted in a recent Arizona Central article that the copper ore mined from Oak Flat will likely be shipped out of the country to be smelted. Rio Tintos top shareholder Chinalco, a corporation owned by the government of China cannot wait for this deal to pass.

In addition, Rio Tinto has repeatedly refused to sever its partnership with the Government of Iran, through the Iran Foreign Investment Company (IFIC), in the Rssing Uranium Mine in Namibia, Africa. The Institute for Science and International Security issued a report on October 24, 2013, stating that the Government of Iran may be in proximate possession of weapons-grade uranium. Both United Against a Nuclear Iran and the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies have raised concerns with this dangerous proposal that directly benefits Rio Tinto and its partnership with the IFIC. Rio Tinto does not concern itself with the United States national security. It only concerns itself with its own profits.

The proponents of Section 3003 claim that the bill was amended to address the Tribes concerns with protection of our sacred places and environmental concerns. These claims are hollow. Despite changes to require consultation with affected tribes and compliance with the National Environmental Protection Act, Section 3003 still mandates the transfer of Oak Flat into the private ownership of Resolution Copper regardless of the results of the consultation or information and recommendations resulting from the NEPA process. A mandatory conveyance defeats the purpose of tribal consultations and the NEPA process that are designed to help provide information before decisions about transferring the land are made. In Section 3003, the outcome is pre-determined, rendering tribal views and public comments meaningless. Furthermore, Section 3003 would not require Resolution Copper to mitigate impacts on the Oak Flat area after conveyance and contains no repercussions or penalties on Resolution Copper for environmental harm or the destruction to our sacred areas.

Proponents also falsely claim that the Tribe was consulted on these changes. The first the Tribe saw the language of Section 3003 was after 11:00 p.m. on the evening of December 2, 2014 when the House Rules Committee posted the bill online. This is the antithesis of democracy. We are extremely disappointed by the lack of transparency and lack of opportunity to comment on this provision. The Tribe greatly appreciates the efforts of Rep. Tom Cole, other Members of the House Rules Committee, and Rep. Betty McCollum for their efforts to remove Section 3003 from S. 1847 during that Committees vote on the rule on the basis that the provision, among other things, subverted the will of the House and was included in S. 1847 without fair process.

For these reasons, I again urge Senate Leaders to strike Section 3003 from the NDAA. If this breach of trust moves forward in Congress, I ask that the Administration veto this measure.

Oak Flat is one of our religious places where our Gaan spiritual deities and Holy People reside. Apache people have lived, prayed, and died in the Oak Flat Area since time immemorial. We are saddened that Congress, through an 11th hour rider, has ignored the will of the people. We are concerned for our children who may never see or practice their religion in their rightful place of worship. We are worried for the children of southeast Arizona who may have to find new places to live to drink clean water. And we are gravely concerned for the American voter whose voice continues to be ignored. However, the Apache people will not remain silent. We are committed to shining light on the Land Exchange and the proposed mine until we have no breath.

Read more at http://indiancountrytodaymedianetwork.com/2014/12/10/re-raiding-native-sacred-places-defense-authorization-everything-wrong-congress

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

The unnamed Senators were McCain and Flake from Arizona.

Once again, not only our sacred places are for sale, but the land of the people of the U.S. is for sale to foreign corporations.

Thank your congress for this gift to greed.

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

Will our President, who claims to support Native American rights, sign it? I think he will.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

I'm sure that he will sign it Grump. Another lesson for Indians and all U.S. citizens, don't believe a damn thing the government tells you.

 
 
 
Nona62
Professor Silent
link   Nona62    12 years ago

AMEN!!

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    12 years ago

Very sad.

Big Business is raping the whole country... They might at least leave your sacred sites...

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

Yes they are Bob...Sadly, it's been on going for decades.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

It is now time for the Native Americans to riot. I know what you and 1stwarrior say about this, Kavika, but peaceful, measured, reasonable arguments do not work.

