Black Lives Don't Matter -- Posted by Daniel Greenfield @ the Sultan Knish blog 12/4/2014
The slogan of the wave of Ferguson protests is Black Lives Matter. But progressives are far more interested in toting around the corpse of Michael Brown to their protests than in the living man he was.
Trayvon Martin, Michael Brown and countless others like them grew up in broken families, their lives haunted by fathers and stepfathers with gang ties. The only masculine culture they had was that of the thug and that culture eventually killed them.
Criminal culture is even more fatal to criminals than it is to their victims. If you attack enough people, eventually one of them will fight back. Eventually one of them will kill you.
It wasnt Darren Wilson who decided that black lives dont matter. Michael Brown did. He did not grow up with a sense that his life was worth anything more than violent posturing could make of it. Just like Martin, that violent posturing eventually killed him.
Rappers recorded a tribute song to Michael Brown titled, Dont Shoot. But Browns own songs had a different theme with lyrics like My favorite part of killing people is when they hit the ground.
Black criminals victimize other black people first. The Ferguson looters went after businesses serving the black community and businesses owned by black people. Thats the way it always is.
Which black lives really matter in Missouri; the lives of criminals shot by police officers or the black lives taken by criminals?
Missouri has a black homicide rate that is nearly double the nationwide homicide rate for black people. And its nearly six times higher than the overall murder rate in Missouri.
If the media were really outraged by lost black lives, they would be outraged by those numbers. If the protesters really wanted to say that black lives matter, they would fight those murder rates instead of contributing to them with their protests. The story of Missouris murder rate is the story of the left.
From the beginning to the end of the 1960s, murder rates doubled, rapes, robberies and car thefts doubled, assaults tripled and thefts quadrupled.
A decade in which America changed left a bloody trail of death and misery in its wake. The victims of the lefts transformation of America filled the gutters, morgues, prisons and hospitals.
When Giuliani pointed out that the police were there to protect black people, he was asserting that black lives matter. And unlike every single one of his self-righteous critics, he actually saved black lives.
The decision of his Socialist successor, Bill de Blasio, to move criminals back into housing projects was a statement that they dont. Housing projects in the pre-Giuliani era belonged to drug dealers. Getting criminals out of housing projects saved black lives, especially those of children.
The Black Lives Matter protesters claim that theres a crisis of police shootings. There isnt. There is a crisis of young black men shooting each other.
After the shooting of drug dealer Derrick Jones, the NAACP breathlessly reported that 37 black people were shot by police in Oakland over four years. Meanwhile there were 1,594 shooting victims in Oakland in one year.
The vast majority of the perpetrators were black. The majority of murder victims were young black men. So were their killers. The leading cause of death for young black men is murder. The perpetrators are other young black men.
If black lives really mattered, then the life of a young black man shot down by a criminal would matter at least as much as Michael Brown. But those black lives dont matter.
The progressive Ferguson protesters not only dont care about them, but they want to take more black lives by empowering criminals and crippling the police.
The gang is to the black community as the cartel is to lawless parts of Mexico, except that the American equivalents of the Narcocorrido, the songs glamorizing cartel drug dealers, are distributed by major music labels and their performers are invited to the White House.
While Mexico tries to fight drug and gang music, American progressives make it mainstream.
Gang culture in Black America, which is responsible for most of the gun violence in the country, isnt the work of a few thugs in a burned out building; its promoted by progressives in the entertainment industry. The black lives taken by its glamorization of drug dealing and violent killing also dont matter.
You dont show that black lives matter by supporting criminal control over entire black neighborhoods. When you fight the criminals who are taking black lives, when you roll back crime, then you show that black lives really matter. When you help criminals you are announcing that black lives dont matter.
Despite its self-righteousness about black lives mattering, the left isnt any good at saving them. It is however really good at taking them. Planned Parenthoods black outreach arm announced on Twitter that it was joining the Ferguson protests because #BlackLivesMatter.
More African-American lives were ended at abortion clinics in the United States than anywhere else. But those black lives also dont matter.
The 6,000 black people murdered in one year dont matter. The 400,000 black babies killed in one year dont matter. Does a black man have to be killed by a white cop for his life to matter to the left? Thats the only conclusion that can be drawn from Ferguson.
To the #BlackLivesMatter crowd, the furious white hipsters crowding malls and staging die-ins, black lives only matter when they feed their own political agendas, their grudges and their own egos.
