╌>

Progressive Mythography -- Officer Wilson should never even have been brought before the grand jury. NRO By Andrew C. McCarthy 11/29, 2014

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  12 years ago  •  102 comments

Progressive Mythography -- Officer Wilson should never even have been brought before the grand jury.   NRO By  Andrew C. McCarthy 11/29, 2014

A s Ferguson burned this week, the law books got a workout. Suddenly, grand-jury procedure was all the rage. Commentators better known for parroting the bromide that a prosecutor can get a grand jury to indict a ham sandwich went berserk when the sandwich on offer was a white cop and the grand jury refused to bite.

Protesters display the "Hands Up, Don't Shoot!" pose in Times Square, November 25, 2014. (Andrew Burton/Getty)

As it turns out, there was no need to thumb the legal treatises of Blackstone or Joseph Story. If you were going to hit the books, Jonah Goldbergs Liberal Fascism would have served you better. Brilliantly illustrating modern liberalisms roots in 20th-century progressivism a movement as comfortable marching lockstep with Stalin as it was borrowing copiously from Mussolini Jonah homes in on the centrality of myth. It is irrelevant whether an idea around which the Lefts avant-garde rouse the rabble is true; the point is the ideas power to mold consciousness and rally the troops.

For the American Left, a bedrock myth is that white cops kill black kids. It derives from the overarching myth that casts racism as our indelible national sin. As Heather Mac Donald explains , citing exhaustive criminology studies, it flows seamlessly from the quackery that dismisses the disproportionately high incidence of violent crime in African-American communities as an illusion as the product of police racism and the consequent hyper-targeting of black boys and men, rather than of racial differences in patterns of offending.

Darren Wilson was a white cop and Michael Brown was a black teenager killed in a violent confrontation with Wilson. Therefore, Brown was the victim of a cold-blooded, racially motivated murder, Q.E.D. That is the myth, and it will be served dont bother us with the facts.

Once youve got that, none of the rest matters. In fact, at the hands of the left-leaning punditocracy, the rest was pure Alinsky: a coopting of language in this instance, the argot of grand-jury procedure to reason back to the ordained conclusion that justice demanded Wilsons indictment for murder. And, of course, his ultimate conviction.

I could spend the rest of the day rehearsing why these legal claims are specious. Particularly risible is the story line that the grand jury convened by St. Louis County Prosecutor Robert McCulloch was a sham a story line that is itself an elaborate fraud.

Prosecutors can indict a ham sandwich, we were lectured, because the states burden in a grand-jury proceeding is so scant. Prosecutors need not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt , as they must do at trial; they merely need show probable cause that a crime was committed and by the person of whom it was alleged and a trial should therefore be held. There was conflicting testimony about who the aggressor was in the WilsonBrown confrontation; therefore, the story line goes, there was more than enough cause to indict Wilson and let the ultimate determination of guilt and you can be sure they mean guilt be made at a public trial. McCulloch instead used the grand jury to exculpate Wilson, a white (cop) privilege that a black defendant could never dream of obtaining.

To describe this as nonsense is a slander on nonsense. It is freely conceded that the grand-jury inquest into Browns killing was more a political than a legal exercise. That, however, was the result of intimidation by the Lefts race-mythology agitators very much including the president and the attorney general of the United States. It was clearly not aimed at benefitting Wilson.

In a typical case, prosecutors rely on the low probable-cause threshold applicable in grand-jury investigations only for the purpose of limiting how much evidence they need to present. Contrary to another regnant myth, guilt is not in doubt in most criminal cases. Overwhelmingly, they are open-and-shut, often supported by post-arrest confessions. As a result, the grand jury can appear to be a pro forma exercise a cookie-cutter procedure the Constitution requires before an accused person can be convicted of a crime he not only clearly committed but to which he will almost certainly plead guilty.

On the other hand, when convinced that the subject of an investigation either is innocent or is incapable of being proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, prosecutors do not present the case to the grand jury. Thats because their focus is the trial, not the indictment. If, after preliminary investigation, prosecutors do not assess the evidence as strong enough to convince a trial jury to render a unanimous guilty verdict, they dismiss the case on the basis of their own professional judgment it never sees the grand-jury room.

At a proper trial, Wilson could not have been convicted of murder. That does not mean what happened was not horrible it was. It does not mean Wilson is not civilly liable (although I doubt that he is). It simply means the circumstances of the shooting do not meet the high criminal-law standards for either intentional homicide or the criminally irresponsible causing of death.

The critics claim that Wilsons innocence is put in doubt by conflicting testimony is legally and factually frivolous. Legally, our system resolves all doubt in favor of the accused as the Left is apt to remind us when a terrorist is in the dock, this is called the presumption of innocence. Factually, the chatter about conflicting testimony falsely implies that all testimony is created equal. In reality, accounts given by anti-Wilson witnesses, where not patently fabricated, tended to be discredited by forensic evidence. The forensics, instead, corroborated the exculpatory testimony much of which came from African-American witnesses, a fact that undermines the myth and therefore goes largely unnoticed. The grand-jury rules are more permissive than those that govern criminal trials, but prosecutors are still ethically barred from asking the grand jury to rely on testimony they believe is false, inaccurate, or unconvincing.

Wilsons own testimony would have powerfully influenced a jury (as a credible defendants testimony always does), and that Wilson would have had the benefit of Missouri law, which looks favorably on the use of deadly force by police officers who are endangered in attempting to make an arrest. A jury would have acquitted Wilson in short order assuming for arguments sake that the judge had not dismissed the case for lack of evidence before letting it get to jury deliberations.

If the Michael Brown shooting were an ordinary case, a grand jury would never have been asked to consider indicting Officer Wilson. McCulloch, the chief prosecutor, directed his office to present it to the grand jury because it was not an ordinary case because it was a racially charged case in which Al Sharptons notorious No Justice, No Peace demagoguery was amplified by the community organizers in the White House and the most politicized Justice Department in American history.

Ordinarily, prosecutors unilaterally decide whether or not to seek an indictment and, in the rare instance when anyone asks why they decided as they did, are restrained by investigative-secrecy protocols from explaining their decision. But McCulloch was understandably unwilling to make a unilateral judgment for which he would have been unable to defend himself from inevitable charges of racism. He thus directed his office to make an exhaustive presentation to the grand jury. It was both a Pontius Pilatestyle abdication that made the community, rather than himself, accountable for the charging decision; and a vehicle that, with the courts blessing, enabled him to disclose the voluminous evidence justifying the decision not to indict.

All very reasonable, but lets not pretend reason has anything to do with what happened in Ferguson this week. In Liberal Fascism s focus on myth, Jonah recalls Mussolinis assertion, It is faith that moves mountains, not reason. Reason is a tool, but it can never be the motive force of the crowd. The crowd in Ferguson was moved to riot on the article of a false faith that condemns America and its police forces as incorrigibly racist. It is from this condemnation that all purported reasoning proceeds.

Such reasoning dictates that our constitutional right not to be indicted in the absence of just cause should be subordinated to the mobs demand for a public trial. Succeeding in that legerdemain, it next dictates that our constitutional right not to be convicted in the absence of proof beyond a reasonable doubt be subordinated to the mobs demand for a guilty verdict.

Such a verdict that would have had only the most tangential connection to the tragedy of an 18-year-olds death or a police officers well-founded fear for his life. But it would have fed the myth.

Andrew C. McCarthy is a policy fellow at the National Review Institute. His latest book is Faithless Execution: Building the Political Case for Obamas Impeachment .


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

How predictable of you.

That also goes for you not reading it. You should, you know!

McCarthy is not just a Fellow. He is a veteran prosecutor who prosecuted the blind sheik.

He is also an AG candidate in the next (Republican) administration.

WHAT A CONTRAST with the present misfit!

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

To you, "right wing" means right of Karl Marx.

Read my edit.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

Says the man who believes that water boarding is not necessarily torture.