Thousands of Indians and whites have said they will physically stand at the border of the Sioux reservation to stop the XL if the people in charge of it, and the government, try to force it through their land... and they said they will stand armed.

Indians have been trying to follow the law of the land for over a hundred years going through the court systems to stop the theft of NDN land and resources that end up in the coffers of private corporations with offshoots to the pockets of Congress members they bought. It doesn't work. Time for a revolution.

Hoka Hey

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

There is a lot of information above that is incorrect. I'll have to get to the office and go through my files, but the State consulted with the tribes - six of them - and, supposedly, this "action" is to transfer the land to a Wildland Forestry area.

But, let me go through my stuff at work to be sure.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

That's not what Rio Tinto thinks 1st. They are going to mine it.

In researching this, the tribe (s) have been battling this ''land transfer'' for 10 years.

McCain and Flake inserted the rider at the 12th hour. Now why would they do that if it wasn't to give the land to Rio Tinto?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

mimi, I'm one that will protest and try lawful protests. I'm also the one that will stand my ground and if need be, fight back in any manner at my disposal.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

I'm totally disgusted. Would it be ok to sell out land from underneath the Glass Cathedral, St Pats?

Does private industry trump Indian traditions?

And the kicker is that the goods from this mine will go to an enemy state. WTF?

Again, I'm disgusted.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

''And the kicker is that the goods from this mine will go to an enemy state. WTF?''

That is a point that should really should have drawn the Senates veto, it didn't. The Senate passed it today.

The only way that this can be stopped is by Presidential veto. He (Obama)claims to be a friend of the Indians, we'll see how much of a friend he is, if the he signs it.

This will be the moment of truth for the President. The next up will be the XL pipeline.

Another in a long list of lies and deceit from the government to Indian people.

Will it continue?

Will the American people of all colors, allow corporations and politicians to sell all of our land to foreign companies?

An open letter posted on FB:

I want to address this to the Government of the United States of America. I am Native American. The Apache Tribes are my people. I have a question for Our Government from the President on down to all of the Senators and the Representatives. That question is..How Much Is Enough? I would really like an HONEST answer to this question. Look around you at all the Beauty that America holds in it. You took this from all of us many Generations ago. You shoved my people off of their Lands time and again because the Land held something you wanted. It had Gold, Silver, Uranium, or even just Places for people to build houses and so you shoved us away until there is Very Precious Little left for the Native Americans. How Much Is Enough? You have killed my people, you have imprisoned my people and now when this Country should be Free it no longer holds that Meaning for Native Americans. Not Truly anyways. If Native Americans went to burning down Church houses or Muslim Temples or destroying any type of Religious Place you would call out the Armed Forces to push us back or kill us. You know this to be true. Yet any place that is Sacred to my people can be taken from us for the purpose of Mining, Commercial building, etc. Why is that? Do you still consider us to be Savages? Are you trying to say that we are NOT Spiritual people because you think we dont worship the same God that you worship? I am here to inform you that there is only 1 God. The Great Creator. No matter whether you call Him Jesus, God, Jehovah, Wankan Tanka, Tunkashila, Ussen, Usen, or Ysun He is still the same God. The ONLY Almighty One Above. Do you believe that He made you and others but Not the Native Americans. Just because we hold Sacred Ceremony to worship and give Him all the Glory instead of going inside your church House does NOT mean that we Worship God any less than you do, Nor does it mean that we were not made by Him. What you are doing by Selling and Trading off Sacred Native American Lands and Sites is paramount to burning down Our Religious Churches that have been in Place in this Country much longer than yours. So truthfully God has nothing to do with what you are doing. It is your GREED that you are feeding and NOT the Betterment of this Country or Our People. I dont know about any of you but I have a personal relationship with God. I worship Him in the ways of my ancestors for that is my Culture. God does NOT deal in GREED. He deals in LOVE. I think honestly you should all take a look inward at your own hearts. What if you were Native American? How would you feel about this? Again I ask the QuestionHow Much Is Enough? How Much Do You Need Before You Stop Taking From Us??? Sincerely, Lisa Cranfield Proud Apache Native American

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Congress Includes Land Grab Provisions in National Defense Authorization

Some lawmakers negotiated the inclusion of land grab provisions in the 2015 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), which will expand the already massive federal real state holdings.