If black lives really mattered to the left, it would not have built an entire industry, an entire culture and an entire political movement around taking them.
Progressives only care about black people when theyre using them as weapons. For black lives to matter to them, they have to be dead at the hands of a white man. For black unemployment to matter to them, they have to be able to blame it on Republicans. Black poverty, black homelessness only matter to them when they can cash in on a social justice solution that doesnt fix the problem.The rest of the time they dont pay attention and dont care.
Black people exist for the political convenience of progressives. Black lives dont matter to them except when they can make use of them. The master-slave relationship has shifted from the plantation to the poll inflating the self-esteem and power of the masters while destroying the lives of their slaves.
The Ferguson protests are not about saving black lives, but promoting the pro-crime politics that take them. Its message is that all black people are criminals and have to be protected from law enforcement. By turning Michael Brown into the ubiquitous black man, the left reveals how racist it really is.
If black lives truly matter, then they matter when the conditions of their misery cant be blamed on white people. If black lives truly mattered to the protesters, they would fight crime instead of supporting the criminals taking black lives.

It's not about separating them, John. It's a question of priorities. Why do liberalsignore "the issues associated with inner city black social dysfunction," which is a much more important problem, in favor ofexploitingthe much lesspervasive occurrence of intentional police misconductvis a vis blacks? The question is why do liberals only care about the latter while ignoring the former?
I live in a village with a large black population and my kids went to integrated schools. Next door, and across the street, my neighbors are Asian.
I was in an organization, "Bridging the Gap"wherein Imentored a black high-school student.
I have no plans to move.
Your assertions about Republicansare self-servingleftist myths.
I would not want to live in a crime-ridden, drug-riddenneighborhood.
Would you?
Its the cold hard truth Black lives only matter when taken by a White ,if it werent the truth these people would be marching through the streets of just about any city with a large Black population. Our so called civil rights leaders such as Sharpton and the NAACP need it this way, and its amazing to me how many Whites have fallen for it . This isnt a racial issue its a Black issue and it needs to be dealt with ,not at Times Square but in the heart of the Black Community
If President Obama wanted to do something that would truly benefit everyone he would read this article word for word on national television .II have yet to read an article more truthful then this one.
It would not benefit him politically.
That is what's important.
Conservative minds work so well that leftists cannot catch up so they remain stuck in their ancient constructs.
It is a racial issue. And like any racial issue, it needs to be addressed in a PROPORTIONAL manner with all the other racial issues. It's a nasty issue, but one that will not allow the other issues to be addressed. And those other issues affect ALL members of the population who seek resolution to the problems that beset them.
It's a hot button issue, John. It's ruining the chances for the morecritical issues to be properly addressed.
organize a protest march to promote your theme, and head down to 67th and Ashland in the Englewood neighborhood of Chicago
How sad. My dad was an alter boy at Saint Theodore, which was located just a few blocks from that intersection. Now the area is apparently so bad that one can't even go there and work for a better society.
Great job Chicago Democrats!
First, I am calling BS on this in the article:
De Blasio does not have a policy to move criminals back into housing projects. What he does have is a policy to move homeless into housing:
Mayor Bill de Blasio's administration plans to dedicate 750 apartments a year in public housing to homeless families , officials said Tuesday, a number that council members and advocates say isn't enough to address record levels of homelessness.
Roughly 5,000 apartments become available each year inside developments run by the New York City Housing Authority, the largest public housing agency in the nation. Advocates and elected officials want the mayor to designate 2,500 a year to move homeless families out of city shelters. More than 53,000 people, including nearly 23,000 children, slept in a city shelter last weekboth records.
...
Now onto the actual topic. There is truth to both sides of this discussion. Black on black crime is something that should be addressed, especially in the public housing. But also there is a need to have better policing techniques. This last case with the so called choke hold, is proof of that. Also having more minority police and community liaisons would be a good start.
This response has nothing to do with the question. Looks like another liberal ignoring inner city black social dysfunction.
It is not only DeBlasio but others before him who allowed more criminals into public housing:
Ideally there should be no correlation between homeless families and crime. But the deterioration of the housing correlated with the homeless priority decision. That is why Mayor Bloomberg rescinded it. Mayor DeBlasio will have to relearn the lesson.
When black cops treat blacks in a disparate way, why is it never an issue of any sort?
That is exactly why...
