Dems, It’s Time to Dump Dixie: With Mary Landrieu’s exit, the Democrats will have lost their last senator in the Deep South. And that’s a good thing.
by:
Michael Tomasky
Lost Cause
Dems, Its Time to Dump Dixie
I dont remember a much sadder sight in domestic politics in my lifetime than that of Mary Landrieu schlumpfing around these last few weeks trying to save a Senate seat that was obviously lost. It was like witnessing the last two weeks of the life of a blind and toothless dog you knew the vet was just itching to destroy. I know that sounds mean about her, but I dont intend it that way. She did what she could and had, as far as I know, an honorable career. I do, however, intend it to sound mean about the reactionary, prejudice-infested place she comes from. A toothless dog is a figure of sympathy. A vet who takes pleasure in gassing it is not.
And that is what Louisiana, and almost the entire South, has become. The victims of the particular form of euthanasia it enforces with such glee are tolerance, compassion, civic decency, trans-racial community, the crucial secular values on which this country was founded I could keep this list going. But I think you get the idea. Practically the whole region has rejected nearly everything thats good about this country and has become just one big nuclear waste site of choleric, and extremely racialized , resentment. A fact made even sadder because on the whole theyre such nice people! (I truly mean that.)
With Landrieus departure, the Democrats will have no more senators from the Deep South, and I say good. Forget about it. Forget about the whole fetid place. Write it off. Let the GOP have it and run it and turn it into Free-Market Jesus Paradise. The Democrats dont need it anyway.
Actually, thats not quite true. They need Florida, arguably, at least in Electoral College terms. Although they dont even really quite need itwhat happened in 2012 was representative: Barack Obama didnt need Florida, but its 29 electoral votes provided a nice layer of icing on the cake, bumping him up to a gaudy 332 EVs, and besides, its nice to be able to say you won such a big state. But Florida is kind of an outlier, because culturally, only the northern half of Florida is Dixie. Ditto Virginia, but in reverse; culturally, northern Virginia is Yankee land (but with gun shops).
So Democrats still need to care about those two states, at least in presidential terms. And maybe you can throw in North Carolina under the right circumstances. And at some point in the near future, youll be able to talk about Georgia as a state a Democrat can capture. And eventually, Texas, too.
But thats presidential politics. At the congressional level, and from there on down, the Democrats should just forget about the place. They should make no effort, except under extraordinary circumstances, to field competitive candidates. The national committees shouldnt spend a red cent down there. This means every Senate seat will be Republican, and 80 percent of the House seats will be, too. The Democrats will retain their hold on the majority-black districts, and theyll occasionally be competitive in a small number of other districts in cities and college towns. But theyre not going win Southern seats (I include here with some sadness my native West Virginia, which was not a Southern state when I was growing up but culturally is one now). And they shouldnt try.
My friend the political scientist Tom Schaller said all this back in 2008, in his book Whistling Past Dixie . I didnt want to agree with Schaller then, but now I throw in the towel. He was a man ahead of his time. Look west, Schaller advised the Democrats. And he was right. Now its true that many states in the nations heartland arent winnable for Democrats, either. Kansas, Nebraska, Wyoming, Idaho, and Utah will never come anywhere close to being purple. But Colorado already is. Arizona can be. Missouri, its not crazy to think so. And Montana and South Dakota are basically red, of course, but are both elect Democrats sometimes. (Did you know that both of Montanas senators right now are Democrats?!) In sum, between the solid-blue states in the North and on the West Coast, and the pockets of opportunity that exist in the states just mentioned (and tossing in the black Southern seats), the Democrats can cobble together congressional majorities in both houses, under the right circumstances
But its not just a question of numbers. The main point is this: Trying to win Southern seats is not worth the ideological cost for Democrats. As Memphis Rep. Steve Cohen recently told my colleague Ben Jacobs, the Democratic Party cannot (and Id say should not) try to calibrate its positions to placate Southern mores: Its come to pass, and really a lot of white Southerners vote on gays and guns and God, and were not going to ever be too good on gays and guns and God.
Cohen thinks maybe some economic populism could work, and that could be true in limited circumstances. But I think even that is out the window now. In the old days, drenched in racism as the South was, it was economically populist. Glass and Steagall, those eponymous bank regulators, were both Southern members of Congress. But today, as we learned in Sundays Times , state attorneys general, many in the South, are colluding with energy companies to fight federal regulation of energy plants.
Its lost. Its gone. A different country. And maybe someday it really should be. Ill save that for another column. Until that day comes, the Democratic Party shouldnt bother trying. If they get no votes from the region, they will in turn owe it nothing, and in time the South, which is the biggest welfare moocher in the world in terms of the largesse it gets from the more advanced and innovative states, will be on its own, which is what Southerners always say they want anyway.
The main point is this: Trying to win Southern seats is not worth the ideological cost for Democrats.
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2014/12/08/dems-it-s-time-to-dump-dixie.html

Feel Free to discuss your thoughts:
I Agree with the Author Michael Tomasky, Why bother?? they despise progressive policies anyway...
Thanks Bruce for your input...
Nice of Tomasky to provide a fine example of a bigot at work. He has a long history of such wignuttery.
" Practically the whole region has rejected nearly everything thats good about this country and has become just one big nuclear waste site of choleric, and extremely racialized , resentment."
Too bad for Tomasky that blacks are actually fleeing the socialist utopias of cities like Chicago and New York to move back to Southern states, where they are safer and have better economic opportunities.
But facts don't matter to a bigot like Tomasky. Like a true zealot, he'll continue to advocate his policies until all of America looks like Detroit.
That is both surprising and understandable .
And then What JR??? Are we going to set up border patrol stations that anyone wanting to travel from southern states to northern and vice versa would be required to have visas or show papers? sounds like we are heading in that direction,( East/West Germany) I do not agree with a lot of the conservative beliefs but some I do, now what? will there be laws made to benefits southern republican states? democrats will not agree to such, we are going to be more divided than currently, I see disaster ahead...
...if I am elected, I promise to turn the clock of this great nation back to 1853, when a man had a gun on his hip and a pint in his pocket-- when a five-dollar gold coin would buy you a steak dinner, a quart of rye whiskey, and a good piece of ass...
Considering that both parties are beholden to corporate dollars, ideological differences between the two is merely window dressing to deceive the uninitiated.
Mary Landrieu doesn't even live in Louisiana. She lives in Washington DC in a $2.5 million dollar house and has raised her children there. About the only time she even goes to Louisiana is around election time. In order to qualify for the ballot in Louisiana she used her parents home. That's why we need to rid ourselves of these career politicians from these political families which are turning into dynasties. She also voted with Obama 97% of the time, so that was a big factor.
Some who have much worse racial problems still think it's the south even though most of the racial problems are not in the south, but it works for them in their propaganda or brainwashed minds.