Critics consider those provisions pork because they have nothing to do with defense or national security. The NDAA provides guidance for U.S. defense spending and policy. It is considered a must-pass legislation.

The public land provisions are included the text of the NDAA for fiscal 2015 under "TITLE XXXNATURAL RESOURCES RELATED GENERAL PROVISIONS."

According to a Democrat summary of the 2015 NDDA initially provided to CQ Roll Call , the legislation is vital to our national security and provides our men and women in uniform with the tools they need as well as the benefits and support that they have earned and deserve.

Nevertheless, a Senate aide, before the NDAA was publishedlate on Tuesday, warned Breitbart News, that land provisions were being negotiated for inclusion in the NDAA. The aide was proven right.

When asked to comment on the potential land grab, Catherine Frazier, a spokeswoman for Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX), told Breitbart News, "Controversial legislation that has not beendebated and is completely irrelevant to our national defense should have no part in the NDAA bill debate."

The Senate aide told Breitbart News that highlights of the lands provision include:

  • 275,000 acres designated as new Wilderness Areas;
  • A Womens History Museum;
  • Four new National Parks seven National Park studies for new parks to be;
  • 16 National Heritage extensions;
  • Three new Wild and Scenic River (WSR) designations and three new WSR studies that are expected to become new designations; and
  • Land entitlement for Sealaska, an Alaska Native Regional Corporation

Conservative Review indicated that some Republicans are driving the efforts to attach the public land package to the NDAA, adding that "the [land grab] bills under discussion are precisely the sorts of expansions of federal land that principled conservatives have regularly objected to."

Jamming liberal pet projects into a defense bill at the expense of Americans best and bravest is something youd expect from the Left. Sadly, its some liberal Republicans leading the charge this time, Gaston Mooney, the executive director of Conservative Review, told Breitbart News.Proponents of this land grab are trying to conceal the legislative language amongst other must pass legislation that is critical for our national security.

This is akin to the Pelosi strategy of passing the bill to find out what is in it. If a bill can't pass on its own, it has no business being hidden among hundreds of pages of text, he added. Further, it is completely unacceptable for liberal pet projects, like a $500 million museum honoring the Planned Parenthood founderand an anti-military activist among others, tobe funded on the backs of our troops."

Buck McKeon (R-CA), the Chairman of the House Armed Services Committee, and Sen. Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.) the ranking-member of the Senate Armed Services Committee, did not immediately respond to requests for comment. They both worked onthe defense authorization.

According to a recent estimate by the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO), the federal government already owns about 640 million acres of land, more than one-quarter of the nations total land area.

The majority of that land is managed by the Department of interior, which has a maintenance backlog of about $20 billion for the land it already owns, according to the office of Sen. Tom Coburn (R-OK).

According to Conservative Review , it is a few members of Congress who are pushing for the inclusion of the land grab package, including some lawmakers who were voted out office or are retiring.

Their gamble is that the imperative of passing an authorization bill for our military will override principled objections to their land grab, writes Conservative Review, later adding, It's this type of legislative log rolling that has led to the explosion of government and exactly what voters rejected at the polls on November 4.

Dan Caldwell, the legislative director for Concerned Veterans of America, expressed disappointment that members of Congress were trying to fund a public land package through an NDAA that cuts benefits to troops.

It is absolutely disgraceful that there are members of Congress who are pushing to include funding in the National Defense Authorization Act for a massive federal government land grab , a womens history museum, and other pet projects while raising healthcare and housing costs for our troops when many of them continue to risk their lives every day in combat in Iraq, Syria, and Afghanistan, Caldwell told Breibart News.

