NYPD Officer Not Indicted in Eric Garner Choke Hold Death
A grand jury in Staten Island has decided not indict New York City Police Officer Daniel Pantaleo in relation to the death of Eric Garner, a man that Pantaleo was seen on video putting in an apparent choke hold in July, according to city officials and lawyers for Garner's family.
The grand jury's decision means that there will not be criminal charges in the case, but NYPD Commissioner Bill Bratton said earlier today that there may be up to three other investigations into the incident that could lead to a civil case or federal charges.
Garner's family has already indicated that they plan to file a wrongful death lawsuit against the NYPD for $75 million.
The grand jury was made up of 23 residents of Staten Island and led by a foreperson. A decision required a majority of the jury -- meaning at least 12 people.
Pantaleo, 29, and his police partner, Justin D'Amico, testified in front of the jury. D'Amico appeared only after being granted immunity from prosecution. - Source
******************************************
I don't know all the details but what I do know is that a white New York City police officer was videotaped causing the chokehold death of an unarmed black man who had been stopped on suspicion of selling loose, untaxed cigarettes.
I'm refuse to make any comparisons to Ferguson as both cases are different but the outcomes are the same; another senseless death.
This kind of animalistic behavior by law enforcement authorities has become epidemic.

True Aeon - and in this one, there is video showing the office placing him in a chokehold - you can hear the man struggling to say "I can't breath - I can't breath" - and you can see the man slump down.
Way too much evidence pointing to excessive force, plus the officer had been cited for excessive force previously.
Big time wrong decision - big time.
Where's Holder when you need him???
When the system is no longer controlled by whites, whites will be the ones screaming for indictments.
This is a disgraceful outcome some days I'm ashamed to be white.
Wow; it will take some time to analyze such a deeply thought out rebuttal.
My God what is this cop haters corner, hug a thug ? What if. just what if Garner had just allowed himself to be handcuffed after he was told he was under arrest ,for how ever silly the charge. One he would still be alive a secondly a bunch of idiots wouldnt be out looking to destroy where they live. The bottom line of all this Black stupidity supposedly is for the lives of Black youths. Whats being overlooked is incidents such as Brown and ths are pretty much exceptions when it comes taking the lives of Black youth. The truth is more Black lives are lost in Black communities by Black people and no one seems to care. A few weeks ago a fourteen year old Black girl was gunned down on the street by a Black teen, she wasnt breaking the law just walking home . Where is the outrage ? Where is Sharptom , Jackson and the NAACP doesnt her life count? The problem with these people is they arent pro Black theyre anti White and its a concerted effort to keep the lie of rampant racisim alive.I actually saw a program the other day where these low lives had a room full of minority children and were telling them how to respond to the police when being treated 'treated differently' by them. I think simply telling them if they act like thugs they will be treated like thugs which is more often then not the truth.
John - 23 on the jury, 8 Black, 15 mix of Hispanic/White. Washington Post article.
Many police are way to eager to shoot first. Check this out which happened in Milwaukee a few days ago;
Everyone is wrongly using "chokehold" as a descriptor.
A retired NY officer told me that a chokehold is one in which a nightstick is used for choking.
I would describe the hold here as a headlock which was used to restrain and subdue a resistant person.
Wilson was criticized for shooting instead of using a non-lethal approach. Here a non-lethal approach was used but the prisoner had a heart attack. He was not killed purposely.
I recall being head-locked as a youth. It was uncomfortable but not fatal.
Predictably enter the canard-carrying apologists.
Most crimes are opportunistic
Blacks don't kill blacks because they have racially profiled their victims nor do whites profile white victims.
But many police officers/departments and police want-to-be types in fact, do profile.
Remember the George Zimmerman 911 call?
First of all you come at me with a knife your getting blasted, Im not going to run from you. This isnt professionalism thats just dumb luck. life is to short and you only get one ,suppose the cop had tripped and wanna be Jack the ripper wasnt so amiable.
Good thing you aren't a cop.
I recall being head-locked as a youth.