The idea that blacks should embrace Republicans is a real hoot
Englewood is exactly why blacks should throw off their Democratic party oppressors. Democrats have controlled the City for generations and have turned large swaths of the city into a slum. Engelwood used to be a stable middle class neighborhood, now as you seem proud of, people can't even go their in safety to have have a discussion. Republicans could not possibly do worse for blacks for then Democrats have done, and Englewood is example A.
How many generations have to be wasted in neighborhoods like Englewood for you to realize that liberal democratic policies have wreaked havoc on black communities?
Blaming problems inner city blacks have on "white flight" is absolute ridiculous bullshit. Please explain why these neighborhoods went down the toilet after white people left. I also challenge you to find one single instance where "white flight" did not coincide with increases in crime.
John,
There you go blaming the problems of inner city blacks on white flight again. Do you think blacks are incapable of governing themselves? What exactly are you trying to say? Please explain why you don't seem to think a city of black people can thrive on their own.
You are avoiding the question. As usual.
Repeating something doesn't make it true. DeBlasio isn't letting criminals into public housing, but is adding public housing for the homeless. Furthermore, the quote you gave from your own article is cherry picked and out of context.
First of all, Mayor Bloomberg didn't rescind it... it clearly says in the article that he was going to go forth with the repairs, but that he became backlogged. The article finds that thecorrelationofneglectof public housing is tied to crime.
NO one yelled louder and fought the blacks from entering Englewood harder than the Chicago Democrat party. The tactics and fear mongering of the Democrat party is as responsible for "white flight" as anything else you can name.
Englewood has been majority black for about 50 years now and has continued to fare extremely poorly under all democratic mayors, black or white. From Daley on, they've all been New Deal liberals who've tried and failed decade after decade to decade to solve englewood's problems with the liberal theory of the day and have uniformly failed.
Yes you are. What difference does it make if there are poor white or black people in the city? Poor is poor and poor is not prejudiced. There are as many poor white as poor black. So why are you trying to blame the problems on white flight? Why do you seem to believe black people are incapable of governing themselves?
He certainly wasn't a social liberal, but he was an economic one.
No John the truth is Blacks have the same opportunity as anyone else and what you are saying is the same thing that as been used by the ghetto pimps such as Sharpton in their brain washing of the Black community for years. How often do you here of the so called civil rights leaders speaking about education or family values? No they sit back and wait like buzzards for opportunitys like this where they can jump out and yell I told you so. Many Black people alienate themselves and the only barrier to escaping crime and poverty is the will to do it.
Actually John, 96 is right here. Poor is poor and most poor areas have a crime rate higher than non poor neighborhoods.
Furthermore, white flight didn't happen in a vacuum. Here is an interesting study done by the Bronx Historical Society, explaining what happened in the Bronx
Now this is not to say, that we shouldn't help the these neighborhoods. Most of the residents that live there are honest good working poor. I spent over 20 years of my life working with these families. But it's about 15% of the crime element that makes life there horrible. That needs to be addressed within the community and by the proper agencies.
I dont really see to many glaring examples of that at least these days. There are bad cops no doubt just like bad priest. Yes it happens but no where near the scale your trumping it up to be .
Gunny you are totally right ,but blowing things totally out of porportion isnt helping, I call it enabling .
Robert,
When I worked in Brownsville, Brooklyn, there was a program of community liaisons. When we had it, crime went down in the neighborhood, along with drug usage. When it was discontinued, it shot right back up. So it is more than just having black cops.
As for our force having racial disparity, I am not sure where you are getting your information.
There is an effort to change this, but this is how it stands now.
I don't disagree with you about the stupidity of how enforcement goes in NYC, it still doesn't make it right.
You neglected to note who has quoted Daniel Greenfield and it's right there at the link.
Oversight? It's on the left sidebar right at the very top.
Nah.
"Quoted" by
A Who's Who of Racist-Panderers!
But let's talk about "lives not mattering."
Choke-hold cop sued in prior misconduct cases
...
As for Daniel Greenfield, how dare a Jewish individual blame a race for its victimization by a culture that institutionalizes racism!
And
Missouri AG confirms Michael Brown grand jury misled by St. Louis DA
...