In addition, many of these same members of Congress have refused to adequately address other long-term issues with the defense budget- including the threat of sequestration and the broken acquisition system which wastes billions of dollars while failing to deliver much-needed equipment to our war fighters, he added. Instead of crafting serious and forward-thinking defense policy, it appears that many members of Congress are more interested in rewarding political supporters and engaging in cronyism.

Carl Levin (D-MI), the Chairman of the Senate Committee on Armed Services and Rep. McKeon are listed as the primary sponsors of the bill.

...

The Liberals keep their eyes closed and don't really know who is on their side by doing so. The media fools them daily while the uptown Democrats and Republicans fail to represent then, only lying to them to get their votes and casting them to the side when their votes don't matter any longer. Only the brave and those who risk their positions continually stand up for Americans while being degraded by the media fooling the stupid Americans once again.

With Flake and McCain you just have two more Democrats in office.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    12 years ago

Does private industry trump Indian traditions?

24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

Six, I'm not sure what your point is, other than naming Flake and McCain as democrats..

The point of this article is the land grab of sacred native land. Your callingFlake and McCain democrats, doesn't change what is happening to Native people, and all other US Citizens, with this underhanded move by republicans.

They don't give a rat's ass about the citizens of their own state, just the money that involved in taking this land.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

I hope that I'm understanding your use of the emocons Bob, and that your laughing at the notion that private industry would not trump Indian traditions.

Actually tradition isn't the correct word. It should be the Apache religion. Indians see Mother Earth in a far different light than non Indians. We do not build church's, or idols. There is a saying among the Ojibwe, ''Gakina Awiiya'', or, ''we are all related'', it refers to all things on earth. It is the circle of life. The land that is being taken, has far more meaning than a tradition. It is part of us.

And to the likes of McCain and Flake it is simply a way to make money. Greed is a sickness, one that some in our government have a bad case of. The destruction of sacred ground means nothing to them. Sadly, it has been on going to centuries.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Flake and McCain Democrats? Huh?

Beyond that

Is it possible to prevent legislation like this, when it is attached to the 2015 NDAA?

The President can veto a proposed law but he does not have the power to do a line veto. In other words, he cant go line by line and say, I want this but I dont want that.

This NDAA is a funding bill that appropriates money to the military. The attached provision that gives away land that is sacred to the Apaches is unrelated to the military- thats why they call it a rider. If the Senate passes this bill and it goes to Obama, he cannot veto the whole thing without being accused of knifing the military in the back.He cant surgically excise Congresss pet projects otherwise known as pork because that would be a line veto. He can either sign the whole thing as-is, or he can veto it- then it would go back to the House to redo it.

In other words, its a trap.

There have been proposals in the past, to give the President line veto power. These proposals generally go nowhere because Congressnever agrees to it. There is also a provision attached to the bill that says the Senate cant change anything in this bill. Theres millions of dollars of pork in lots of things, but this one really takes the breath away.

Congress Raids Ancestral Native American Lands With Defense Bill

Iran Uranium Partner Could Get Gift From Lame-Duck Congress

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

Bob, That's probably the rudest, most malicious comment I have ever seen on NT.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

Lying is part of their make-up MM.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

And, Kavika, what's even funnier to me is - Henry Dawes attached a clause to the 1870 Defense Budget that ended treaty making with the tribes - and no one saw it until it had been signed by the President.

Wonder if McCain and Dawes are related?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

If not related, then they are of the same mind set 1st.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Do you have the link to that FB page. I am sure people can add their remarks.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

No I don't Perrie.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Six, I'm not sure what your point is, other than naming Flake and McCain as democrats..

My point Kavika is the media condemns Cruz and Lee, while it is the Democrats and Republicans who are not conservative promoting this land grab and the representatives who were voted out of office by the American people recently.