The above reads more as an attempt to sell a book than it does a position statement.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
"Darren Wilson was a white cop and Michael Brown was a black teenager killed in a violent confrontation with Wilson. Therefore, Brown was the victim of a cold-blooded, racially motivated murder, Q.E.D. That is the myth, and it will be served dont bother us with the facts.

Once youve got that, none of the rest matters."

This is spot on..All the witnesses and physical evidence in the world would never be enough to overcome their reflexive, quasi religious belief in the innate guilt of officer Wilson.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

You obviously did not read the article either and know crap about grand jury necessity or procedure.

There is not one single thing he wrote that you tried to contradict.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Police shoot and kill over 400 people a year -- over one daily.

If Brown were white we would not have even known about it.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

McCarthy IS an expert and you are far from one.

Prove you read it by quoting a single thing you disagree with, and why.

I will not hold my breath.

 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

Every one has earnedover 4stars at Amazon.

I'm not exactly sure what that means, I don't shop Amazon.

What he is saying is that reason played no part in events in Ferguson after the shooting. I'm personally still trying to find the "reason" in the event itself.

If you want to discuss the reasonableness of police and prosecutorial actions, then by all means, let's do so.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

If you don't shop Amazon how do you know? Very few books get over 4 stars, especially with many reviewers.

Please quote what confuses you. McCarthy used "reason" in several places and in different ways.

What I think you are referring to is that the crowd needed no reason to demand revenge. Theirsufficientreason was a white cop and a black victim regardless.

The prosecutor did not need a grand jury to decline indictment. He organized one to cover his behind in the face of pressure.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

You don't even realize that all that "nutbag horse$hit" is what motivates you.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Very true. The media invented this controversy. They, and the grievance industry, are responsible for the riots, looting, and arson that inevitably followed.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
A cogent response that would have benefited from verbs and sentence structure.
 
 
 
Steve Ott
Professor Silent
link   Steve Ott    12 years ago

I don't believe I'm confused about anything. The article states:

but lets not pretend reason has anything to do with what happened in Ferguson this week.

If you don't shop Amazon how do you know?

How do I know what? I stated that I don't shop Amazon. How would I know whether 4 or 14 stars was a good thing, and what do the stars stand for?

I'll try to be less confusing in my statements.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

It is very simple.

The crowd in Ferguson was moved to riot [noton reason but rather]on the article of a false faith that condemns America and its police forces as incorrigibly racist. It is from this condemnation that all purported reasoning proceeds.

On Amazon you pretended to know that almost all books are rated over 4 stars
(of 5) and now admit you know nothing about the rating system.

Very few authors have six books rated over four stars; a testament to McCarthy's wisdom.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Wilsons own testimony would have powerfully influenced a jury (as a credible defendants testimony always does), and that Wilson would have had the benefit of Missouri law, which looks favorably on the use of deadly force by police officers who are endangered in attempting to make an arrest. A jury would have acquitted Wilson in short order assuming for arguments sake that the judge had not dismissed the case for lack of evidence before letting it get to jury deliberations.

If the Michael Brown shooting were an ordinary case, a grand jury would never have been asked to consider indicting Officer Wilson. McCulloch, the chief prosecutor, directed his office to present it to the grand jury because it was not an ordinary case because it was a racially charged case in which Al Sharptons notorious No Justice, No Peace demagoguery was amplified by the community organizers in the White House and the most politicized Justice Department in American history.

Ordinarily, prosecutors unilaterally decide whether or not to seek an indictment and, in the rare instance when anyone asks why they decided as they did, are restrained by investigative-secrecy protocols from explaining their decision. But McCulloch was understandably unwilling to make a unilateral judgment for which he would have been unable to defend himself from inevitable charges of racism. He thus directed his office to make an exhaustive presentation to the grand jury. It was both a Pontius Pilatestyle abdication that made the community, rather than himself, accountable for the charging decision; and a vehicle that, with the courts blessing, enabled him to disclose the voluminous evidence justifying the decision not to indict.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Fair enough!

When you are right (rarely), you're rightSmile.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Really?

Oh, I surely agree that Wilson should not have been brought before a grand jury; instead, HE SHOULD HAVE BEEN INDICTED FOR DESTROYING and TAMPERING WITH EVIDENCE, OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE and, for MURDER.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
I thought kevin williamson gave a pretty succinct, big picture summary of the situation:"One of the strangest arguments to come out of the Ferguson legal wrangling: The prosecutor presented a case that was insufficiently biased.To complain that legal institutions are insufficiently hostile, and to maintain that they are doing wrong by making all the evidence available, is to misunderstand what the law is there to do.I am not much of a legal analyst, but if your argument comes down to a complaint that grand jurors were given all the evidence, thats pretty weak tea. "
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

"One of the strangest arguments to come out of the Ferguson legal wrangling: The prosecutor presented a case that was insufficiently biased.

Ridiculous choice of words; any such reference should be worded

"The Prosecutor failed to act as such and instead presented alleged exculpatory "evidence" thus acting like Wilson's defense. Defense attorneys for suspects are not permitted to address a GJ; if a suspect chooses to go before a GJ, he or she may consult with the defense counsel outside of the courtroom."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

McCulloch was understandably unwilling to make a unilateral judgment for which he would have been unable to defend himself from inevitable charges of racism.

McCullough made a unilateral judgement innot recusing himself and instead allowing the appointment of a special prosecutor, and, used unilateral judgement in NOT indicting Wilson.

McCullough stated at great length, that there were conflicting eyewitness testimonies ... ordinarily in-and-of-itself a reason to go to trial on probable cause.

McCullough spoke at length about how many eyewitnesses testimonies were found to be untrue compared with physical evidence. But since there is no cross-examination by the G.J. and all eyewitnesses were presented in front of the G.J McCullough cannot definitively say that any eyewitness testimonies were not credible unless he (his office) presented them as such.

Among the conflicting testimonies were those regarding Michael Brown's alleged bull rush at Darren Wilson prior to his being shot to death. That was Wilson's testimony, BUT THERE WAS ACCORDING TO McCULLOUGH HIMSELF, CONFLICTING TESTIMONY yet McCullough stated publicly a one-sided description WHICH WAS DISPUTED BY SOME WITNESSES!

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago

as such and instead presented alleged exculpatory "evidence"


That is the perfect example of:


"if your argument comes down to a complaint that grand jurors were given all the evidence, thats pretty weak tea. "

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago

and the "accused" was allowed to testify without adversarial cross examination.

Even if you believe the prosecutor was not adversarial enough, its not like Wilson would havetestifiedat trial anyway.Whywould he? the state couldn't come closeto demonstrating his guilt beyond a reasonable doubt based on the witness testimony and physical evidence. I'd be surprised if a judge actually let the case go to a jury because the state would have no chance to satisfy its burden of proof.

What McCullough apparently did was essentially give the GJ a chance to second guess his belief that a indictment would be a miscarriage of justice. The standard for an indictment is so incredibly low that the very fact that the GJ couldn't indict demonstrates how weak the case was. If the neutral presentation of evidence couldn't even net an indictment, there is no way a conviction could occur because the evidence already favors Wilson, and the prosecution witnesses, if there were any, would have been destroyed under adversarial examination.

The case against Wilson benefits more from a neutral presentation of evidence than the case against.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Even if you believe the prosecutor was not adversarial enough, its not like Wilson would havetestifiedat trial anyway.

Wilson would have been cross-examined by a REAL PROSECUTOR, Sean and he would have been asked about compromising evidence among other things.

Fanciful and not credible: CNN legal analyst destroys Darren Wilsons testimony

...

Nancy Grace Absolutely Obliterates Darren Wilson And Prosecutor Robert McCulloch On CNN (VIDEO)

When Darren Wilson escaped being indicted for murder by the grand jury, outrage erupted in Ferguson and across the nation, and that outrage extended to the CNN set as Nancy Grace made it crystal clear that she thinks Wilsons testimony is complete garbage and that he should have been indicted.

On Wednesday, Grace appeared on CNN with Brooke Baldwin to discuss the grand jury decision. Grace didnt hold back, and she thoroughly ripped Darren Wilson, his testimony, the grand jury, and the prosecutor a new one.