OOH im sorry youre approaching this from the cop hater angle not the racial angle hard to keep track ,sorry for the derail. But all thw whinninng aside all the man had to do was let them arrest him. When the cops tell you youre under arrest,your going easy or hard , Mr Garner choose the latter without checking wih his doctor to see if his heart was strong enough for stupidity. By the way I live about ten miniuted from Newark NJ so there aint a whole lot you can tell me about Black on Black crime. There was 11 shootings there over thanksgiving got a White neighborhood that can top that?
Len the apologist.
Hey Len, Garner DIED that makes it LETHAL.
The prisoner had a heart attack because the police used excessive force even after Garner sain he couldn't breathe.
My God! The myopia is palpable.
A headlock is applied somewhat higher on the body than a choke hold
See, a choke hold makes it hard to breathe because, you know, you choke.
The fucking racist rationalizations here are sickening.
We have a genocide situation in America minorities are the targets and ignorant white people are the apologists, cheerleaders and or the murderers.
When a particular demographic is not only victimized, but is robbed of its "day-in-court" both literally and figuratively, WTF is it supposed to do?
Hey Len, recall the uprising in the Warsaw Ghetto
When Nazis made laws that sanctioned the murders of Jews, THAT WAS THE LAW OF THE LAND NO INDICTMENTS, Len.
See the parallel? Rigged game.
Well you're the expert then wow ten minutes
Keeping score are you?
I already explained the phenomenon of opportunistic crime vs. racial profiling.
But you live 10 minutes from Newark so what the hell do I know about inner city blacks?
Its all in the eyes of the beeholder Hal my pal .and aside from saggy pants you didnt mention animal abusers , and child molesters .
Aeon is a better thing you arent because you haaavent got a clue . The meek shall inherit nothing.
I would love to see how some of these keyboard Kojaks would react if they were police officers.
ifs thats your picture i think thats what i should be asking you .I rose from the inner city whats your claim to fame?
My claim to fame?
70 years in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Worked extensively and directly with thousands of inner city kids, most were black.
Still live IN PHILADELPHIA
Elected twice to Philadelphia Democratic City Committee, represented hundreds of public employees (mostly black) in adverse action hearings and arbitrations, worked as a consultant to teachers in the Philadelphia Public Schools, teaching them to use Apple/Mac computers in the day-to-day classroom, was technical consultant to a project wherein Phiily public school kids (elementary/middle and high school) and their teachers designed and created a mural, "History of South Philadelphia" installed in one of the city's hospital lobbies, represented one of the teachers in part responsible for the formation of the R&B group, Boyz II Men.
Need more?
No Democrat pretty much said it all. Malcom x had some flattering things to say about the Democratic party which sadly still ring true today.
WTF does that have to do with this thread?
A. Mac - I'd kinda back off the "racist" calling here.
Grand Juries are obsolete they originally existed to act as a deterrent to oppressive government. BUT NOW THEY ARE INHERENTLY CONFLICT-OF-INTEREST TOOLS FOR PROSECUTORS WHEN IT COMES TO (NOT) INDICTING POLICE!
And why?
BECAUSE PROSECUTORS OFTEN NEED POLICE COOPERATION TO HELP THEM WIN THEIR CASES!
That's how it is.
Just explain why racism isn't an issue and I might.
Is this the comment that brought about your request?
Did you see this rationalization despite the video and photo in the article?
Some can't see the choke hold even though it's not disputable and a violation of the NYPD protocol!
Here's a winner!
Sorry 1st. I'm not backing away from my assertion.
You brought it up,
Do you think this cop was using something he learned , in other words knew what he was doing or do you think it was just a grab what you can?
Did you ask for my background?
You used "ten minutes from Newark" as your credentials then asked for mine.
And once I gave them, you failed to comment on all but my election to office (in an actual city).
"Do you think this cop was using something he learned , in other words knew what he was doing or do you think it was just a grab what you can?"
He was doing something HE LEARNED NOT TO DO BECAUSE IT VIOLATES NYPD PROTOCOL!
More bending over backwards to rationalize away the obvious.
How about before you do the seat-of-the-pants case-making, you get some background on the subject?
Len, a chokehold isn't a headlock and it is lethal.
Big people deserve bias !