The bill was sponsored by one Republican from California, Howard McKeon, who is retiring 2015 and Carl Levin a Democrat who is retiring in 2015.

It may be the Republicans in your eyes, but who just lost so many political elections last month? Was it Republican or Democrats?

It takes 51 votes and who has the power to complete this deal? It's not Republicans. So you can blame Republicans all you want and it is warranted for the people like McCain who you people love when he says something you like and hate when he doesn't, but it is the uptown Republicans and Democrats who are pushing this, not the Conservatives.

When asked to comment on the potential land grab, Catherine Frazier, a spokeswoman for Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX), told Breitbart News, "Controversial legislation that has not beendebated and is completely irrelevant to our national defense should have no part in the NDAA bill debate."

If the Democrats don't want it, they have the votes and the Republicans can't do a thing about it, so put the blame on who really has the votes to avoid it.

I can't stand McCain, but McCain has one vote, but the Democrats have 51 votes. So if this passes and I suppose it did, then put the blame where it is, on the people who have the votes.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

Six, in this article I did not blame the republicans. I blame Flake and McCain. Your the one trying to avoid the rider added.

As far as ''you people'' loving McCain is BS Six. If you want to talk about the land grab, feel free. If you want to try to excuse McCain and Flake for the rider. Write your own article.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

It's always the white man. The Democrats like to brag about their diversity in Congress who by the way have the votes to either pass this or not.

And you have the black man in office who has the power to either veto this or not.

Sen. Cruz: NDAA Does Not Protect Our Vital National Security Interest

Votes against final NDAA bill

December 12, 2014

202-228-7561

WASHINGTON, DC -- U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas, today voted against the National Defense Authorization Act citing several concerns, including an extreme land grab provision and ongoing assistance to Syrian rebels.

The 2015 National Defense Authorization Act includes a number of problematic provisions, including an extension through 2016 of the program to arm Syrian rebels and an extreme land grab that restricts more than a half-million new acres of property from productive use, said Sen. Cruz. This is yet another example of Majority Leader Reids legacy of obstruction by not allowing any amendments to be called on this bill.

Although this legislation contains a number of individual provisions I support, it is fundamentally flawed in that it neither protects our most basic rights as American citizens, nor safeguards the vital national security interests of the United States. Congress should reject this attempt to exploit our Armed Forces by self-serving politicians. The NDAA should serve to strengthen our national security and it is imperative that Congress respects and upholds this vital function. The men and women of our military deserve no less.

Areas of concern in the bill include:

  • No prohibition on indefinite detention of citizens and lawful permanent residents.
  • No prohibition on funds used to transfer Guantanamo detainees to Yemen.
  • Extended authorization through 2016 to train and equip Syrian rebels.
  • Public land package which would increase the deficit by $82 million and restrict more than a half million new acres of land.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

I think you are all missing Bob's point. To him the idea of our government doing a land grab is just so obvious and expected.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

Six, it wasyou that brought up race. In fact both Flake and McCain are white. So what the hell is your point.

In fact, Cruz own comments do not mention the 2400 acres that are being taken from the Apache, only that business is restricted from destroying half a million acres.

If your going to start quoting Cruz, it would be best to look at the article and the 2400 acres. That is the crux of this article Six.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Dream Snatcher

apacheland.jpg

Claim: Congress voted to give Apache land to an environmentally exploitative foreign corporation.

content-divider.gif
mixture.gif MIXTURE
content-divider.gif

Example: [Collected via e-mail, December 2014]

Did the house Republicans just approve a bill to give away of Apache ceremonial land to a foreign mining company?