GRACE: When people say, it just doesnt add up, I will tell you what doesnt add up, these photos. Because I was expecting to see and weve all seen them, Ive looked at a them, Ive studied them, and I was expecting to see his face mangled. I hear what hes saying and that he was afraid and this happened and that happened, but I always go back to the beginning and the beginning is this: You got an armed man and an unarmed man. The unarmed man is shot six to seven times. He unloaded many many more bullets. Why? He doesnt even have a bruise, right? Its red. Hes got a red mark! I dont see it. And another thing, when he says It all happened so fast I couldnt think, then later says I paused and thought, Can I legally shoot him? Listen, it doesnt add up.

BALDWIN: He says he didnt have any other options.

GRACE: Look, do you know how many times I have sided against a cop? Never. But to me, this is bigger than a badge. And I dont like speaking out against a cop, but this doesnt add up. And another thing, grand jury. I have presented to grand juries so many times I cant even count them. On a single day, we would present 75 to 150 cases to the grand jury and we would do that two times a week I feel that the district attorney, as much as I respect him in other ways, used the grand jury to do as he wanted them to do as his tool. He didnt want to drop it. He presented it in such a way that this grand jury would not bring charges and I dont like that.

Baldwin then talked about Wilsons description of Brown and the altercation that allegedly occurred. Wilson said that Brown looked like a demon and that his size was like Hulk Hogan, even though both men are about the same size. Baldwin asked if his testimony should have been questioned and challenged by the prosecutor instead of treating Wilson with kid gloves.

GRACE: The grand jurors are like sheep, theyre babes in the woods. The prosecutors duty is to seek the truth. I am telling you that the prosecutors, if they want an indictment, they will get an indictment. When I went to a grand jury, I went to the grand jury on each case because I believed the offense had been committed and I had the right guy or the police had the right guy, and I went in there to present our evidence. If I didnt think there was a case I would never have gone to the grand jury. You dont use the grand jury to achieve your personal gain, to achieve what you want them to do. You go in to get a true verdict.

Grace then held up the photos of Wilsons injuries and declared that theres nothing here, not even a bruise and then slammed Wilson for taking alternative actions that wouldnt have resulted in a teenager being brutally shot to death if Brown indeed had reached his arm into his police cruiser as he claims.

...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

"if your argument comes down to a complaint that grand jurors were given all the evidence, thats pretty weak tea. "

No, Sean, in McCullough's own words, they were give conflicting evidence which is exactly why such cases go to trial after an indictment.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

The suspects rarely speak to GJs because THEY ARE NOT PERMITTED AN ATTORNEY IN THE COURT ROOM AND THEY ARE GUARANTEED TO BE CROSS-EXAMINED BY A REAL PROSECUTOR IF THEY DO SPEAK!

And Robert G does what Darren Wilson did before making his care, he attempts to smear anyone who takes an opposing view -- as Wilson and the Ferguson Police Department and the "prosecutor" did to Michael Brown

ditto what was done to Trayvon Martin.

1. Ferguson Police Quickly Blame The Dead. What happened before Brown was shot six times by Officer Darren Wilson is not fully known. Eyewitness Dorian Johnson told MSNBC that Brown was walking down the street when police drove up and demanded that Brown get into the vehicle and he ignored the order. St. Louis County Police Chief Joe Belmar said Brown fought Wilson and reached for his gun, justifying the shooting. The police did not initially name the officer, although that detail came out a few days later.

Johnson told MSNBC a very different story. He said Wilson drove up in a police truck and aggressively went after the pair. He first demanded that they get on the sidewalk. When they kept on walking, Johnson said that Wilson nearly hit them with his truck, and then yelled and used the truck door to knock Brown down. Wilson then jumped out and grabbed Brown, who resisted being choked, Johnson said. When the pair started to flee, Wilson shot at Brown, who stopped and yelled he didnt have a gun. Johnson said he saw Brown shot, while facing Wilson, and then collapsing onto the street.

2. Police Release Video Smearing Brown For Alleged Robbery. Before Ferguson police released Wilsons identity, they released a video that allegedly showed Brown confronting a convenience store employee and taking a package of cigars. Missouri Gov. Jay Nixon told NBCs Meet The Press that neither his office nor the state highway patrol team he deployed to take over local policing were informed beforehand. Quite frankly, we disagree deeply, Nixon said. To attempt to, in essence, disparage the character of this victim in the middle of a process like this is not right. Its just not right.

3. Mainstream Media Makes The Video Bigger Than His Death . As the department surely knew, the release of the video would swamp most of the coverage, because any police investigation, whether by that department or outside agencies would take time. The police know the mainstream press will consider them to be an official source, because they are an arm of government, more so than a biased participant. However, as the DailyKos Barbara Morrill reported, the videos release before police identified the shooter meant that much of the media coverage would focus on the robbery.

Well, that didnt take long, she wrote . Barely two hours after Ferguson Police Chief Thomas Jackson named the police officer who gunned down 18-year-old Michael Brown last Saturday, and the demonization ofyou guessed itMichael Brown is well underway. She cited half a dozen headlines mixing the officers identity with the alleged robbery, and this tweet from @fivefifths: We officially have more facts about a likely unrelated robbery of a single [pack of] Swisher [cigars] than we do about the execution of Mike Brown.

4. Police Release Autopsy Detail Saying Brown Had Smoked Pot. The DailyKos Morrill concluded, The victim has become the suspect. That was before another leak further victimizing Browna preliminary autopsy report showing traces of marijuana in his blood. It hardly matters that many scientific studies have found that marijuana doesnt increase violent behavior. This was more innuendo from police telegraphing that Brown was no angel. Right-wing media took the ball and ran with it. Fox News interviewed the medical examiner who conducted the initial autopsy, who speculated on the air that because of pot, Brown may have been acting in a crazy way and may have done things to the police officer that normally he would not have done.

5. Mainstream Media Doesnt Question Sources Motives. From a media criticism perspective, whats incredible is not just that these narrativesthe alleged burglary or pot smokingare far less important than the fact that an unarmed teenager was shot and killed by a police officer. The local police arent innocent bystanders. They are not a disinterested source. Neither is the local medical examiner who works with the police. But that conflict of interest does not stop certain outlets from quoting this law enforcement community to again smear Brown.

6. Next Smear: Ferguson Called Crime-Filled Community. As MediaMatters noted , Right-wing media emphasized the supposed prevalence of black-on-black violence in response to the shooting death of unarmed black teen Michael Brown Such emphasis takes the crime statistics out of context in order to hype the racial aspect. Actual crime statistics for Ferguson reveal it is both better and worse than national averages, depending on the crime. Nonetheless, commentators at the Wall Street Journal , National Review Online, Fox News and elsewhere are calling it a bastion of bad behavior.

7. Public Defenders Say Theres Nothing New In Police Smears. Public defenders face off in court representing low-income clients against police and prosecutors. Miles Gerety, who recently retired after three decades as a Connecticut public defender specializing in death penalty cases, said he was not surprised at all about the Ferguson police. Its an unsophisticated albeit primative attempt to justify what seems unjustfiable: The deceased was a bad person and thus deserved to die.Gerety also noted that these slurs and character assassinations would not be allowed in a courtrom trial, even though they are getting media play and shape public opinion.

A crime is a crime. Just because your victim may have been a bad actor at some point, doesnt make killing that person justifiable, he said. In a trial for murder, for instance, the fact that the victim may have committed a crime before being killed would be completely irrelevant unless the defendant knew of the conduct and it somehow related to a self-defense claim. Its ironic that the Ferguson police resorted to this tactic of blaming the victim when you damn well know theyd blast any defense lawyer who resorted to the same tactic. Ive found it doesnt pay to malign the dead.

...

NOTE: Michael Brown was unavailable to testify.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
McCullough actually said the pro- brown testimony was internally inconsistent ( constantly changing) and not consistent with the physical evidence.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Hey John,

If you read the transcript you will see that 11 witnesses testified that Wilson shot Brown as he was running away; only five as he was advancing.

Yet the forensic evidence contradicted the 11 and supported the 5.