No John, that is not what you said at all because you keep pointing to white flight as part of the problem. The white people that left did not make the black people poor. The black people that bought the houses that the white people used to own, bought houses they could afford, which goes to say they were in pretty much the same financial situation as the white people that left.
sorry had to delete the other and repost
Who said the quote is not the point. The point is that you keep trying to say white flight is part (or even most) of the problem. Like I said before, it was not the white people moving that made the black people poor and the black people who bought homes from fleeing white people were in about the same financial class. Otherwise they could not afford the home. Which brings us back to:
You can't blame the situation that the black people are in, in any particular city, on the fact that the white people left that city. It is ridiculous. You are basically saying black people are incapable of governing themselves.
No, job discrimination, segregated, under-resourced schools and neighborhoods each played a part.
But you may not be aware of BLOCKBUSTING AND RED LINING
Blockbusting was a business practice of U.S. real estate agents and building developers meant to encourage white property owners to sell their houses at a loss, by implying that racial minorities were moving into their previously racially segregated neighborhood, thus depressing real estate property values .
[1] Blockbusting became possible after the legislative and judicial dismantling of legally protected racially segregated real estate practices after World War II , but by the 1980s it largely disappeared as a business practice after changes in law and the real estate market. [2]
And REDLINING
Well I am sure that this is a factor. I question how big of one. I can tell you in my case crime is the reason we left Detroit. Crime is also hand in hand in declining housing prices. I am not trying to argue that there are segregated neighborhoods either. I would argue that it is kind of a tough to try to say black people were "corralled" into living together or suckered into living together by low housing prices. Why wouldn't they just sell the house if they didn't want to live there any more and move somewhere else? There are plenty of poor neighborhoods in this country to choose from.
Another riveting rebuttal from a guy who often has nothing of substance to say
but says it anyway.
Going from one poor neighborhood to another to escape of of the manifestations of a "poor neighborhood," namely crime how can that work as an alternative?
Indeed you are.
Try to rebut using
a rebuttal.
Not that complicated a concept.
It worked for us. We moved to a more rural area.
You are slandering all these people and vainly attempting to conflate conservatism with racism. At least one of those names is a Black man.
If he was not convicted in any of them (which he was not)you are simply smearing him. That is Number 2 for you AMac.
Read it again. He is blaming "progressives" primarily.
Let us see how that turns out. Accusations are cheap and you8 are a prime example.
Check their history; Dathans come in all colors.
Shall I give you some of the histories?
Let's begin
GLENN BECK
As for
He's blaming the victims for their own victimization.
Keeping score, Len? Conviction by a jury doesn't establish innocence or guilt; it renders a verdict based on the presentation of information which, if you note my DNA evidence exoneration (in another comment) and others, indicates that juries sometimes make mistakes, are intentionally misled, or, are prejudiced.
Dismissed and sealed and the city settled. Not the same as "innocent." Why sealed? Why settled? For how much?
As for McCulloch the facts are established regardless of whether or not he is charged with misfeasance. I have posted those facts but you failed to address any.
Perrie, you are presumably referring to this. Looking at your chart there were relatively few homeless additions during this period. But crime is a lagging indicator and the increase cited is arguably a result of the earlier surge in homeless admissions.
When I was in my early teens I lived in public housing that was biracial. The only crime was that of my friends and I playing football on the large lawns from which we kept getting chased away by porters. The facilities were clean and people were civil. I chanced to visit another project a few years ago and the appearance was quite different. There was graffiti and rubbish all over.
You are slandering all these people and vainly attempting to conflate conservatism with racism. At least one of those names is a Black man.
What is a "dathan?"
You began and ended with him. I am no fan or follower but virtually all your "evidence" was meaningless tripe; weak at best. You toss slander around freely and casually.
If he was not convicted in any of them (which he was not)you are simply smearing him. That is Number 2 for you AMac.
Now you are dissembling with platitudes. Do you expect us to throw up our hands in confusion? No such luck!
After demeaning jury verdicts you raise yourimplications of a settlement above such verdicts. And you pretend to be logical?
Opinions are not facts.
I give you ten detailed specific examples and you come back with
I didn't mention "conservatism," YOU DID; are you saying all the names on the list are conservatives, Len.?
Dathan is a traitor one who sells out his own people in exchange for favorable treatment from his/their oppressors.
Say the word, I'll go down the list for you.
Providing the correct logistics of the process is not in-and-of-itself demeaning; each phenomenon I listed occurs in jury trials.
Do I have to post the facts AGAIN?
November 25, 2014
And
...
. ..
I'm always happy to debate with you, Len, but don't play word games with me using platitudes and pronouncements.
I don't know all the names but the ones I know are conservatives.