1ofmany, it's not lethal if used properly, when not used properly or is meant to be lethal, it is lethal.
Agreed 1ofmany.
Perhaps we need perspective from a lawyer regardingwhatforce police are "allowed" to use when some one is resisting arrest. We can discuss whether this "hold" and eventual take down is excessive, but what are the legal instructions to a grand jury? If a suspect puts hands on an officer, I believe the officer can determine what force is necessary to apprehend. In this case the law would be on the side of the officer and the suspects heart attack is beyond his control.
Until we review the laws of engagement between police and the population these instances will continue.
Comparing Nazi Germany to the US is a non starter.
As is slandering me.
You are the one always pontificating about sticking to issues and avoiding personal attacks. Doc; heal yourself.
This GJ was normal in its secrecy and it was much larger than the Ferguson one. You will not be able to nit-pick except to call them all racists.
WhenGarner said he can't breath the grip was loosened in a few seconds. His death, later in a hospital,was likely due to heart disease caused by his size and excitement.
The prosecutor is seeking courtapproval to release selectGJ minutes so he is not trying to hide anything.
To be continued -- for sure.
Because theracism accusation these days is the last refuge of leftist scoundrels who cannot accept that people under arrest should submit peacefully and let the ACLU do their fighting.
Why is that so hard for you to accept in every instance? Are you an anarchist?
They attempted to handcuff him but he refused to be handcuffed.
As an experthow would you have restrained this hulk without force?
How do you know?
1ofmany,
Personally, I find this entire incident fraught with questions and the unnecessary force probably contributed to this mans death. That's why I wanted to examine the legal aspects, particularly when we're viewing several incidents and grand juries are not indicting.
I don't know if "minimal" resistance even matters in the letter of the law. I think once resisting occurs the incident escalates and deadly force is now in the officers response protocol.
Kudos and a tip of the Swami's turban AP... simply priceless!!
Thanks i was just wondering
Mac though it is a public forum the question wasnt for you and is it against rhe COC to tell someone to shut the fuck up?
Grand jury secrecy is now used and abused by prosecutors to protect rogue cops because the prosecutors must work with those police officers/departments in many of the cases they prosecute. Both the Ferguson and Staten Island cases make that abundantly clear.
As for the Warsaw Ghetto comparison, when laws are used to institutionalize bigotry and prejudice and others skirted to allow the indiscriminate murder of a race or other demographic, and that race cannot get its day in court because the system is rigged against it, little or nothing is left but for them to demonstrate, rebel ...
The apologists for those who murder black kids the perpetrators of which are then protected by the "legal system," rely essentially on what all abusive power structures rely upon, that being tacit approval, outright support and ... Apologists!
A death dealing choke hold delivered by an excessive-force tag team is NOT a "headlock" in some little kids' wrestling match and comparing it to that is making an apology for a crime by mischaracterizing the reality and somehow then, smearing and blaming the victim. Garner was murdered because he was depriving the government of the sales tax derived from the alleged sale of a loose cigarette!
AND BECAUSE HE WAS BLACK!
It's all too clear how the death of a black kid by the gun of a bad cop or a George Zimmerman brings out the cheerleaders and apologists despite the glaring legal and inhuman abominations associated.
You make your arguments I'll make mine; if you're going to become sensitive when the gloves come off, show a little sensitivity for the black kid who didn't need to die, his family, all the blacks in America who have to be afraid because they are black, and for an America that has a hate problem embedded in its soul.
Michael Brown was not a "Hulk Hogan Demon" as he was thus smeared and Garner too, Len, you call a "hulk!"
NO! THESE WERE HUMAN BEINGS JAY WALKERS AND SELLERS OF LOOSE CIGARETTES WHO WERE MURDERED FOR BEING BLACK AT THE WRONG TIME IN THE WRONG PLACE!
Don't tell me about PLAYING THE RACE CARD WHEN THOSE WHO LIVEit, in their way, enable the bad cops and George Zimmermans to kill and walk free.
Who told you to "shut the fuck up?"
How many cops have to be holding you down on the concrete, one leaning on your head, that while hearing 11 times, the words, "I CAN'T BREATHE," before it becomes lethal?