Yet you still insist that not prosecuting was a miscarriage of justice.

IMHO the 11 should be indicted for perjury.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Is 'professor' who helped with Michael Brown autopsy who he says he is?

Fraud and apparent liar.

...

Had Wilson been indicted, this fraud would have had to testify about his "credentials" and the autopsy at a trial.

Anyone actually interested in the asking the tough questions?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

But Hostin said the claim that Brown attacked Wilson inside of the police car, and tried to fire his service weapon did not make sense to her.

It appeared to be very fanciful, Hostin said. When a prosecutor has a prospective target, a suspect, a defendant a prospective defendant inside of the grand jury, thats the prosecutors chance to cross-examine that person. These prosecutors treated Darren Wilson with such kid gloves.

Hostin talks like just another advocate rather than like an objective reporter. It "did not make sense to her" without saying why or noting that blood was found in the car. She has no clue that GJ testimony is not supposed to be on the rigorous level of trial testimony, as McCarthy, the former federal prosecuting attorney noted. Neither did Hostin note that Wilson need not have testified at all and such is very rare. Neither does she say that it was the first time Wilson fired his gun in the line of duty.

Grace is more of the same bull. How come none of them noted the forensicevidence thatBrown's blood was found on the gun, uniform and police cruiser belonging to Wilson? Instead they are dissatisfied with the severity of Wilson's injuries.

Read McCarthy again. He is right on from soup to nuts.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

So many specific, unanswered questions but there are some among us that seem to know the answers.

Others of us would like the answers to questions asked in a trial that would be open to the public.

In the meantime, 14 unarmed blacks have bee killed by white police officers since Michael Brown was shot.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Ridiculous choice of words; any such reference should be worded

"The Prosecutor failed to act as such and instead presented alleged exculpatory "evidence" thus acting like Wilson's defense. Defense attorneys for suspects are not permitted to address a GJ; if a suspect chooses to go before a GJ, he or she may consult with the defense counsel outside of the courtroom."

This is just not true, Mac. He presented ALL the evidence and you know it. IIf he was so biased he need not have called the GJ at all.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

This is just not true, Mac. He presented ALL the evidence and you know it. IIf he was so biased he need not have called the GJ at all.

Len, he called for a Grand Jury to avoid indictment.

RIGGED GAME OVER.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Do you have a point?

Unlike yourself, yes.

"Smears and the disingenuous types who use them in order to try and discredit those who have opposing opinions, and, at times, those they murder."

That about wraps it up.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

WRT your calling on"experts" -- CNN reporters to prove your case that Wilson should have been indicted, here is liberal Alan Dershowitz contradicting you, as well as lambasting the "ignorance" of the CNN reporters.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Darren Wilson's gun was NOT tested for Michael Brown's fingerprints, and officer was able to wash blood from his hands: Probe's serious errors exposed in grand jury files

  • A jury ruled Darren Wilson will not stand trial over Michael Brown shooting
  • Jury files reveal examples of crime scene protocol not being followed
  • Officer Wilson was allowed to drive himself away from the crime scene
  • He then put his weapon in an evidence bag himself after washing his hands
  • Wilson claimed that Brown had tried to wrestle his gun from him
  • But the gun was never tested for fingerprints, an investigator revealed
  • Serious errors in the handling of the Michael Brown shooting have been exposed by the grand jury files on the case, including Darren Wilson's gun not being tested for fingerprints and the officer washing blood off his hands.

    A 12-person jury, after hearing more than 70 hours of testimony from 60 witnesses, ruled that Officer Wilson will not have to stand trial over the fatal shooting of 18-year-old Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri.

    However, in the thousands of pages of evidence released to the public afterwards were glaring examples of crime scene protocol not being followed.


    ...



 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Which facts?

And you presumably know more about the purpose of a GJ than the former federal prosecutor of the blind sheik?

What law school did you get your LLB from?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
If that's what you want to call being truthful.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

How come you were not called to testify?

You do not want a trial. You want a lynching.

Alan Dershowitz agreed with McCarthy that Wilson would never be convicted but you know better.

Do you think there would be less anger and riots if Wilson were found "Not guilty" in a trial? IMHO a lot more!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Len,

There are other attorneys who have already disagreed with Dershowitz's point on probable cause.

Fact: In a criminal trial , a prosecutor needs to prove that a defendant is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt in order to convict him.

But the reasonable doubt standard has no bearing on grand jury proceedings.

the standard that grand juries use is probable cause . Probable cause is a low standard.

Watch the video

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

You are whitewashing the liars.

Why am I not surprised?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Is this some sort of joke that you ridicule the professor hired by Brown's own family?

Is that also McCullough's fault?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

People who claim to be liberal, then complain that a potential defendant has too many rights, aren't liberal.

More irrelevant pronouncements.

A potential defendant has the right to a fair trial but not the right to a flawed protocol engineered to avoid his indictment.

Instead of the smear-liberal track, address specifically all the specific points I've posted.

It's not about me, or you or liberals.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

"You do not want a trial. You want a lynching."

Another pronouncement guy.

You don't want a discussion, you want to avoid one.

You cited an attorney, I cited an attorney. It's a wash.

How about addressing all of the specifics I posted?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

That's the way the cookie crumbles.

What's this; the main cryer of crocodile tears for murdered black youth suddenly sees it as cookie crumbs.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Prosecutors can indict a ham sandwich, we were lectured, because the states burden in a grand-jury proceeding is so scant. Prosecutors need not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt, as they must do at trial; they merely need show probable cause that a crime was committed and by the person of whom it was alleged and a trial should therefore be held. There was conflicting testimony about who the aggressor was in the WilsonBrown confrontation; therefore, the story line goes, there was more than enough cause to indict Wilson and let the ultimate determination of guilt and you can be sure they mean guilt be made at a public trial. McCulloch instead used the grand jury to exculpate Wilson, a white (cop) privilege that a black defendant could never dream of obtaining.

To describe this as nonsense is a slander on nonsense. It is freely conceded that the grand-jury inquest into Browns killing was more a political than a legal exercise. That, however, was the result of intimidation by the Lefts race-mythology agitators very much including the president and the attorney general of the United States. It was clearly not aimed at benefitting Wilson.

If there is ever a race war in this country the blame is Obama's and Holder's.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Is that also McCullough's fault?

It's McCullough's fault that he did not examine the examiner's credentials and that, in spite of what is now known, McCullough ran with the report any way.

Brown's parent aren't qualified to investigate credentials.

Damn! Bend over backwards little further to keep the pesky realities in the can.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

You are whitewashing the liars.

Why am I not surprised?

That's a personal slam, Len.

Just explain why a statement is wrong in your opinion

more smear.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

The only ones that go to trial are those where there is decent probability of conviction.

Here there was none.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

If there is ever a race war in this country the blame is Obama's and Holder's.

I'm done here.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Your hypotheticals are irrelevant.

Brown may have begun at 50 feet "or so"but was lots closer for the head shot. Brown had been retreating after the scuffle and Wilson gave chase. Then Brown turned and charged Wilson.

Blood spots showed he moved 21 feet towards Wilson after turning. That is a good pace.

A young woman riding through the area with her family in a van said she saw much of the events from the window and also believed unequivocally that Brown was charging, although she said he seemed at some point to have thought about raising his hands.

When he first started running, maam, he was not staggering, she told the prosecutor. He was charging this officer and thats how I feel it was, like he was running towards him. If he had got close enough, I feel like he would have tackled him up against the car, she said.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

The world model of PC, the UK with Islamophile royalty,which ignored Muslim pedophiles who preyed forcibly on hundreds of teen British teenagers for over ten years, is now lecturing us about justice?

And you endorse them as a modelby citing them?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

I don't do social media.

You are trying to make this into a "He says/She says" issue.

I trust Dersh notwithstanding his liberalism.

At least he is a liberal -- not a leftist.

For leftists the issues are all about race, class and gender.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

they were give conflicting evidence which is exactly why such cases go to trial after an indictment.