Origins: On

2014, the site Addicting Info published an article titled "House Votes to Sell Apache Land to Foreign Corporation, The Tribe Is Furious" regarding a trade of federally managed land in Arizona (of cultural significance to the Apache) appended to an unrelated and more urgent bill involving the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA). The article stated:
For over 5 years, a measure to cede 2,400 acres sacred to the Apache tribe for use in copper mining has been pushed in Congress. Backed by various well-paid corporatist congress members such as Senator John McCain, this measure inevitably dies from the outrage of the native tribes who care for this land. So, this year the members backed by legalized bribes by foreign corporations have attached the measure to the must-pass National Defense Authorization Act in a lame duck session of congress.
The attempt to hide this brazen attempt to sell off cultural heritage for mere coin tells us how these congress members feel about their duty to protect this nation. One must wonder how much of the estimated in revenue is to be lining these congress members pockets if the bill passes intact. After all, members of congress regularly reap huge profits from bills they introduce.
The article linked to a more detailed explanation of the controversial measure:
The House approved a bill on December 4 that gives of sacred Apache land to a giant international mining corporation, then sent it to the Senate for a fast vote in a process that won't allow amendments to be made. The Senate is expected to act on it this week.
The land swap bill, called the Southeast Arizona Land Exchange and Conservation Act of 2013 was attached as a rider to the annual must-pass National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) along with several other land-related bills.
Much of the claim is correct: a effort to pass the Southeast Arizona Land Exchange and Conservation Act came to issue on 2014 when the measure was attached by members of the House of Representatives to a vote on funding for the NDAA. The NDAA is a United States federal law specifying the budget and expenditures of the United States Department of Defense; as there is no substantive link between the two measures, their attachment amplified criticism that adding the land swap rider to the NDAA unreasonably suppressed opposition to the former.
Native Americans and conservation groups opposed the legislative transfer of land to Resolution Copper Mining, citing both environmental and cultural concerns. Opponents of the measure believed the mode of transfer was heavy-handed and unwarranted:
Pushing a through Congress is not the only option for the mining company to acquire the land, opponents say.
"Rio Tinto has yet to articulate any credible reason why a congressional land exchange is needed, versus the normal administrative processes," states the 2013 letter from the Inter-Tribal Council of Arizona to Congress.
Administrative land exchanges are much more common than legislative land exchanges, says a 2010 policy brief from the University of Montana.
Conservation groups also objected to the privatization of public land, especially culturally significant areas:
"We don't think we should be privatizing public land, especially land that's part of a national forest," and land that's important to indigenous groups, said Athan Manuel, director of the lands protection program for the Sierra Club in Washington.
While the land in question in Arizona is culturally significant to Native American groups such as the Apache, it is not tribal land currently belonging to them. The land is not is being "given" to a mining company; it is being traded for several other parcels, which although cumulatively larger are not valuable to the tribal groups. Use of the land adjacent to the proposed mining site would very likely be disrupted or devalued should the land swap occur as planned.
The Senate voted to advance the NDAA on 2014, with several Republicans voicing strong opposition to the "land grab" measures attached. A final vote was expected on 2014.

Last updated: 12 December 2014
You see you have been fooled again. You let the media determine your opinion. It's the uptown Republicans and Democrats who you should attack, not the Conservatives such as Mike Lee and Ted Cruz who voted in your favor in spite of all the demonizing they receive from the media. The media doesn't want you to know the truth. We are loaded down with bad Republicans and bad Democrats who don't give a crap about any of us.
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

If you missed my point by the end of the next comment, then it is futile to try and get through to you, sorry.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

I'm not excusing McCain nor Flake, but you're excusing the Democrats who have the votes to stop this in its tracks. It may take awhile, but I think you will be able to understand eventually.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

Six, take your political rant and post your own article.

I damn well know that both parties suck when it comes to Indian affairs. I'm also much more informed on this article then having to goggle it to find out what is really happening.

I'm speaking as, and from an Indian point of view Six. Don't try to tell me what is right and wrong and that I'm being lead by newspapers etc. You have no idea what my political leaning are, nor my thought process.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    12 years ago

I hope that I'm understanding your use of the emocons Bob, and that your laughing at the notion that private industry would not trump Indian traditions.