Just wondering.
I have been arrested three times in protests I was in, as an act of civil disobedience. However, I was coached ahead by an attorney about the do's and don't. The first thing is that all citizens must comply with the lawful commands of the police, even if you think it is not lawful or violates your rights. That will be decided by a court of law should you pursue it.
In my cases, I was asked to move and did not, which at that point was put under arrest. Once that happened then I complied with the police....no going limp and no arguments. I made no statements other than I wanted to talk to my lawyer.
They key here is that you MUST COMPLY with their commands. If you argue and resist in anyway, they legally can and WILL use force. There is no getting around that.
Can you possibly think of any situation in history when a race of individuals should have submitted peacefully to being arrested because "THE LAW" allowed it.
Where does the atrocity begin, Len? How many incidents have to be perpetrated before it becomes institutionalized, the norm?
14 black kids have been killed by white cops since Michael Brown was killed. How many before that how many more to come?
The 14 Teens Killed by Cops Since Michael Brown
Bravo! We have perspective!
So is the use of a choke hold by the NYPD.
Are you suggesting that Garner was killed for cause?
Indeed!
Manslaughter then?
Manslaughter is an unlawful killing that doesnt involve malice aforethoughtintent to seriously harm or kill, or extreme, reckless disregard for life. The absence of malice aforethought means that manslaughter involves less moral blame than either first or second degree murder.
Wrongful death?
The taking of the life of an individual resulting from a willful or negligent act.
Ironic.
Oh great....policing for profit. NYC charges a $1.50 per pack tax and it cost a man's life.
With 5 or 6 other cops on top and 11 "I can't breathe" statements? I disagree, he could certainly get an inkling.
Let's get something straight regarding why a black man might not want to be arrested.
Study: Black Defendants Are At Least 30% More Likely To Be Imprison...
...
Get it?
The system is rigged from start to finish!
No one ,but there is some one Id like to.
So Mac basically you are saying there is never a need to shoot some one Black regardless of the circumstances which seems to be the message here and echoed throughout ghettos all over the country. See post like this one are positive reinforcement for crime in Black neighborhoods. Did you actually read some of what you posted and do you really think any rational person would feel sympathy for most of them? Your not helping Mac not one bit
Mac, I understand what you're getting at, but really, if they intend to fight the police when being placed under arrest and if they are at such high risk of being seriously injured or killed by police when being placed under arrest.... where's the percentage in indulging in petty crimes that place them in a position of being arrested by police?
It's beyond idiotic to assume one will always get by with doing the same thing over and over and never get caught. And wasn't this guy already out on bail for the same thing?
He didn't deserve to die for selling cigarettes... in fact, for offenses such as these, a ticket similar to a traffic ticket should be the way to go with a summons for a court date.
Well, we are at last on the same page.
Im sorry Mac but Im a Black man and would like to tell you that what you are posting is simply garbage.Devoid of any common sense and logic. Yes they were jay walkers and sellers of loose cigarettes who escalated a minor offense into a felony and paid for it with thier lives. Color had very little to do with this, bad judgement and stupidity won out.
No, YOU are saying I'm saying that.
I have been quite clear about what I object to, nowhere even coming close to implying that there are never legitimate reasons for a police officer to use deadly force.
If you believe my posting facts that contradict your incorrect cause/effect relationships on certain positions is equivalent to mysaying "there is never a need to shoot some one Black regardless of the circumstances which seems to be the message here and echoed throughout ghettos all over the country," you are the one not helping.
Neither Brown and Garner were killed in black ghettos and the circumstances in each murder call into question why they needed to die and why a pair of grand juries were so obtuse given the conflicting information in the Brown case and the obvious in the Garner case.
Just quote my exact words when you take issue with them and I'll be happy to dialogue/debate with you. But don't paraphrase, mischaracterize or misrepresent my words the ask me to defend what I never said.
njmick,
What do you think of the McCarthy article on this case that I just seeded?
Please respond there (though I don't need to suggest that
)
We disagree.
Wow! Air tight and fact-laden rebuttal.