You have got it backwards. Trials are not fishing expeditions for sorting evidence. A prosecutor does not go to trial unless he has a good chance for conviction.

That was one of McCarthy's points that eluded you.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

You were done before you beganGrin.gif

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

That is like calling a taxi so you can walk.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

The medium is the message.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Are you telling us that the 11 who insisted Brown was shot while going away were credible?

I recall that as YOUR position BF (before forensics).

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Is it McCullough's duty to interview and approve the Brown team?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

I don't recall Wilson asserting that Brown gripped his gun -- just that he attempted to do so.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

You have the discernibility and intelligence of a mouse.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

The forensic evidence of the blood trail of 21 feet supported the "bull rush."

When do DAs appoint special prosecutors? I have never heard of such an event except in rare federal cases.

The only complaint you have against McC is his failure to indict. He did not withhold any evidence.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Response to such an incident is not scripted and you can nitpick any such.

People don't have good judgment of distance. Witness 10 did not use a tape measure or laser range finder.

Your objections are in YOUR words andweak reeds.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

The only complaint you have against McC is his failure to indict. He did not withhold any evidence.

Yes! Based on the many reasons I posted, none of which you are able to rebut.

Assisting with investigations and prosecutions

In Missouri

The Attorney General's Office assists prosecuting attorneys in complicated trials or are appointed as special prosecutors when there is a conflict of interest. This important legal work saved counties approximately $2.5 million in 2012.

There is "conflicting testimony" re: the "bull rush," which is why all witnesses, including Wilson should have been questioned on direct and cross-examined under oath DURING A TRIAL.

If McCullough wanted to, he could present evidence in the case to a new grand jury and seek an indictment of Wilson. Although a constitutional protection known as double jeopardy says you cant be charged with the same crime twice, the provision has not yet been triggered since Wilson was never charged.

Of course, McCullough would never pursue new charges because as he made clear in his press conference he vehemently believes Wilson is innocent. It is McCulloughs vocal allegiance to the defendant that has caused many legal experts to question the process.

So in order for the evidence to be presented to a new grand jury, a new prosecutor would have to be appointed. Missouri Governor Jay Nixon has the power to appoint a special prosecutor for the case. But Nixon, through a spokesman, said he would not appoint one . Most people have treated this as the end of the story.

There is a provision of Missouri Law MO Rev Stat 56.110 that empowers the court having criminal jurisdiction to appoint some other attorney to prosecute if the prosecuting attorney be interested. (The term be interested is an awkward legal way to refer to conflict-of-interest or bias. The statute dates from the turn of the 20th century.)

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

the assistant DA's at the GJ misinformed the panel as to one of the laws governing their decision.

And that ain't all

Justice Antonin Scalia , in the 1992 Supreme Court case of United States v. Williams , explained what the role of a grand jury has been for hundreds of years.

It is the grand jurys function not to enquire upon what foundation [the charge may be] denied, or otherwise to try the suspects defenses, but only to examine upon what foundation [the charge] is made by the prosecutor. Respublica v. Shaffer, 1 Dall. 236 (O. T. Phila. 1788); see also F. Wharton, Criminal Pleading and Practice 360, pp. 248-249 (8th ed. 1880).

As a consequence, neither in this country nor in England has the suspect under investigation by the grand jury ever been thought to have a right to testify or to have exculpatory evidence presented.

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This passage was first highlighted by attorney Ian Samuel, a former clerk to Justice Scalia .

In contrast, McCulloch allowed Wilson to testify for hours before the grand jury and presented them with every scrap of exculpatory evidence available. In his press conference, McCulloch said that the grand jury did not indict because eyewitness testimony that established Wilson was acting in self-defense was contradicted by other exculpatory evidence. What McCulloch didnt say is that he was under no obligation to present such evidence to the grand jury. The only reason one would present such evidence is to reduce the chances that the grand jury would indict Darren Wilson.

Compare Justice Scalias description of the role of the grand jury to what the prosecutors told the Ferguson grand jury before they started their deliberations:

And you must find probable cause to believe that Darren Wilson did not act in lawful self-defense and you must find probable cause to believe that Darren Wilson did not use lawful force in making an arrest. If you find those things, which is kind of like finding a negative, you cannot return an indictment on anything or true bill unless you find both of those things.

Because both are complete defenses to any offense and they both have been raised in his, in the evidence.

As Justice Scalia explained the evidence to support these complete defenses, including Wilsons testimony, was only included by McCulloch by ignoring how grand juries historically work.

There were several eyewitness accounts that strongly suggested Wilson did not act in self-defense. McCulloch could have, and his critics say should have , presented that evidence to the grand jury and likely returned an indictment in days, not months. Its a low bar, which is why virtually all grand juries return indictments .

But McCulloch chose a different path.

I realize that Len and others don't want an actual debate here; but I will continue to present information nevertheless.

Len, Scalia is no liberal.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I don't recall Wilson asserting that Brown gripped his gun -- just that he attempted to do so.

There's a lot you don't recall, Len watch the video interview.

Repeating what he told a grand jury investigating the shooting , Wilson said Brown reached into his police vehicle and grabbed for his gun. He feared for his life, he said.

How many times do you need to be apprised before you at least acknowledge that you may not have the whole story?

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

I admired Scalia but you cannot quote him out of context.

Iam certain he does not favor presenting evidence selectively to indict every subject. If there were no negative evidence at all why assemble the gj?

The subject has no right to testify but neither is he forbidden.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Iam certain he does not favor presenting evidence selectively to indict every subject. If there were no negative evidence at all why assemble the gj?

I admired Scalia but you cannot quote him out of context.

The subject has no right to testify but neither is he forbidden.

I've already explained this at least three times. Your last sentence seems self contradictory it is.

The reason suspects do not usually testify before GJs is because they know they will be vigorously cross-examined by the prosecutor -- UNLIKE WHAT McCULLOCH DID -- that is, acting as Wilson's advocate.

I did not quote Scalia "out of context," I cited his view of how GJs are supposed to be conducted.

Clearly, Len, you are unwilling to consider anything other than the outcome you like -- I offer particular after particular and you dismiss every one off-handedly.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Len>>I don't recall Wilson asserting that Brown gripped his gun -- just that he attempted to do so.

Mac>>There's a lot you don't recall, Len watch the video interview.

Repeating what he told a grand jury investigating the shooting , Wilson said Brown reached into his police vehicle and grabbed for his gun. He feared for his life, he said.

"Grabbed for" does not infer success. That is a difference without substance.

Brown's blood was found on the gun but that is alsonot proof he gripped it.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

4. Investigators did not test Wilsons gun for fingerprints.

Talking with police investigators and before the grand jury, Wilson claimed that Brown had grabbed at Wilson's gun during the initial incident in the police car and that Brown's hand was on the firearm when it misfired at least once. Wilson also told police that he thought Brown would overpower him and shoot him with his own gun. I was not in control of the gun, Wilson said. Eventually he regained control of the weapon and fired from within the car.

Investigators could have helped to prove or disprove Wilsons testimony by testing his service weapon for Browns fingerprints. But the gun was not tested for fingerprints. An investigator argued before the grand jury that the decision was made not to test the weapon because Wilson never lost control of his gun.

5. Wilson did not immediately turn his weapon over to investigators...

A detective with the St. Louis County Police Department, who conducted the first official interview of Wilson, testified to the grand jury that Wilson had packaged his own service weapon into an evidence envelope following his arrival at the police station in the wake of the shooting. The detective said the practice was not usual for his department, though he was unclear on the protocol of the Ferguson Police Department. He said he didnt explore that aspect further at the time.

According to the detectives testimony, standard practice for the St. Louis County Police Department would be for an officer involved in a shooting to keep his or her weapon holstered until it can be turned over to a supervisor and a crime scene unit detective. While that clearly didnt take place in Wilsons case, the detective also testified that he believed the firearm was handled in a way that preserved the chain of custody.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

McCarthy rebutted you:

In a typical case, prosecutors rely on the low probable-cause threshold applicable in grand-jury investigations only for the purpose of limiting how much evidence they need to present. Contrary to another regnant myth, guilt is not in doubt in most criminal cases. Overwhelmingly, they are open-and-shut, often supported by post-arrest confessions. As a result, the grand jury can appear to be a pro forma exercise a cookie-cutter procedure the Constitution requires before an accused person can be convicted of a crime he not only clearly committed but to which he will almost certainly plead guilty.