Exactly.

Nothing stands in the way of Big Business.

Big Business is more sacred to America than any religion...

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

Good, thank you Bob.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior    12 years ago

Six - under the Sacred Sites Act, as long as the land was, at one time, aboriginal title, or if the tribe/nation at one time utilized the land - it is to be protected - by law.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

My comments have not been a rant. Sorry you interpreted it that way. I didn't have to Google anything to tell you what I did. I agree both parties suck, but it is not only Indian Affairs. I understand Indians have had the screws put to them much more than any other ethnic group, but land grabbing isn't limited to Indians. It's a government pastime these days as many have lost their land to the government much more recently than every before as a whole.

So you can do your Indian rant and blame it all on the Republicans when the Republicans didn't have the votes to do it.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

All I was saying 1stwarrior is two people who get the short end of the media stick stood up against the land grab, maybe not for the Sacred Sites Act, but for all Americans, which is better than those who didn't stand up against it for any reason.

I see signs all the time in my 60 to 70 thousand miles a year where people's land have been taken from them by the government. They may not be Indians, but they are Americans, and not by choice, but birth and they lose their land as well.

I'm not belittling the land in question here or the tribes at all. All I was saying is this is a national problem we are having.

I'm already aware the Indians have been done wrong many more times than anyone else in this country. That's why it is important to elect those who adhere to the Constitution. Then this wouldn't be happening to any of us.

In the beginning of the comments it was blamed on John McCain and Flake who I despise. That's why I wanted someone to know not all Republicans are like John McCain and not all Democrats are like Tom Cole. If they were then this problem would be solved with a minimum 51 votes to not have the land grab.

It certainly wasn't a political rant, only a little information showing who is standing up for us and who isn't.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

MY ''Indian rant''...LOL, did I say yours was a ''white rant''...It's you Six that keep bringing up race and straying off topic. I blamed McCain and Flake, what part of that are you incapable of understanding?

You keep avoiding the point of the article....Apache land being given to a foreign company...GOT IT!!!!!

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

I know, Kavika. I also know that in your youth and prime, you answered the call above and beyond.

My statement was referring to you and 1stwarrior driving it into the thick skulls of some of us that Indians have a liability that other citizens of this country do not when it comes to protesting and "rioting." I won't ask you or 1stwarrior to post the "rules and restrictions" that Native Americans have to keep in mind when leaving the rez or disagreeing with the feds.

I meant no belittlement of either of you as I am aware you stand tall even when barefoot.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Kavika     12 years ago

''referring to you and 1stwarrior driving in into the thick skulls''...LOL mimi.

I didn't take it as belittlement mimi.

As for standing tall even barefoot, I think that I'm shrunk a inch or so the last couple of years....Smile.gif

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Kavika, would it make you feel any better if it wasn't Apache land being given to a foreign country?

My only point is Ted Cruz and Mike Lee voted against it because of several things including the "Land Grab". Maybe they didn't vote against it because it was "Apache" land, but the principle was they were against "Land Grabbing" which most of the Republicans didn't have a problem with and not enough of the Democrats had a problem with it, and the media would make many in this country believe McCain has 51 votes when the fact is you had two people who were both white who voted with the Constitution as a guideline and didn't discard it as the others are and have been doing.

Sorry, I didn't mean anything about "Indian Rant" other than your whole article deals with Indians and I'm just saying whether it's Indians or anyone else, it's wrong and especially wrong as 1stwarrior has indicated by his comment as to how the law is being broken.

I know it has happened many times and I don't blame you for having the feelings you have about it at all. I have the same feelings, but I not only have these feelings when it involves Indians, I have them when it involves anyone.

 
 
 
Nigel Dogberry
Freshman Silent
link   Nigel Dogberry    12 years ago

Thanks for the clarification, Bob. I misunderstood.

 
 

Who is online



Sean Treacy
Tacos!
CB


92 visitors