And I'm a white man who is ashamed at how many blacks are treated in America; I am simultaneously intelligent enough to understand that not all whites are haters of blacks, that individuals of all races commit crimes, and, that racial profiling employed by people in positions of trust is a dangerous phenomenon.
Color has much to do with the bad judgement and stupidity that were also involved. If indeed you are a black man, then surely you are aware of the predisposition of some whites to regard you as somehow subhuman and almost by definition, suspicious and predisposed to criminality.
And if you are a black man, you should be happy that white men like myself have the balls to call out racists of all colors.
Agreed, Gunny.
But in Garner's case, it was not an excuse, it was reality.
Yea ,yea and Im sure you have a black friend. Mac regardless of all the good you may think you are doing you are doing little more then echoing the rhetoric of Al Sharpton,Jessie Jackson , and the other race baiters out there . A man should be judged by their character and not the color of their skin, seems somehow you got that all twisted. You are a White man telling a Black man whats racist for him ,hey let me decide whats racist and whats just plain ignorant.
njmick--
I see both sides of this. In my view, Amac has a valid point that the justice system is not always just when it comes to unarmed black men being killed by police (often over trivial offenses). I appreciate people like Amac who recognize this problem and are standing up to confront it. On the other hand, people like you are cautioning that the cure should not be worse than the disease and lead to undermining law enforcement. From this perspective, as AP said, you can object to discriminatory treatment but you can't resist arrest. If you do, then you will be taken by force. Both sides are right.
I think there are racist/callous police but all are not that way and the good should not suffer for the bad. Apart from institutional changes like independent prosecutors and civilian review boards, we need to examine each case on its own merits. I initially thought the cop in this case was guilty of murder but, after thinking about it, I've changed my mind.
This trivial offense should be handled like a parking ticket. It wasn't. The police should have been more sensitive to Garner's hypersensitivity about being harassed and allowed him to cool off a bit. They didn't. Garner should have submitted to arrest. He didn't. Although, as I have said, the cop used a choke hold to try and subdue Garner, I don't think he applied the hold with the intent to do anything other than restrain Garner. I don't see criminal intent on the cops part to sustain a murder charge or recklessness sufficient for involuntary manslaughter. Amac is right that we need changes to the system but others are right that the injustice in the system does not give anyone (black or white) the right to resist arrest (even if the resistance is not violent).
Racisim is real and its out there ,but no where near the scope the race baiters try and make you believe . This police officer did nothing wrong ,at all. Regardless of the offense Garner broke the law.One thing that was bred into me was a respect for the law.of which there is very little in the Black community. And people like Sharpton and his mindless minions like it that way.
Maybe if she had been concerned about his health and his illegal activities, she wouldn't be without him now. He was obese, had heart and breathing problems, and still didn't feel like he had to obey an officer.
I think this is about both race and class. Poor black people tend to live in high crime areas and require a greater police presence. The police, by and large, are white men from outside the communities they patrol. Some police act like a guards in a penal colony and, for that reason, are reviled by some people in the blackcommunity. Blacks have complained for decades about outrageous treatment at the hands of white police officers and now, thanks to video cams, we have proof. Trust and respect is earned, njmick, not bred. The police have a lot of trust to earn. There used to be a program where citizens could ride with police officers and see things from their perspective. Maybe, in addition to institutional changes, such a program would help promote mutual understanding and respect.
My God!
Is that 99% of the black community? Mostly criminal types in black America? Is it possible that more of your community members are law abiding than disrespectful of the law?
50-50 maybe?
Don't cops in NY have anything better to do than cluster ingroupsto take down a fat man allegedly sellingcigaretteson a street corner? He didn't obey because he snapped over what he perceived as constant harassment for no reason. He was irrational but not violent. All they had to do was talk him into going peacefully. If it were an elderly white lady sellingcigarettes on a street corner and she had recoiled when a cop tried to grab her, I bet they wouldn't have put her in a choke hold, thrown her to the ground, and sat on her while she blurted repeatedly "I can't breathe."
Garner offered ONLY PASSIVE RESISTANCE!
He had his hands up.
Why would Garner et al black men resist?