On the other hand, when convinced that the subject of an investigation either is innocent or is incapable of being proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, prosecutors do not present the case to the grand jury. Thats because their focus is the trial, not the indictment. If, after preliminary investigation, prosecutors do not assess the evidence as strong enough to convince a trial jury to render a unanimous guilty verdict, they dismiss the case on the basis of their own professional judgment it never sees the grand-jury room.

At a proper trial, Wilson could not have been convicted of murder. That does not mean what happened was not horrible it was. It does not mean Wilson is not civilly liable (although I doubt that he is). It simply means the circumstances of the shooting do not meet the high criminal-law standards for either intentional homicide or the criminally irresponsible causing of death.

The critics claim that Wilsons innocence is put in doubt by conflicting testimony is legally and factually frivolous. Legally, our system resolves all doubt in favor of the accused as the Left is apt to remind us when a terrorist is in the dock, this is called the presumption of innocence. Factually, the chatter about conflicting testimony falsely implies that all testimony is created equal. In reality, accounts given by anti-Wilson witnesses, where not patently fabricated, tended to be discredited by forensic evidence. The forensics, instead, corroborated the exculpatory testimony much of which came from African-American witnesses, a fact that undermines the myth and therefore goes largely unnoticed. The grand-jury rules are more permissive than those that govern criminal trials, but prosecutors are still ethically barred from asking the grand jury to rely on testimony they believe is false, inaccurate, or unconvincing.

Wilsons own testimony would have powerfully influenced a jury (as a credible defendants testimony always does), and that Wilson would have had the benefit of Missouri law, which looks favorably on the use of deadly force by police officers who are endangered in attempting to make an arrest. A jury would have acquitted Wilson in short order assuming for arguments sake that the judge had not dismissed the case for lack of evidence before letting it get to jury deliberations.

If the Michael Brown shooting were an ordinary case, a grand jury would never have been asked to consider indicting Officer Wilson . McCulloch, the chief prosecutor, directed his office to present it to the grand jury because it was not an ordinary case because it was a racially charged case in which Al Sharptons notorious No Justice, No Peace demagoguery was amplified by the community organizers in the White House and the most politicized Justice Department in American history.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

In a typical case, prosecutors rely on the low probable-cause threshold applicable in grand-jury investigations only for the purpose of limiting how much evidence they need to present.

I have cited numerous examples as to why this GJ/prosecutor was anything but typical.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Talking with police investigators and before the grand jury, Wilson claimed that Brown had grabbed at Wilson's gun during the initial incident in the police car and that Brown's hand was on the firearm when it misfired at least once. Wilson also told police that he thought Brown would overpower him and shoot him with his own gun. I was not in control of the gun, Wilson said. Eventually he regained control of the weapon and fired from within the car.

Investigators could have helped to prove or disprove Wilsons testimony by testing his service weapon for Browns fingerprints. But the gun was not tested for fingerprints.An investigator argued before the grand jury that the decision was made not to test the weapon because Wilson never lost control of his gun.

So? That does not contradict. At the struggle neither had control of the gun but Wilson regained control and Brown never had control. I don't know where Brown's blood on the gun came from.Possibly his hand was grazed during a firing. That may be when he backed off and Wilson could open the door.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

by Thomas Sowell:

E veryone seems to have an opinion about the tragic events in Ferguson, Missouri. But, as Daniel Patrick Moynihan used to say, Youre entitled to your own opinion, but youre not entitled to your own facts.

Soon after the shooting death of Michael Brown, this 285-pound young man was depicted as a gentle giant. But, after a video was leaked, showing him bullying the owner of a store from which he had stolen some merchandise, Attorney General Eric Holder expressed displeasure that the video was leaked. In other words, to Holder the truth was offensive, but the lie it exposed was not.

Many people who claimed to have been eyewitnesses to the fatal shooting gave opposite accounts of what happened. Some even gave accounts that contradicted what they themselves had said earlier.

Fortunately, the grand jury did not have to rely on such statements, though some in the media seemed to. What the grand jury had, that the rest of us did not have until the grand jurys decision was announced, was a set of physical facts that told a story that was independent of what anybody said.

Three different medical forensic experts one representing Michael Browns parents examined the physical facts. These facts included the autopsy results, M ichael Browns DNA on the door of the police car and on the policemans gun , photographs of the bruised and swollen face of policeman Darren Wilson and the pattern of blood stains on the street where Brown was shot.

This physical evidence was hard to square with the loudly proclaimed assertions that Brown was shot in the back, or was shot with his hands up, while trying to surrender. But it was consistent with the policemans testimony.

Moreover, the physical facts were consistent with what a number of black witnesses said under oath, despite expressing fears for their own safety for contradicting what those in the rampaging mobs were saying.

...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I go by your judgment and experience, as always.

Given that you apparently lack the latter, you certainly are free with handing down the former.

One more personal swipe with no attempt to add or address content.

I admire your

consistency.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

He wrote: " In a typical case ," not "for a typical prosecutor."

According to published reports, the police kill roughly 200 blacks a year most of them attacking the officer. In 2013, there were 6,261 black homicide victims in the U.S. The police could eliminate all fatal shootings without having any significant impact on the black homicide death rate. The killers of those black homicide victims are overwhelmingly other blacks, responsible for a death risk ten times that of whites in urban areas. In 2013, 5,375 blacks were arrested for homicide, which is greater than the number of whites and Hispanics combined (4,396), even though blacks are only 13 percent of the national population.---

The Times trots out the misleading statistic published by ProPublica last month that young black males are 21 times more likely to be shot dead by police than young white males a calculation that overlooks that young black men commit homicide at nearly ten times the rate of young white and Hispanic males combined. That astronomically higher homicide-commission rate means that police officers are going to be disproportionately in black neighborhoods to fight crime, where they will more likely encounter armed shooting suspects. If the black crime rate were the same as the white crime rate, the victims of police shootings would most certainly also be equal among the races. Asians are minorities, which, according to the Times ideology, should make them the target of police brutality. But they barely show up in police-shooting data because their crime rates are so low.

For the years 20052009, a significant portion of victims in the ProPublica study 62 percent were resisting arrest or assaulting an officer asMichael Brown did. The cop hatred that activists and press organs like the Times do their best to foment significantly increases the chances of such aggressive and dangerous behavior.

The Times serves up a good example of anti-cop propaganda when it confidently states that many police officers see black men as expendable figures on the urban landscape, not quite human beings. That will be news to the thousands of police officers who are the only people willing to put their lives on the line to protect innocent blacks from predation. Until the Times editors and reporters start patrolling dark stairwells in housing projects and running toward gang gunfire, their superior concern for black men will lack credibility.

...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

I wonder if you studied all the cases alluded to in my above message to conclude that all those cases were either typical or anything but typical.

Or were you simply hypothecating to make your point?

McCarthy is a top experienced prosecutor who successfullyprosecuted the blind sheik so he knows what he is talking about.

You were a newsman with all the limitations that that implies.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

According to published reports, the police kill roughly 200 blacks a year most of them attacking the officer.

Published reports from whom/what sources.

Heather Lynn Mac Donald (born 1956) is an American political commentator and journalist described as a secular conservative .

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

When conservatives reference a mediaitem why do leftists always reiterate the source's pedigree?

Do you want me to disqualify your "Think Progress" or "Puffington Host" references? You omitted the following:

She is a John M. Olin Fellow of the Manhattan Institute . [ 12 ] In addition, she is a contributing editor to New York's City Journal , [ 12 ] and a lawyer by training. [ 13 ] She has written numerous editorials and is the author of several books. She was born in California , [ 9 ] graduated from Phillips Academy in Andover in 1974 and graduated from Yale's Berkeley College in 1978, [ 14 ] then attended Cambridge , and graduated from Stanford law school in 1985.