Is that your new version of uncle Tom? That is a slander of Alan West, a war hero who was unjustly drummed out of service.
Your intent was to trivialize the first and raise the second; a sophomoric means of countering my points..
Opinions are not facts.
November 25, 2014
Prosecutors can indict a ham sandwich, we were lectured, because the states burden in a grand-jury proceeding is so scant. Prosecutors need not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt , as they must do at trial; they merely need show probable cause that a crime was committed and by the person of whom it was alleged and a trial should therefore be held. ---
To describe this as nonsense is a slander on nonsense. It is freely conceded that the grand-jury inquest into Browns killing was more a political than a legal exercise. That, however, was the result of intimidation by the Lefts race-mythology agitators very much including the president and the attorney general of the United States. It was clearly not aimed at benefitting Wilson.
In a typical case, prosecutors rely on the low probable-cause threshold applicable in grand-jury investigations only for the purpose of limiting how much evidence they need to present. Contrary to another regnant myth, guilt is not in doubt in most criminal cases. Overwhelmingly, they are open-and-shut, often supported by post-arrest confessions. As a result, the grand jury can appear to be a pro forma exercise a cookie-cutter procedure the Constitution requires before an accused person can be convicted of a crime he not only clearly committed but to which he will almost certainly plead guilty.
On the other hand, when convinced that the subject of an investigation either is innocent or is incapable of being proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, prosecutors do not present the case to the grand jury. Thats because their focus is the trial, not the indictment. If, after preliminary investigation, prosecutors do not assess the evidence as strong enough to convince a trial jury to render a unanimous guilty verdict, they dismiss the case on the basis of their own professional judgment it never sees the grand-jury room.
At a proper trial, Wilson could not have been convicted of murder. That does not mean what happened was not horrible it was. It does not mean Wilson is not civilly liable (although I doubt that he is). It simply means the circumstances of the shooting do not meet the high criminal-law standards for either intentional homicide or the criminally irresponsible causing of death.
The critics claim that Wilsons innocence is put in doubt by conflicting testimony is legally and factually frivolous. Legally, our system resolves all doubt in favor of the accused. (Andrew McCarthy)
I don't know of that forum but, based on your citation, it is likely run by leftist lawyers. It is easy to find experts who contradict those you roll out.
I am familiar with Pamela Geller. She is a great American performing an unappreciated service by reporting news the mass media ignores because of their inclination to PC. You ought to read her blog instead of quoting some a$$hole Islamophile.
Robert G. your entire response is just idiotic and sickening!!!!
Local prosecutors who call grand juries with regard to the possible indictment of a local police officer, are often guilty of a conflict-of-interests; THEY NEED THE POLICE TO MAKE MOST OF THEIR CASES AND DO NOT WANT TO ALIENATE THEM.
If you don't see this, you don't grasp the realty.
All such cases should be given to a SPECIAL PROSECUTOR with no ties to local police.
Pamela Geller is an Islamaphobe. She works hard to give the impression that every Muslim is a terrorist. And every intelligent, objective person knows that's not the case. She panders to ethnocentrists who, broad-brush hate.
Shall I go to the next one?
To describe this as nonsense is a slander on nonsense.
I am familiar with Pamela Geller. She is a great American performing an unappreciated service by reporting news the mass media ignores because of their inclination to PC. You ought to read her blog instead of quoting some a$$hole Islamophile. You evidently are one too. You also ought to read Tom Friedman in today's NY Times. He stepped out of the box and will undoubtedly earn your wrath as another islamophobefor criticizing Islam:
Take your head out of the sand and shed your dogma about the "religion of peace" that has committed 25,000 terrorist attacks just since 9/11. That is five per day. Here is a list:
I didn't say nor imply anything about the religion itself, only that painting every member of a particular religion with the same brush is inherently inaccurate.
Think of how Jews have been mischaracterized with stereotypes and demagoguery and the haters with their heads in the sand who run with the stereotypes.
Of course there are many good individual Muslims but they keep their mouths shut. If only 5 % of the 1.57 billion Muslims are jihadists that comes out to 78.5 million -- 25% of the US population.
About 14% of Muslims in the nations surveyed (by Pew in 2013)said violence against civilians is "often" or "sometimes" justified. That is 220 million. The Qur'an urges violence against non-Muslims.
How can this be compared even remotely to Christianity or Judaism? The media hides what Muslim perpetrates while Pamela Geller reports it.