BECAUSE THEY ARE 30% MORE LIKELY TO BE CONVICTED THAN WHITES CHARGED WITH THE SAME CRIMES!
IT'S A RIGGED F'N GAME!
Study: Black Defendants Are At Least 30% More Likely To Be Imprisoned Than White Defendants For The Same Crime
Some food for thought.
I think his hands were up only because he was trying to avoid having them grabbed by the officer in front of him.
Resistance is futile.
I'd like to see the article itself, or at least portions of it, posted here.
1. Eric Garner had been busted before for selling untaxed cigarettes.
In March 2014, 43-year-old Eric Garner was arrested for selling untaxed cigarettes . The NYPD cracks down on low-level offenses like these because of "broken-window policing" a strategy that former Mayor Rudy Giuliani started in which low-level offenses are given harsh penalties. Why?
According to Giuliani :
So untaxed cigarettes were also on the same spectrum as murder. A bit ironic given how much cigarettes negatively affect people's health, and yet none of the huge tobacco manufacturers are being pursued by the police.
Before you say, "But Eric was breaking the law!" keep this in mind. A pack of cigarettes. A pack of untaxed cigarettes. Let that image remain in your head.
2. The day he died, Garner was trying to break up a fight. When police arrived, the fight was over.
It happened on Staten Island . Two policemen spotted Garner successfully breaking up a fight between two other people.
In spite of this, the police didn't concern themselves much with the two people who were fighting. Instead, they focused on Garner.
3. The police again tried to arrest Eric for selling cigarettes.
Even though Garner had just stopped two people from assaulting each other, he was suddenly the culprit in the situation.
When the two policemen tried to arrest him, Garner's response was :
One of the policemen who tried to arrest Garner is Daniel Pantaleo .
4. Pantaleo placed Garner in a choke hold.
That image above? That's like the choke hold used on Eric. Pantaleo probably didn't know it, Eric was suffering from asthma.
5. Choke holds are banned by the NYPD.
Before you say, "But Pantaleo had the right to use force on a man who was breaking the law!" what he did was actually against the NYPD's rules as of 1993 . By putting Garner in a choke hold, he was violating the rules he was bound to as a police officer. He did not have the authority to use that force.
A few days after Garner's death, Pantaleo was stripped of his badge and gun .
6. Garner died after the chokehold. His last words were, "I can't breathe."
His last words started trending on Twitter months later under the hashtag #ICantBreathe .
7. Four medics at the scene didn't give Garner CPR.
In a cellphone video, one of Garner's friends showed that neither the EMTs nor the policemen at the scene were giving him CPR, even though he was clearly unconscious.
This was after Garner's head hit the concrete, according to a friend, and blood was coming out of his mouth.
The four EMTs were suspended for two days without pay.
8. A medical examiner ruled Garner's death a homicide.
On Aug. 1, 2014, the NYC medical examiner linked Pantaleo's chokehold to Garner's death , as well as "prone positioning during physical restraint by police."
9. There was a video of Eric's death.
Out of respect, we're choosing not to include the video. This description from a Time article should be enough:
How about the guy who filmed Garner's death, Ramsey Orta? Well...
10. A grand jury indicted the man who filmed Garner's death.
He wasn't indicted for filming the incident. But Orta was indicted on weapons charges about a month after he filmed Garner's death. According to the Huffington Post:
And then, in a twist of fate...
11. A grand jury did not indict the police officer who killed Garner.
See the New York Times for the story.
So selling untaxed cigarettes ended up in a man dying and a policeman not facing charges. How can we call this justice?
10 out of 1,000 American police officers are accused of misconduct.
23.8% of those have been accused of excessive force.
68% of felony defendants in the general population are convicted.
However, only 33% of police accused of misconduct are convicted.
Ok but I can't size it.
Thanks for posting this.
I agree, but that still constitutes passive resistance. The position of his hands was not one of aggression.
Why are untaxed cigarettes an issue in NY? Here's what I didn't know. NY imposes a tax of nearly $6.00 for a 20 pack of cigarettes, driving the cost to a whopping $14.00 a pack! It has created a black market as people buy cigarettes elsewhere and smuggle them into NY to sell in packs or as singles.