A lawyer too!

Can you match this? I can't. She did not obtain all those honors by lying.

 
 
 
Jim Cassity
Freshman Silent
link   Jim Cassity    12 years ago

A Mac,

Getting a clear identifiable latent finger print with identifiable ridges, from a gun that two people are struggling over would be impossible. If you read the GJ report, the forensics lab had a choice to either test the weapon for fingerprints, which is actually useless, or they could swab the gun for DNA evidence. The gun was swabbed for DNA evidence as there was red stains on the pistol.

5. Every police department as different protocols for handling weapons that have been used in a use of force incident. Ours was similar after the seen was determined safe, the involved officer would then, in company with another officer, make the gun safe place it in a evidence bag labeled and signed, and placed in a evidence locker.

This fact is relatively insignificant, in this case, the only thing questionable would be chain of custody, if Wilson said that was not his gun, which would be a non starter as the guns are assigned to a police officer, and that guns serial number is attached to his personal file.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Getting a clear identifiable latent finger print with identifiable ridges, from a gun that two people are struggling over would be impossible. If you read the GJ report, the forensics lab had a choice to either test the weapon for fingerprints,

That's a presupposition and even if it were a verifiable one, questioning the forensics "expert" under cross-examination by a real prosecutor in a murder trial, might reveal information not pursued by McCulloch.

It's already been established that the forensics "professor" lied about his credentials! And Wilson turned in his own gun was he questioned about how he handled that gun and he washed the blood off of his hands.

Evidence handling in Ferguson shooting case under fire, emphasis on gun

Sincethe St. Louis County prosecutor released thousands of pages of evidence the grand jury used to decide not to indict a white police officer inthe deadly shooting of a black teen, the public has been scrutinizing themanner in which officials handled evidence, particularlythe officersgun, immediately following the incident.

According to official documents , supervisors allowed Wilson to drive himself back to the police station after the shooting where he washed blood from his hands, and placed his own pistolinto an evidence bag without it being checkedfor fingerprints all of which some experts say is anything but orthodox.

An officer driving himself back? Wrong. An officer booking his own gun into evidence? Wrong,David Klinger, a former police officer andcriminal justice professor with emphasis on use of force, told T he Washington Post .

I understand why some people are happy there's no indictment, no trial, no hard questions from a real prosecutor.

Real answers to real questions

It's your country wait until the white establishment no longer runs the show then you'll be screaming for indictments.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
here's a criminal procedure professor defenestraing the changing testimony of brown's accomplice, Dorian Johnson:

"So Johnsons story was his friend raised his hands in a surrender position, turned around and then, as he was in the process of saying he was unarmed, was gunned down before he had time to move more than a step toward the officer.The difficulty with this version is that it simply fails to match the physical evidence. With apologies for referring to a bloody photograph which an unsqueamish reader can view here a 20 to 22 foot trail of what appeared to be Mike Browns blood was on the road (next to evidence markers 19 and 20), leading back directly to where Wilson was and to where Mike Browns body was fatally shot. That trail of blood shows that Brown was moving towards Wilson for far more than a step and thus the dramatic ending to Johnsons account is simply incredible."
...
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Sean,

Among McCulloch's first words in his televised statement were those regarding conflicting evidence including testimonies that changed.

That does not address Wilson's actions re: his gun, the washing of his hands and all the other specifics I've posted.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
I haven't because I can't take Lawrence Odonnell seriously,a guy who uses a national television show to claim that "golf" is a racist term has no credibility with me.


I will try and watch it later when I can listen to it.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Not just a lawyer!

McCarthy is a top experienced prosecutor who successfullyprosecuted the blind sheik so he knows what he is talking about.

That includes all the ins and outs of grand jury procedure.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
I'm curious why you think any of those things matter. Wilson admits shooting him, he admits struggling with brown. It's hard to imagine any of these things adversely impacting Wilson.

Whatever missteps were made by the police department wouldn't be admissible in a trial against Wilson anyway. Missing evidence certainly doesn't support the case for an indictment , rather the opposite because missing evidence can't be used against a criminal defendant. The theory that the missing evidence might possibly have implicated Wilson is not a basis to convict.
 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

You keep pushing a trial but it would not quiet the naysayers any more than the Zimerman trial did.

 
 
 
Jim Cassity
Freshman Silent
link   Jim Cassity    12 years ago

AMac

Having served as a police officer for 10 years, and investigating numerous crimes fingerprints, are rarely identifiable. At times being an investigator or you have a choice that has to be made when determining how to test and deal with certain evidence. Some evidence can only be tested once. For example if you fingerprint the gun, you will destroy DNA evidence, if DNA test the gun, you will destroy fingerprint evidence. You often have to make an educated guess based on your experience as to what evidence will be more valuable in court.

The likely hood of recovering an identifiable latent print off of a gun that was involved in a struggle is almost zero. This is based off of my experience in recovering and trying to recover fingerprints. If I had been the detective I would have swabbed for DNA also.

The Argument of how the gun was handled is a red herring that everyone is buying into. Forensics prove that the gun that was involved in the shooting was the gun that was placed into evidence. Police department records prove that the gun placed in the envelope was Wilson's. The only discrepancy is the chain of custody of the gun. Wilson testified to the fact that he made the gun safe by removing the magazine from the gun and unloading it, placing the magazine the remaining bullet and the pistol in the evidence bag and sealing the bag. This is not all that unusual especially if you work in a small department.

As far as Officer Wilson leaving the scene alone, it is a non issue. This happens all the time with small police departments that do not have the man power to send someone with the officer and maintain scene integrity. Is it the preferred method absolutely not is it detrimental to a criminal case no it is not.

Should the blood have been collected off of Wilson's hands absolutely. But the simple act of washing your hands will not remove all blood evidence, the investigating detective should have used a blacklight, and swabbed all areas of Wilsons hands that showed blood evidence. This evidence should then have been tested for DNA.

Having testified in GJ cases this was not all that unprecedented as far as I can tell. The prosecuting attorney has an obligation to bring forth evidence and witnesses. The GJ can request and has the ability to call any and all witness, and review all evidence that is in the police reports. They listened to 70 hours of witness testimony and determined that there was no probable cause to believe that a crime had been committed.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Zimmerman was guilty also.

Yeah who needs juries or evidence when he have the mouse that roared ?!

 
 
 
Sister Mary Agnes Ample Bottom
Professor Participates
link   Sister Mary Agnes Ample Bottom    12 years ago

Have you checked out JR's article wherein O'Donnell demonstrates that the ADA intentionally instructed the jury using old law that had been found unconstitutional by the Supremes in 1985? Before the ADA was in high school much less law school.

If one researches the law, they will discover that only certain parts were considered unconstitutional, and therefore the parameters of the 'fleeing felon' part were revised. If a criminal, say...a jaywalker...decided to run from police, lethal force could not be used unless the felon presented a serious threat to public safety (like producing a weapon or grabbing a hostage). However, if thefleeingsuspectwas deemed to be a threat to public safety, i.e. ifhe had just committed a strong-armed robbery or tried to take possession of a law enforcement officer's gunafter beating him about the face and head,thenlethal forcebecomes an unindictable option.

It was dishonest for Mr. O'Donnell (or anyone else)topresent a monologuebased on a self-serving and untrue premise.

In addition, I'm not sure why people are focused solely on the actions of the prosecutor as the cause behind theGJ decision. There were three investigations. St. Louis County conducted one, theUSDepartment of Justiceconducted another one, and a civil rights team conducted the third. Not for one moment would any reasonable person believe that the vast number of people involved in those investigations could keep quiet if they were required to bea part of a jury-rigging operation.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

I respect your experience as a law enforcement officer and ask that you consider mine in the representation of individuals in adverse actions brought against them.

I was always meticulous in compiling information, and, in the relentless insistence that those who had "evidence" to present, followed protocol and all due process provisions.

You wrote

But the simple act of washing your hands will not remove all blood evidence, the investigating detective should have used a blacklight, and swabbed all areas of Wilsons hands that showed blood evidence. This evidence should then have been tested for DNA.

And therein exists a pair of a number of objections to the investigation process that McCulloch SHOULD HAVE EMPHASIZED before the GJ. Because Wilson was simply allowed to compromise evidentiary elements either inadvertently, willfully and/or with the Ferguson PD looking the other way, those circumstances in-and-of-themselves CRIED "INDICT!"

The prosecuting attorney has an obligation to bring forth evidence and witnesses.

The prosecution has no obligation to present exculpatory evidence because he's the PROSECUTOR. Further, this prosecutor should have recused himself or indicted Wilson; the GJ, IMO, was a set up to allow Wilson to simply walk.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

Thanks Jim.

It is gratifying to have a real-world practitioner here to counterthe theoretical pontificators.

I hike with a retired NYC patrolman. He never drew his gun in some 30 years on the streets but he talks just like you do.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

AMac>>The prosecution has no obligation to present exculpatory evidence because he's the PROSECUTOR

McCarthy>>Darren Wilson was a white cop and Michael Brown was a black teenager killed in a violent confrontation with Wilson. Therefore, Brown was the victim of a cold-blooded, racially motivated murder, Q.E.D. That is the myth, and it will be served dont bother us with the facts.

Once youve got that, none of the rest matters. In fact, at the hands of the left-leaning punditocracy, the rest was pure Alinsky: a coopting of language in this instance, the argot of grand-jury procedure to reason back to the ordained conclusion that justice demanded Wilsons indictment for murder. And, of course, his ultimate conviction.

I could spend the rest of the day rehearsing why these legal claims are specious. Particularly risible is the story line that the grand jury convened by St. Louis County Prosecutor Robert McCulloch was a sham a story line that is itself an elaborate fraud.---

In a typical case, prosecutors rely on the low probable-cause threshold applicable in grand-jury investigations only for the purpose of limiting how much evidence they need to present. Contrary to another regnant myth, guilt is not in doubt in most criminal cases. Overwhelmingly, they are open-and-shut, often supported by post-arrest confessions. As a result, the grand jury can appear to be a pro forma exercise a cookie-cutter procedure the Constitution requires before an accused person can be convicted of a crime he not only clearly committed but to which he will almost certainly plead guilty.

On the other hand, when convinced that the subject of an investigation either is innocent or is incapable of being proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, prosecutors do not present the case to the grand jury. Thats because their focus is the trial, not the indictment. If, after preliminary investigation, prosecutors do not assess the evidence as strong enough to convince a trial jury to render a unanimous guilty verdict, they dismiss the case on the basis of their own professional judgment it never sees the grand-jury room.

At a proper trial, Wilson could not have been convicted of murder. That does not mean what happened was not horrible it was. It does not mean Wilson is not civilly liable (although I doubt that he is). It simply means the circumstances of the shooting do not meet the high criminal-law standards for either intentional homicide or the criminally irresponsible causing of death. ---

If the Michael Brown shooting were an ordinary case, a grand jury would never have been asked to consider indicting Officer Wilson. McCulloch, the chief prosecutor, directed his office to present it to the grand jury because it was not an ordinary case because it was a racially charged case in which Al Sharptons notorious No Justice, No Peace demagoguery was amplified by the community organizers in the White House and the most politicized Justice Department in American history.

Ordinarily, prosecutors unilaterally decide whether or not to seek an indictment and, in the rare instance when anyone asks why they decided as they did, are restrained by investigative-secrecy protocols from explaining their decision. But McCulloch was understandably unwilling to make a unilateral judgment for which he would have been unable to defend himself from inevitable charges of racism. He thus directed his office to make an exhaustive presentation to the grand jury. It was both a Pontius Pilatestyle abdication that made the community, rather than himself, accountable for the charging decision; and a vehicle that, with the courts blessing, enabled him to disclose the voluminous evidence justifying the decision not to indict.

 
 
 
Jim Cassity
Freshman Silent
link   Jim Cassity    12 years ago

AMAC,

The way the gun was handled, and the washing of the hands are a protocol issue within the police department. That I agree need to be addressed, but they are not detrimental to a criminal case, nor are they used to establish probable cause that a crime was committed.

Eyewitness testimony is rarely accurate. You could place ten people in the same room and have ten different versions of what happened in that room while they where in it. It is even less accurate during high stress moments when gunshots are going off, and people are more concerned about self preservation than what is happening. It is not uncommon for eyewitness testimony to change and change extensively after the initial statements are taken. Having investigated many crime scenes and having taken thousands of witness statements it is my experience that eyewitness testimony does not usually coincide with the forensic evidence at the scene.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

f thefleeingsuspectwas deemed to be a threat to public safety, i.e. ifhe had just committed a strong-armed robbery or tried to take possession of a law enforcement officer's gunafter beating him about the face and head,thenlethal forcebecomes an unindictable option.

Very early on, the Ferguson police chief, in a live and videoed interview, stated that Wilson was not aware of the cigar store robbery and that Wilson stopped Brown and his friend from interfering with traffic by walking in the middle of the street jaywalking.

Nevertheless, the Ferguson PD released the store video and subsequently allowed "reports" that Wilson knew of the robbery.

Further, you may recall that the Ferguson PD reported that Wilson suffered a damaged eye socket yet another lie debunked.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Eyewitness testimony is rarely accurate.

Indeed, and conflicting testimonies often are a primary reason for indictment. When facts are in dispute, the dispute is usually addressed in a trial.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Sean, do you do this as on-line pro-bono therapy, to help obsessive delusional people?

Does it ever help anyone?

Robert G, is there a salient pointfrom youanywhere in our future, thatregarding the content rather than your trademark snarky slams?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Blood is a bio-hazard

In the critical first minutes after a shooting, investigators are trained to follow a time-tested process of protecting the scene to ensure that evidence is not compromised

A shooting suspect even a police officer must be cordoned off in a controlled area and stripped of his clothing, his weapon secured by investigators, and must be escorted by officers if he leaves.

An officer driving himself back? Wrong. An officer booking his own gun into evidence? Wrong, said David Klinger, an expert on police shootings with the University of Missouri at St. Louis who is also a former police officer. The appropriate investigative procedures were not followed.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    12 years ago

Sure. All irrelevant. There is and never was any controversy about whose blood it was, where it was, or about whose gun it was, or about which gun the bullets came from.

Wilson's account indicates that an examination of his gun might have revealed Brown's fingerprints or DNA or both.

Wilson then grabbed his gun. He said he warned Brown that he was going to shoot if Brown didn't get back, but Brown reportedly grabbed his gun and said "you are too much of a p---y to shoot me."

Brown reportedly then dug Wilson's gun into Wilson's hip. Wilson said he could feel Brown's fingers reaching for the trigger.

Wilson eventually regained control of his gun and tried to fire it two times without it working properly. On the third try, a shot fired through his car door, he said.

Don't f'n tell me about time and space your idea of meaningful dialogue is to talk down, mock and insult without offering much else.

Read more: ...

More

Wilson's OWN WORDS

Wilson said he didn't know whether he would be able to "withstand another hit like that." He takes his gun out, points it at Brown, and says, "Get back or I'm gonna shoot you." Immediately, Brown grabs the top of Wilson's gun and says, "You're too much of a p**** to shoot me."

"And while he's doing that, I can feel his hand trying to come over my hand and get inside the trigger guard and try and shoot me with my own gun. And that's when I pulled the trigger for the first time," said Wilson.

Watch the video

...

If Brown made contact with Wilson's hand, gun or both, there's much reason for suspicion regarding washing away blood and or DNA.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

If you micro-analyzed everyevent nothing would be accomplished in the real world.

To be sure, cases are dismissed for protocol violations but they need to be material.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

That is all up to the prosecutor.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    12 years ago

You should have been the prosecutor. You have been acting like one here.

Evidently, you decided in advance that Wilson should be both indicted and convicted and you have been trying to prove it since.

Onward to Staten Island.

I would guess you also are upset about that GJ verdict.

 
 

Who is online



shona1


68 visitors